onsubmit should be a SubmitEvent, not a FocusEvent

[WorldSEnder]

Problem

yew/packages/yew/src/html/listener/events.rs

Line 169 in 3758e6d

onsubmit(FocusEvent)

That sounds.. wrong.

Questionnaire

• I'm interested in fixing this myself but don't know where to start
• I would like to fix and I have a solution
• I don't have time to fix this right now, but maybe later

[siku2]

Agreed. I think most of the event types are sourced from the MDN docs, which unfortunately don't appear to very trustworthy in this case.
We should reference a proper source like the HTML spec itself for the event types going forward.

[prockallsyms]

Would this be the spec we should reference? Also what would it take to correct this? I'd love to help.

[WorldSEnder]

@Dom-1 oh yeah, that spec should serve fine. Following the links on the Event handler event types also takes one directly to the event type as specified by IDL. For reference, the event types are implemented in

yew/packages/yew/src/html/listener/events.rs

Lines 75 to 213 in 3758e6d

	// Unspecialized event type
	impl_short! {
	onabort
	oncancel
	oncanplay
	oncanplaythrough
	onclose
	oncuechange
	ondurationchange
	onemptied
	onended
	onerror
	onformdata // web_sys doesn't have a struct for `FormDataEvent`
	oninvalid
	onload
	onloadeddata
	onloadedmetadata
	onpause
	onplay
	onplaying
	onratechange
	onreset
	onresize
	onsecuritypolicyviolation
	onseeked
	onseeking
	onselect
	onslotchange
	onstalled
	onsuspend
	ontimeupdate
	ontoggle
	onvolumechange
	onwaiting
	onchange
	oncopy
	oncut
	onpaste
	onpointerlockchange
	onpointerlockerror
	onselectionchange
	onselectstart
	onshow
	}
	// Specialized event type
	impl_short! {
	onauxclick(MouseEvent)
	onclick(MouseEvent)
	oncontextmenu(MouseEvent)
	ondblclick(MouseEvent)
	ondrag(DragEvent)
	ondragend(DragEvent)
	ondragenter(DragEvent)
	ondragexit(DragEvent)
	ondragleave(DragEvent)
	ondragover(DragEvent)
	ondragstart(DragEvent)
	ondrop(DragEvent)
	onblur(FocusEvent)
	onfocus(FocusEvent)
	onfocusin(FocusEvent)
	onfocusout(FocusEvent)
	onkeydown(KeyboardEvent)
	onkeypress(KeyboardEvent)
	onkeyup(KeyboardEvent)
	onloadstart(ProgressEvent)
	onprogress(ProgressEvent)
	onloadend(ProgressEvent)
	onmousedown(MouseEvent)
	onmouseenter(MouseEvent)
	onmouseleave(MouseEvent)
	onmousemove(MouseEvent)
	onmouseout(MouseEvent)
	onmouseover(MouseEvent)
	onmouseup(MouseEvent)
	onwheel(WheelEvent)
	oninput(InputEvent)
	onsubmit(FocusEvent)
	onanimationcancel(AnimationEvent)
	onanimationend(AnimationEvent)
	onanimationiteration(AnimationEvent)
	onanimationstart(AnimationEvent)
	ongotpointercapture(PointerEvent)
	onlostpointercapture(PointerEvent)
	onpointercancel(PointerEvent)
	onpointerdown(PointerEvent)
	onpointerenter(PointerEvent)
	onpointerleave(PointerEvent)
	onpointermove(PointerEvent)
	onpointerout(PointerEvent)
	onpointerover(PointerEvent)
	onpointerup(PointerEvent)
	ontouchcancel(TouchEvent)
	ontouchend(TouchEvent)
	ontransitioncancel(TransitionEvent)
	ontransitionend(TransitionEvent)
	ontransitionrun(TransitionEvent)
	ontransitionstart(TransitionEvent)
	}
	macro_rules! impl_passive {
	($($action:ident($type:ident))*) => {
	impl_action! {
	$(
	$action($type, true) -> web_sys::$type
	=> crate::html::listener::cast_event
	)*
	}
	};
	}
	// Best used with passive listeners for responsiveness
	impl_passive! {
	onscroll(Event)
	ontouchmove(TouchEvent)
	ontouchstart(TouchEvent)
	}

[prockallsyms]

@WorldSEnder From my understanding, the current state of the issue is that web_sys doesn't provide the entirety of the Event types which we require for our event handlers. Should we consider building those into Yew for the sake of cohesion, or should work be done in web_sys to provide the necessary Event types?

[WorldSEnder]

@Dom-1 I hope we see a merge and web-sys release including rustwasm/wasm-bindgen#2922 before yew 0.20, otherwise I think the best strategy is to fallback to the unspecific Event for now.

[ranile]

@Dom-1 I hope we see a merge and web-sys release including rustwasm/wasm-bindgen#2922 before yew 0.20, otherwise I think the best strategy is to fallback to the unspecific Event for now.

Seems like it has been merged and released as part of 0.2.81

[spanishpear]

Any issues with me (attempting) to pick this up? Would be my first non-documentation PR so I won't be as good as y'all 😝

[WorldSEnder]

@Dom-1 are you still on this? I think the prerequisites are in place now

[prockallsyms]

My apologies, things have picked up in pace at my work and I haven't had the time to commit. If someone else would like to pick it up that's alright with me.

From what I understand, all you have to do is change FocusEvent to SubmitEvent and then include it in the Cargo.toml.

Also I'm not sure if this is the problem of the person sending this PR or perhaps another issue we should open, but the other event types should be checked for correctness.

[WorldSEnder]

@Dom-1 ty for the response, no worries.

@spanishpear if you want to take it up, go ahead. Double-checking the other types mentioned in the spec would be appreciated but just correcting the SubmitEvent would make a fine PR too.

[ranile]

It seems @spanishpear isn't taking up on this so I'll take this up