Tags · hyphanet/plugin-WebOfTrust

build0019

Web of Trust Version 0.4.5 build0019

------------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK (detailed changelog is below):

As the previous build was mostly new code to improve performance, the
main focus of this release shall be bugfixes, UI improvements and many
new tools for developers.
Alternating between new code and maintenance hopefully guarantees the
quality of the codebase to flourish.
To not give you a boring release without apparent changes, the build
also ships a bugfix / optimization of startup time and a minor general
performance improvement. There are 4 new translations and 12 updated
ones.

For developers, there is a special goodie available: I have released
my bachelor's thesis about last year's WoT performance work.
The thesis contains a large introduction which explains how WoT works.
As it is intended for an audience with no prior Freenet-related
knowledge, it shall be considered as the WoT core developer's manual.
There are also open algorithmic questions outlined in the thesis - so if
you want to do some computer science, please have a look at it, feedback
is welcome.
There are also:
- new command line operations.
- unit test framework improvements, most notably code to analyze test
coverage.
- a simplification of an on-disk fileformat.

Outlook for the next build: The missing piece in the "first round" of
the most promising performance improvements is planned to ship in the
next build:
Currently, WoT creates an USK subscription for all of the known
identities, which amounts to over 14 000. This puts very heavy load on a
typical Freenet node.
The fix will address this by only subscribing to the identities which
the user has assigned trust to. The other identities will only be
fetched "on-demand" when WoT learns by gossip that they surely have
published a new edition.
For details of the planned algorithm, see:
https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=3816

In other news:
Please excuse that this release took very long to be developed.
I've been a volunteer since December and thus currently cannot provide as
much time as I could when I was being an employee.
This is because Freenet had run out of money. Luckily we've recently got a
donation which will fund 1 year of development. I have not got a different job
at the hope of being able to return to Freenet, so if the community decides to
allow me to continue being an employee, I'll do my best to provide more
frequent WoT releases again :)
And even if not, I'll cut down the target size for the upcoming release: This
release was planned to resolve 12 issues, and it ended up having to resolve
31. So the next release will be aimed at ~ 6 issues to take less time.

If you want to help the project to avoid a half-a-year funding gap from
happening again, please consider donating:
https://freenetproject.org/
Scroll down to see the fundraising progress bar.
Bitcoin is also accepted in case you want to stay semi-anonymous!

HOW TO INSTALL:

While this release has not yet been bundled with a new Freenet
release, it can be acquired a lot easier than previous non-bundled
ones:
1) Unload the "WebOfTrust" plugin and load the "WebOfTrust Testing
Versions" plugin. Please do first read the description for the
security implications!
WARNING: When sending data to the network, WoT will include which
version you are using. Thus, if you are a very early tester, it may
become easier for attackers to correlate which identities belong to
you, as there may be very few people using the new release.
2) If you had already done step 1 previously, i.e. are already running
a previous testing release, you need to restart Freenet or unload
and re-load the plugin for getting the update: Freenet will only
check for updates of the testing version when the plugin is
restarted.
You will also get this release someday even if you do not switch to the
testing versions. It will just take longer: Non-testing releases are
shipped together with regular Freenet releases; and Freenet releases do
not happen as often as WoT releases.

CHANGELOG - prefixed with the bugtracker issue number:

- 0006653: [Bugs] IdentityFileProcessor can get triggered during early
startup, slows it down (xor)

The previous build's changelog promised an improved startup time of
WoT of 2 minutes.
Unfortunately, in practice, a bug could cause this to become over 20
minutes.

This bug has been fixed, and startup times of 2 minutes should in fact
be possible now.

This is of course still too much. The next build's work shall reduce
this to almost zero startup time.
See https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=3816

- 0006663: [Performance] Enforce maximum numer of trust values when
importing trust lists (xor)

When WoT uploads trust lists to the network, there is a limit of 512
trust values. If you set more trust values than 512, only 512 of them
will be exported.

Unfortunately, this limit was not enforced when importing trust lists
which were downloaded from the network. Thus, a malicious user could
upload trust lists with much more trust values to conduct a denial of
service attack on the network.
Luckily, this was not a real security issue, since there was still
an indirect limit:
The file size of trust lists was properly limited to 1 MB.
Still, a lot of trust values can fit in 1 MB, which is why this caused
noticeable performance issues.

This build fixes import to ignore trust lists with more than 512
entries.
This could have an impact on 3rd party clients such as LCWoT: If they
only ever produce trust lists that large, their identities will be
ignored by WoT.
Thus, if you're an author of a 3rd party client, please fix it to
limit the amount of exported trust values to 512.

- 0006648: [Performance] StatisticsPage: Add statistics to monitor
worst case runtime of new distrust computation (xor)

The previous release delivery a rewrite of the core WoT algorithm to
be fully incremental. This was subject of the bachelor's thesis which
this build ships as PDF.
While the algorithm shows a sufficiently quick average runtime, the
mathematical theory indicates a potential worst case runtime which
would not be acceptable.
It is unclear whether and how often the worst case will happen with
the real network - this depends a lot on the network topology and
usage patterns.
To investigate whether further optimization of the algorithm would be
worthwhile, this build adds statistics to measure how often the worst
case happens during normal operation of WoT.

If you want to help this investigation, please provide the following
statistics from the "Community / Statistics" menu:
- Number of incremental trust value re-computations due to new
distrust
- Number of incremental trust value re-computations due to new
distrust - only of those which took more than 10 seconds
- Average seconds for incremental trust value re-computation due to
new distrust
- Average seconds for incremental trust value re-computation due to
new distrust - only of those which took more than 10 seconds

Please ensure your WoT has been running for at least a day before you
provide the stats. Ideally keep it running for as long as you can.
Thank you!

- 0006722: [Security] Improve captchas by randomization (bertm)

Existing captchas were insecure: cracking was possible in under 1
second on an average PC, without the use of any advanced techniques,
by means of best pattern match incremental generation.

This fix introduces a new WordRenderer and GimpyEngine for the
Kaptcha library that randomize:
- Horizontal inter-glyph separation
- Vertical glyph alignment
- Glyph rotation
- Twirl filter parameters (angle)
- Ripple filter parameters (amplitude, wavelength)
- Water filter parameters (centre, radius)

Efforts have been made to keep the captchas readable by humans. The
resulting captchas should not be much harder to read, but are far more
difficult to crack by means of simple pattern matching.

Also, for developers, code has been added to create arbitrary amounts
of captcha JPG files on disk to examine what the captchas look like.
See JavaDoc of function main() of class CaptchaFactory1.

- 0006816: [Usability] Update translations from Transifex, add new ones (xor)
0006817: [Bugs] Fix Norwegian Bokmål and Portuguese (Brazil)
translations to work (xor)

New translations:
Croatian
Bokmål (Norwegian)
Portuguese as spoken in Brazil
Portuguese as spoken in Portugal

Huge thanks to the many translators on Transifex!

- 0006569: [Usability] L10n: Backport improvements at German l10n to
English (xor)
0006570: [Usability] L10n: Instead of "Trust" / "Score", use "Trust"
and "Computed trust" (xor)
0006214: [Usability] L10n: Get rid of technical terms "Insert /
Request URI" (xor)
0006568: [Usability] L10n: Instead of "contexts", use "services"
(xor)
0006565: [Usability] Statistics page l10n: "Average time for full
score re-computation" string lacks unit (seconds) (xor)
0004901: [Usability] L10n: Fix glitches (xor)
0006409: [Usability] L10n: when logged in the option “Create new
Identity” seems strange. (xor)
0006818: [Usability] Process issues on Transifex (xor)

In the last release, the German translation had received a full review
& revamp. As I'm German, this means that it can be considered a
reference translation now.
Due to the large amount of improvements, it was decided to not
immediately port them to English in the previous release.
Thus this WoT release now ships the same improvements to the English
l10n.

The amount of improvements would be too large to explain here.
You can check the differences on GitHub: freenet:build0018...freenet:3aff914346079760fa2e5921c30633e6f44c49a0

Click "Files changed", then "39 changed files", then
"src/plugins/WebOfTrust/l10n/lang_en.l10n".

- 0006812: [Features] wotutil.sh: Allow usage of FCP API (xor)

build0018 had added "wotutil.sh" as a new command line user interface
for offline use of WoT databases, i.e. without running WoT in a
Freenet node.
It allows analytics and maintenance operations.

The tool now supports using most of the WoT FCP API on the terminal.
As FCP is the intended main API for building applications on top
of WoT, this allows usage of most of the WoT API on the terminal.
"Most of" means that the event-notifications FCP message "Subscribe"
is not supported. This is necessary because "Subscribe" is
asynchronous, i.e. the replies will be delivered in the future.
wotutil.sh bypasses the network layer, so asynchronous replies are not
possible.

Please do notice that this does *not* allow connecting to a WoT
running inside of Freenet. It instead allows simulating FCP by
directly loading the data from a closed WoT database on disk.

- 0006651: [Bugs] "wotutil.sh -testAndRepair" says "Database OK!" if
the database file did not exist, should fail (xor)

build0018 had added "wotutil.sh" as a new command line user interface
for offline use of WoT databases, i.e. without running WoT in a
Freenet node.
It allows analytics and maintenance operations.

The "-testAndRepair" command checks the database for inconsistencies.
Unfortunately, it had a bug which caused it to consider the database
file not existing as "the database is healthy!".
This has been fixed to show an error message now.

