Skip to content

Record approved Identity ADRs and validate Decisions build - #92

Merged
szmyty merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
codex/identity-69-disposition-review
Oct 10, 2026
Merged

szmyty merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
codex/identity-69-disposition-review

Conversation

@szmyty

@szmyty szmyty commented Oct 10, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Identity #69 needed explicit human dispositions and canonical records before the shared Decisions collector could admit the real corpus. Maintainer szmyty approved R1 at 418aa9757898b6c09b4f01eface522778cff90e8; the durable approval records that explicit decision on October 10.

This PR applies the approved dispositions to all 21 ADRs, preserves every original substantive prose line and historical date, adds the required metadata/anatomy and 12 exact approved notes, updates the index, and changes the shared caller's ADR adoption from legacy to present. Implementation stays distinct: 12 implemented, 7 in progress, 2 not started; none is marked verified. The frozen R1 packet and earlier receipt remain unchanged.

The new receipt binds immutable source 12227dad43c90b02e14971030f22242f3a205c9d and observation 2026-10-10T15:43:57Z. The final checkpoint e23fad23227b933f524e6677ea1e195cf1ba1788 changes only continuity, the validation guide and that receipt; all 25 selected ADR/index/policy/workflow/configuration blobs match the tested source.

Validation:

  • All 21 schema, anatomy, approval, original-prose preservation and index checks passed; independent review found no blockers.
  • Native ADR collection exited 0: ready, 21 accepted records, complete/current Decisions coverage. Hygiene and coverage valid; Observatory normalized; EgoLint incomplete for other uncollected domains.
  • Native architecture validation exited 0: incomplete/warning, five non-ADR findings and no errors. Native history is bounded at 100 commits; this does not reduce complete ADR collection.
  • Two immutable native replays were byte-identical. Two separate clean full-history production builds produced 19 byte-identical files.
  • Generated Decisions HTML has 21 accepted records, declared approvals and immutable source links; no broken local links/anchors. Manifest SHA-256: f28e126078ff885c008231ea5b38ce72220ce9848f09f0396efbbd392f593cb1.
  • Documentation links, exact continuity schema/12 headings/size/privacy, source-equivalence and whitespace checks passed.
  • At tested source 12227dad, decision validation and CLI validation succeeded. Decision artifact upload was verified through metadata and logs; its archive was not independently downloaded. At final head e23fad23227b933f524e6677ea1e195cf1ba1788, decision validation and CLI validation also succeeded. No final-head archive download is claimed.

The production evidence is local execution of the pinned shared action, with fresh production admission. Review envelopes still deny publication by definition. No production upload, host assignment, deployment or live-route verification is claimed. The existing Brand Kit and organization experience retain their owners.

Next: merge the reviewed source checkpoint, record consumer-owned hosting/route/alias/composition/rollback, deploy a fresh admitted artifact, and obtain maintainer feedback on the real Decisions page before fleet rollout. Keep Identity #69 and Relay #115 open for remaining acceptance.

Decision impact: transcribe the explicitly approved existing ADR dispositions under egohygiene/hygiene#ADR-002; no new hosting architecture is selected. Pinned Aether authoring 2.0.0 and continuity 1.1.0 were loaded from source 8ef3bd34d5fec835da54eb8acd0d074b79ee8fe2; Hygiene policy 1.1.0 remains at c589587395750cd1c79c6fa0bef010189c547249.

Refs #69.

Review all 21 decisions with explicit recommendations, dated scope notes,
and refreshed continuity. Preserve ADR source and pending human authority.

Refs #69
ADR not required: prepares review evidence without changing architecture or dispositions.

szmyty commented Oct 10, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Human ADR disposition — R1 approved on 2026-10-10

Recorded by Codex on behalf of maintainer szmyty, following their explicit approval of the recommendation set and instruction to continue.

Reviewed packet: R1 at 418aa9757898b6c09b4f01eface522778cff90e8.
Reviewed ADR source: 434f60c8b829c695b3bcd1a45faf5e0c114d37cf.

Disposition:

  • Retain the accepted direction now for ADR-001, ADR-002, ADR-003, ADR-004, ADR-005, ADR-006, ADR-007, ADR-008, ADR-009, ADR-010, ADR-011, ADR-012, ADR-013, ADR-014, ADR-015, ADR-016, ADR-017 and ADR-018, with R1's listed scope qualifiers and exact notes N004, N005, N006, N007, N008, N009, N010, N011, N012, N013, N016 and N017.
  • Separately accept ADR-019 (immutable release contract), ADR-020 (channel-registry governance) and ADR-021 (governed mascot package).
  • Record the actual approval date as 2026-10-10. Preserve original text, historical date/status claims and provenance; do not backdate this approval.
  • Continue with canonical metadata/anatomy, the approved clarifications, and shared validation/collection.

The approval retains the intended future Rust validation port while accurately recording current Python validation, as specified by N005. Implementation and verification states remain evidence-bound. The disposition does not select a Decisions host, activate external accounts, approve new creative assets, publish a release or claim deployment.

The delivery sequence remains Identity first: obtain a working deployed Decisions page and maintainer feedback before repository-by-repository fleet adoption.

This comment is the durable record of the maintainer's disposition for the named records and exact packet.

Transcribe maintainer R1 approval with canonical metadata and preserved history.

Roadmap-Step: IDN-Q05
ADR-Ref: egohygiene/hygiene#ADR-002
Retain immutable native, deterministic artifact and hosted advisory evidence.

Roadmap-Step: IDN-Q05
ADR-Ref: egohygiene/hygiene#ADR-002
@szmyty szmyty changed the title docs: prepare review of Identity ADR dispositions Record approved Identity ADRs and validate Decisions build Oct 10, 2026
@szmyty
szmyty marked this pull request as ready for review October 10, 2026 15:49
@szmyty
szmyty merged commit 642d096 into main Oct 10, 2026
2 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant