Repository navigation
feat(peer): continue remote delegated jobs and stop later work - #392
Conversation
github-actions
Bot
added
vouch:trusted
Thread transfer impact✅ Thread transfer remains within every enforced ceiling.
Baseline: unavailable · PR result: Scenario and decoded snapshot size10 historical turns, 5 command tools per turn, 878.9 KiB retained MCP result per historical turn, and a 1.05 MiB retained result in the measured turn.
Updated in place by a trusted workflow. PR artifacts are strictly validated and never executed. |
Agent work on this PREstimated cost unknown · 13 responses · 31 sessions · 30.3 h wall time
Flags: 10 large tool outputs · 22 repeated commands · 8 repeated failures · 170 repeated reads · 22 repeated skill loads · 13 unpriced responses Details: snapshot, prices, coverage, counters
Token counters by model (native counter semantics; never added across semantics):
Generated tokens (reasoning and other output are disjoint; other output includes code, tool calls and replies):
Selected rates (USD per million tokens). These rates value the report at the selected schedule date; they do not establish historical prices or subscription spending.
Other output and reasoning are priced without double counting inclusive native output. Missing rates remain unknown. Local measurement from native records; usage totals are not billing. Updated in place by |
|
What: Sol MEDIUM R1 verdict is REQUEST_CHANGES for the exact #381 candidate, with one blocking Stop replay finding. Reviewer: Codex harness, actual runtime Exact reviewed identity:
Blocking finding S1: P1, preserve newer Stop obligations when replaying an older requestLocation: RemoteDelegation.ts:1019-1038, The idempotency check recognizes a request only when its identity equals the single current Reproduction through the actual source service used by
This is a normal delayed/lost-response retry, not a request to stop the later work with the old identity. It can silently lose a deliberate cancellation of later remote/nested work. The source must retain/reconcile historical request identities without replacing a newer obligation, and bind semantics durably at its serialized acceptance boundary. A related source probe also demonstrates that changing an older request's reason after a newer Stop succeeds and overwrites the newer intent instead of rejecting the semantic conflict. Destination conflict checks do not repair this source-state loss. Independent retained reproductions, only in reviewer-owned
Coverage and limitsRead the cumulative 50-file component diff, surrounding authority/Stop/completion consumers, current full #379/#381 bodies/comments and frozen v5 decisions, complete canonical handoff, precise forwarding ownership exception, durable ended-parent Stop decision, and #380 audit/matrix/adjudication. Checked the retained original parent-Stop, terminal-commit paging and source-conflict red evidence. The three-line PeerForwarding exception is respected; no #382 namespace/attachment or #384 private implementation was added. Settled trust/resource-scope decisions are not reopened. Independently ran the candidate's original four-file focused selection: The probes change only a test file in that detached worktree. Production source stays at the exact candidate. Planner/author/canonical source workspaces were not modified. All logs and patches are retained locally; no fix, merge, dependency clearance, Issue closure, build, install or shipment was performed. No final GitHub review or Source-reviewed web/desktop shared and mobile viewer/navigation/guarded Stop integration. Did not drive clients, browser/device UI, live provider processes, live userdata or actual multi-machine topology. Deterministic provider-boundary and effect-worker evidence does not prove live provider interruption. Did not run full CI, broad repository checks, or independently rerun the author's type/lint/knip/native-cancel selections. Those reported runs remain author evidence; actual client/provider/topology acceptance and current aggregate review/CI belong to the parent. #369 response policy, #382 attachments/namespace and #384 autonomy remain future slices. Requirements and who asked: User/parent required this independent exact-candidate MEDIUM read-only #381 review under frozen #379, preserving accepted R1-R8 regressions and both-reviewer coverage. |
|
What: Request changes on exact head Why: Those clicks navigate to B whenever this client is connected there. Only the relationships panel and the mobile agents sheet use the source viewer. So what: Parent relays this REQUEST_CHANGES with the other exact-candidate review. The implementer should send those three opens through the source viewer when Verdict: REQUEST_CHANGES Reviewer: installed Grok 4.7, reasoning effort medium (thread configuration Identity verified read-only in the author worktree, no checkout:
FindingBlocking. Source-only inspection is skipped on three open paths for
Reproduction, from the source (this review did not click the UI; parent owns browser acceptance):
Impact: a connected client reads and can act on B's thread outside the immutable source projection, qualified provenance, and durable source Stop. Unmarked #380 jobs are supposed to keep direct navigation. Negotiated jobs are not. The new pending-work roster makes the banner path apply to continued v1 observation, which is the case this change exists to show. Coverage inspectedServer seams, read at the exact tree: destination stop command id and semantic conflict before dispatch; existing Client seams: relationships panel and mobile agents sheet source-viewer branches; web and mobile viewer components; the three open paths above. Retained worker logs opened, not re-executed by this review:
Historical #380 R1-R8 workflow tests remain in that 88-test file. No new authority hole found on the stop, replay, generation, or actual-target paths that those tests cover. Rejected descendant-environment and hostile-pair designs were not reopened. LimitsThis review did not re-run the suite, did not open a browser, simulator, or device, and did not treat the deterministic stop adapter as live provider death. CI, both-reviewer aggregation, and multi-machine acceptance stay with the parent. A descendant created after |
|
What: Sol MEDIUM R2 verdict is REQUEST_CHANGES on exact head Reviewer: Codex harness, actual runtime Exact reviewed identity, checked against local Git and live PR #392:
Required correction S2: P2, preserve cancellation replay across normal launch attachmentLocation: Orchestrator.ts:7847-7857, especially the A cancellation can lawfully be accepted after the remote launch was sent, while its accepted reply is delayed and the source has not attached Independent reproduction through registered native MCP
The retained source-event query shows that the same Stop request first has a null target and later has the accepted child ID. The assertion fails at the final public retry, after the positive before-attachment retry and actual attachment assertions have passed. Production source remains at the exact candidate. This does not demonstrate that the original Stop is lost or that an additional native Stop runs; the demonstrated defect is permanent false rejection of a lawful retry after normal launch recovery. It also affects the shared source owner used by Keep the durable historical replay protection, semantic-conflict rejection and generation fence. Completing the original accepted launch must remain a valid transition for an already accepted cancellation identity. Retained independent evidence:
