Repository navigation
fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy - #539
Conversation
github-actions
Bot
added
vouch:trusted
Thread transfer impact✅ Thread transfer remains within every enforced ceiling.
Baseline: unavailable · PR result: Scenario and decoded snapshot size10 historical turns, 5 command tools per turn, 878.9 KiB retained MCP result per historical turn, and a 1.05 MiB retained result in the measured turn.
Updated in place by a trusted workflow. PR artifacts are strictly validated and never executed. |
|
What: PR539's local native116-case proof is green, but current CI still fails on inherited formatting, two stale test consumers and16mobile type errors already repaired in the preserved383 checkpoint. Requirements and who asked: User requires inherited CI repair, each current reviewed component before merge and one final approval PR. Both current reviews remain exact116b24d/base63c41 and must distinguish these baseline gate failures from supported code findings. Main advanced to e5936c2 through530 Mac login mirror; final integration must include it, but539 target remains frozen63c41 and no final-current-main claim exists. Parent also prepared local-only383 alignment: stopped d892's EXACT3authoredcommits over7c70 rebased onto539116b24d in exclusive/home/luke/dev/toolboxmd/chromeria-worktrees/379-383-alignment, branchalign/379-383-current, localHEAD913df7d4920081d05ea56a4e49443b308cec7fc4/tree4a5bd98ec9027b7e47341779c43125e5b5da24e8. Preserved the full added pending532 test with new383 cases, hoisted native worktree decoder, complete RPC exports/definitions/middleware and canonical/shared metadata owners. RemotePR534 and originalRockyworktree are untouched; originald892 remains preserved. This is preparation only, not newbase validation or permission to reuse old proof. Affected newbase checks are underway, and subsequent539changes require another cascade before review/publication. |
|
What: APPROVE PR #539 at Identity and independence
Elon recordRequirements and who asked: The current user/parent requested a whole independent component review preserving #379 v5, #369 native request guarantees and merged #533 Promachos answering, with bounded inherited proof repairs. FindingsAPPROVE. No required correction or optional rewrite is requested. Pending-request policy and transport composition
Retained #369 guaranteesThe native content and revision read remains one same-client SQL transaction through the real ProjectionStore, with initial management/legacy preparation and network authorization outside that transaction. SQL without the required store fails rather than returning an invented modern revision. The existing planning and commit guard still enforce status, revision and content/option shape atomically with events, receipt and outbox. The explicit offered empty value remains distinct from an absent required answer. Qualified exact-target, selected-task, human-session, replay, concurrent answer/dismiss, native intake-before-commit and Stop controls are retained. All ten existing Fixture, WebSocket and metadata changes
Fresh checks executed by this reviewerAll tests/compiler commands used task-local Node 24.13.1 / pnpm 11.10.0 through:
That is 141 passing tests across six files, scoped feedback. No repository-wide check or full 116-case rerun was performed. No new disposable source probe was necessary or left behind. Author evidence checked separatelyVerified every one of the 12 source/metadata hashes and every retained log hash in The matching final logs report full native 116 passed/374.26s, focused 159, consumers 255, discovery 28, fixture repair 14, scoped lint/format, server export Knip and committed fork gate. These remain author executions. The 159 selection predates the later approval-list assertion; the final 28 and 116 cover the respective final source. The parent's earlier compiler total also included its restored omitted helper; I do not attribute all those errors to inherited baseline. No older approvals or CI runs were transferred. Records, ownership and limitsApplied canonical operations verification/code review/review-method/impact-analysis and diagnosis guidance, repository instructions/triad/glossary and Great Library guidance. Review inputs include the complete #539 body and author handoff 3796270138641; approved v5 parent body/Design Review; compatibility decision 3796269063649, narrowed authority 3796269504815 and driver map 3796269777203; full Issue #532 and comments and merged #533 diff/tests/body; #369 repair/aggregate/appendix/client packet 6248420108/6248544656/6249019046/6249106298; both whole #531 findings and disposition 6269155719/6269257839/6269292475; and the stopped #383/parent transfer records 6269799768/6269852888 and supplied caches. The #369 appendix's prior packet is exactly identical to the canonical 345-line packet after its six-line historical wrapper, checked directly. The accepted #531 premature content-less receipt and root turn-item query findings remain separately owned. Their implementation is not imported here; this component's fixture repair does not prove their resolution or replace their required fresh notice proofs. The d892 mobile/React Compiler and other remaining #383 repairs likewise remain separate. No old design blocker is reopened by this review. Current CI and aggregate review acceptance were not established by these local checks. Full application/Ws.layer bootstrap, actual web/desktop/mobile interaction/media, physical machines, real provider prompts/callbacks, OS crash/restart, migration/rollback and final combined #379 acceptance remain unverified here and parent-owned. Old discovery/404/timing and cost UNKNOWNs are not explained by these passes. The newer main/browser synthesis remains parent-owned. No source/index mutation, commit/push, checkout/rebase/merge/topology operation, other-worktree write, product/dev server, browser/device, provider prompt, live data, grant or running Chromeria operation occurred. Only isolated fixture HTTP/SQLite tests and task-local evidence files were used. All finite reviewer commands completed; source remains clean at the reviewed identity. Authored by Codex / gpt-6.1-sol / MEDIUM. This is this reviewer's whole-component verdict only. |
