Remove hardwired backoffs (#51)

src/Equinox/Equinox.fs

@@ -69,8 +69,11 @@ type ICategory<'event, 'state> =
         -> events: 'event list * state: 'state
         -> Async<Storage.SyncResult<'state>>
 
+/// Defines a hook enabling retry and backoff policies to be specified
+type IRetryPolicy = abstract member Execute: log: ILogger * attemptNumber: int *  call: Async<'T> -> Async<'T>
+
 // Exception yielded by Handler.Decide after `count` attempts have yielded conflicts at the point of syncing with the Store
-exception FlowAttemptsExceededException of count: int
+exception MaxResyncsExhaustedException of count: int
 
 /// Internal implementation of the Store agnostic load + run/render. See Handler for App-facing APIs.
 module private Flow =
@@ -92,25 +95,14 @@ module private Flow =
         member __.State = snd __.Memento
         member __.CreateContext(): Context<'event, 'state> =
             Context<'event, 'state>(fold, __.State)
-        member __.TryOrResync attempt (log : ILogger) eventsAndState =
+        member __.TryOrResync (retryPolicy : IRetryPolicy) (attemptNumber: int) (log : ILogger) eventsAndState =
             let resyncInPreparationForRetry resync = async {
-                // According to https://github.com/EventStore/EventStore/issues/1652, backoffs should not be necessary for EventStore
-                // as the fact we use a Master connection to read Resync data should make it unnecessary
-                // However, empirically, the backoffs are needed in app code and hence need to live here for now
-                // TODO: make each store inject backoffs iff necessary
-                // See https://github.com/jet/equinox/issues/38
-                if attempt <> 1 then
-                    match Backoff.defaultExponentialBoundedRandomized (attempt-2) with
-                    | None -> ()
-                    | Some ms ->
-                        log.Information("Resync backoff for {Ms}", ms)
-                        do! Async.Sleep ms
-                let! streamState' = resync
+                let! streamState' = retryPolicy.Execute(log, attemptNumber, resync)
                 tokenAndState <- streamState'
                 return false }
             tryOr log eventsAndState resyncInPreparationForRetry
         member __.TryOrThrow log eventsAndState attempt =
-            let throw _ = async { return raise <| FlowAttemptsExceededException attempt }
+            let throw _ = async { return raise <| MaxResyncsExhaustedException attempt }
             tryOr log eventsAndState throw |> Async.Ignore
 
     /// Obtain a representation of the current state and metadata from the underlying storage stream
@@ -124,7 +116,7 @@ module private Flow =
     /// 2a. if no changes required, exit with known state
     /// 2b. if saved without conflict, exit with updated state
     /// 2b. if conflicting changes, retry by recommencing at step 1 with the updated state
-    let run (sync : SyncState<'event, 'state>) (maxSyncAttempts : int) (log : ILogger) (decide : Context<'event, 'state> -> Async<'result * 'event list>)
+    let run (sync : SyncState<'event, 'state>) (retryPolicy: IRetryPolicy, maxSyncAttempts : int) (log : ILogger) (decide : Context<'event, 'state> -> Async<'result * 'event list>)
         : Async<'result> =
         if maxSyncAttempts < 1 then raise <| System.ArgumentOutOfRangeException("maxSyncAttempts", maxSyncAttempts, "should be >= 1")
         /// Run a decision cycle - decide what events should be appended given the presented state
@@ -140,7 +132,7 @@ module private Flow =
                 do! sync.TryOrThrow log (events, ctx.State) attempt
                 return outcome
             else
-                let! committed = sync.TryOrResync attempt log (events, ctx.State)
+                let! committed = sync.TryOrResync retryPolicy attempt log (events, ctx.State)
                 if not committed then
                     log.Debug "Resyncing and retrying"
                     return! loop (attempt + 1)
@@ -151,10 +143,10 @@ module private Flow =
 
     /// Internal implementation providing a handler not associated with a specific log or stream
     /// Not 'just' making it public; the plan is to have Stream.Handler represent the public interface until further significant patterns present
-    type HandlerImpl<'event, 'state>(fold, maxAttempts) =
+    type HandlerImpl<'event, 'state>(fold, maxAttempts, retryPolicy) =
         let execAsync stream log f = async { let! syncState = load fold log stream in return! f syncState }
         let exec stream log f = execAsync stream log <| fun syncState -> async { return f syncState }
-        let runFlow stream log decideAsync = execAsync stream log <| fun syncState -> async { return! run syncState maxAttempts log decideAsync }
+        let runFlow stream log decideAsync = execAsync stream log <| fun syncState -> async { return! run syncState (retryPolicy,maxAttempts) log decideAsync }
 
         member __.Decide(stream : IStream<'event, 'state>, log : ILogger, flow: Context<'event, 'state> -> 'result) : Async<'result> =
             runFlow stream log <| fun ctx -> async { let result = flow ctx in return result, ctx.Accumulated }
@@ -187,15 +179,16 @@ module Stream =
     let ofMemento (memento : Storage.StreamToken * 'state) (x : IStream<_,_>) : IStream<'event, 'state> = InitializedStream(x, memento) :> _
 
 /// Core Application-facing API. Wraps the handling of decision or query flow in a manner that is store agnostic
-type Handler<'event, 'state>(fold, log, stream : IStream<'event, 'state>, maxAttempts : int) =
-    let inner = Flow.HandlerImpl<'event, 'state>(fold, maxAttempts)
+type Handler<'event, 'state>(fold, log, stream : IStream<'event, 'state>, maxAttempts : int, ?retryPolicy) =
+    let retryPolicy = defaultArg retryPolicy ({ new IRetryPolicy with member __.Execute(_log, _attemptNumber, f) = async { return! f } })
+    let inner = Flow.HandlerImpl<'event, 'state>(fold, maxAttempts, retryPolicy)
 
     /// 0. Invoke the supplied `decide` function 1. attempt to sync the accumulated events to the stream 2. (contigent on success of 1) yield the outcome.
-    /// Tries up to `maxAttempts` times in the case of a conflict, throwing FlowAttemptsExceededException` to signal failure.
+    /// Tries up to `maxAttempts` times in the case of a conflict, throwing MaxResyncsExhaustedException` to signal failure.
     member __.Decide(flow : Context<'event, 'state> -> 'result) : Async<'result> =
         inner.Decide(stream,log,flow)
     /// 0. Invoke the supplied _Async_ `decide` function 1. attempt to sync the accumulated events to the stream 2. (contigent on success of 1) yield the outcome
-    /// Tries up to `maxAttempts` times in the case of a conflict, throwing FlowAttemptsExceededException` to signal failure.
+    /// Tries up to `maxAttempts` times in the case of a conflict, throwing MaxResyncsExhaustedException` to signal failure.
     member __.DecideAsync(flowAsync : Context<'event, 'state> -> Async<'result>) : Async<'result> =
         inner.DecideAsync(stream,log,flowAsync)
     /// Low Level helper to allow one to obtain the complete state of a stream (including the position) in order to pass it within the application

src/Equinox/Equinox.fsproj

@@ -10,7 +10,6 @@
   </PropertyGroup>
 
   <ItemGroup>
-    <Compile Include="Infrastructure.fs" />
     <Compile Include="Equinox.fs" />
   </ItemGroup>