R1 repair assessment and cumulative coverageRead the full current #379 and #381 bodies/comments, frozen-v5 contract and proof limits, original and superseding handoffs, both unchanged R1 reviews and author responses, parent adjudication, precise forwarding ownership exception and ended-parent Stop decision. Also read #380's complete final audit, matrix and rejected-design adjudication. Reviewed the cumulative 57-file component diff plus the R2 repair diff and surrounding consumers. S1's older-Stop/newer-obligation scenario is repaired in the exercised scope: history lookup and accepted commit run under the existing parent command lock, historical replay returns without disposing/replacing current intent, changed historical reason rejects, late disposition updates must match the current request, and startup reconstruction retains the newer Stop. The registered fixture exercises concurrent new Stop submissions plus an old replay, internal owner replay, reconstruction, a distinct destination receipt, native effect drain and persisted confirmed state. S2 covers the newly introduced untested transition from an unresolved to an attached target. G1's three reported web/desktop paths now select the source viewer before destination-profile availability. Traced actual transcript/notification consumers and ChatView's banner through the new shared action, plus the item inspector, relationships panel, mobile work-log notification, task group and agents sheet. The 20 web interaction cases click real consuming components, mount the real viewer and observe source-addressed queries/content, with B connected and disconnected; local and unmarked legacy navigation controls remain. UI primitives/query results are substituted, so these are meaningful component/data-routing tests with limited scope. Item-inspector and mobile routing were source-reviewed, not independently interaction-tested here. Checked native Stop owner/receipt dedupe, source durable intent validation, per-hop inherited Stop authority, creation/latest-input contributor conjunction, actual destination/descendant resource and mode checks, claim/retry fences, generation/revocation denial, immutable terminal-COMMIT result paging, legacy persisted import and negotiated marker selection, ordered result delivery and late-result suppression. Independently executed proof and limitsDependency preparation and test writes occurred only in the fresh detached reviewer workspace. Retained probe patches/logs, then restored both test files byte-for-byte from the candidate before the unchanged workflow rerun; the review worktree is clean. No author/planner/canonical source writes, checkout/switch/pull/rebase/reset, product server, browser, device, live userdata, provider process or deployment operations. Initial exact-candidate command:
Result: 109 passed, 1 failed, 6 files, 63.95s, Unchanged full workflow rerun: 42 passed, 1 file, 64.18s, The candidate's original suites and reviewer probes are reported separately. The original six-file run includes the repaired S1 fixture, all 39 RemoteDelegation cases, seven orchestration cases, source-only query/guard test, 20 web consumer cases and native cancellation integration. No independent full CI, type/lint/knip run or actual browser/desktop/mobile/provider/multi-machine acceptance is claimed. A deterministic effect executor and persisted interrupted run do not prove live provider process death. Old-head CI39067969610 is historical. Parent owns current CI, both-reviewer aggregation, integration and actual client/provider/topology acceptance. #369 response policy, #382 and #384 remain their assigned later slices. No final GitHub review, aggregate Requirements and who asked: User/parent requires a fresh independent Sol MEDIUM exact-candidate #381 R2 review of the complete component, both accepted R1 repairs, retained authority regressions and frozen-v5 proof limits. |
|
What: Approve exact head Verdict: APPROVE Reviewer: installed Grok 4.7, reasoning effort medium. Session record Exact reviewed identity, read-only in the author worktree and confirmed on the live PR:
No blocking finding. S1, cleared
The registered control fixture now drives this through the source service, then through a direct G1, cleared
Coverage and limitsRead the R2 diff in full and the cumulative file list. Re-read the Stop dispatch lock, follower Independent run in detached Did not drive a browser, simulator, device, or live provider process, and did not exercise a real multi-machine topology. Did not click the web item inspector or the mobile notification row; those callers were read. Did not rerun typecheck, lint, knip, fork check, or GitHub CI. Prior CI on Requirements and who asked: Parent required this independent exact-candidate Grok 4.7 MEDIUM read-only R2 review under frozen #379/#381. Both R1 findings were in scope. No verdict transfers from |
|
What: Sol MEDIUM R3 verdict is APPROVE on exact head Reviewer: Codex harness, actual runtime Exact identity, verified against local Git and live PR at start and again after proof:
Findings and R3 assessmentNo supported actionable blocking code finding. S2, cleared in the exercised scope. The registered same-credential workflow passed: B accepts the launch while its successful reply is held; the same public native S1 remains repaired. Historical matching replay returns before replacing or disposing the current obligation. Changed historical reason fails; late dispositions must name the current request. The original registered concurrent/newer-intent/reconstruction fixture passed, including distinct native Stop2 receipt, persisted interrupted later work and confirmed Stop2. Destination receipt replay alone leaves independent later work running. Callback compatibility and G1 remain repaired. The shared open hook invokes local/native callbacks with exactly one argument and qualified remote callbacks with two. Necessary #389 ownership exception is respected. Only Cumulative review coverageReviewed the cumulative component source/test changes and R3 repair, with surrounding registration, authority, source acceptance, attachment, native Stop/effect, result and navigation consumers. Read current #379/#381 records and frozen-v5 limits, the complete supplied original/R1/R2/R3 handoffs, BOTH full R1 and R2 reviews with responses, the forwarding/post-parent-Stop decisions, and #380's final authority audit, matrix and rejected-design adjudication. Earlier approvals are historical evidence only. Checked original-result versus launch provenance, immutable terminal-COMMIT result paging, cursor/replay/backpressure and late-result disposal, legacy unmarked import/negotiation, stable destination Stop receipts and semantic conflict, actual authenticated pair/generation checks, typed ended-parent cleanup authority, per-hop inherited obligations, creation/latest-input contributor conjunction, current source and actual-target/descendant modes/resources, and effect claim/retry fences. Existing #380 R1-R8 workflow regressions remain in the passing workflow file. No new authority bypass was found in these inspected paths. The settled explicit-grant/cooperative-server decisions were not reopened without new evidence.