|
What: Sol approved exact PR #539 head Requirements and who asked: The user requires independent review from another model family; the recorded parent review policy additionally names Sol MEDIUM and Grok MEDIUM. Sol task: The existing CI-frontier decision remains: transfer only necessary baseline repairs from the stopped, preserved #383 checkpoint into lower #539, then revalidate and obtain fresh required exact-candidate reviews. The parent retains topology ownership. Local #383 alignment |
|
What: The existing #539 compatibility owner may include the two preserved web test-consumer migrations and their metadata in the current baseline repair. Requirements and who asked: The user requires inherited typecheck and CI repair; the compatibility owner requested a finite extension after executing the actual web compiler. Finite ownership extension: migrate the existing RemotePendingRequest test to its preserved Native request was answered with “Include the two existing test migrations (Recommended)”; response sequence |
|
What: Grok's full round2 review failed before a verdict; the authorized Opus5.5 MEDIUM whole-component review is starting on the same frozen candidate. Requirements and who asked: The user explicitly authorizes one Grok retry then Opus5.5MEDIUM fallback; retain independent exact-candidate review before component merge. Base remains63c41e7b0ab32460dae0287b448a87c3ac9e8e51, tree7701851d176a136cbe52b3b526fe8031297fe352. Author stoppedclean/no pendingchildruns. Parent verified all23cumulative manifest path entries and50retained log hashes with no mismatch. Both approval verdicts and currentCI remain outstanding. Parent-owned local-only383cascade now clean1ea65b79c80e56a438d36de54b3ae8f56f8f674a/tree040add47a7f9c0a0bbc90186d048f46700b49da1 overcurrent5392b; preserved improved web fixture binding and bothPRrefs, noPR534remote/originalRockywrite. It needs fresh proof/review; older five-case proof remains historical. No mainmerge/deploy/runningChromeriarestart/live-dataaction. |
|
What: APPROVE PR #539 at Exact identity and independence
Elon recordRequirements and who asked: The current user/parent requires a fresh whole PR539 review preserving #379 v5, #369 native request guarantees and merged #533 Promachos answering, plus only the explicitly transferred existing CI consumer repairs. Findings and whole-component coverageAPPROVE. No required correction or optional rewrite is requested. Request policy, actual destination and response admissionInspected
Baseline server fixtures, RPC inference and formatter-only pathsInspected
Mobile/web consumers and save semanticsInspected all three mobile paths:
Metadata and source attributionRead both Independently compared the eight claimed exact-transfer files with stopped checkpoint Fresh executions by this reviewerAll commands used task-local Node24.13.1/pnpm11.10.0 via
These are scoped checks. No repo-wide gate or full116-case workflow rerun occurred. The DOM and Chromium executions cover the same23web cases in different runtimes and are not counted as distinct behavior cases. Checked author evidence, historical records and limitsVerified manifest SHA256 Author current-source85server/11native/3mobile/23DOM/23Chromium/compiler/lint/format/export/fork logs retain their stated identities. Scoped lint/format/Knip/fork executions beyond my inventory/whitespace check are reused author evidence, not my reruns. The old116-case/159/255 proofs and prior Sol141-test/compiler report remain historical, not current complete merge coverage. Read current full PR539 body, canonical3796270880310 and supplied local handoff; full original539R1 report6270356613, response6270379537/frontier6270303720 and current scope/fallback records; full parent v5 body,532body/comments and merged533diff/tests; compatibility/authority/map3796269063649/6269504815/6269777203; full369repair/aggregate/appendix/client packet6248420108/6248544656/6249019046/6249106298; both whole531reports/disposition6269155719/6269257839/6269292475; and383checkpoint/transfer6269799768/3796269852888. Verified the appendix contains the canonical repair verbatim and the531disposition embeds both complete reports. Applied canonical operations review/verification/review-method/impact-analysis/diagnosis, repository direction/instructions/glossary and Great Library guidance. The accepted531premature content-less receipt and root turn-item query findings remain separately owned. This component does not mask or prove their repair. Its formatter-only RemoteDelegation edit is not their implementation. Existing original404/discovery/timing/cost UNKNOWNs remain unknown. Current CI, full application/Ws.layer bootstrap, actual integrated source-only web/desktop/mobile clients and images, real provider processes, physical machines, OS/process-crash proof, migration/rollback and combined379acceptance remain unverified here and parent-owned. Package compilation and repository Chromium tests do not replace them. Current-main synthesis and the383cascade remain parent-owned. No blocker or original production policy is waived. No source/index edit, commit/push, checkout/rebase/merge/topology mutation, other-worktree write, product/dev server, browser panel/device, live grant/data/provider operation, additional agent or status mutation occurred. All finite reviewer commands completed. Only task-local evidence and isolated native fixture/DOM/repository Chromium tests were used. The only authorized forge write is this complete PR comment. Authored by Codex / gpt-6.1-sol / MEDIUM. This is this reviewer's whole-component verdict only. |
|
What: APPROVE PR #539 at Requirements and who asked: The user authorized a fallback independent whole-component review by Claude Opus 5.5 at MEDIUM effort after Grok returned 402. Scope: exact head Identity
FindingsAPPROVE. No required change. Policy core (unchanged since 116b, re-read in full)
Baseline transfer (116b→2b, 12 paths)
Fresh checks run by this reviewerPrefix:
Total: 88 fresh passing tests and 3 compilers. I did not rerun lint, fmt, knip or fork-check. For those I checked only the author's log hashes, not reran them. LimitsNot covered by this review:
All of these are parent-owned. I did not reload the AgentsMD operations procedures for this round. No source or index writes, commits, topology changes, product or dev servers, live data, grants or subdelegation. This comment is the only external write. Authored by Claude Code / claude-opus-5-5 / MEDIUM (user-authorized fallback for Grok). This is this reviewer's verdict only. |
|
What: APPROVE PR #539 at Requirements and who asked: The parent and the user asked for a fresh whole-component review of exact head Applied guidanceI read these in full before this review: AgentsMD Identity
FindingsAPPROVE. There are no required changes and no optional rewrites. Policy core
Baseline transfer and consumers
Fresh checks by this reviewer (this round)Prefix:
Reused, not rerun (after checking hashes and log contents): the author's lint (10 files), fmt (12 files, pass), Knip exports, fork-check (52 features), and the PeerGrantSettings React Compiler case (1 passed / 1093 filtered). The author's LimitsNot covered by this review:
All of these are parent-owned. The accepted #531 findings (an early notice without content must not consume the receipt, and the bounded root turn-item query) remain separately owned. This component neither masks nor proves them, and its formatting-only No source or index writes, commits, topology changes, product or dev servers, live data, grants, provider prompts or subdelegation. This comment is the only external write. Authored by Claude Code / claude-opus-5-5 / MEDIUM (user-authorized fallback for Grok). This is this reviewer's verdict only. |
|
What: Independent whole-component review passes for PR539 exact head Requirements and who asked: User379 requires independent exact-candidate review; the latest user explicitly authorizes Opus5.5MEDIUM after the bounded Grok retry fails. Full independent reports:
Grok R1 and full R2 returned402 withnoverdict; shortexecutionprobeAVAILABLE wasnotreviewreliability. Userfallbackauthorization3796270860672 and actualfallback6270966711 remain the policy trail. No billing diagnosis/topup/configchange was made. Both acceptedcurrentreviewtasks terminal/no pendingchildruns; sourcecleanunchangedtree7701851d176a136cbe52b3b526fe8031297fe352. No authorworkcontinueson539. Adjudication: no supported requiredfix or unresolved codeobjection. Opusnotedthetest-onlyhoistedmockobjectretainskeys; eachtestsetsallkeysituses, so thereisnocurrentbehavioraldependency orjustifiedproductionchange. Existing reviewer tests distinguishobservable mountedbehavior fromstaticmarkup; no gateorpermissionpolicy changed. Preserve stricter369self/unrelated/outsideOAuthquestionrefusal beside main533Promachosalternative; actualtarget ceilingsandancestryremain enforced. This status covers current independent review only. Full116workflow currentcandidate coverage comesfromfutureCI, notold116b localpass; appbootstrap,actualintegratedweb/desktop/mobile/provider/machineproof,latestmain530synthesis,383cascade,531noticefindings,384/385/386remaininggaps,migration/rollback andfinalapprovalPR remainunverifiedorunfinishedasrecorded. No mainmerge/deploy/runningChromeriarestart/live-dataaction. |
|
What: Move the existing537recovery fixture repair into lower compatibility539 before its next reviewed candidate; do not merge539with failedCI. Requirements and who asked: User379 requires inheritedCI repair, no failing-gate waiver, one topology owner and reviewed component integration. The same test defect and complete repair were already owned in537. Finite new539writegrant: apps/server/src/prism/RecoveryReactor.test.ts exactly as preserved537blob; docs/map.md addPR539toexistingPrismroutingpart ratherthan537asmerged. No RecoveryReactor production source edit. Parent537branch/workspace remainsread-only and preserved, separate384worker hasnoPrismfileownership. Full3casetest,scopedlint/fmt/inventory/whitespacecurrentcandidate proof; originalred/validmutationsource equivalence mustremainexplicit. Mapmetadataonlyadapts539reference. Updatecurrent539body/handoff/hashmanifest andSTOPcleanafterordinaryforwardpush. Newwhole-componentreviewsSol+OpusMEDIUMandfreshCIrequired, noactualclientpassorotherproofwaived. Previousfull539Sol6271047252/Opus6271180993verdicts remain true scoped historical reports at2b; thecurrentcandidatecannotmergebecause of thisCIgate and sourcewillchange. No finalPR/mainmerge/deploy/runningChromeriarestart/livedata. PR531branchuntouched. Parentretainsallsquashmerge/cascade decisions; repositorysupportsquashonly, nofast-forwardpushshortcut. |
|
What: APPROVE PR #539 at Requirements and who asked: The parent and the user asked for a fresh review of the whole component by Claude Opus 5.5 at MEDIUM, at exact head Applied guidanceBefore reviewing I read these in full: AgentsMD Identity
FindingsAPPROVE. There are no required changes. Delta 2b→472
Whole component (unchanged since 2b, re-read)
Fresh checks by this reviewerPrefix:
Limits
No commits, pushes, topology changes, other-worktree writes, product or dev servers, live data, grants, provider prompts or subdelegation. The only source write was the disposable mutation probe above, restored byte for byte. This comment is the only external write. Authored by Claude Code / claude-opus-5-5 / MEDIUM (user-authorized fallback for Grok). This is this reviewer's verdict only. |
|
What: APPROVE PR #539 at Identity and method
Requirements and who asked: The user/parent requires a fresh whole PR539 MEDIUM review preserving #379 v5, #369 native guarantees and merged #533 answering, plus the finite existing #383/#537 baseline repairs. Findings and coverageAPPROVE. No required correction or optional rewrite is requested. Request policy and native acceptanceInspected
Recovery observer fixtureRead the complete test,
