Skip to content

Conversation

@tomasnorre
Copy link
Owner

@tomasnorre tomasnorre commented Aug 20, 2025

Description

This is a PR idea that might solve the problem with issue #1137 at the end, this is still rough WIP, but wanted some feedback.

Breaking Change

This will result in a breaking change, as the runPollSuccessHooks hook changes. See documentation changes for more info.

I have

  • Checked that CGL are followed
  • Checked that the Tests are still working
  • Added description to CHANGELOG.md (github-handle is optional)
  • Added tests for the new code

@tomasnorre
Copy link
Owner Author

@cweiske As you are currently quite active, which I highly appreciate, do you have an suggestion/feedback/opinion on this PR?

And if you like the approach could you help me get the tests green again?

@cweiske
Copy link
Contributor

cweiske commented Aug 28, 2025

At first I thought that a simple variable in the CrawlerInitialization class could be used instead of applicationData, but as I see it, the problem is that other extensions have to be able to communicate their success to crawler somehow.
Writing applicationData was an easy way to do that without having to know if crawler is installed at all.

With the removal of applicationData, extensions must to be adjusted, in one way or another. In this case, crawler could provide an API method for the other extensions and would not need to rely on the request attributes at all.

My suggestion would be a static method e.g. CrawlerInitialization::extensionSuccess($key, $status) that other extensions would need to call instead setting $GLOBALS['TSFE']->applicationData['tx_crawler']['success'][$key] = true. This would need to be wrapped in a if (class_exists()) call of course.

@tomasnorre
Copy link
Owner Author

Thanks for your input, I'll take that into consideration. I don't have a solution/final idea myself yet.

@tomasnorre tomasnorre changed the title [WIP] Idea for solving applicationData is deprecated [TASK] Replace application with request attributes Oct 27, 2025
@tomasnorre tomasnorre changed the title [TASK] Replace application with request attributes [TASK] Replace deprecated applicationData with request attributes Oct 27, 2025
@tomasnorre tomasnorre changed the title [TASK] Replace deprecated applicationData with request attributes !!! [TASK] Replace deprecated applicationData with request attributes Oct 28, 2025
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants