Skip to content

Expanded yield system / auto-pass options#9643

Open
MostCromulent wants to merge 32 commits intoCard-Forge:masterfrom
MostCromulent:YieldRework
Open

Expanded yield system / auto-pass options#9643
MostCromulent wants to merge 32 commits intoCard-Forge:masterfrom
MostCromulent:YieldRework

Conversation

@MostCromulent
Copy link
Contributor

@MostCromulent MostCromulent commented Jan 30, 2026

Screenshot 2026-01-30 202344 Screenshot 2026-01-30 202416 Screenshot 2026-01-30 202451 Screenshot 2026-01-30 204155

Summary

Inspired by recent discussion on the Forge Discord, this PR adds an expanded yield system to reduce click fatigue in multiplayer games and speed up play. Changes are extensively documented in Documentation. Fully backwards compatible with current functionality: the feature is disabled by default and must be explicitly enabled in preferences.

Problem

In multiplayer Magic games (3+ players), the current priority system requires excessive clicking:

  • Dozens of priority passes every turn in a 4-player game.
  • Players must manually pass priority even when they have no possible actions.
  • This creates click fatigue and slows down gameplay significantly (particularly if players are inattentive and don't immediately respond to prompts).

Solution

Expanded yield options that give players more flexibility to control yield timing and conditions. The aim is to help players spend less time responding to unnecessary priority prompts and let them get to their desired phase of action quicker:

Particularly helpful for that one friend who won't pay attention to priority prompts in Commander.

  • Yield Options Panel: Dockable panel with extended yield buttons and visual feedback (blue=ready, red=active)
  • Six Yield Modes: Next Phase, Before Combat, End Step, End Turn, Your Next Turn, Stack Clears
  • Smart Suggestions: Prompts to auto-yield when player cannot respond (no mana, no actions, can't respond to stack). Configurable through checkbox options in game taskbar menu.
  • Configurable Interrupts: Automatically cancels yield when attacked, targeted, mass removal cast, etc. Interrupt conditions are highly configurable through checkbox options in game taskbar menu.
  • F-Key Hotkeys: F1-F6 for yield modes, ESC to cancel.

Key Design Decisions

  • GUI-layer only: No changes to game engine or network protocol (Edit: though see comments below about network implementation to avoid desync).
  • Feature-gated: Default OFF, requires explicit enable + restart
  • Network independent: Each client manages its own yield state locally
  • Backward compatible: Existing Ctrl+E behavior unchanged when feature disabled

Testing

Changes have been tested in local play (thanks to PotionSTAT for testing and feedback). As changes are purely on the GUI layer and do not involve network logic, there is no reason to think testing would not replicate in network use cases. (Edit: see comments about network play below).


Code authored by Claude Code (Opus 4.5) under human direction and review.

MostCromulent and others added 15 commits January 28, 2026 19:52
Adds feature-gated yield options to reduce clicking in multiplayer games:
- 3 yield modes: Until Stack Clears, Until End of Turn, Until Your Next Turn
- Right-click End Turn button for yield menu
- Keyboard shortcuts (Ctrl+Shift+S, Ctrl+Shift+N)
- Smart yield suggestions when player can't respond
- Configurable interrupt conditions via Game menu
- Master toggle in preferences (default OFF)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Add checkbox in Gameplay section (after Auto-Yield)
- Hide yield keyboard shortcuts when feature disabled
- Update description to cover all features

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Fix yield not auto-passing: mayAutoPass() now delegates to
  shouldAutoYieldForPlayer() for experimental yield modes
- Fix keybind/menu not passing priority: added selectButtonOk()
  call after setting yield mode
- Fix re-prompting when already yielding: added getYieldMode()
  method and isAlreadyYielding() check
- Integrate suggestions into prompt UI instead of modal dialogs:
  suggestions now appear in prompt area with Accept/Decline buttons
- Fix "no actions" prompt not firing: hasAvailableActions() now
  checks actual playability via getAllPossibleAbilities() instead
  of just checking if hand is non-empty

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Fix interrupt conditions to only trigger when player is specifically
  attacked (using getAttackersOf instead of getDefenders.contains)
- Separate UNTIL_END_OF_TURN and UNTIL_YOUR_NEXT_TURN end conditions:
  - UNTIL_END_OF_TURN now clears on UNTAP phase of any new turn
  - UNTIL_YOUR_NEXT_TURN clears when player's turn starts
- Remove yieldTurnOwner/yieldTurnNumber tracking (simplified approach)
- Fix menu checkboxes to stay open when toggled

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Documents the yield system rework including:
- Feature overview and yield modes
- Smart yield suggestions
- Interrupt conditions (with multiplayer scoping)
- Technical implementation details
- Testing guide and changelog

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- End Turn button now uses experimental yield system when enabled
- Exclude triggered abilities from "opponent spell" interrupt
  (targeted triggers handled by "targeting" interrupt instead)
- Move Auto-Yields into Yield Options submenu when experimental enabled
- Track turn number for UNTIL_END_OF_TURN to respect phase stops
- Fix yield re-enable after interrupt (track turn on first check)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Clarifies that all code was written by Claude AI under human instruction.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
New features:
- UNTIL_BEFORE_COMBAT: Yield until entering combat phase (F3)
- UNTIL_END_STEP: Yield until end step phase (F4)
- Updated hotkeys: F1-F5 for yield modes, ESC to cancel yield

Bug fixes:
- UNTIL_STACK_CLEARS now checks simultaneous stack entries
- UNTIL_END_OF_TURN no longer interrupted by combat on own turn

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Add turn/phase tracking for UNTIL_END_STEP yield mode (same pattern as combat)
- Add tracking for UNTIL_YOUR_NEXT_TURN to handle clicks during own turn
- Rename "End Turn" button to "Next Turn" for clarity
- Update tooltips to accurately describe yield behavior
- Update documentation to reflect new tracking logic

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Auto-suppress declined suggestions until next turn with hint text
- Fix PlayerView instance matching in yield methods (map key bug)
- Add yield button priority over smart suggestions
- Extend reveal interrupt to cover opponent choices
- Disable yield buttons during cleanup/discard phase
- Add isBeingAttacked helper for planeswalker/battle attacks
- Change YIELD_INTERRUPT_ON_REVEAL default to false
- Update documentation with all changes

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds a new interrupt condition that triggers when an opponent casts a
mass removal spell (board wipes, exile all, etc.) that could affect
the player's permanents. Detects DestroyAll, ChangeZoneAll (with
exile/graveyard destination), DamageAll, and SacrificeAll effects.

Only interrupts if the player has permanents matching the spell's
ValidCards filter - empty board means no interrupt.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
New Features:
- UNTIL_NEXT_PHASE yield mode that clears on any phase transition
- Dynamic hotkey display in tooltips and prompts based on user preferences
- Button layout reordered: Next Phase, Combat, End Step / End Turn, Your Turn, Clear Stack

Hotkey defaults (F1-F6):
- F1: Next Phase (new)
- F2: Combat
- F3: End Step
- F4: End Turn
- F5: Your Turn
- F6: Clear Stack

Files changed:
- YieldMode.java: Added UNTIL_NEXT_PHASE enum
- YieldController.java: Phase tracking, dynamic cancel key display
- VYield.java: New button, dynamic tooltip updates
- CYield.java: Action listener and highlight logic
- KeyboardShortcuts.java: New shortcut action
- ForgePreferences.java: New preference, reordered F-keys
- en-US.properties: Localization with {0} placeholders for hotkeys

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Applied 10 amendments to improve documentation quality:

CRITICAL FIXES:
1. Add missing YieldController.java to file lists and architecture
   - YieldController is a core component that was completely missing
   - Updated "New Files" section from 3 to 4 files

2. Add comprehensive Architecture section
   - Component hierarchy diagram showing GUI layer organization
   - Detailed explanation of YieldController, AbstractGuiGame interaction
   - Network independence architecture with multi-player scenarios
   - Complete data flow diagrams for all yield operations
   - File organization with clear component responsibilities

MODERATE IMPROVEMENTS:
3. Expand State Management section with delegation pattern
   - Show AbstractGuiGame's lazy initialization of YieldController
   - Document YieldCallback interface implementation
   - Add complete state map documentation from YieldController
   - Include mode-specific end condition table

4. Correct Modified Files count and descriptions
   - Updated from 14 to 13 files (removed EDocID, FButton, ProtocolMethod)
   - Improved descriptions to match actual implementation
   - Clarified that network protocol has no yield-specific changes

MINOR ENHANCEMENTS:
5. Clarify Yield Options Panel button layout
   - Document 2-row layout structure
   - Add visual feedback section
   - Note cleanup/discard phase button disabling

6. Add PlayerView lookup technical detail
   - Document TrackableTypes.PlayerViewType.lookup() usage
   - Explain Map key consistency requirement