Remaining server and client repairs
Fresh proof executed in this roundAll runner commands use task-local Node24.13.1/pnpm11.10.0:
Reused evidence and unverified limitsVerified current manifest SHA256 Historical inputs also include full original539R1 report6270356613 and handoffs6270138641/6270880310; parent compatibility/authority/map decisions6269063649/6269504815/6269777203; scope/fallback/frontier records; full532body/comments and merged533diff/tests/body;369repair/aggregate/appendix/client packet6248420108/6248544656/6249019046/6249106298; both whole531reports/disposition6269155719/6269257839/6269292475; and full383checkpoint/transfer6269799768/6269852888. Exact duplicate embeddings were checked: the369appendix contains the canonical repair verbatim and the531disposition includes both complete reports. No historical approval transfers. The separately owned531early content-less notice receipt and unbounded root turn-item query findings remain separate; this component neither implements nor proves their repair. Original native404/discovery/timing/cost UNKNOWNs remain unknown. No Server1 cause is inferred. The full116-case workflow on472, current-head complete CI, full application/Ws.layer startup, integrated web/desktop/mobile client evidence/images, real provider processes, physical-machine behavior, OS/process-crash proof, migration/rollback, current-main/383cascade and combined379acceptance remain unverified here and parent-owned. Focused tests and package compilers are scoped feedback, not a complete merge gate. PR537 remains preserved/draft, not merged; parent owns closure as absorbed after539lands. No source/index edit, commit/push, checkout/rebase/merge/topology mutation, other-worktree write, product/dev server, browser panel/device, live grant/data/provider operation, dependency installation, extra agent or status mutation occurred. All finite checks completed. PR539 is app-linked and watching=false. The only task forge write is this full findings comment. Authored by Codex / gpt-6.1-sol / MEDIUM. This is this reviewer's exact-candidate whole-component verdict only. |
|
What: Fresh independent whole-component reviews approve PR #539 at472e960572ccd6c842869962acd294797e1feff3; no supported blocking finding remains. Requirements and who asked: User379 requires reviewed component PRs and a final cumulative approval PR; the standing fallback authorizes independent Sol MEDIUM and Opus5.5 MEDIUM after Grok failed. Exact base63c41e7b0ab32460dae0287b448a87c3ac9e8e51, head472e960572ccd6c842869962acd294797e1feff3, tree79e196e151cc3f07a78a5835beaa22ea29eba314; targetfeat/379-cross-machine-parity unchanged.
Both frozen review trees are clean, unchanged at exact472, and both native delegated jobs report terminal with no pending child runs. No review is author self-approval. All prior reports, accepted findings/responses and parent recovery absorption decision remain inputs, not transferred verdicts. Parent independently inspected the actual recovery test change and matching537blob plus cumulative manifest/source/log hashes; the production coalescer remains unchanged.
No main merge, deploy, installed Chromeria restart, live grants/data or package version changes. Parent remains sole topology owner; routine supported internal squash merge follows only when current exact readiness is verified. |
|
What: The watch alert names historical2bServer7failure; current472Server7and the fullCIworkflow reportSUCCESS. Requirements and who asked: User379requires exact-current complete proof and independently reviewed internal integration, with no main merge/deploy/runningChromeriarestart/live-data change. CurrentCI https://github.com/toolboxmd/chromeria/actions/runs/39282401928 ; Server7 https://github.com/toolboxmd/chromeria/actions/runs/39282401928/job/118159099332 ; exactfreshreviewaggregate #539 (comment). APIjob/rollupsubsets still showed delayed queued/inprogress states while the actualrunheaderreportedcompleted/success; no causal claim beyond the separatelyconfirmedGitHubincident. No remainingcheckisassumedgreenfroma greenCIrun ifitbelongs toaseparateworkflow. The oldfixturecause, faithfulmutation, originalfailedattemptandearliest-ownercorrectionarealreadyretainedin3796271556362andfreshreviewreports; this latealert adds no newReflectionfinding or reason to change global guidance. No source/head/topology mutation, workflow dispatch or merge was performed in response. |
|
What: PR #539 is ready for the user-authorized internal squash merge at exact472e960572ccd6c842869962acd294797e1feff3 into #379's integration branch. Requirements and who asked: User379explicitlyauthorizes reviewed component merges into the integration branch and reserves final mainmerge approval. StandingSol+OpusMEDIUM fallback and no live data/deploy/installedChromeriarestart remain in force. Targetbase63c41e7b0ab32460dae0287b448a87c3ac9e8e51; expectedpostmergetree79e196e151cc3f07a78a5835beaa22ea29eba314. UseGitHubsupportedghprmerge--squash--match-head-commit472, preservecomponentbranchuntildependentstackneedsarecleared, verifyresultSHA/tree/parent/livebranchbeforeclaimingmerged. No additionalversionbumpunderrepooverride. Currentnativeclientbuild prerequisite is separatelyverified3796272095101, not substitutedforcombinedacceptance. Parentdoesnotrebaseactive384writerorMuse383diagnosis; theirstoppedhandoffsremainrequired. |
b6d778b
into
feat/379-cross-machine-parity
* fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy * fix(compat): restore inherited CI consumers Reuse baseline-only repairs from the preserved #383 checkpoint d892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7 under the #379 ownership transfer. Adapt the two web test fixtures for actual Chromium collection without changing production web behavior. * test(prism): absorb native recovery observer fixture Transfer the exact test blob authored in cdd4780 and preserved by PR537 at fcd3162. Await the native observer marker before measuring the live batch; preserve the duplicate assertion and production source.
* fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy * fix(compat): restore inherited CI consumers Reuse baseline-only repairs from the preserved #383 checkpoint d892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7 under the #379 ownership transfer. Adapt the two web test fixtures for actual Chromium collection without changing production web behavior. * test(prism): absorb native recovery observer fixture Transfer the exact test blob authored in cdd4780 and preserved by PR537 at fcd3162. Await the native observer marker before measuring the live batch; preserve the duplicate assertion and production source.
* fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy * fix(compat): restore inherited CI consumers Reuse baseline-only repairs from the preserved #383 checkpoint d892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7 under the #379 ownership transfer. Adapt the two web test fixtures for actual Chromium collection without changing production web behavior. * test(prism): absorb native recovery observer fixture Transfer the exact test blob authored in cdd4780 and preserved by PR537 at fcd3162. Await the native observer marker before measuring the live batch; preserve the duplicate assertion and production source.
* fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy * fix(compat): restore inherited CI consumers Reuse baseline-only repairs from the preserved #383 checkpoint d892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7 under the #379 ownership transfer. Adapt the two web test fixtures for actual Chromium collection without changing production web behavior. * test(prism): absorb native recovery observer fixture Transfer the exact test blob authored in cdd4780 and preserved by PR537 at fcd3162. Await the native observer marker before measuring the live batch; preserve the duplicate assertion and production source.
* fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy * fix(compat): restore inherited CI consumers Reuse baseline-only repairs from the preserved #383 checkpoint d892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7 under the #379 ownership transfer. Adapt the two web test fixtures for actual Chromium collection without changing production web behavior. * test(prism): absorb native recovery observer fixture Transfer the exact test blob authored in cdd4780 and preserved by PR537 at fcd3162. Await the native observer marker before measuring the live batch; preserve the duplicate assertion and production source.
* feat(peer): preserve authority and native returns across environments (#391) * feat(peer): return notices and delegate onward within durable authority * fix(peer): retain authority through queued execution and recovery * fix(peer): preserve active run authority across native operations * fix(peer): retain authority for every accepted run input * fix(peer): check every contributor against the actual target * fix(peer): validate joint work against its actual resource * docs(peer): inventory retained consent seams * fix(peer): remove unused authority helper re-export * fix(peer): bound private output by effective caller modes * fix(ci): weight the measured peer authority workflow * fix(peer): retain effective caller modes during task cancellation * feat(peer): continue remote delegated jobs and stop later work (#392) * feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime * fix(peer): preserve attachment bytes and native request acceptance (#410) * fix(peer): preserve attachment bytes and native request acceptance * docs(peer): link request recovery component review * docs(peer): register attachment recovery review provenance * fix(peer): declare device receipt owner in fork inventory * fix(server): preserve scoped retries and scheduler acceptance * fix(peer): preserve authorized manual admission and saved snapshot replay * fix(peer): preserve native preview capability refusal * fix(attachments): recover exact native discard acceptance * fix(attachments): retain bytes after keyed discard acceptance * fix(preview): reconcile native recording claims before replay * feat(peer): answer remote descendant requests from the source (#416) **What**: Exact #369 candidate42051c passed real source-only web and Codex peer request acceptance, including committed replay after both full CLI servers restarted. **Why**: Independent tests cannot establish that the production composition, real provider callback and source-only client work together. **So what**: The planner accepts this bounded internal component for integration into #379 after a fresh head/base/gate check; combined multi-machine/client acceptance and final shipment remain pending. Requirements and who asked: User #379 mandates native delegated lifecycle and all permitted tools with two MEDIUM reviewers and real isolated client/provider proof. Deleted: No fake provider, direct SQL mutation, injected browser RPC, capability expansion, alternate harness or duplicate callback. Bottleneck: Current candidate integration; #383 shared device authority/discovery and #384/#385/#386 remain outstanding. Checked myself: Primary planner drove actual source A browser, inspected native B events/provider results, restarted both CLI products, replayed exact original request, and reopened the same source-only result. Identity: HEAD42051c47813c354682b80677009b199d86fef1a0, treef9efef2d7df1b8b91ac64b09018386e79ccc1d45, baseab1bf53640e2a6541a2ba9f316839cedf81d4f46. Clean author workspace /Users/rocky/.t3/worktrees/chromeria/feat-369-remote-pending-requests. Both full production servers ran that source, with meaningful copied task-owned history in NEW /tmp/chromeria-369-acceptance-a and -b; old382 homes/evidence remained untouched. Node24.18, A server14247/web7663, B14248, source incognito Browser connected ONLY to A950a38f2-e2a5-4242-9171-c17e0cb8412c. Actual B is ef047b58-1edf-4ad6-a1ba-44320188325c. No live userdata write, new grant, physical device or standalone worker server. Human source-only flow: A actual Codex gpt-6.1-sol/MEDIUM delegated real async B task369-parent-native-question-v1 in existing B project/root. B actual Codex asked request_user_input_async, persisted pending at B sequence288. Primary opened source task viewer from transcript; browser URL stayed A, no B profile. The actual card displayed369 REAL REMOTE QUESTION, ACCEPT_369/DECLINE_369 and disabled Send answer until selection. Primary selected ACCEPT_369 and sent once. B durable request resolved at sequence290, command mcp:request:385bcb2f7e0a7415a3c0d1cda8a0cabb0b7204f83949b505a9f4fe4cb6482210:0, 2026-10-18T10:10:47.347Z. Real provider consumed the answer and completed369_REMOTE_ANSWER=ACCEPT_369. Source returned exact original result and zero pending requests. Not inferred from dispatch acceptance. Agent tool flow: Separate deliberate B task369-parent-native-agent-answer-v1, same explicit Color. Native delegate mode wait returned on real pending question with waitTimedOut:false, requestCount1, actual qualified target/revision334. Source local list{} correctly returned[]; explicit remote descendant list returned its actual request. Native qualified read returned real369 REAL AGENT QUESTION/options/revision334. Source called t3_pending_request_respond with original target/route/expectedRevision334, answers{0:AGENT_ACCEPT_369}, stable key369-parent-agent-response-v1. Initial AND exact retry both returned sequence340. B request has exactly one pending334 and one resolved336 event; real provider completed369_AGENT_RESULT=AGENT_ACCEPT_369. Two B tasks intentionally created, each ordinal1 completed, no duplicate B run. Restart proof: Read-only query found zero preparing/queued/starting/running/waiting runs in A/B. Primary stopped only captured own sessions47643/49402 (exit130), restarted same source and same NEW homes in sessions86505/9639. A actual Codex ordinal34 called ONLY the exact original respond input/key after reconstruction: sequence340 again. Postrestart B has no additional request resolution or provider run. Source previous-agent viewer reopened after both restarts with original human result, real accepted answer and zero pending requests. Actual client screenshot inspected before upload. Evidence: local immutable/raw read-only oracles /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-actual-question-proof.json, /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-native-agent-tool-proof.json, /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-postrestart-proof.json. Full CLI logs /tmp/chromeria-369-acceptance-{a,b}-server.log and -restart.log retained. Native Browser screenshots in existing UNPUBLISHED draft evidence-379, never a public release:   Both fresh exact-candidate independent MEDIUM reviews APPROVE: Sol #416 (comment) and installed Grok4.7 #416 (comment). Full aggregate #369 (comment). Current420 CI39116640008, Fork39116640150 and final fingerprint39116844636 SUCCESS; original canceled fingerprint retained separately. Authenticated newest review/independent SUCCESS by lukemaj. Neither review substitutes for the actual proof above. Full author/R1/R2 packet #369 (comment). Limits: These are TWO isolated Rocky environments, web/source-only browser and actual Codex provider. No physical cross-machine/tunnel/mobile/native desktop/all-provider/real live approval, durable-dismiss or secret acceptance claim. Registered native tests retain their own broader and S1/S2 race/empty-choice proof. Earlier native initialization404 remains UNKNOWN; later tests/CI/actual positives do not diagnose it. Operational verification earlier used invalid exact=true locator syntax and a stale assumed web port; corrected to supported selectors/actual dev-runner7663 without alternate browser or product changes. Cost supported publish #416 (comment) is partial task379 coverage, not complete cost; old unplaced/unpriced usage remains unknown. Background supported sync still pending at this record, not presumed complete. States: implemented YES; current focused/native tests YES under their exact records; BOTH reviewed YES; current CI YES; bounded primary product proof YES; internal integration NOT YET at this record; main merged/build/shipped/activated/live combined acceptance NO. No package bump. All rollback/evidence/workspaces retained under explicit #379 instruction until final acceptance. * fix(client): clarify remote requests and count pending work once * fix(client): make remote request choices readable and accessible * docs(peer): track the remote request client repair * fix(peer): count initial remote work once in sparse shells * feat(device): add typed remote device execution core (#421) * feat(device): execute typed commands across peer links * docs(map): link the typed device core component * fix(device): preserve native authority and typed command semantics * fix(device): recheck authority before native shutdown * wip: preserve native contexts and purpose metadata after main alignment * fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy (#539) * fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy * fix(compat): restore inherited CI consumers Reuse baseline-only repairs from the preserved #383 checkpoint d892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7 under the #379 ownership transfer. Adapt the two web test fixtures for actual Chromium collection without changing production web behavior. * test(prism): absorb native recovery observer fixture Transfer the exact test blob authored in cdd4780 and preserved by PR537 at fcd3162. Await the native observer marker before measuring the live batch; preserve the duplicate assertion and production source. * fix(client): hide remote children from default navigation (#546) * wip: hide remote children from default navigation * wip: register destination navigation component PR * wip: retain user forks with remote provenance * wip: cover phone and alternate sidebar navigation * wip: declare phone and legacy carried upstream edits * feat(peer): keep destination automations authorized offline (#555) * feat(peer): retain destination automation authority offline * docs(peer): link destination authority component PR * wip: repair destination authority recovery and acceptance findings * wip: fence schedule acceptance and preserve live birth permissions * wip: preserve birth permission purpose and split native proof * wip: preserve recovery routes and birth dependency lifetime * wip: retain paired recovery routes through repeated unlink * wip: wake exact automation disable recovery at known expiry * feat(remote): view and control qualified browser and device resources (#534) * wip: combine qualified resources with destination automation * wip: bound mobile returned-resource row height * wip: respect native top safe area for tool resources * wip: preserve current-main cross-machine compatibility checkpoint * wip: preserve linked research and tool policy identity across main alignment * wip: repair vault authority and keyed MCP configuration replay * test(server): validate credential refusal error envelopes (#566) * fix(peer): render HTML from idle destination contexts (#563) * fix(server): prepare HTML in idle peer resource contexts * docs(map): track the open idle HTML component * fix(orchestration): wake parents for remote pending requests (#531) * fix(orchestration): wake parents for remote pending requests * fix(orchestration): deliver held remote requests when parent waits end * fix(peer): wait for request content before notifying parents * fix(orchestration): catch up requests after remote original completion * test(web): isolate panel keyboard tests from inherited pointer (#575) * fix(peer): attribute remote follow-ups to the completing run (#582) * fix(peer): attribute remote follow-ups to the completing run * docs(map): link remote completion provenance repair * fix(peer): use observed purpose for first remote completion * fix(scheduled-tasks): record refused keyed manual runs as terminal failures A keyed run_scheduled_task_now whose dispatch failed with a typed error and left no native receipt returned outcome_unknown and kept the schedule marked running forever. Record it as the request's failed outcome, release the running reservation, and replay the same failure for the same key. Interrupted or defective dispatches stay outcome_unknown. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(orchestration): accept blank optional answers in remote request admission Remote pending-request answers with expectedRevision rejected a blank or omitted optional choice-only question as an unoffered option. Skip blank optional answers before validating options, matching the message-response path. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(fork): keep one owner for server shard weights #581 registered shardWeights.json under run-groups while the integration already owns it under fork-maintenance; fork-features requires one owner. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(server): weight typed peer effects by their CI time PeerAuthority.typedEffects.workflow.test.ts takes about 197s in a CI shard but was weighted 46.4s, so Test Server 8 exceeded its 10-minute limit. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): reopened parents follow their remote tasks again Archiving a parent ended its remote follower, and nothing restarted it on unarchive, so the reopened parent missed later remote results until a server restart. The follower now stays registered and waits for the parent's unarchive or deletion instead of exiting, so reopening resumes observation without a new entry point or a duplicate follower. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): threads read and answer their own questions again The replacement pending-request service refused every "own" answerer, so a thread reading or answering its own user-input question, or an ordinary full-access MCP client doing so, got capability_denied. Own access is restored for local, non-linked callers on threads not delegated from another environment. Own approvals, dismiss, linked clients and remote delegated children keep their existing refusals. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(web,mobile): remote request cards keep multiline editor answers Remote pending-request cards rendered every custom answer as a single-line field, so a multiline editor prefill displayed and was stored flattened. Editor questions (those with an initialAnswer) now use the Textarea on web and a multiline, newline-submitting field on mobile, as the local paths do. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): keyed pause and resume replay their receipt A keyed update_scheduled_task carries clientRequestId on its input, so the enable-only shortcut never matched: a keyed pause or resume fell through to the full definition update and was refused without a purposeIntent. The shortcut now ignores routing fields, and setEnabled records and replays the keyed mutation receipt like create, update and delete. A retried keyed pause after a later resume replays instead of retiring the newer automation certificate. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): post-admission recheck refusals release keyed manual runs A typed refusal from the recheck after admission, or after the dispatch claim, now records the key as failed and frees the schedule instead of leaving it running. The stage-guarded claim keeps uncertain dispatches outcome_unknown. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(childThreads): stop-disposed remote children stay pending background work A parent interrupt disposes a delegated completion with disposedBy "stop" without stopping the remote child. The sparse SQL remote arm dropped that row while the local arm and pendingDelegatedChildTasks kept it, so shells, auto-settlement and storage cleanup treated the parent as idle. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): final recheck refusals no longer fail a concurrent same-key dispatch The final live recheck ran after the prepared -> dispatching claim and terminalized a refusal from the dispatching stage. For an existing-thread schedule a same-key retry can read dispatching and send concurrently, so the refusal failed the request and freed the schedule while that send was accepted. The final recheck now precedes the claim, so a refusal is only recorded through the prepared-stage compare-and-set. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): finished remote jobs no longer hold back live Stops A lifecycle-v1 follower keeps long-polling its job there after the result, so a later Stop or follow-up is still observed. Each poll held one of the eight shared peer permits for up to 20 s, so more than eight finished jobs starved Stops and live observations of other jobs. Followers whose job has nothing left to do there (result available, no queued runs, questions or recovery wait, or a confirmed Stop) now wait on their own semaphore. Stops, unconfirmed and acknowledged stops, live jobs and follow-ups seen as working keep the existing eight permits. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): stopped remote jobs with new work there keep live permits A confirmed Stop counted a job as settled whatever its latest snapshot said, so fresh direct input on the destination child after the Stop left its follower queued behind idle settled long-polls, also after a restart. A job is now settled only while its latest snapshot is quiet (result available, no queued runs, questions or recovery wait); a confirmed Stop also needs that quiet snapshot. Anything showing activity uses the shared network permits. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 participant
What: Preserve current-main Promachos request answering through #379's verified cross-environment authority and repair the inherited server/client CI consumers.
Why: The aligned base retained the answerer helper but used ancestor-only admission; baseline fixtures and existing client tests depended on removed APIs, incidental shapes or startup replay being mistaken for a live recovery batch.
So what: Fresh Sol and Opus5.5 MEDIUM reviews approve the exact candidate; the parent awaits complete current CI before internal integration, cascade and final cumulative acceptance.