Independent executed proofFresh exclusive detached reviewer worktree: Exact unchanged command from that worktree: pnpm exec vp test run apps/server/src/peer/PeerAuthority.workflow.test.ts apps/server/src/peer/RemoteDelegation.test.ts apps/server/src/orchestration-v2/RemoteDelegatedTask.test.ts packages/client-runtime/src/state/remoteTasks.test.ts apps/web/src/components/chat/V2LifecycleRow.remote.test.tsx apps/server/src/mcp/TaskCancelNativeSubagent.integration.test.ts apps/server/src/auth/SessionStore.test.ts apps/web/src/components/chat/MessagesTimeline.test.tsx --reporter=verboseExit 0: 8 files, 229 tests passed, 65.39s, Opened retained author red outputs for original restoration, real parent Stop first, mutable result paging, semantic conflict and R3 S2/expiry/callback failures. Those retain their original source identities and are not independently rerun baseline claims. Material unresolved proof limitsThe author's two unchanged eight-file combined selections remain FAILED, each 228 passed / 1 failed, not retroactively green:
Both report The original R2 Sol six-file run on No independent full CI, type/lint/knip/fork run, product server, browser, device, live userdata or provider prompts/processes. Deterministic external adapters plus real SQLite/command/event/receipt/outbox/EffectWorker paths prove their scoped observations, not live provider process death. Actual web/desktop/mobile behavior and images, devices/simulators, physical multi-machine topology/restart/upgrade and final outcome acceptance remain parent-owned. Raw transport diagnostics stay private locally and were not uploaded. No aggregate Requirements and who asked: Parent requires a fresh independent Sol MEDIUM exact-candidate review of complete #381 plus R3 S2/callback/expiry repairs, preserving frozen-v5 authority and all prior findings/proof limits. |
|
What: Approve exact head Verdict: APPROVE Reviewer: installed Grok 4.7, reasoning effort medium. Session record Exact reviewed identity, read-only against the author worktree and confirmed on the live PR:
No blocking finding. S2, cleared
The pair row is written by The registered fixture S1 and G1, still holdingThe historical replay still returns without a new event when the first accepted semantics match, so a newer Stop stays the projection.
Expiry, cleared in the authorized issuance owner
Authority fences inspectedRead the R3 diff in full and the cumulative file list. Re-read source Stop acceptance, the parent command lock, launch attachment, Independently executed proof and limitsReview workspace: detached Exact command, from that worktree:
Result: 8 files, 229 tests passed, 64.89s, This pass does not clear the author's two unchanged combined runs on this same source. Those remain 228 passed / 1 failed: Did not drive a browser, simulator, device, or live provider process, and did not exercise a real multi-machine topology. The executor is the deterministic test adapter. Did not rerun typecheck, lint, knip, fork check, or GitHub CI. Current CI remains parent-owned. #369 response policy, #382 attachments, and #384 autonomy stay future slices. #389 remains open for its own acceptance. Requirements and who asked: Parent required this independent exact-candidate Grok 4.7 MEDIUM read-only R3 review of the whole component, the S2 and expiry and web repairs, and the retained R1 and R2 findings. No verdict transfers from |
|
What: Real client acceptance fails on both-reviewed, CI-green 076c6e1 because the running production server does not expose delegated lifecycle routes. Independently observedExact source 076c6e1, tree6761e5bf150fe322a83c77ae9e4d22ff1f3eae84, component baseac4ce6bfdc323d7eeaa53e8888f68bc4ef10ba29. Both full R3 approvals6241597731/6241760370 and CI39071586544 were inspected; exact independent success was initially recorded, then changed to FAILURE at21:58:29UTC after this real acceptance failure. Those reviews remain accurate historical scoped verdicts, not runtime acceptance. Primary used the authorized repository test-t3-app workflow and app Browser panel against fresh isolated homes only. A: reviewed worktree, vp run dev --home-dir /tmp/chromeria-381-acceptance-a, server14247/web6207, terminal71225. B: same source, node apps/server/src/bin.ts --base-dir /tmp/chromeria-381-acceptance-b --port14248 --no-browser, terminal9754. No testkit adapters or direct projection injection. Both endpoints expose real descriptors, isolated SQLite and real installed provider catalog. This is two local environments on Rocky, not physical cross-machine proof. A environment950a38f2-e2a5-4242-9171-c17e0cb8412c and project8b939b61-b567-4f99-9791-a836e6098ec9 at /tmp/chromeria-381-work-a. B environmentef047b58-1edf-4ad6-a1ba-44320188325c and project42f73d00-0cdd-474b-b9f7-819cdb6a386f at /tmp/chromeria-381-work-b. Both disposable directories were initialized as empty Git repositories. Supported CLI paired A to B under isolated full-access consent, no live link or user data changes. Through the real browser A-only connection, selected Codex/gpt-6.1-sol/MEDIUM before first prompt and verified persisted model selection. Fixture parent890ae979-9db3-4d16-a023-5efc71cfb6fe first called remote orchestrator_capabilities successfully and confirmed B Sol MEDIUM support. Its first delegation was blocked by AgentsMD's orchestration-read prerequisite before task creation; same fixture then read the required module and retried the identical key381-parent-browser-fixture-v1. Product call returned OrchestratorMcpFailure code orchestration_error, message The delegated lifecycle operation could not be confirmed. No taskId/remoteChild returned. Read-only source and destination queries show zero subagent tasks and zero return pairs. No child provider started. Fixture parent ended; no pending provider work. Direct GET /mcp/peer-control/tasks on A returns404, B returns503 with No static directory configured and no dev URL set. Both /.well-known/t3/environment return200; ordinary authenticated remote MCP capability discovery works. The lifecycle request is falling through, not reaching expected MCP authentication or v1 response. Source inspection: McpHttpServer.ts1040-1053 resolves optional authority/thread/SQL/outbox dependencies and returns ordinary post/stream routes without task routes when any is absent. Production server.ts755 and runtimeLayer internal layerStores may not export the effect outbox to this composition. Exact missing dependency is a hypothesis for the worker to establish, not yet a verified root cause. Required correction and proofSame existing #381 task resumed ordinal6 by supported t3_thread_send key379-381-real-runtime-route-blocker-repair-v1, returned started; Codex Sol MEDIUM unchanged. Existing server/runtime/global gateway ownership covers the correction. No new competing writer. Worker must reproduce at the production composition seam, establish the missing owner, install the real shared service correctly, retain authenticated fail-closed boundaries and prove real route/launch/attach/observe/Stop-effect paths. A test that manually supplies the missing service while production still omits it is insufficient. Do not weaken authentication or capability negotiation, create a duplicate orchestrator, add speculative future-slice hooks, or misattribute unrelated earlier discovery/native404 failures to this unproved cause. Parent retains both isolated homes, services, browser and private logs for the follow-up. Worker must not start/stop or mutate these resources. Raw server logs contain pairing credentials and fixture conversation text and stay private. Future new candidate needs both NEW independent exact-head/base MEDIUM reviews with all full R1/R2/R3 findings/responses, this parent counterexample and production proof, plus current CI. Parent repeats real client/provider acceptance and owns final topology, integration, migration and cross-machine acceptance. #382/#384 stay stopped, native edges unchanged, no merge/Issue close/ship. Requirements and who asked: User requires every permitted tool and full delegated lifecycle to work natively, with isolated real client/provider acceptance before shipment. |