- 0006640: [Bugs] KnownIdentitiesPage: IndexOutOfBoundsException when
searching (xor)

On the 'Other people's identities' page, the search function could
cause an error due to an IndexOutOfBoundsException.
This has been fixed.

- 0006596: [Bugs] Add workaround for db4o bug (xor)

This fixes potentially showing wrong information on the last page of
the "Other people's identities" menu (previously "Known anonymous
identities").

It is difficult to say whether this did happen in practice, it was
triggered by a db4o bug which is too complex to justify doing an
analysis of when it would happen.
If it did happen, it should at least have only affected the UI, not
the actual database contents.

If you are a developer and have assertions enabled, it also fixes
AssertionError happening on that page. Notice that assertions slow
down WoT very much, so you should only enable them for test runs.

CHANGELOG about stuff only interesting for developers:

- 0006840: [Code quality] Provide xor's WoT bachelor thesis as a
developer's manual (xor)

My past year's Freenet work of improving the core algorithm of WoT had
been recycled into my bachelor's thesis.
It did pass examination by the university, and now is contained in the
WoT source code at:
developer-documentation/core-developers-manual/
OadSFfF-version1.2-non-print-edition.pdf

Besides explaining last year's work, it has another purpose:
Since the thesis aims to require no prior Freenet-related knowledge,
it provides a pretty thorough explanation of how WoT works.
Thus, you may consider it as the WoT core developer's manual.

Beyond getting to know how WoT works, it would be of scientific
benefit for the project if you do read it:
The end of the thesis describes how the algorithm might be further
improved by investigating what can be considered as a whole class of
algorithms. I have not heard about such a class of algorithms being
identified and named by science yet. But this might be merely due to
lack of my knowledge.
So I hope that someone knows if this class of algorithms has already
been discovered and analyzed by other people. This could help us a lot
to further improve WoT with algorithms which are specially crafted to
be fast at this type of problem.
EDIT: Meanwhile, Bert Massop already remarked that this may very well
be the class to solve the "dynamic single-source shortest-paths
problem"! There may still be some benefit in thinking about this
though, as the paper he cited sounds like there could still be better
solutions to the problem than what it provides. The paper is called:
Roditty, L., & Zwick, U. (2011). On dynamic shortest paths problems.
Algorithmica, 61(2), 389-401.

Feedback for improvement of the document is welcome:
Besides some layout changes it is still identical to what I handed in
at university.
Thus, it may contain many stupid mistakes caused by pre-deadline
caffeine intoxication.

- 0006849: [Code quality] Allow Java 7 features to be used in the code
(xor)

Freenet build 1473 switched from Java 6 to Java 7 as the minimal
required Java version. As a consequence, this now also applies to WoT.

As a positive consequence, developers can now benefit from the new
language features and API of Java 7.

- 0006861: [Code quality] Ant builder: Support analyzing test coverage
with Cobertura (xor)

Cobertura is a tool which injects its own code during the unit tests
to analyze which code of the WoT core is called during test runs.
This yields HTML output which contains things such as:
- a view of the source code with the lines being color-coded as:
red = untested, green = tested.
- a percentage of how many lines of code are covered by the tests.
- a percentage of how many code paths (if() etc) are covered by the
tests.
- bonus (static?) analysis: the "average McCabe's cyclomatic code
complexity for all methods." = average number of code paths. This
can be used to find giant functions which need to be split up.
- the above statistics both for the whole repository and also for each
package and class.

I've amended the Ant builders of fred and Web of Trust to optionally
use Cobertura and provide the HTML output at ./test-coverage/html.

As dependency you only need to install the standard Ubuntu "cobertura"
package. Alternatively, put a cobertura.jar into /usr/share/java/
It can then be executed by:
ant -Dtest.coverage=true
You can also compute test coverage as caused by only a specific single
unit test class:
ant -Dtest.coverage=true -Dtest.class=packageName.ClassName

For fred, the code is pending as a pull request:
hyphanet/fred#553

Here are the current analysis results for fred and WoT:
Summary of analysis:
Freenet core: http://i.imgur.com/xTuZwBv.png
Web of Trust: http://i.imgur.com/tdfcM0J.png

Detailed HTML output (you need Freenet for those links):
Freenet core: http://127.0.0.1:8888/CHK@ukoL~NGt6t0p9VRJ7RATO0vxlGVr0mBvL0qB164A4Y8,DbjfwdzSP7hDN11-s20k79tRURobCRtyZyVGppVH1ZY,AAMC--8/test-coverage-fred_testing-build-1474-pre1-122-g5baa142/index.html
Web of Trust: http://127.0.0.1:8888/CHK@vw18zCPqOdqfT5yLekpJjGVJlEzMLgCYJdLf8w34Cmw,bfQZ1je7uBpP1BzJqPYC7kr7oZ7KV5FrVk40Vw967cs,AAMC--8/test-coverage-WebOfTrust-build0019/index.html

- 0006760: [Code quality] Use Travis CI (nextgens, xor)

Travis CI is a cloud service which does the following when a developer
files a new pull request:
- It runs the unit tests on the branch the developer submitted.
- It does a temporary merge of the submitted branch into the target
branch and also runs the unit tests there.
This is the "CI" part: Continous integration means continous
testing of whether the branches of multiple developers integrate
cleanly into the main repository.
- The test runs are done on multiple JREs:
* Oracle Java 7
* Oracle Java 8
* OpenJDK 7
- The success/failure of the test runs are shown at GitHub in the pull
request. The log files can also be viewed.
- The tests are repeated if you push new commits to the branch.

Not only does this enforce that unit tests are monitored, but it can
also help developers with slow computers or lack of JUnit:
If you cannot run the tests yourself, you may submit a pull request
marked as "don't merge yet" just to get the test results.
In my experience, GitHub even triggers Travis CI as soon as you open
the site for creating a pull request. Thus you don't need to submit it
immediately if you first want to check for test failures.
Travis CI notably is a widely used service, so Google may help you
with plenty of documentation about things such as how to trigger more
test runs.

- 0006815: [Code quality] l10n: Add config for Transifex command line
tool "tx" (xor)

Translations nowadays are being managed on a collaborative website:
https://www.transifex.com/

They offer a command line tool called "tx" for downloading and
uploading translations. The tool is open source and available in
package management of Ubuntu for example.
Hence a configuration file for the tool was added to the WoT
repository. It can be found in the ".tx" directory where tx expects
it.

To use the tool, it is recommended to use the "transifex-pull" script
from our scripts repository: https://github.com/freenet/scripts
Please make sure to first read the manual at the beginning of the
tool's Python source code.

- 0006846: [Code quality] Use a human readable file format for
serializing Identity XML files to disk (ArneBab, xor)

The core network traffic of WoT is upload and download of "Identity
XML files". These contain things such as the name of your identity,
the applications it uses (Sone, Freemail, etc.), and the trust values
you have chosen to publish.
WoT downloads those files for all known and trusted identities.

As download from the network is usually faster than processing the
files, they will be queued to disk before processing.
Class IdentityFileDiskQueue can be configured to archive the files
after processing so they can be used for scientific or debugging
purposes. For example, you can run an offline instance of WoT and feed
its Identity file queue with previously archived files to reproduce
bugs.

To ease those developer purposes, the format of the files has been
changed from Java serialization to a human readable file format.
The file format is based on fred's class SimpleFieldSet, which is the
foundation of the Freenet client protocol (FCP). Thus, if a FCP
library is available in your favorite programming language, it shall
be easy for you to write a parser for the new file format.

For an explanation of the file format, see: https://github.com/freenet/plugin-WebOfTrust/blob/3aff914346079760fa2e5921c30633e6f44c49a0/src/plugins/WebOfTrust/IdentityFile.java#L22-L70
For an explanation of how to repeat test runs using the queue, see: https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=6873
For FCP libraries in various programming languages, see: https://wiki.freenetproject.org/Projects

Thanks to ArneBab for making me realize this feature is a good idea!

- 0006557: [Code quality] Ant: Builder silently won't run unit tests if
there is no JUnit installed, should instead abort with error
message (xor)

When compiling WoT with the standard command line "ant", it will not
only compile, but also by default run the unit tests.
As new developers typically have different machines than the existing
ones, this gives us a good feedback on whether the tests succeed in
different environments.

Unfortunately, new developers are also likely to forget installing
JUnit 4 and Hamcrest, which are the requirement for the tests.

If the dependencies were not found, the old code just didn't run the
unit tests then, there was no error message - a rather severe
breakage :(
It will abort the whole compilation now.
Thus, if you want to ensure good testing of WoT, please consider
checking whether the unit tests do run now.

If you want to skip the tests, use "ant -Dtest.skip=true".

- 0006588: [Code quality] Unit tests: Check
WebOfTrust.verifyDatabaseIntegrity() when finished (xor)

This is a test which checks whether the contents of the database
match the database schema.
It verifies not only structural integrity, but also semantic
correctness. This can be things such as "is the modification date of
this Identity *before* the creation date?".
The test is implemented by calling the startupDatabaseIntegrityTest()
functions on all objects which extend class Persistent. See those
functions for what is tested.

By calling the database integrity test from the base-classes for all
unit tests, it is now run at the end of every unit test - even those
which are not related to the database schema at first glance.
This should ensure quite a bit of general shotgun testing.

That's a necessary insurance due to the general complexity of
enforcing a database schema in db4o, which does not have any schema
checks of its own: The only thing which ensures the schema is obeyed
is WoT code, so it's easy for new developers to cause damage.