Refs #379 and #532. This component targets
feat/379-cross-machine-parityand does not close the parent. Approved v5 compatibility decision; current complete handoff.PendingRequestServiceowns actual-target resource/mode checks and shared answerer policy for read/respond/dismiss. Verified native/qualified ancestry retains precedence; the existing actual top-level Promachos role otherwise follows main533's ancestor-first rule. Responses persistansweredBy, approval discovery uses the same helper, legacy trusted full-access/default scope remains bounded, and modern grants still apply at the actual destination. Forwarding retains the native caller used to derive the source role. No arbitrary agent/header/client claim becomes authority.The registered two-environment proof uses real production kernels, SQLite, authenticated MCP and peer authority. It covers actual source role, narrow resource refusal, current source mode denial, one concurrent winner, persisted attribution and remote-child parent ownership. Retained #369 tests preserve qualified identity, content/revision atomicity, original/current checks, ordinary approvals, empty choices, replay and human-route isolation.
Baseline reuse is limited to existing owner repairs: published PR534
b9b4596700221922146026665b69d2eafc2dde9fsupplied native resolver/runtime context, Spectrum registry, fixture schedule-purpose/returned-worktree and complete RPC inference hunks. The user's finite stopped383 transfer adds necessary baseline hunks fromd892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7: two formatter repairs, native RunGroups/Spectrum assertions, removed mobile UI/renderer consumers and supported PeerGrantSettings async cleanup. Exactly two additional existing web tests migrate to DOM/browser APIs; actual Chromium fixture adaptations retain observable assertions and use the real button owner. Their additional grant changes no web production source. No #383 feature was imported. Fork inventory retains one owner and registers the renamed test; the map cites539.The finite recovery absorption decision adds only PR537's existing
RecoveryReactor.test.tsblob from preservedfcd3162f740ea5e766fe461d75e0d5d932f84310, originally authored incdd478059c47896aab0eda5ce5422a92496f6eff, and the existing Prism map part's PR539 reference. The test awaits a native EventSink marker's recovery callback before measuring the original four-event batch; the duplicate-recipient assertion and production coalescer remain unchanged. PR537 is draft/preserved, not merged, pending the parent's absorption closure after539lands.Requirements and who asked: User requires approved #379/#532 compatibility, meaningful native/client proof and inherited CI repair, including only the finite existing383 and537 transfers. Final approval PR and topology remain parent-owned.
Deleted: Wholesale overrides, duplicate handler/recovery logic, removed renderer dependency, incidental assertions, sleeps/timeouts, weakened duplicate checks, production coalescer edits, compiler/gate suppressions, unrelated features, version bumps and topology mutations.
Bottleneck: The owned recovery fixture belongs in the lower baseline repair to remove a lower-CI/upper-fix gate cycle. Fresh exact-head Sol+Opus MEDIUM reviews have passed; complete current CI remains the parent's frontier.
Checked myself: Actual main533/source contracts, observed CI/compiler diagnostics, source checkpoint diffs, original recovery red/high-water/faithful mutation/restored evidence, byte equivalence, fresh three-case recovery and scoped checks. Full commands, hashes, failed attempts and limits are in the current handoff.
Current candidate
472e960572ccd6c842869962acd294797e1feff3, tree79e196e151cc3f07a78a5835beaa22ea29eba314, unchanged integration base63c41e7b0ab32460dae0287b448a87c3ac9e8e51. Immediate parent2b9443bae55bb712b6872c0ab75f92976fa2e870; ordinary forward commit and verified push, clean workspace. This delta changes exactly the recovery test and map.Fresh delta validation, task-local Node24.13.1/pnpm11.10.0:
vp test run apps/server/src/prism/RecoveryReactor.test.ts: 3passed, exit0,26.26s.2e2d14ca443d644d64a931cd96ad7d181f79d3d0. Recovery production/direct dependencies and lockfile match preserved537. Of358relative-import files, only previously reviewed PeerAuthority differs after transfer, so original mutation proof remains historical; the current3-case run is fresh. No production mutation was performed.Actual2bCI Server7 job118146648689/run39277877062 completedFAILURE17:32Warsaw with only this known fixture: 1failed/1199passed/2skipped. The stale GraphQL in-progress rollup did not override Actions/log evidence. The original faithful removal of
new Setmade the same duplicate assertion fail; the earlier attempted mutation that restored source before module loading is invalid and not counted. Raw original and current logs are retained and hashed in the handoff.Earlier unchanged-source2bproof remains historical:85server/11native/3mobile/23DOM/23compiledChromium, PeerGrantSettings compiler case, actual server/mobile/web package compilers, scoped lint/format/export/fork checks. Earlier116b's full116-case workflow and other selections also retain their original identities. These checks were not rerun or relabeled a current complete merge gate in this two-path continuation.
Whole2b Sol APPROVE and fresh Opus R3 APPROVE are historical and carry no supported code finding. The Opus R2 guidance omission and its full R3 correction remain in the next review packet. No historical approval transfers to472e. Fresh whole-component Sol APPROVE and Opus5.5 APPROVE independently cover472e. The parent aggregate records fresh/reused/unverified proof and review/independent success on472e. Current Actions run39282401928 still reports all jobs queued with no steps at readiness inspection; cause unknown. Complete CI, internal merge and cumulative acceptance remain separate, unmet gates. No further Grok delay or self-approval.
Website/SEO impact: none, existing compatibility, test synchronization and internal metadata only. No version bump under project policy. No product/dev server, browser/device, live data, grants, deploy/install/restart, rebase/retarget or merge. Other component workspaces remain untouched. Real integrated acceptance and the final approval PR remain parent-owned. Source and Git writing are STOPPED clean on the candidate above.
Implemented with GPT-6.1 Sol, MEDIUM reasoning, through the Codex harness. Existing-source attribution is recorded above and in the complete handoff.