|
What: Sol MEDIUM R4 verdict is APPROVE on exact head Reviewer: Codex harness, actual runtime Exact identityVerified local Git and live PR at start and after proof:
Findings and production repair assessmentNo supported actionable blocking code finding. The parent's real production counterexample is accepted evidence, not overruled by earlier approvals or CI. Read the complete parent record, including actual A404/B503 fallback, working descriptors/ordinary authenticated capabilities and native delegation failure before any task existed. Reviewed all five repair files, the full cumulative component diff and relevant surrounding consumers, current #379/#381 bodies/comments and frozen-v5 contract, original complete handoff, full R1/R2/R3 findings and author responses, precise forwarding and ended-parent Stop decisions, and #380 audit/matrix/rejected-design adjudication. Actual runtime ownership. Actual service composition and authenticated transport. Regression fidelity and limits. The runtime test fixture's explicit masking Read Preserved cumulative contracts
Independent executed proofFresh exclusive detached reviewer worktree: Exact unchanged candidate selection: pnpm exec vp test run apps/server/src/orchestration-v2/runtimeLayer.test.ts apps/server/src/mcp/McpHttpServer.test.ts apps/server/src/peer/PeerAuthority.workflow.test.ts apps/server/src/peer/RemoteDelegation.test.ts apps/server/src/orchestration-v2/RemoteDelegatedTask.test.ts packages/client-runtime/src/state/remoteTasks.test.ts apps/web/src/components/chat/V2LifecycleRow.remote.test.tsx apps/server/src/mcp/TaskCancelNativeSubagent.integration.test.ts apps/server/src/auth/SessionStore.test.ts apps/web/src/components/chat/MessagesTimeline.test.tsx --reporter=verboseExit 0: 10 files, 335 tests passed, 85.09s, Separately added a reviewer-only HTTP composition probe in the detached worktree, then ran: pnpm exec vp test run apps/server/src/mcp/ReviewR4LifecycleComposition.test.ts --reporter=verboseExit 0: 2 tests passed, 8.12s, Material unresolved proof limitsOpened the decisive retained failure output. The author's R4 four-file selection remains FAILED: 90 passed / 1 failed out of91,
No full repository suite, independent current CI assessment, type/lint/knip/fork rerun, full CLI daemon boot, actual web/desktop/mobile interaction/screenshots, live provider Stop/process-death, physical cross-machine topology or process crash/upgrade/rollback acceptance was executed here. Parent owns current CI and repeated actual product acceptance, both-reviewer aggregation, integration and final topology. No aggregate Requirements and who asked: Parent requires a fresh independent Sol MEDIUM exact-candidate review of complete #381 plus the production wiring repair, preserving frozen-v5 authority and every prior accepted regression and proof limit. |
|
What: Parent actual web/native-provider proof now passes original result, two continuations, server restart, source-only inspection and later-work Stop on 0031306. Exact runtime and isolationHEAD00313067e47a64f1a39ffbbb83ec7fb3e74f601b, tree305d63ed38070ac5b0f382e603eec11425118cf0, component baseac4ce6bfdc323d7eeaa53e8888f68bc4ef10ba29. Actual CLI processes from /Users/rocky/.t3/worktrees/chromeria/feat-381-remote-task-lifecycle, no testkit adapters or projection writes. A home/tmp/chromeria-381-acceptance-a, server14247/web6207; B home/tmp/chromeria-381-acceptance-b, server14248. Both local on Rocky, not physical cross-machine evidence. Browser is app-owned incognito tab_4_c2742435-82bd-4ede-aa32-7d090869baad, connected ONLY to A. No B client profile/token was added. A and B CLI link is isolated, existing live user data and services untouched. A environment950a38f2-e2a5-4242-9171-c17e0cb8412c, project8b939b61-b567-4f99-9791-a836e6098ec9/work/tmp/chromeria-381-work-a; B environmentef047b58-1edf-4ad6-a1ba-44320188325c, project42f73d00-0cdd-474b-b9f7-819cdb6a386f/work/tmp/chromeria-381-work-b. Empty disposable Git projects. Exact Codex/gpt-6.1-sol/MEDIUM selected in UI before first provider run and independently verified in A and B persisted thread model selections. No model fallback or shell agent CLI. Actual flow and persisted evidenceBefore repair, exact076c6e1 real native dispatch failed before task creation and route fell through A404/B503, recorded6241863959. After restart on exact0031306, unauthenticated lifecycle GET returns401 at both servers, preserving authentication. Same request key381-parent-browser-fixture-v1 then succeeds through the real native adapter/app MCP. Source parent890ae979-9db3-4d16-a023-5efc71cfb6fe delegates one visible task. Its source task ID is node:delegated-task:command%3Amcp%3Athread%253A950a38f2-e2a5-4242-9171-c17e0cb8412c%253A890ae979-9db3-4d16-a023-5efc71cfb6fe%3Aremote-delegate%3A381-parent-browser-fixture-v1; source childThreadId remains null. Qualified B child is mcp:launch:client%3A458a1b3e-815e-4c3c-aed1-740133f0e7df:fwd%3A9fc4b828d70782f4263d4519c944652af8e670541331dfe0e1f2911555ce6826. Real B provider ordinal1 returns ORIGINAL_381_REAL_PROVIDER. Two deliberate t3_thread_send continuations to the SAME B child, keys381-real-continuation-1 and381-real-continuation-2, return CONTINUATION_1_381_REAL_PROVIDER and CONTINUATION_2_381_REAL_PROVIDER from ordinals2/3. Automatic source parent wakes arrive and the native task status reports the latest result. Parent independently reads isolated SQLite: task.result and originalResult ordinal1 unchanged, latestResult advances to ordinal3, lifecycleVersion1 persisted, foreign IDs qualified, local childThreadId null. Clicked real transcript Open Subagent action. A's RemoteTaskViewer displays original and latest result plus all three messages/results, remaining on A's route without any B browser connection. At later B work it reports working while retaining original/latest completed result, rather than reporting done. This independently exercises the consumer that R1G1 had missed. Component tests separately cover connected-B, notification, banner, local and legacy controls; this actual pass does not relabel those as independently clicked here. With both test homes showing zero active runs, stopped ONLY retained own A51445/B82684 sessions and restarted same homes/source. Current A terminal2400 and B4369, logs/tmp/chromeria-381-acceptance-a-r4-restart.log and...-b-r4-restart.log. Browser reconnects with its existing A session; reopened source viewer makes a fresh request and preserves original plus latest ordinal3. No reseeding, new task, projection mutation, auth bypass or reverse ordinary link. Later B ordinal4 runs a bounded native command. Parent A turn had already ended. Source viewer Stop records client-stop:fb1056c4-bc12-4617-8468-de05fc8ad33c, destination peer-task-stop:0afc121947b0fb17073ed25d703db2c56c00bf2f2c093cfda8e18fde3d85110d. B run and command item become interrupted, actual delegated-tasks.stop and provider-turn.interrupt effects both succeeded, A stop confirmed, original result unchanged. The initial process-inventory filter did not capture an OS PID, so this first Stop alone does NOT claim OS process death. A NEW explicit continuation starts B ordinal5 with one bounded Python process and the sole permitted fixture witness/tmp/chromeria-381-stop5.pid. This is new deliberate work after Stop, not an old request replay. PID49836 is captured from that process's own witness and verified alive with its exact Python fixture command before UI Stop. Witness mtime22:21:03.633629UTC. A's sending turn completed22:21:04.405UTC. Parent clicks source-view Stop; B run ordinal5 completed as interrupted22:21:29.232UTC, about25.6seconds into the55second process, before natural exit. Immediately after, os.kill(pid,0) reports ProcessLookupError/absent. No manual process kill or pattern cleanup occurred. Before/after witnesses retained/tmp/chromeria-381-stop5-before.json and...-after.json. Second source request client-stop:e894daa0-69f9-4ef5-aa65-68b2ebbe311c is confirmed; destination command peer-task-stop:f489d9a3cf1ca044c2368ae698a1cd563c12c38393f0cf1c4ea68c89d3fd3a20 differs from first. Its exact effect::delegated-tasks.stop and effect::provider-turn.interrupt:provider-turn:provider:codex:native-turn:01a14bf4-3fa2-7b83-bbc8-3c50eb27ec03 both persist succeeded. Source latest result ordinal5 interrupted, original literal remains unchanged, no pending children/queued runs/requests. This is real Codex adapter/process interruption in isolated state; it does not establish other-provider process behavior or nested real-provider interruption. Retained imagesParent saved and visually inspected fixture-only screenshots, with no secrets, then uploaded to the SAME task-owned UNPUBLISHED GitHub draft evidence container. Container remains isDraft=true, never a software release: https://github.com/toolboxmd/chromeria/releases/tag/untagged-cf149e2fe74d54191ae2. Authenticated repository access is required.
Upload completion verified, GitHub asset digests match local SHA256. Images are UI state evidence on0031306, not comparative baseline screenshots on076c6e1. No screenshot assets committed to source. Raw private server logs, native credentials, fixture conversations and unselected screenshots stay local. Remaining gatesBoth NEW R4 reviews and new-head CI remain required. Full #379 integration, physical different-machine/client topology, mobile/simulator, remaining tools and later dependent slices, combined migration/protocol/artifact/activation/live verification remain outstanding. Original unknown native404 and initial link failures remain unknown, not attributed to the outbox fix. No final acceptance, component merge, blocker clearing, Issue closure, release/build/install/shipment is claimed. Parent-owned test homes/browser/resources remain available; worker never operated them. Current evidence is bound to exact source0031306 and existing isolated consent. Requirements and who asked: User requires native delegated lifecycle and real isolated client/provider proof under #379, with both reviews/current CI before delivery. |
|
What: Approve exact head Verdict: APPROVE Reviewer: installed Grok 4.7, reasoning effort medium. Session record Exact reviewed identity, read-only against the author worktree and confirmed on the live PR at the start and again before this comment:
No blocking finding. Production route, cleared in the inspected composition
The registered test builds Prior repairs still holdingR4 does not change the Stop, open, or issuance owners. Independently executed proof and limitsReview workspace: detached Exact commands, from that worktree:
Result: 8 files, 230 tests passed, 68.65s,
Result: 2 files, 105 tests passed, 8.85s, Opened the author's retained red Did not boot Requirements and who asked: Parent required this independent exact-candidate Grok 4.7 MEDIUM read-only R4 review of the whole component plus the five-file production wiring repair, after real acceptance failed on |
|
What: Current #381 CI attempt 1 failed one unchanged composer performance assertion; no lifecycle server or web test failed. Exact head Both required reviews still gate integration: Sol R4 approved in #392 (comment); Grok R4 remains running. Parent actual-runtime/source-client/real-provider proof is #381 (comment), with its explicit remaining combined/machine/mobile/provider limits. Implemented/proved within those limits, not yet accepted, integrated, shipped or activated. Requirements and who asked: #379 requires current CI and both independent MEDIUM reviews. |
|
What: Both required independent MEDIUM reviews approve exact #381 head Sol gpt-6.1-sol MEDIUM: #392 (comment). Grok grok-4.7 MEDIUM: #392 (comment). Both full findings were read; Grok's retained logs independently show 230 component tests and 105 runtime/HTTP tests passed. These do not erase the author's unknown initial discovery failures. Parent's actual CLI, source-browser, continuation/restart and installed Codex Stop/process-death proof on this same head is #381 (comment); its physical-machine/mobile/other-provider/combined limits remain explicit. The notification's failed Check job No merge, blocker clearing, build, shipment or activation yet. #409 retains the original composer timing failure and unknown cause. |
|
What: #381 exact candidate is independently reviewed and current CI is green for internal integration. Base The original attempt-1 unchanged composer timing failure remains unexplained in #409. One unchanged rerun passed; no threshold/source change or further rerun. Transfer measurements pass every enforced ceiling, with no successful main baseline available. Both unknown historical discovery/native404 observations remain on their original evidence; later passes do not assign a cause. The 381 author worktree, isolated A/B acceptance homes/processes, reviewer evidence and dependency installations remain needed by #379 acceptance/rollback and next slices. Internal integration is not terminal finalization. No package version bump, main merge, Issue closure, release/build/distribution/activation or cleanup of protected prior mobile outputs is authorized by this component milestone alone. Requirements and who asked: User-authorized #379 component integration after independent exact-candidate proof/review and CI, preserving one final outcome PR. Agent Observer supported sync and sequential publish both exited 0. Updated cost/gap record: #392 (comment). Its unknown/unplaced/unpriced coverage is not a complete total; no manual attribution or rates were added. |
c8423b4
into
feat/379-cross-machine-parity
* feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime
* feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime
* feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime
* feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime
* feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime
* feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime
* feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime
* feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime
* feat(peer): preserve authority and native returns across environments (#391) * feat(peer): return notices and delegate onward within durable authority * fix(peer): retain authority through queued execution and recovery * fix(peer): preserve active run authority across native operations * fix(peer): retain authority for every accepted run input * fix(peer): check every contributor against the actual target * fix(peer): validate joint work against its actual resource * docs(peer): inventory retained consent seams * fix(peer): remove unused authority helper re-export * fix(peer): bound private output by effective caller modes * fix(ci): weight the measured peer authority workflow * fix(peer): retain effective caller modes during task cancellation * feat(peer): continue remote delegated jobs and stop later work (#392) * feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime * fix(peer): preserve attachment bytes and native request acceptance (#410) * fix(peer): preserve attachment bytes and native request acceptance * docs(peer): link request recovery component review * docs(peer): register attachment recovery review provenance * fix(peer): declare device receipt owner in fork inventory * fix(server): preserve scoped retries and scheduler acceptance * fix(peer): preserve authorized manual admission and saved snapshot replay * fix(peer): preserve native preview capability refusal * fix(attachments): recover exact native discard acceptance * fix(attachments): retain bytes after keyed discard acceptance * fix(preview): reconcile native recording claims before replay * feat(peer): answer remote descendant requests from the source (#416) **What**: Exact #369 candidate42051c passed real source-only web and Codex peer request acceptance, including committed replay after both full CLI servers restarted. **Why**: Independent tests cannot establish that the production composition, real provider callback and source-only client work together. **So what**: The planner accepts this bounded internal component for integration into #379 after a fresh head/base/gate check; combined multi-machine/client acceptance and final shipment remain pending. Requirements and who asked: User #379 mandates native delegated lifecycle and all permitted tools with two MEDIUM reviewers and real isolated client/provider proof. Deleted: No fake provider, direct SQL mutation, injected browser RPC, capability expansion, alternate harness or duplicate callback. Bottleneck: Current candidate integration; #383 shared device authority/discovery and #384/#385/#386 remain outstanding. Checked myself: Primary planner drove actual source A browser, inspected native B events/provider results, restarted both CLI products, replayed exact original request, and reopened the same source-only result. Identity: HEAD42051c47813c354682b80677009b199d86fef1a0, treef9efef2d7df1b8b91ac64b09018386e79ccc1d45, baseab1bf53640e2a6541a2ba9f316839cedf81d4f46. Clean author workspace /Users/rocky/.t3/worktrees/chromeria/feat-369-remote-pending-requests. Both full production servers ran that source, with meaningful copied task-owned history in NEW /tmp/chromeria-369-acceptance-a and -b; old382 homes/evidence remained untouched. Node24.18, A server14247/web7663, B14248, source incognito Browser connected ONLY to A950a38f2-e2a5-4242-9171-c17e0cb8412c. Actual B is ef047b58-1edf-4ad6-a1ba-44320188325c. No live userdata write, new grant, physical device or standalone worker server. Human source-only flow: A actual Codex gpt-6.1-sol/MEDIUM delegated real async B task369-parent-native-question-v1 in existing B project/root. B actual Codex asked request_user_input_async, persisted pending at B sequence288. Primary opened source task viewer from transcript; browser URL stayed A, no B profile. The actual card displayed369 REAL REMOTE QUESTION, ACCEPT_369/DECLINE_369 and disabled Send answer until selection. Primary selected ACCEPT_369 and sent once. B durable request resolved at sequence290, command mcp:request:385bcb2f7e0a7415a3c0d1cda8a0cabb0b7204f83949b505a9f4fe4cb6482210:0, 2026-10-18T10:10:47.347Z. Real provider consumed the answer and completed369_REMOTE_ANSWER=ACCEPT_369. Source returned exact original result and zero pending requests. Not inferred from dispatch acceptance. Agent tool flow: Separate deliberate B task369-parent-native-agent-answer-v1, same explicit Color. Native delegate mode wait returned on real pending question with waitTimedOut:false, requestCount1, actual qualified target/revision334. Source local list{} correctly returned[]; explicit remote descendant list returned its actual request. Native qualified read returned real369 REAL AGENT QUESTION/options/revision334. Source called t3_pending_request_respond with original target/route/expectedRevision334, answers{0:AGENT_ACCEPT_369}, stable key369-parent-agent-response-v1. Initial AND exact retry both returned sequence340. B request has exactly one pending334 and one resolved336 event; real provider completed369_AGENT_RESULT=AGENT_ACCEPT_369. Two B tasks intentionally created, each ordinal1 completed, no duplicate B run. Restart proof: Read-only query found zero preparing/queued/starting/running/waiting runs in A/B. Primary stopped only captured own sessions47643/49402 (exit130), restarted same source and same NEW homes in sessions86505/9639. A actual Codex ordinal34 called ONLY the exact original respond input/key after reconstruction: sequence340 again. Postrestart B has no additional request resolution or provider run. Source previous-agent viewer reopened after both restarts with original human result, real accepted answer and zero pending requests. Actual client screenshot inspected before upload. Evidence: local immutable/raw read-only oracles /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-actual-question-proof.json, /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-native-agent-tool-proof.json, /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-postrestart-proof.json. Full CLI logs /tmp/chromeria-369-acceptance-{a,b}-server.log and -restart.log retained. Native Browser screenshots in existing UNPUBLISHED draft evidence-379, never a public release:   Both fresh exact-candidate independent MEDIUM reviews APPROVE: Sol #416 (comment) and installed Grok4.7 #416 (comment). Full aggregate #369 (comment). Current420 CI39116640008, Fork39116640150 and final fingerprint39116844636 SUCCESS; original canceled fingerprint retained separately. Authenticated newest review/independent SUCCESS by lukemaj. Neither review substitutes for the actual proof above. Full author/R1/R2 packet #369 (comment). Limits: These are TWO isolated Rocky environments, web/source-only browser and actual Codex provider. No physical cross-machine/tunnel/mobile/native desktop/all-provider/real live approval, durable-dismiss or secret acceptance claim. Registered native tests retain their own broader and S1/S2 race/empty-choice proof. Earlier native initialization404 remains UNKNOWN; later tests/CI/actual positives do not diagnose it. Operational verification earlier used invalid exact=true locator syntax and a stale assumed web port; corrected to supported selectors/actual dev-runner7663 without alternate browser or product changes. Cost supported publish #416 (comment) is partial task379 coverage, not complete cost; old unplaced/unpriced usage remains unknown. Background supported sync still pending at this record, not presumed complete. States: implemented YES; current focused/native tests YES under their exact records; BOTH reviewed YES; current CI YES; bounded primary product proof YES; internal integration NOT YET at this record; main merged/build/shipped/activated/live combined acceptance NO. No package bump. All rollback/evidence/workspaces retained under explicit #379 instruction until final acceptance. * fix(client): clarify remote requests and count pending work once * fix(client): make remote request choices readable and accessible * docs(peer): track the remote request client repair * fix(peer): count initial remote work once in sparse shells * feat(device): add typed remote device execution core (#421) * feat(device): execute typed commands across peer links * docs(map): link the typed device core component * fix(device): preserve native authority and typed command semantics * fix(device): recheck authority before native shutdown * wip: preserve native contexts and purpose metadata after main alignment * fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy (#539) * fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy * fix(compat): restore inherited CI consumers Reuse baseline-only repairs from the preserved #383 checkpoint d892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7 under the #379 ownership transfer. Adapt the two web test fixtures for actual Chromium collection without changing production web behavior. * test(prism): absorb native recovery observer fixture Transfer the exact test blob authored in cdd4780 and preserved by PR537 at fcd3162. Await the native observer marker before measuring the live batch; preserve the duplicate assertion and production source. * fix(client): hide remote children from default navigation (#546) * wip: hide remote children from default navigation * wip: register destination navigation component PR * wip: retain user forks with remote provenance * wip: cover phone and alternate sidebar navigation * wip: declare phone and legacy carried upstream edits * feat(peer): keep destination automations authorized offline (#555) * feat(peer): retain destination automation authority offline * docs(peer): link destination authority component PR * wip: repair destination authority recovery and acceptance findings * wip: fence schedule acceptance and preserve live birth permissions * wip: preserve birth permission purpose and split native proof * wip: preserve recovery routes and birth dependency lifetime * wip: retain paired recovery routes through repeated unlink * wip: wake exact automation disable recovery at known expiry * feat(remote): view and control qualified browser and device resources (#534) * wip: combine qualified resources with destination automation * wip: bound mobile returned-resource row height * wip: respect native top safe area for tool resources * wip: preserve current-main cross-machine compatibility checkpoint * wip: preserve linked research and tool policy identity across main alignment * wip: repair vault authority and keyed MCP configuration replay * test(server): validate credential refusal error envelopes (#566) * fix(peer): render HTML from idle destination contexts (#563) * fix(server): prepare HTML in idle peer resource contexts * docs(map): track the open idle HTML component * fix(orchestration): wake parents for remote pending requests (#531) * fix(orchestration): wake parents for remote pending requests * fix(orchestration): deliver held remote requests when parent waits end * fix(peer): wait for request content before notifying parents * fix(orchestration): catch up requests after remote original completion * test(web): isolate panel keyboard tests from inherited pointer (#575) * fix(peer): attribute remote follow-ups to the completing run (#582) * fix(peer): attribute remote follow-ups to the completing run * docs(map): link remote completion provenance repair * fix(peer): use observed purpose for first remote completion * fix(scheduled-tasks): record refused keyed manual runs as terminal failures A keyed run_scheduled_task_now whose dispatch failed with a typed error and left no native receipt returned outcome_unknown and kept the schedule marked running forever. Record it as the request's failed outcome, release the running reservation, and replay the same failure for the same key. Interrupted or defective dispatches stay outcome_unknown. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(orchestration): accept blank optional answers in remote request admission Remote pending-request answers with expectedRevision rejected a blank or omitted optional choice-only question as an unoffered option. Skip blank optional answers before validating options, matching the message-response path. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(fork): keep one owner for server shard weights #581 registered shardWeights.json under run-groups while the integration already owns it under fork-maintenance; fork-features requires one owner. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(server): weight typed peer effects by their CI time PeerAuthority.typedEffects.workflow.test.ts takes about 197s in a CI shard but was weighted 46.4s, so Test Server 8 exceeded its 10-minute limit. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): reopened parents follow their remote tasks again Archiving a parent ended its remote follower, and nothing restarted it on unarchive, so the reopened parent missed later remote results until a server restart. The follower now stays registered and waits for the parent's unarchive or deletion instead of exiting, so reopening resumes observation without a new entry point or a duplicate follower. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): threads read and answer their own questions again The replacement pending-request service refused every "own" answerer, so a thread reading or answering its own user-input question, or an ordinary full-access MCP client doing so, got capability_denied. Own access is restored for local, non-linked callers on threads not delegated from another environment. Own approvals, dismiss, linked clients and remote delegated children keep their existing refusals. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(web,mobile): remote request cards keep multiline editor answers Remote pending-request cards rendered every custom answer as a single-line field, so a multiline editor prefill displayed and was stored flattened. Editor questions (those with an initialAnswer) now use the Textarea on web and a multiline, newline-submitting field on mobile, as the local paths do. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): keyed pause and resume replay their receipt A keyed update_scheduled_task carries clientRequestId on its input, so the enable-only shortcut never matched: a keyed pause or resume fell through to the full definition update and was refused without a purposeIntent. The shortcut now ignores routing fields, and setEnabled records and replays the keyed mutation receipt like create, update and delete. A retried keyed pause after a later resume replays instead of retiring the newer automation certificate. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): post-admission recheck refusals release keyed manual runs A typed refusal from the recheck after admission, or after the dispatch claim, now records the key as failed and frees the schedule instead of leaving it running. The stage-guarded claim keeps uncertain dispatches outcome_unknown. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(childThreads): stop-disposed remote children stay pending background work A parent interrupt disposes a delegated completion with disposedBy "stop" without stopping the remote child. The sparse SQL remote arm dropped that row while the local arm and pendingDelegatedChildTasks kept it, so shells, auto-settlement and storage cleanup treated the parent as idle. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): final recheck refusals no longer fail a concurrent same-key dispatch The final live recheck ran after the prepared -> dispatching claim and terminalized a refusal from the dispatching stage. For an existing-thread schedule a same-key retry can read dispatching and send concurrently, so the refusal failed the request and freed the schedule while that send was accepted. The final recheck now precedes the claim, so a refusal is only recorded through the prepared-stage compare-and-set. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): finished remote jobs no longer hold back live Stops A lifecycle-v1 follower keeps long-polling its job there after the result, so a later Stop or follow-up is still observed. Each poll held one of the eight shared peer permits for up to 20 s, so more than eight finished jobs starved Stops and live observations of other jobs. Followers whose job has nothing left to do there (result available, no queued runs, questions or recovery wait, or a confirmed Stop) now wait on their own semaphore. Stops, unconfirmed and acknowledged stops, live jobs and follow-ups seen as working keep the existing eight permits. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): stopped remote jobs with new work there keep live permits A confirmed Stop counted a job as settled whatever its latest snapshot said, so fresh direct input on the destination child after the Stop left its follower queued behind idle settled long-polls, also after a restart. A job is now settled only while its latest snapshot is quiet (result available, no queued runs, questions or recovery wait); a confirmed Stop also needs that quiet snapshot. Anything showing activity uses the shared network permits. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 participant
What: Remote delegated jobs retain their original result while observing later work, with source-only inspection and durable Stop.