- 0006686: [Code quality] Unit tests: Check
WebOfTrust.verifyAndCorrectStoredScores() when finished (xor)

One of the main jobs of WoT is to accumulate the trust ratings which
identities give to each other.
For identities which have not received a direct trust rating of the
user, it will use the trust values of remote peers to calculate a
Score value. The Score is a weighted average which acts as a
replacement for missing direct trust ratings of the user.
Thus, Scores are the central "output" of WoT, and their correctness is
very important.

The function verifyAndCorrectStoredScores() validates the correctness
of the whole Score database using the reference algorithm.
By calling this function from the base-classes of all unit tests, it
is now run at the end of every test.
As the reference implementation is not used in practice, but was
replaced by a faster algorithm in build0018, this kind of shotgun
testing ensures that the optimized algorithm works properly.

- 0006682: [Code quality] Unit tests: Check WebOfTrust.isTerminated()
when finished (xor)

WoT has many different subsystems which run on a thread of their own.
During shutdown, hypothetical threading issues such as deadlocks could
prevent shutdown of some subsystems.
This would be difficult to notice by the user: To make sure that
terminating Freenet is always possible, shutting down WoT may not
abort with an error message.

So to ensure shutdown works properly, code was added to the
base-classes of all unit tests. At the end of every test, it will
check whether the subsystems reported successful sutdown.

- 0006594: [Bugs] Invalid usage of HashMap/*Set with objects of
subtypes of Persistent (xor)

Child classes of Persistent, such as Identity / Trust / Score,
typically have a hashCode() and equals() function, so they are
eligible for being used with hash tables.
However, there is a pitfall: The equals() function does not only
compare whether the entity behind the object is the same. It also
compares the current state of the object.
For example, an Identity objects represents the entity of a single
person. This person is always the same. But the state of an Identity
object also includes things such as the list of WoT applications the
identity uses. These things may change over time.
Hence, equals() may return false if it is used to compare multiple
different versions of the same identity.
The consequence of that is that code which uses HashSets together with
multiple versions of identities will cause multiple entries in the
HashSets when there should only be one.
The same applies to class HashMap when objects of class Persistent are
used as key, their ID should be used instead.

To fix this, class IdentifierHashSet was implemented. This class only
considers the ID of the objects for determining equality.
All code which uses HashSet was reviewed and fixed to use the new
class instead where necessary.
The code which uses class HashMap was reviewed to use the ID of
Persistent objects as key where necessary.

- 0006671: [Code quality] XMLTransformer: Log parsing failures as
warning instead of normal so developers notice them (xor)

WoT transfers its data using XML across the network.
As we already have the experimental alternative implementation of LCWoT
available thanks to digger3, it's possible that there are
incompatibilities between the XML which WoT and LCWoT produce.

Thus, the log level of XML parsing failures was raised from NORMAL to
WARNING. This ensures they will be noticed during test runs:
The developer documentation recommends to search the logs for messages
of priority WARNING and ERROR after test runs.

- 0006814: [Code quality] Identity.setNickname(): Provide more
descriptive Exception message if given nickname is null (Ademan)

The message was misleading previously, as we did not actually check
whether the given nickname is null. The NullPointerException was
merely being thrown implicitly due to nickname.trim() failing.
Thanks to Ademan for this fix!

Thanks to:
- Ademan
- ArneBab
- Bert Massop
- nextgens
- The many translators on Transifex

Aug 7, 2016
cc62a06
zip
tar.gz

build0018

Web of Trust Version 0.4.4 build0018

------------------------------------------------------------------------

TLDR:
Measurements [1] of removing Trust values show an average execution
time of 1.7 seconds, which previously was 49 seconds
= a speed improvement of factor 28.

IMPORTANT STUFF:

NOTICE: According to TheSeeker, his machines have been seized by the US
government. This gives the government access to his WoT / FMS
identities, his freesites, etc. Please update your Trust values.
He was a seed-identity until ~2 years ago, and thus might have received
a Trust value of 100 from you automatically if you created your
identities back then.
(He says this was due to stuff *not* related to Freenet, and that he
was neither intentionally committing a crime nor being aware of
unintentionally having illegal things on his computers.)

NOTICE: While this release has not yet been bundled with a new Freenet
release, it can be acquired a lot easier than previous non-bundled
ones:
1) Update your Freenet to the testing version using the shell command
"./update.sh testing" on Linux or "update.cmd testing" on Windows.
2) Unload the "WebOfTrust" plugin and load the "WebOfTrust Testing
Versions" plugin. Please do first read the description for the
security implications!
3) If you had already done step 2 previously, i.e. are already running
the previous testing release build0017, you need to restart Freenet
or unload and re-load the plugin for getting the update: Freenet will
only check for updates of the testing version when the plugin
is reloaded.
Once Freenet build 1471 is released, step 1 will not be necessary
anymore.
You will also get this release someday even if you do not switch to the
testing versions. It will just take longer: Non-testing releases are
shipped together with regular Freenet releases; and Freenet releases do
not happen as often as WoT releases.

SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK (detailed changelog is below):

This WoT version finally ships some of the long awaited core performance
improvements:

- Previous builds would fall back to "full Score re-computation" upon
Trust changes which cause "distrust": Removal of a Trust value,
changing a Trust value from above zero to zero or negative, or adding
a zero or below zero Trust value. The full re-computation was a
*very* slow piece of code as it basically recalculates the whole
Score database. It usually took ~ 1 minute, or even 10 minutes on some
machines. This was made even worse by the fact that it happened not
only for local Trust changes but also for remote ones. Also, due to
unfortunate current limitations of the database code [4], it would
block the web interface from responding during the whole time.
This build ships an incremental Score re-computation algorithm for
these situations - which should be a lot faster:
Measurements [1] show an average execution time of 1.7 seconds, which
previously was 49 seconds = a speed improvement of factor 28.
As there was an incremental re-computation code for non-distrust Trust
changes already, Score re-computation is fully incremental now.

- In previous versions, restarting WoT usually caused:
1) a defragmentation of the database.
2) a full Score re-computation (to prevent bugs in the existing
incremental Score computation code from causing wrong values to
exist for a long time).
This has been changed to:
1) Defrag only happens once a week.
2) Full Score re-computation only happens once every 4 weeks.
As a consequence, startup should be a lot faster.
It now takes ~2 minutes on my machine.

NOTICE: WoT client applications which were not yet updated to use the
new "event-notifications" API (see build0015 changelog) can put a very
high load on WoT. For example Sone currently downloads almost the whole
WoT database every 60 seconds [8].
So if you want to get a realistic grasp of whether this WoT release is
faster, please test without any client applications.

Next steps of development will be:

- While the average execution time of 1.7 seconds of the new incremental
Score computation algorithm is acceptable, its measured worst case
execution time of above 60 seconds is not.
It is difficult to judge how frequently the worst case happens, as the
benchmark which was conducted had to be synthetic: The operations
which cause the new code to run are quite rare in network dumps, so
real world Trust changes couldn't be used as a benchmarks.
It thus can be hoped that the worst case is a "worst case of a worst
case" and very rarely happens on the real network.
To determine how often it happens, the next build will ship additions
to the "Statistics" page to monitor the worst case [2]. (The average
case was already added to the statistics, search for "distrust".)
If it happens too often, there is still hope: During the months of
development of the new code, quite a few ideas for further improvement
arose. Part of those are completely new algorithms, and thus they're
not implemented yet but will have to wait until we have measurements
to show whether the effort of rewriting this yet once more is
indicated.

- The improved startup time of ~2 minutes is still too much.
It is caused by the fact that WoT will currently subscribe to the USKs
of *all* trusted Identities - currently over 11 000!
This is not only unacceptable from a startup point of view, but also
from a network-load perspective - it causes a O(N²) network-wide
load; and also slows down each individual node significantly.
Hence, the algorithm will be changed to only subscribe to the USKs of
directly trusted identities; and to fetch non-directly-trusted ones in
a more sparse, opportunistic approach. See [3].
This is likely the primary goal of the next release.

- The new incremental distrust computation algorithm was the subject of
my bachelor's thesis. Therefore not only the new code was written,
but also a very long document which describes the old algorithm and
the steps towards the new one.
This thesis' document has turned out to be well-suited to become a
"WoT developer's manual", and I plan to release it as such soon.
I will wait with that until university has graded it (ETA: October)
for slightly selfish reasons: I don't want to risk getting negative
opinions on it before I know for sure whether I passed - that'd only
cause needless panic. I hope this is only "slightly" selfish as a
not-in-panic xor is a happy xor and a happy xor will produce more
WoT code :)
I will announce the document on FMS / IRC / my flog / the mailing list
once it is available.

CHANGELOG - prefixed with the bug tracker issue number:

- 0006605: [Performance] Prevent using ObjectContainer.activate() if
already activated to sufficient depth (xor)

"Activation" is a technical term of the db4o database which WoT uses.
It is similar to a "join" in relational databases:
For example, activating a Trust object will load the identities which
gave / received the Trust value. This involves disk IO, and therefore
is an expensive operation.

When an object is already activated, and then db4o's activate()
function is called again, db4o should do nothing in theory.
Profiling has shown that this is not the case unfortunately, it
takes db4o quite a bit of time to determine that nothing needs to
be done.

Thus code has been added to WoT to prevent activating stuff twice.

The performance impact of this has not been measured, but it should
help quite a bit: All getter functions of WoT classes have activation
code; and when doing stuff with objects one often calls more than
one getter on each object.

- 0006621: [Usability] Update translations (operhiem1)

10 files changed, 106 insertions(+), 55 deletions(-)
de | 22 +++++++++++-----------
el | 28 +++++++++++++++++++++++-----
es | 25 +++++++++++++++++++++++--
fi | 2 --
fr | 28 ++++++++++++++++++++--------
hu | 2 --
nl | 2 --
pt_BR | 14 +++++++++-----
ru | 22 ++++++----------------
zh-cn | 16 ++++++++++++++--

(The fact that some languages received more removals than additions
is due to changed English source strings which were not translated
yet.)

Huge thanks to the volunteers on Transifex for providing these,
and to operhiem1 for managing Transifex.

- 0006610: [Code quality] Add command line utility for dumping Trust
histogram (xor)

WoT now has another user interface: The "wotutil.sh" terminal tool.

One of its features is to gather statistics about the Trust network.
This shall be of use for statistical evaluations.

It already yielded a discovery [5]:
The Trust value distribution is not "smooth". There are certain
discrete steps of Trust values such as 75 which occur a lot more
often than ones which would seem less "natural" to humans.

It can be speculated that a reason for this is UI design in WoT
client applications such as Sone which encourages discrete steps
instead of small +/- 1 changes.

If you are a client application developer, please consider changing
your UI to encourage +/- 1 steps.
The WoT algorithm supports the full input range of [-100, +100], and
it would be usage below its capabilities if we only used a few of
those 201 values.

- 0006617: [Code quality] WOTUtil: Add feature for doing database
integrity test and recomputing all Scores (xor)

Since Score computation is fully incremental now (as explained in the
summary at the beginning of the changelog), wrong Scores caused by
bugs will persist for a long time.

To be able to detect and fix this, the aforementioned "wotutil.sh"
has an option "-testAndRepair" which does a full re-computation
(and an integrity test of the database schema).

You shouldn't need to run this in normal operation as WoT will do
a full re-computation every 4 weeks.
It is meant mostly as a tool for developers to be able to validate
success of test runs.

Nevertheless, users might help testing by doing this sometimes.

- 0006618: [Code quality] StatisticsPage: Show date of last defrag /
verification of Scores (xor)

Since full Score re-computation and database defragmentation have been
changed from happening every startup to every few days (as explained
in the summary at the beginning of the changelog), the new code to
only run them every few days might have bugs.

To assist users with noticing these bugs, the dates when those
maintenance operations last happened are displayed on the "Statistics"
page.

- 0006627: [Bugs] Trying to load new databases with old WOT versions can
break them (xor)

The structure of WoT databases ("database schema") is versioned. The
version is changed if the structure changes. To ensure that old
versions of WoT do not load databases with a newer structure version,
there has always been code in WoT which makes it refuse loading a
newer database.

Unfortunately, in WoT versions prior to this one, this code was
bugged. Even though WoT refused to start and showed an error message,
the database *was* being loaded, which could cause corruption.

This has now been fixed, so WoT versions starting from this one will
correctly refuse to load newer databases.

However, old versions such as the previous one cannot be fixed as
they're out in the public already.
And since this new version does change the database structure, the
previous one *will* cause corruption. (You'll at least notice if your
database is corrupted, WoT will crash at startup. I can write code to
repair such databases if you don't have a backup; please ask me then.)

Thus, please do *NOT* try to downgrade this release to build0017 or
before!

- 0005994: [Security] Schedule defragmentation after deletion of an
OwnIdentity (xor)

Databases are complex structures. Thus, deleting data from them might
not actually erase it from disk. The free space might be kept as-is
until something else fills it.

To prevent leaking of deleted user identities, a defragmentation is
scheduled after the user deletes an identity.
This will happen at the next restart of WoT.

NOTICE: In general, WoT is not yet safe against leaking data to disk.
It for example does not yet encrypt its database if Freenet is
configured for encryption. Freenet will hopefully soon notice the
user about this, see [6].

- 0006607: [Security] deleteOwnIdentity() will cause the replacement
non-own Identity to be fetched even if it is distrusted (xor)

When the user deletes one of his local identities, it is not actually
deleted but converted to a non-local one. (This is for security
reasons: Other local identities might have assigned Trust to it,
which should not get deleted.)

This code had a bug which would cause the deleted identity to continue
to be downloaded no matter whether it was trusted or not.
While distrusting one of your own identities after deleting it for
sure is a rare use case, this nevertheless was fixed.

- 0005757: [Performance] Get rid of using computeAllScoresWithoutCommit
whereever possible (xor)

This is the new incremental distrust computation code which was
described in the summary at the beginning of the changelog.

- 0006636: [Performance] computeRankFromScratch() should
opportunistically compute ranks and put them into a cache
(xor)

As explained in the summary at the beginning of the changelog, the
new incremental distrust computation code has a high worst-case
runtime.
To alleviate the worst-case, this algorithmic optimization has been
applied already. It is of a complex nature and thus beyond explaining
here.

Once my aforementioned bachelor's thesis has been published, you
will be able to realize that this optimization is one of those
suggested in the "Outlook" section of the thesis.
Reading the thesis will then explain this optimization.

The measurements at [1] aim to show how much this optimization helps.
It is labeled as "revision 2" there; the version before it (which is
the thesis' original code) is labeled as "revision 1".

- 0005962: [Performance] Don't defragment at every startup, defragment
every 7 days (xor)

As explained in the summary at the beginning of the changelog.

- 0006616: [Performance] Don't run verifyAndCorrectStoredScores() at
every startup, run it once every 28 days (xor)

As explained in the summary at the beginning of the changelog.

- 0006631: [Code quality] Provide development versions of WOT via fred
USK plugin updater (xor)

As explained in the summary at the beginning of the changelog.
Some more information:

These are compiled by myself instead of being compiled by the release
manager. So instead of on a dedicated high-security system which is
only booted for releases, they're compiled on a regular development
machine which is in daily online use.
They're downloaded from my main USK which is used for my flog and
WoT identity, and thus hooked up to the network quite often.
These both are inherently less secure.

With regards to quality testing, I plan to keep the same standards as
with regular releases. I will test new code before deployment just as
I always did. The releases will be packaged with a "buildXXXX" number
as regular releases, and also be announced as such.

So basically, this release channel has the main goal of allowing me to
do releases myself without paying the security price of giving me
access to the main Freenet release keys.
This is necessary as nowadays Freenet releases happen less often than
WoT releases.
It provides the side effect of allowing many users to provide testing
without big hassle so the release gets well-tested before it is put
onto the main network.

CHANGELOG about stuff only interesting for developers:

- 0006620: [Code quality] Add Hamcrest to junit-build classpath (pull
request 32) (operhiem1)

Hamcrest is a framework complementary to JUnit [7].
It may be used for easing unit test development.

Thanks to operhiem1 for wiring it in to WoT!

- 0006609: [Performance] Add synthetic benchmark for improvements of
issue 5757 (xor)

Multiple attempts have been conducted to benchmark the aforementioned
Score computation improvements:

- Class WOTUtil's function benchmarkRemoveTrustDestructive():
This can be used upon a regular WoT database, i.e. a dump of the
real network, to measure the performance of the function for
removing Trust values.
It does so by removing random Trust values one-by-one, and measuring
the time it takes for each.
This specifically tests the new code as described in the changelog's
summary, and thus is what was used for producing the benchmarks [1]
which were cited there.

- Class ScoreComputationBenchmark:
It aims to simulate the topology of the Trust graph as measured on
the real network using WOTUtil's new histogram features.
This was not completed to full extent yet: It does follow the Trust
value distribution, and the trustee count distribution (thanks
ArneBab!), but not the received-Trust distribution.
Future development might complete this. It then could be used to
make the unit tests more realistic: They do use random Trust graphs
already, but the probability distribution was chosen arbitrarily,
not from measurements.

A more detailed elaboration of the benchmarks can be studied in my
bachelor's thesis once it is published.

- 0005882: [Core] computeAllScoresWithoutCommit() return value should be
false when the IdentityFetcher state was wrong (xor)

computeAllScoresWithoutCommit() is the full Score re-computation
function which the summary of the changelog talks about.

It not only serves the purpose of re-computing stuff, but also of
*validating* correctness of the existing database contents. This is
used heavily in assert()s, and thus also in unit tests.

It previously did not check the correctness of the instructions given
to the IdentityFetcher of whether it should fetch each of the
known Identities or not.
Now it also validates whether the IdentityFetcher has been correctly
told to fetch/ignore Identities.

This means that the new Score computation code is also tested to
correctly feed the IdentityFetcher with commands.

- 0006608: [Code quality] IdentityFetcher should have a
"network dump mode" where it will also download old editions
(xor)

By default, the IdentityFetcher will try to only fetch the latest
edition of each known Identity.
A network dump using the IdentityFileDiskQueue thus is a snapshot of a
possibly infinitesimally short timespan. It will therefore lack the
temporal nature of Trust values being changed around by users.
This is a problem if you want to test/benchmark things which happen
across longer timespans.

Hence the new flag IdentityFetcher.DEBUG__NETWORK_DUMP_MODE can be set
to true to make the IdentityFetcher try to download some *old*
editions as well.

Unfortunately, my test run of a handful of hours showed that most old
editions could have fallen out of the network. IIRC, less than 100
Identities were discovered, even though we have over 11 000 nowadays.
I did not have very much patience though (less than half a day), so
you might give this a try yourself.

- 0006596: [Bugs] Add workaround for db4o bug (xor)

This one is too boring to explain in detail here.
What can be said is that assert()s have been added to make developer's
notice if they use programming patterns which might trigger this db4o
bug.

