Mesh distance symmetric #2041
Mesh distance symmetric #2041
Conversation
| auto field = m.distance(m2)[0]; | ||
| auto field = m.distance(m2, Mesh::DistanceMethod::SymmetricPointToCell)[0]; | ||
| // TODO: disable debug | ||
| std::cout << "Debug Mode | Computing distance with SymmetricPointToCell method in Studio Viewer " << std::endl; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
K, let's remove this debug line and I think it's good to go.
| referenceMesh (point) -> targetMesh (cell) (and get closestPoint) | ||
| referenceMesh (cell) -> targetMesh (closestPoint) | ||
| */ | ||
| auto targetCellLocator = vtkSmartPointer<vtkCellLocator>::New(); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
use the faster vtkStaticCellLocator
| targetCellLocator->SetDataSet(target.poly_data_); | ||
| targetCellLocator->BuildLocator(); | ||
|
|
||
| auto refCellLocator = vtkSmartPointer<vtkCellLocator>::New(); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
vtkStaticCellLocator as above
|
Hello, I propose also to add the signed point-to-cell metric, I will amend the commit |
| } | ||
| } break; | ||
|
|
||
| case SymmetricPointToCell: { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Missing a unit test for that case ?
|
@nawazishkhan1-nk , do you have an update on the PR? |
|
@nawazishkhan1-nk , any update on this? |
I don't have the time but I suggest we add the signed point-to-cell metric: the sign is defined as follow: // Determine the signed distance |
|
Additionally, instead of this symmetric distance (that will never be higher than traditional point-to-cell metric), I would propose that we implement the Chamfer Distance (sum of A to B and B to A distances) which is used in numerous publications to compare mesh to mesh. |
The Chamfer Distance, as far as I can find, is only defined for point sets. Do you propose to use vertices only and not the point to cell distance? |
Yes from point sets only. It would be an additional metric along signed and absolute point-to-cell distances. |
[WIP] - Do Not Merge
Summary
This PR addresses issue #2040.
Changes Made
Testing Done
Known Issues
Screenshots
Symmetric Point-to-cell distance vs. regular Point-to-cell distance