7. Expand Smart Yield Suggestions section
   - Add preference names for each suggestion type
   - Document auto-suppression behavior in detail
   - Clarify when suggestions appear vs. don't appear
   - Explain yield button priority over suggestions

8. Add Initial Implementation changelog entry
   - Document YieldController architecture rationale
   - Explain delegate and callback pattern choices
   - Note lazy initialization strategy

9. Fix typo: Make "disabled" bold for clarity in interrupt section

10. Add comprehensive Troubleshooting section
    - Yield activation issues
    - Unexpected yield clearing
    - Smart suggestion behavior
    - Network play expectations
    - Performance considerations

The documentation now accurately reflects the codebase implementation,
includes the requested Architecture section explaining component
interactions, and provides helpful troubleshooting guidance for users.

https://claude.ai/code/session_01SBGxSAqnqbpVuEsinNtrnZ
…-OorXS

Comprehensively update DOCUMENTATION.md for accuracy and completeness
DOCUMENTATION.md now contains all PR documentation, making the
separate .documentation/YieldRework-PR.md file redundant.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MostCromulent and others added 3 commits January 31, 2026 06:53
The yield interrupt for "targeted by spell or ability" was not
triggering for Oona, Queen of the Fae's ability because the targeting
is in a sub-ability (DB$ Dig), not the main ability (AB$ ChooseColor).

Modified targetsPlayerOrPermanents() to recursively check sub-instances
via getSubInstance(), ensuring targeting in nested sub-abilities is
properly detected.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Per PR review feedback from tool4ever: hasAvailableActions was identical
to canRespondToStack. Removed the duplicate and reuse canRespondToStack
in shouldShowNoActionsPrompt.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Refactored YieldController to use network-safe GameView properties
instead of gameView.getGame() which returns an unsynchronized dummy
object for network clients.

- Use gameView.getPhase/getTurn/getPlayerTurn/getStack/getCombat
- Use CombatView and StackItemView instead of direct Game access
- Added StackItemView.getApiType() for mass removal detection

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@MostCromulent
Copy link
Contributor Author

MostCromulent commented Jan 30, 2026

Testing by PotionSTAT has revealed an issue with network play integration not realised before PR.

YieldController was using gameView.getGame() which returns an unsynchronized dummy object for network clients. Have refactored to use network-safe GameView properties and added StackItemView.getApiType() for mass removal detection. Will also check implications for smart prompts.

@MostCromulent
Copy link
Contributor Author

MostCromulent commented Jan 30, 2026

Re: Network Code Changes

While the yield system was designed to avoid network protocol changes, in testing discovered that smart suggestions in InputPassPriority had a network compatibility issue requiring new TrackableProperties. This is because the logic was checking the Game object on the server which doesn't exist on network clients.

The solution: Add two TrackableProperties (HasAvailableActions, WillLoseManaAtEndOfPhase) to PlayerView. These piggyback on existing GameView serialization—no protocol changes required. The host calculates these values and they're automatically included when GameView is sent to clients.

The yield system remains client-local; this ensures the data for yield suggestions is synchronized, while yield decisions stay independent per client.

The alternative to making these network changes would have been implementing a more basic heuristic for the yield prompts which would have been a worse and experience for the player.

Edit: Claude AI's explanation for why server needs to know client yield mode state

The server needs to track the client's yield mode to detect end conditions because the client doesn't have access to the same context as the server, which has the authoritative game state and can reliably detect when yield end conditions are met across all players.

When client activates a yield mode it uses notifyYieldModeChanged to notify the server. The server then monitors game state and checks yield end conditions in YieldController.java. When end condition is met the server calls clearYieldMode() which triggers syncYieldModeToClient() to notify the client.

Both server and client stay in sync about yield state. If only the client tracked it, multiplayer edge cases could cause the client to yield too long or not long enough.

MostCromulent and others added 4 commits January 31, 2026 10:18
- Add HasAvailableActions and WillLoseManaAtEndOfPhase TrackableProperties
- Refactor InputPassPriority to use PlayerView/GameView instead of transient Game
- Fix suggestions appearing immediately after yield ends (yieldJustEnded tracking)
- Fix wrong yield mode when clicking yield buttons (legacy set interference)
- Add PlayerView lookup to autoPassUntilEndOfTurn/autoPassCancel methods

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Add setYieldModeSilent() to break infinite recursion when syncing
  yield state between server and client (stack overflow fix)
- Fix getPlayerView() in InputPassPriority to use network-synchronized
  PlayerView from GameView instead of local Player object
- Enhance hasAvailableActions() to actually check mana availability
  using heuristic (CostPartMana.canPay() always returns true)
- Smart suggestions now correctly trigger when player has cards but
  can't afford any spells