- 0006647: [Code quality] Provide changelog template (xor)

See file "developer-documentation/Changelog-template.txt".

Thanks to:
- All volunteers on Transifex for updating many translations.
- ArneBab for the ideas about graph topology modeling in
ScoreComputationBenchmark.
- operhiem1 for coordinating Transifex.

Links:
[1] http://localhost:8888/CHK@DPyogjdlfKp1rUavVANbwRH2NTM7Anq~7dpFA3azdqo,CJ968vmM890poA1FNi7MXlB3-r6zMxv6fytmXPlf7d4,AAMC--8/WoT-benchmark-build0016-commit-3edbad7a70-vs-build0018.png
Produced using this GnuPlot script:
https://gist.github.com/xor-freenet/33b7a17db0d3b80b842e
[2] https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=6648
[3] https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=3816
[4] https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=5748
https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=6247
[5] http://localhost:8888/CHK@iCe9WZKq52Esq73iRePhdQiu63nyKrHC7RwS8pP1TaA,sh0ODWAyYOuoHd85Llfr7pF2Sy-mnZwavkx3Lz7puuQ,AAMC--8/WoT-trust-value-histogram-2015-07-23.png
[6] https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=6559
[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamcrest
[8] Bombe/Sone#11

Sep 16, 2015
a752009
zip
tar.gz

build0017

Web of Trust Version 0.4.3 build0017

------------------------------------------------------------------------

This is merely a quick hotfix release for build0016 which could not
be deployed to due a bug:
build0016 was incompatible to Java 6, but Freenet policy still is to be
compatible to it.
Sorry. I did not notice this since my development system is on Java 7
already for security reasons.

For the "real" changelog, please read the announcement of build0016.

CHANGELOG - prefixed with the bugtracker issue number:

0006629: [Bugs] Remove usage of Java 7 API so WOT works on Java 6 (xor)
  As aforementioned.

  Thanks to operhiem1 for noticing this!

Aug 18, 2015
612b046
zip
tar.gz

build0016

Web of Trust Version 0.4.3 build0016

---------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK - detailed changelog is below:

The main goal of this build is to improve the very poor latency of the
web interface.
This is done by redesigning the way fetched Identity XML files are
processed.
Previously, each file would be processed in a thread of its own, even
though the actual processing requires a single lock which can only be
taken by one thread at once. This did cause processing to be effectively
single-threaded, while hundreds or even thousands of threads would be
piling up when competing for the single lock.
With this build, processing is redesigned to queue fetched XML files to
disk and process them one-by-one on a single thread.
As a result, the web interface thread now does not have to compete
against hundreds of threads who want the same lock.
This will result in much lower latency of the web interface, especially
if your WOT is not permanently running and thus at startup has to
process many identity files in bulk.

There are some more benefits which are listed in the detailed changelog
below.

It is still possible for the web interface to stall for minutes due to
the fact that the computations to import a trust list are still
implemented with a very poor algorithm.
The goal of the next build is to improve this algorithm significantly.
The next build is feature-complete already and will be available as
release candidate soon.

Also, please notice that usage of client applications which have not
been adapted to use the new WOT event-notifications API yet can slow
down the web interface significantly. This applies to especially Sone
which downloads almost the whole WOT database every 60 seconds [1].
If you are a client application developer and want to make usage of
event-notifications, please contact me on IRC (nick "xor-freenet"), I am
willing to help by explaining how to use the reference implementation
FCP client.

Some builds later on, the locking on the web interface will be removed
completely to allow it to always render instantaneously. This will take
a lot of time to implement due to issues with the database and thus has
been postponed to after the more easy algorithm improvements.

In addition to the performance fixes, many new translations of the UI
are included: 9 new languages, and 3 updated ones.
Very very many thanks to the contributors on Transifex, and to operhiem1
for mentoring them!

CHANGELOG - prefixed with the bugtracker issue number:

- 0006244: [Performance] Queue fetched trust lists instead of processing
           them immediately (xor / nextgens)

  This is what has been described in the introduction.

  Beyond the latency improvement of the web interface, this also:
  - Helps plugins such as FlogHelper which have not been adapted to
    event-notifications yet. They should lose connection to WOT less
    frequently, which fixes issues such as FlogHelper saying that WOT
    is not loaded even though it is.
  - Helps users of machines with little memory such as Raspberry Pi.
    Less threads = less memory usage.
  - Speeds up shutdown
  - Reduces total CPU/IO usage by identity file deduplication: If an
    identity file is queued for processing with edition N, and the node
    fetches edition N+1 of that identity before edition N has been
    processed, then the old edition N will be dropped. Only the newest
    will be processed. It is possible that deduplication does not yield
    a good ratio yet. To fix this, more measurements will have to be
    done in the future to tweak the time window for which we wait before
    processing a queued file. Generally, on slower machines there will
    be more deduplication, which is a nice side effect as deduplication
    reduces load and slow machines can use that.
    To compute the deduplication ratio, go to the "Statistics" page
    and divide "Deduplicated files" by "Total ever enqueued (= fetched)
    files". Feel welcome to share this number with the team.
  - Helps make WOT look less buggy to new users: They were the ones
    where the most new XML files would be fetched at once, and thus
    did suffer the most severe web interface lockup.
  - Persists fetch-progress across restart: Previously, the progress of
    the stalling threads would be lost at shutdown. The new queue code
    will keep the queued files across restarts.
  - Allows creation of "bootstrap" bundles of a dump of the XML files of
    all Identities to help new users with slow connections.
    See below at issue 006597. (Please do read this, there is a security
    pitfall with this feature!)
  - Helps developers to deterministically test changes to WOT,
    see below at issue 0006597.

  You can view statistics about the new identity file queue and identity
  file processor on WOT's "Statistics" page.
  In particular, the two "Failed files" counters are of interest.
  Consider looking at your log files if they are non-zero.

- 0006561: [Usability] L10n: Add new translations from Transifex, update
           existing ones (operhiem1, and many Transifex contributors)
  0006560: [Security] L10n: Review German translation on Transifex (xor)
  0006495: [Usability] L10n: Update Transifex, new l10n strings have
           been added (operhiem1)

  New translations:
    Brazilian Portugese
    Finnish
    French
    Greek
    Hungarian
    Norwegian
    Polish
    Simplified Chinese
    Spanish

  Updated translations:
    Dutch
    German  (also fully reviewed and improved compared to English, now
             can be considered as reference translation)
    Italian

- 0006499: [Security] Web interface: Allow sorting identities by edition
           count (xor)

  This allows you to check for identities which insert an excessive
  amount of trust lists, which can be considered as a denial of service
  attack.
  If an identity does this, please try to contact them to find out
  whether it is a bug in their WOT; and distrust them if do not
  cooperate to fix this behavior.
  Also, report this to the Freenet team please so we can check for bugs.

- 0006554: [Code quality] Web interface / Statistics: Add "Number of
           unfetched identities" (xor)

  For first time users or people whose WOT has been offline for a long
  time, this number can be used to find out how far WOT is with
  downloading all identities.

- 0006230: [Security] Make sure to always display the logged-in identity
           in the web interface (xor)

  This is to prevent you from accidentally revealing which of your
  identities are owned by the same person by setting a trust value
  or trust comment with the wrong identity.

  For now, it will show the full ID of the identity, which is very long
  and thus ugly.
  Fixing this is a bit of work and thus it will have to wait until
  after performance is fixed.
  See https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=6072

- 0006493: [Usability] Web interface: Change page title from
           "Web of Trust" to "Community"; allow translating (xor)

  This is to ensure that the page title matches the name of the
  "Community" menu through which WOT is accessed.

- 0006491: [Performance] Update seed identity edition numbers
           immediately before releasing (xor / ArneBab)

  This will speed up downloading all identities for new users.

CHANGELOG about stuff only interesting for developers:

- 0006597: [Code quality] IdentityFileDiskQueue: Support deterministic
           repeat by dequeuing sorted by filename (xor)

  The new disk queue for identity files, which was described above at
  issue 0006244 already, has a feature for repeating test runs:
  - If DEBUG logging is enabled, it will archive files after processing
    - to the directory "IdentityFileQueue/Finished".
    The filenames will be prefixed with an index number to indicate the
    order in which they were processed.
  - If DEBUG logging is enabled, it will process files in the "Queued"
    directory sorted by filename instead of in random order.
    This means you can copy files from the "Finished" to the "Queued"
    directory to repeat a test run in a deterministic way - the index
    number prefix together with the sorted import will guarantee that
    the files will be imported the same order as in the original run.
    Please shutdown WOT before doing this.

  The deterministic test runs are a useful feature for:
  - Reproducing bugs in a debugger.
  - Benchmarks: The statistics page shows the total time the identity
    file processor spent importing files.
  - Creating "bootstrap" dumps of Identity files of all Identities so
    new users can add them to their queue instead of waiting for them
    to be fetched. Please be aware that the cryptographic signatures of
    the files are NOT verified and thus you put a lot of trust in the
    person who provides the bundle - the files can be modified in any
    way.

- 0006531: [Code quality] Unit tests which can fail on slow machines
           should only be executed if "test.unreliable=true" (xor)

  This applies to the tests in package "plugins.WebOfTrust.util.jobs".
  They test a timer class, and thus are timing-sensitive and fail
  randomly on slow or heavily loaded machines.

- 0006523: [Code quality] Ant build improvements (xor)

  The "-projecthelp" parameter now lists all build targets. It was
  missing "junit".
  It now also lists the various "-D" options for junit.
  The "-D" options for junit now all start with "test.". Namely,
  "-Dbenchmark=true" is now "-Dtest.benchmark".