Why: The original follower ended at the first result, and ordinary interactive authority could not stop later destination work once the parent had stopped.
So what: This internal #381 component targets
feat/379-cross-machine-parity; the parent owns both fresh exact-candidate reviews, CI acceptance, integration and real client/provider acceptance.Related #381 and parent #379. Approved frozen v5 contract and design. The canonical implementation/proof handoff records selected authority decisions, retained red/green evidence, exact checks, compatibility boundaries, ownership and limits. This PR does not close #381 or establish final #379 acceptance.
Typed operations extend the authenticated pair/control path. Destination persisted terminal events supply ordered replay, acknowledgement, bounded pages and truthful nested/queued/recovery state. Source reconciliation preserves original task results, qualifies actual original/latest real runs, and uses existing completion/question/delivery owners. New negotiated jobs can be inspected through the source connection from web, desktop and mobile; unmarked #380 jobs retain their original read/wait/direct-navigation behavior.
Stop persists an exact source obligation, executes the existing native destination Stop owner with a stable command, and distinguishes acceptance from settled effects. Only this named operation tolerates the parent run ending because of Stop. Current grants, original generation, frozen/all-contributor ceilings and actual destination/descendant checks remain enforced through native claim/retry and each B-to-C hop. Replays reconcile committed receipts without stopping later independent work.
The only #382 ownership exception is three added lines in
PeerForwarding.ts: an optional expectedLinkIdentity argument passed through the existing forwarding owner. No request namespace rewrite, private attachment/receipt implementation, scheduler/Spectrum work or speculative consumer hooks.R1 corrections: historical Stop request identity and semantics are accepted under the parent dispatch lock against durable event history, so old receipt retries cannot displace a newer obligation. Transcript, notification, background-banner and inspector opens now select the negotiated source viewer before considering B's connection; mobile notification opens follow the same guard. Local and unmarked legacy navigation are preserved. Both complete original R1 REQUEST_CHANGES findings and author responses are retained in the handoff; fresh exact-candidate reviews remain required.
R3 corrections: an already accepted Stop now reconciles normal null-to-child attachment only when the original launch identity and authenticated registered return pair prove that child and generation. Historical reason/task/environment/generation/launch fences and newer-obligation preservation remain. Local callback arity is restored without weakening the established MessagesTimeline assertion. Newly issued session expiry is capped at the existing year-9999 sentinel under the explicitly authorized SessionStore ownership exception; #389 remains open. No existing session rows or date predicates are rewritten.
R3 historical proof and material limit: deterministic S2 and real issuance red/green pass, full MessagesTimeline89 and source-view20 pass, all43 authority workflows including original-session destination-reader reconstruction pass, and all29 SessionStore cases pass. Both current combined eight-file commands finished228 passed/1 failed out of229, each failing a different RemoteDelegation case at INITIAL peer discovery before its behavior; cause remains unknown. An unchanged isolated case and diagnostic full RemoteDelegation39 run pass. These are scoped passes across runs, NOT a combined229-test green run or CI acceptance. Affected server/web types, scoped lint/format/knip and postcommit fork check pass. Every exact command/result, initial reviewer404 unknown, both full R2 reviews, historical R1 records/responses and limits are in the current handoff.
Actual browser/desktop/mobile behavior, before/after images, real provider process death and multi-machine topology are unverified here and reserved for the parent after integration. Registered transport/SQLite/native-effect tests use deterministic external runtime adapters. No product server, device, live userdata, release or version bump. The automatic Agent Observer summary reports estimated cost unknown; no manual price estimate is supplied.
Requirements and who asked: Parent-approved frozen #379/#381 outcome and explicit lifecycle, durable Stop and compatibility decisions.
Deleted: Generic reverse RPC, duplicate orchestration, public capability assertions, rival namespace, speculative #382/#384 hooks and raw-mode privileges.
Bottleneck: Exact persisted Stop authority after the originating parent ends, including native recovery and destination-local descendant propagation.
Checked myself: Complete authored diff/callers self-review, retained registered/persisted failing-before evidence, final affected tests/types/lint/knip/format/fork checks; independent and live acceptance remain parent-owned.
Implementation: gpt-6.1-sol, MEDIUM reasoning, Codex harness in T3 Code.
R4 corrects the production composition found during parent actual client acceptance: RuntimeLayer exports its existing effect outbox; server.ts requires construction of the lifecycle service; transport consumes it and advertises version1 only when present. The production-kernel regression no longer injects the missing outbox and covers authenticated registered native delegation/attachment/source view plus persisted Stop pending-to-settled and native effect drain. Existing auth and authority policies stay unchanged.
Current proof: runtime/HTTP105 pass; authority workflows44, orchestration7 and native-cancel1 pass. The four-file lifecycle selection is FAILED90/91 because one RemoteDelegation initial link returned not_a_t3_environment before delegation; cause remains unknown. Unchanged standalone RemoteDelegation39 and final production-kernel native regression pass. Server types, five-file lint/format, server knip and postcommit fork check pass. These are scoped results, not full CI or actual product runtime acceptance.
Current review candidate:
00313067e47a64f1a39ffbbb83ec7fb3e74f601b, tree305d63ed38070ac5b0f382e603eec11425118cf0, baseac4ce6bfdc323d7eeaa53e8888f68bc4ef10ba29. Clean push verified. Complete R4 handoff retains exact commands/results, parent runtime counterexample, BOTH WHOLE R3 reviews and mandatory prior R1/R2 full findings/responses/authority records. Both R3 approvals and old CI are historical. Parent owns BOTH fresh exact-candidate MEDIUM reviews, current CI, actual product client/provider proof and final acceptance. No merge/close/shipment claim.