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ayout

- Add populate() calls to SLayoutIO.openLayout() and revertLayout() after
  loading completes, following the pattern used in FControl.setCurrentScreen()
- This fixes yield panel not reappearing after View > Refresh Layout or
  Layout > Open operations
- Incidentally fixes the same issue for other dynamic panels (dev mode, etc.)
- Add stale parent cell detection in VMatchUI to handle layout refresh
- In 2-player games, move Clear Stack button to middle position since
  Your Turn button is not shown (only relevant for 3+ player games)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Create user-facing documentation for the experimental yield system:
- Yield modes and their end conditions
- Access methods (panel, right-click menu, keyboard shortcuts)
- Smart yield suggestions
- Configurable interrupt conditions
- Troubleshooting guide

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

private PlayerView getPlayerView() {
return getController().getPlayer().getView();
// For network clients, we need to get the PlayerView from the GameView
Copy link
Contributor

@tool4ever tool4ever Jan 31, 2026

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I still need to investigate this, seems rather hacky

  • but if it's needed it should reuse lookupPlayerViewById

Copy link
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I'll address the duplicate function issue now, and can come back to this if you find a better approach.

Move lookupPlayerViewById to IGuiGame interface and reuse in
InputPassPriority instead of duplicating the ID-based lookup logic.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
MostCromulent and others added 8 commits February 1, 2026 07:49
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Mobile GUI (Libgdx) doesn't support the yield panel, so check
isLibgdxPort() before enabling experimental yield features.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Clicking an already-active (highlighted) yield button now deactivates
that yield mode, giving users an intuitive way to cancel auto-yield
without using the ESC key.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Replace multiple per-mode tracking maps with single YieldState object
- Extract isAtOrAfterCombat() and isAtOrAfterEndStep() helpers
- Share formatShortcutDisplayText() between YieldController and VYield
- Extract isValidSuggestionContext() to reduce duplication in InputPassPriority
- Add safety check for UNTIL_NEXT_PHASE when startPhase wasn't initialized

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Move hasManaAvailable() helper from InputPassPriority to PlayerView
per reviewer feedback to keep helpers closer to their intended usage.

Add trackAvailableActions flag to GameRules to control whether the
expensive hasAvailableActions() computation runs on priority passes.
The flag is set based on YIELD_EXPERIMENTAL_OPTIONS preference.

Network play note: The computation is controlled by the host's
preferences. Checking per-client preferences would require network
protocol changes (clients communicating preferences during match
setup), which adds complexity not warranted for an experimental
feature. Individual suggestion toggles still control client-side
display independently.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds two toggleable preferences to control when yield suggestions are
suppressed:
- "Suppress On Own Turn" (default ON): Suppresses suggestions during the
  player's own turn (always suppressed on first turn regardless)
- "Suppress After Yield Ends" (default ON): Suppresses suggestions for
  one priority pass after a yield expires or is interrupted

Both options appear in Game > Yield Options > Automatic Suggestions.

Updates Expanded-Yield-Options.md to document both behaviors.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Documentation preserved in NetworkPlay/dev:.documentation/YieldRework-Documentation.md

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…nces

Addresses PR Card-Forge#9643 feedback from tool4ever on commit cbcd373:

1. "the code should probably also be moved to the View classes"
   - Moved hasAvailableActions() computation from Player to PlayerView
   - PlayerView.updateHasAvailableActions() now contains full logic

2. "that commit did not clean up Player class"
   - Removed hasAvailableActions() and updateAvailableActionsForView()
   - Player.java no longer has yield-related methods

3. "we definitely don't want another field in GameRules class"
   - Removed trackAvailableActions field and accessors from GameRules
   - Removed setTrackAvailableActions() call from HostedMatch

4. "should just query the PlayerController"
   - Added shouldTrackAvailableActions() to PlayerController (returns false)
   - PlayerControllerHuman overrides to check YIELD_EXPERIMENTAL_OPTIONS
   - PhaseHandler queries controller, skipping AI players automatically

This approach keeps GUI preferences out of the game engine, enables
per-player preference checking, and maintains network compatibility.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@tehdiplomat tehdiplomat added the QOL Quality of Life label Feb 1, 2026
Only compute mana loss warnings when experimental yields are enabled,
matching the pattern used for updateHasAvailableActions. This avoids
unnecessary computation for AI players and when the feature is disabled.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

QOL Quality of Life

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

5 participants