- 0006522: [Code quality] Merge PR 28: Ant build: allow for
           -Dtest.class=... unit test selection (bertm / xor)

  This allows running only a single unit test class from Ant. It's
  useful if you are working on a new test class for example.

  Thanks to bertm for implementing this!

- 0006368: [Bugs] Identicon leaks an InputStream (xor)

  This memory leak would only apply when using a WOT-based application
  which showed Identicons via WOT. This probably applied to Sone.

Thanks to:
  - nextgens for motivating me to implement the performance optimization
    which is the main feature of this build.
  - operhiem1 for administrating Transifex which has proven to be a huge
    source of new Translations; and for committing the new l10n files.
  - ArneBab, stanley and probably some more people I forgot about for
    testing
  - bertm for the Ant improvements
  - you, the users, for having patience while performance optimizations
    are implemented one after another.

Links:
  [1] Bombe/Sone#11

Aug 15, 2015
1b03629
zip
tar.gz

build0016-rc03

For changelog, see tag build0016-rc02.

The only change after that is code which is only enabled if DEBUG
logging is enabled.
See https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=6597

Jul 15, 2015
8c96b32
zip
tar.gz

build0016-rc02

Web of Trust Version 0.4.3 build0016 release candidate 02

---------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK - detailled changelog is below:

(Changes compared to release candidate 01 are only visible to
developers, and not interesting to discuss.)

The main goal of this build is to improve the very poor latency of the
web interface.
This is done by redesigning the way fetched Identity XML files are
processed.
Previously, each file would be processed in a thread of its own, even
though the actual processing requires a single lock which can only be
taken by one thread at once. This did cause processing to be effectively
single-threaded, while hundreds or even thousands of threads would be
piling up when competing for the single lock.
With this build, processing is redesigned to queue fetched XML files to
disk and process them one-by-one on a single thread.
As a result, the web interface thread now does not have to compete
against hundreds of threads who want the same lock.
This will result in much lower latency of the web interface, especially
if your WOT is not permanently running and thus at startup has to
process many identity files in bulk.

There are some more benefits which are listed in the detailled changelog
below.

It is still possible for the web interface to stall for minutes due to
the fact that the computations to import a trust list are still
implemented with a very poor algorithm.
The goal of the next build is to improve this algorithm significantly.

Also, please notice that usage of client applications which have not
been adapted to use the new WOT event-notifications API yet can slow
down the web interface significantly. This applies to especially Sone
which downloads almost the whole WOT database every 60 seconds.
If you are a client application developer and want to make usage of
event-notifications, please contact me on IRC, I am willing to help by
explaining how to use the reference implementation FCP client.

Some builds later on, the locking from the web interface will be removed
completely to allow it to always render instantaneously. This will take
some time to implement due to issues with the database and thus has
been postponed to after the more easy algorithm improvements.

In addition to the performance fixes, many new translations of the UI
are included: 9 new languages, and 3 updated ones.
Very very many thanks to the contributors on Transifex!

CHANGELOG - prefixed with the bugtracker issue number:

- 0006244: [Performance] Queue fetched trust lists instead of processing
           them immediately (xor / nextgens)

  This is what has been described in the introduction.

  Beyond the latency improvement of the web interface, this also:
  - Helps plugins such as FlogHelper which have not been adapted to
    event-notifications yet. They should lose connection to WOT less
    frequently, which fixes issues such as FlogHelper saying that WOT
    is not loaded even though it is.
  - Helps users of machines with little memory such as Raspberry Pi.
    Less threads = less memory usage.
  - Speeds up shutdown
  - Reduce total CPU/IO usage by identity file deduplication: If an
    identity file is queued for processing with edition N, and the node
    fetches edition N+1 of that identity before edition N has been
    processed, then the old edition N will be dropped. Only the newest
    will be processed. It is possible that deduplication does not yield
    a good ratio yet. To fix this, more measurements will have to be
    done in the future to tweak the time window for which we wait before
    processing a queued file. Generally, on faster machines there will
    be less deduplication.
    To compute the deduplication ratio, go to the "Statistics" page
    and divide "Deduplicated files" by "Total ever enqueued (= fetched)
    files". Feel welcome to share this number with the team.
  - Helps make WOT look less buggy to new users: They were the ones
    where the most new XML files would be fetched at once, and thus
    did suffer the most severe web interface lockup.

  You can view statistics about the new identity file queue and identity
  file processor on WOT's "Statistics" page.
  In particular, the two "Failed files" counters are of interest.
  Consider looking at your log files if they are non-zero.
  Instructions for logging are in "Testing instructions.txt"

- 0006561: [Usability] L10n: Add new translations from Transifex, update
           existing ones (operhiem1, and many Transifex contributors)
  0006560: [Security] L10n: Review German translation on Transifex (xor)
  0006495: [Usability] L10n: Update Transifex, new l10n strings have
           been added (operhiem1)

  New translations:
    Brazilian Portugese
    Finnish
    French
    Greek
    Hungarian
    Norwegian
    Polish
    Simplified Chinese
    Spanish

  Updated translations:
    Dutch
    German (also fully reviewed and improved compared to English, can be
            considered as reference translation)
    Italian

- 0006499: [Security] Web interface: Allow sorting identities by edition
           count (xor)

  This allows you to check for identities which insert an excessive
  amount of trust lists, which can be considered as a denial of service
  attack.
  If an identity does this, please try to contact them to find out
  whether it is a bug in their WOT; and distrust them if do not
  cooperate to fix this behavior.
  Also, report this to the Freenet team please so we can check for bugs.

- 0006554: [Code quality] Web interface / Statistics: Add "Number of
           unfetched identities" (xor)

  For first time users or people whose WOT has been offline for a long
  time, this number can be used to find out how far WOT is with
  downloading all identities.

- 0006230: [Security] Make sure to always display the logged-in identity
           in the web interface (xor)

  This is to prevent you from accidentally revealing which of your
  identities are owned by the same person by setting a trust value
  or trust comment with the wrong identity.

  For now, it will show the full ID of the identity, which is very long
  and thus ugly.
  Fixing this is a bit of work and thus it will have to wait until
  after performance is fixed.
  See https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=6072

- 0006493: [Usability] Web interface: Change page title from
           "Web of Trust" to "Community"; allow translating (xor)

  This is to ensure that the page title matches the name of the
  "Community" menu through which WOT is accessed.

- 0006491: [Performance] Update seed identity edition numbers
           immediately before releasing (xor / ArneBab)

  This will speed up downloading all identities for new users.

CHANGELOG about stuff only interesting for developers:

- 0006531: [Code quality] Unit tests which can fail on slow machines
           should only be executed if "test.unreliable=true" (xor)

  This applies to the tests in package "plugins.WebOfTrust.util.jobs".
  They test a timer class, and thus are timing-sensitive and fail
  randomly on slow or heavily loaded machines.

- 0006523: [Code quality] Ant build improvements (xor) - resolved.

  The "-projecthelp" parameter now lists all build targets. It was
  missing "junit".
  It now also lists the various "-D" options for junit.
  The "-D" options for junit now all start with "test.". Namely,
  "-Dbenchmark=true" is now "-Dtest.benchmark".

- 0006522: [Code quality] Merge PR 28: Ant build: allow for
           -Dtest.class=... unit test selection (bertm / xor)

  This allows running only a single unit test class from Ant. It's
  useful if you are working on a new test class for example.

  Thanks to bertm for implementing this!

- 0006368: [Bugs] Identicon leaks an InputStream (xor)

  This memory leak would only apply when using a WOT-based application
  which showed Identicons via WOT. This probably applied to Sone.

Thanks to:
  - nextgens for motivating me to implement the performance optimization
    which is the main feature of this build.
  - operhiem1 for administrating Transifex which has proven to be a huge
    source of new Translations; and for committing the new l10n files.
  - ArneBab, stanley and probably some more people I forgot about for
    testing
  - bertm for the Ant improvements
  - you, the users, for having patience while performance optimizations
    are implemented one after another.

Jul 11, 2015
1342cf8
zip
tar.gz

build0016-rc01

Web of Trust Version 0.4.3 build0016 release candidate 01

---------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK - detailled changelog is below:

The main goal of this build is to improve the very poor latency of the
web interface.
This is done by redesigning the way fetched Identity XML files are
processed.
Previously, each file would be processed in a thread of its own, even
though the actual processing requires a single lock which can only be
taken by one thread at once. This did cause processing to be effectively
single-threaded, while hundreds or even thousands of threads would be
piling up when competing for the single lock.
With this build, processing is redesigned to queue fetched XML files to
disk and process them one-by-one on a single thread.
As a result, the web interface thread now does not have to compete
against hundreds of threads who want the same lock.
This will result in much lower latency of the web interface, especially
if your WOT is not permanently running and thus at startup has to
process many identity files in bulk.

There are some more benefits which are listed in the detailled changelog
below.

It is still possible for the web interface to stall for minutes due to
the fact that the computations to import a trust list are still
implemented with a very poor algorithm.
The goal of the next build is to improve this algorithm significantly.

Also, please notice that usage of client applications which have not
been adapted to use the new WOT event-notifications API yet can slow
down the web interface significantly. This applies to especially Sone
which downloads almost the whole WOT database every 60 seconds.
If you are a client application developer and want to make usage of
event-notifications, please contact me on IRC, I am willing to help by
explaining how to use the reference implementation FCP client.

Some builds later on, the locking from the web interface will be removed
completely to allow it to always render instantaneously. This will take
some time to implement due to issues with the database and thus has
been postponed to after the more easy algorithm improvements.

In addition to the performance fixes, many new translations of the UI
are included: 9 new languages, and 3 updated ones.
Very very many thanks to the contributors on Transifex!

CHANGELOG - prefixed with the bugtracker issue number:

- 0006244: [Performance] Queue fetched trust lists instead of processing
           them immediately (xor / nextgens)

  This is what has been described in the introduction.

  Beyond the latency improvement of the web interface, this also:
  - Helps plugins such as FlogHelper which have not been adapted to
    event-notifications yet. They should lose connection to WOT less
    frequently, which fixes issues such as FlogHelper saying that WOT
    is not loaded even though it is.
  - Helps users of machines with little memory such as Raspberry Pi.
    Less threads = less memory usage.
  - Speeds up shutdown
  - Reduce total CPU/IO usage by identity file deduplication: If an
    identity file is queued for processing with edition N, and the node
    fetches edition N+1 of that identity before edition N has been
    processed, then the old edition N will be dropped. Only the newest
    will be processed. It is possible that deduplication does not yield
    a good ratio yet. To fix this, more measurements will have to be
    done in the future to tweak the time window for which we wait before
    processing a queued file. Generally, on faster machines there will
    be less deduplication.
    To compute the deduplication ratio, go to the "Statistics" page
    and divide "Deduplicated files" by "Total ever enqueued (= fetched)
    files". Feel welcome to share this number with the team.
  - Helps make WOT look less buggy to new users: They were the ones
    where the most new XML files would be fetched at once, and thus
    did suffer the most severe web interface lockup.

  You can view statistics about the new identity file queue and identity
  file processor on WOT's "Statistics" page.
  In particular, the two "Failed files" counters are of interest.
  Consider looking at your log files if they are non-zero.
  Instructions for logging are in "Testing instructions.txt"

- 0006561: [Usability] L10n: Add new translations from Transifex, update
           existing ones (operhiem1, and many Transifex contributors)
  0006560: [Security] L10n: Review German translation on Transifex (xor)
  0006495: [Usability] L10n: Update Transifex, new l10n strings have
           been added (operhiem1)

  New translations:
    Brazilian Portugese
    Finnish
    French
    Greek
    Hungarian
    Norwegian
    Polish
    Simplified Chinese
    Spanish

  Updated translations:
    Dutch
    German (also fully reviewed and improved compared to English, can be
            considered as reference translation)
    Italian

- 0006499: [Security] Web interface: Allow sorting identities by edition
           count (xor)

  This allows you to check for identities which insert an excessive
  amount of trust lists, which can be considered as a denial of service
  attack.
  If an identity does this, please try to contact them to find out
  whether it is a bug in their WOT; and distrust them if do not
  cooperate to fix this behavior.
  Also, report this to the Freenet team please so we can check for bugs.

- 0006554: [Code quality] Web interface / Statistics: Add "Number of
           unfetched identities" (xor)

  For first time users or people whose WOT has been offline for a long
  time, this number can be used to find out how far WOT is with
  downloading all identities.

- 0006230: [Security] Make sure to always display the logged-in identity
           in the web interface (xor)

  This is to prevent you from accidentally revealing which of your
  identities are owned by the same person by setting a trust value
  or trust comment with the wrong identity.

  For now, it will show the full ID of the identity, which is very long
  and thus ugly.
  Fixing this is a bit of work and thus it will have to wait until
  after performance is fixed.
  See https://bugs.freenetproject.org/view.php?id=6072

- 0006493: [Usability] Web interface: Change page title from
           "Web of Trust" to "Community"; allow translating (xor)

  This is to ensure that the page title matches the name of the
  "Community" menu through which WOT is accessed.

- 0006491: [Performance] Update seed identity edition numbers
           immediately before releasing (xor / ArneBab)

  This will speed up downloading all identities for new users.

CHANGELOG about stuff only interesting for developers:

- 0006531: [Code quality] Unit tests which can fail on slow machines
           should only be executed if "test.unreliable=true" (xor)

  This applies to the tests in package "plugins.WebOfTrust.util.jobs".
  They test a timer class, and thus are timing-sensitive and fail
  randomly on slow or heavily loaded machines.

- 0006523: [Code quality] Ant build improvements (xor) - resolved.

  The "-projecthelp" parameter now lists all build targets. It was
  missing "junit".
  It now also lists the various "-D" options for junit.
  The "-D" options for junit now all start with "test.". Namely,
  "-Dbenchmark=true" is now "-Dtest.benchmark".

- 0006522: [Code quality] Merge PR 28: Ant build: allow for
           -Dtest.class=... unit test selection (bertm / xor)

  This allows running only a single unit test class from Ant. It's
  useful if you are working on a new test class for example.

  Thanks to bertm for implementing this!

- 0006368: [Bugs] Identicon leaks an InputStream (xor)

  This memory leak would only apply when using a WOT-based application
  which showed Identicons via WOT. This probably applied to Sone.

Thanks to:
  - nextgens for motivating me to implement the performance optimization
    which is the main feature of this build.
  - operhiem1 for administrating Transifex which has proven to be a huge
    source of new Translations; and for committing the new l10n files.
  - ArneBab, stanley and probably some more people I forgot about for
    testing
  - bertm for the Ant improvements
  - you, the users, for having patience while performance optimizations
    are implemented one after another.

Jul 7, 2015
f5819e2
zip
tar.gz

build0015

This build makes no functional changes but removes two flawed tests. …

…One did not

support Java 6 - the minimum version required by Freenet - and the other was
timing-sensitive.

May 23, 2015
0d25504
zip
tar.gz

build0014

With 30 787 lines of code, this version includes 76% more lines of code

than the previous version which was 17 494 LOC (source: see [1]).
There is a very large amount of code quality improvements and bugfixes.
This will pay out a lot during future development hopefully; for example
the improved unit testing architecture may speed up debugging a lot.

Even though the primary purpose of this build is to alleviate the
performance issues, it will still be very slow until applications built
on top of WOT have been adapted to use the new performance features.
This has a technical reason:
The main new performance improvement is the so-called
"event-notifications" FCP API which enables apps to request notification
of changes without having to download the whole WOT database every few
minutes. This cannot be put to use without applications being changed to
use it. A reallife example to understand why this is the case: If your
mail service delivers letters by horse, they won't arrive any faster
because the government has just build a railway system. The mail company
needs to first start using trains instead of horses.
If you are a developer of a WOT application, please read the "Changelog
for developers" section for instructions how to wire it in to your app.

There are at least 5 further strong algorithmic performance
optimizations possible within WOT itself which I shall work on for the
following releases. Those then should speed up WOT without requiring
adaptions from client application developers. It was chosen to implement
event-notifications before these so we can have a parallelization of
development: Client app developers can start integrating
event-notifications now, while I can work on the WOT core optimizations.

Sorry that speeding up WOT takes so long. WOT is a major project of
30 000 lines of code already, and as such just takes its time to
optimize. I am as annoyed as anyone else by the performance issues, and
trying to do my best to get them fixed ASAP. Please stay patient :)

What follows now are two changelogs of this build:
- One of the new features which are primarily relevant to the users
- One for new stuff which can be used by developers of applications
which use WOT.
The changelogs are briefly sorted by importance, most important stuff
first. The number left to each change is the issue number in the
bugtracker.

Notice: The changelogs exclude a LOT of the actual changes. This is
because the development of this build took a very long time, and thus to
speed up the release, I produced the changelog from the bugtracker
instead of reviewing the whole amount of the 1800 commits. So what had
no bugtracker entry is likely not included. Also, I've removed anything
which isn't "visible" to users or developers, i.e. anything which is not
a new feature or bugfix. And bugfixes are also only listed if they are
easy to explain/understand. As a conclusion, the very very many code
quality improvements and core reliability bugfixes are not in the
changelog. If you're interested in the unfiltered list of the 48
resolved bugtracker entries in this release, go to
https://bugs.freenetproject.org/changelog_page.php?version_id=63.
Sorry about the lack of a complete changelog due to the time pressure to
release soon. I will aim for a MUCH shorter release cycle with following
builds; and then you'll get full changelogs again.

Changelog for users:

- 0006039: [Web Interface] WebInterface "Log in" refactoring TODOs (xor)
Operhiem1 helped a lot with dealing with the job of refactoring the
general style of the web interface to allow users to "Log in" with a
certain identity instead of having to chose which identity to work
with at every page. This should greatly increase usability as it
matches the general convention of how websites work.
Also, this functionality can be used by authors of other plugins so
there is one common WOT login for anything which uses WOT.

- 0006027: [Web Interface] Backport LogInPage features from Freetalk to
WOT (xor)
The new "Log in" page features a wizard for creating and restoring
identities. This wizard explains what WOT is, what an identity is,
what trust values are, etc. It allows the user to chose preferences.
Also, it fixes the issue of people mixing up the features for
restoring an existing identity and creating a new one from a SSK,
which could have caused their identity to be permanently broken. This
is fixed by explaining the difference very clearly.
Same as with the "Log in" page, the wizard can be used by other
plugins.

- 0006225: [Web Interface] Make the KnownIdentitiesPage split the list
into pages (xor)
Previously, the "Known identities" page would list ALL identites in a
single page. This was obviously not acceptable anymore since we have
> 11 000 identities nowadays.
Now the list is split into pages.

- [Not in bugtracker] [Web Interface]: Translation updates
Add French and Simplified Chinese translations, and update Italian,
Dutch, and Russian.
Thanks to the volunteers on Transifex, and thanks to operhiem1 for
putting this into a pull request.
Notice: This is probably incomplete already because it was done before
adding the "Create identity" wizard. AFAIK, the new stuff is up on
Transifex already, so if you want to contribute with translating it,
please contact me or operhiem1. Mail xor@freenetproject.org, or even
better join the #freenet channel on Freenode IRC.

- [No bugtracker entry] [Web Interface]: Tell the user whats invalid
bout a chosen nickname
When the user enters a nick which contains non-allowed characters, we
now tell him which those characters are.

- 0006136: [Web Interface] "Restore identity" is only accessible if the
user creates an identity first (xor)
Previously, the menu for restoring an old identity was only accessible
if you actually had already created least one identity. The
"Restore identity" feature can now be used through the
"Create identity" wizard without creating a completely new identity
first.

- 0006148: [Web Interface] Randomly generated nicknames may exceed 30
character limit (xor)
The nicknames now always fit the 30 character limit.

- 0005354: [Web Interface] Usability of the web interface (xor)
When clicking on "Community" or "Community -> Home", the "Own
anonymous identities" page is now shown instead of the "Statistics"
page.

- 0006458: [Performance] Parallelize shutdown (xor)
During shutdown, instead of waiting for each subsystem of WOT to have
terminated before termining the next one, we now terminate them all in
parallel using threads.
This should speed up shutdown a lot (but please don't expect wonders,
there are further issues with shutdown which the next release will
improve).

- 0006447: [Performance] IdentityInserter thread period constant is too
low and causes inserts to never succeed (xor)
This fixed bug would prevent your identities from ever being inserted
unless you had very high uptime.

- 0006001: [Core] Restore WebOfTrust.db4o.backup if WebOfTrust.db4o does
not exist (xor)
This fixed bug would happen if your computer crashed while WOT was
starting up. The symptom would be loss of your database, i.e. all your
identities would be gone.

- 0004854: [Web Interface] Stacktrace when clicking 'switch to simple
mode' while viewing an identity (xor)
Clicking this web interface link of Freenet did cause WOT to display
an error, which is now fixed.

- [No bugtracker entry] [Performancde] New seed identity, thanks to
operhiem1
Having another seed identity should speed up the bootstrapping for new
users.

Changelog for developers:
- [Various bugtracker entries] Event-notifications:
This new FCP API should provide a HUGE reduction of the load which
client apps put onto WOT.
What this changes is as follows: To get an up-to-date list of all
known identities (or trusts/scores), you previously had to download
ALL of them by FCP every X minutes. You would do this even if NONE of
them changed - a huge CPU/IO load for nothing. Now you just
"Subscribe" to the list of identities. As a result, WOT will send you
all of them once as you subscribe, and then keep you up to date on its
own by sending changed identities only when a change happens.
Thus, instead of a constant load of O(N = number of identites) every X
minutes, independent of the amount of changes, you now get a load of
O(1) for each change as it happens.

If you are a client application developer, and want to integrate
event-notifications in your app, I strongly recommend you to
1) Use the new classes DebugFCPClient and
FCPClientReferenceImplementation. The latter aims at being
something which you can copy-paste to your client application
plugin so you have a fully working FCP client which you can use to
connect to WOT and obtain event-notifications. The DebugFCPClient
uses the aforementioned reference FCP client to have WOT connect
to itself and test whether event-notifications ships correct
information (test runs of this have been done for several nights).
For your purposes, it can also be considered as an example of how
to actually use the FCPClientReferenceImplementation.
2) Contact me in case you need help in understanding how to use it! :)
Mail xor@freenetproject.org, or even better join the #freenet
channel on Freenode IRC.

- 0006039: [Web Interface] WebInterface "Log in" refactoring TODOs (xor)
(Even though this seems something for users, it IS interesting for
developers, please continue reading)
Operhiem1 helped a lot with dealing with the job of refactoring the
general style of the web interface to allow users to "Log in" with a
certain identity instead of having to chose which identity to work
with at every page.

And this functionality can be used by your plugins! You can redirect
users of your plugin to the log in page of WOT, and have WOT redirect
the users back to your plugin after they have logged in. For an
example of how to use this, see
https://github.com/Thynix/plugin-DVCS-WebUI/blob/4893cb22d919c0d6b9178711dbb4990f66a52232/src/main/java/org/freenetproject/plugin/dvcs_webui/ui/web/VelocityToadlet.java

Please contact me or operhiem1 for further help. Mail
xor@freenetproject.org, or even better join the #freenet channel on
Freenode IRC.

- 0006027: [Web Interface] Backport LogInPage features from Freetalk to
WOT (xor)
The new "Log in" page features a wizard for creating and restoring
identities.
Same as with the "Log in" page, the wizard can be used by other
plugins. For an example of how to use this, contact me. Mail
xor@freenetproject.org, or even better join the #freenet channel on
Freenode IRC.

- 0006231: [Core] Finish synchronous FCP API at fred (xor)
The implementation of event-notification spawned a huge 569-commit
side-project at Freenet itself aka "plugin-fcp-rewrite": The rewrite
of the FCP API for communication with plugins, and especially for
plugin-to-plugin FCP communication.
This adds a lot of new features to replace the code duplication in
existing plugins, as they had usually implemented their own extensions
of the old API to fix its shortcomings. It also provides new stuff
which was completely impossible with the previous API. Notably for
example the ability for servers to send messages to the client on
their own, without any recent message from the client. This allows
plugin FCP server authors to deploy events to clients.
Also it improves the code quality of the FCP plugin API a lot - the
old API was completely undocumented, the new one has full JavaDoc.
There is a much longer and more complete description of whats new in
the new API at the pull request. Anyone who has written a plugin which
offers an FCP server or uses FCP to connect to another plugin such as
WOT, please read it: hyphanet/fred#319

Notice: WOT will for a while stay backwards-compatible to users of the
old API. However, to use event-notifications, you must use the new
API. I would strongly recommend you to just copypaste the WOT class
FCPClientReferenceImplementation for communicating with WOT by FCP, it
does use the new API alredy.

- [Pull request 26] Background jobs
Bertm did a great job with implementing a framework for replacing
dangerous usage of the fred implementations of interface Ticker such
as especially TrivialTicker. This might be interesting for fred code
and other plugins which use those fred classes. The issue was that the
existing fred classes provide a "no duplicates" flag which sounds like
it ensures that a scheduled job will only ever be executed once. But
under certain conditions, the job can actually be executed multiple
times in parallel. The new interface "BackgroundJob" and its
implementations provide a way to run a thread with a time delay and
the guarantee that it will execute only once in parallel. This is a
candidate for being moved to fred or a common library.
Bertm saved me probably weeks of work with that, thanks a lot!

- [No bugtracker entry]: Full-node unit tests
WOT now contains class "AbstractFullNodeTest" which can be used as a
base class for unit tests. This class starts a regular Freenet node,
and loads the WOT plugin into it just as it would be loaded during
normal operation of Freenet. From a quality point of view, this is a
lot better since it provides a more real environment than the previous
approach of manually creating certain WOT classes in a synthetic
environment. Also, it allows unit tests to use the full capabilities
of Freenet. This is a foundation for future tests which could do fancy
stuff such as testing the Identity introduction code by doing real
uploads / downloads of puzzles and their solutions.

Notice: This might also be interesting to authors of other plugins.
The code is pretty generic and should be easy to re-use there.

- [No bugtracker entry]: Randomized unit tests which aim to cover all
code paths of WOT
Function doRandomChangesToWOT() in the new class
AbstractJUnit4BaseTest is a framework for thorough, randomized unit
tests. It simulates real usage by doing a random amount of changes
chosen among many of the possible UI action:
- WebOfTrust.createOwnIdentity()
- WebOfTrust.deleteOwnIdentity()
- WebOfTrust.restoreOwnIdentity()
- WebOfTrust.restoreOwnIdentity() with existing colliding non-own
Identity
- WebOfTrust.addIdentity()
- WebOfTrust.addContext() (adds context to identity)
- WebOfTrust.setProperty (adds property to identity)
- Add/change/Remove trust values
This can help with testing stuff for which it is difficult to say what
might cause problems.
It is already used for testing-event notifications: Any of the
mentioned user actions are sources of events, so it is a good idea to
test a random permutation of them for whether event-notifications
ships their events correctly.

Thanks to:
- operhiem1 for various pull requests, the great amount of web
interface work, and insane amount of code review.
- bertm for the giant background-job pull request which probably saved
me weeks worth of work
- ArneBab for various pull requests and code review
- TheSeeker for testing
- anyone who I forgot about
- and basically EVERYONE in the project for having the great great
patience of awating this release for over a year. Sorry again that
it took so long! The only explanation I can offer of why this
happend is because I wanted to not release half-finished stuff
anymore given that the whole WOT peformance disaster was a result of
deploying half-finished code as an official plugin. Nevertheless, I
hope to have learned something from all the complaints about the
huge delay of the release, and will try to have a MUCH shorter
release cycle in the future.

[1]
Lines of code were computed excluding the third-party CAPTCHA library
"kaptcha" using the command:
find src/ test/ -iname '*.java' | fgrep -vi kaptcha | xargs wc -l
NOTICE: This use of xargs can be dangerous if used upon directories
which contain files with the newline character in their name.

Mar 29, 2015
56752c7
zip
tar.gz

PreviousNext

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

build0020