Skip to content

stac-fastapi-core does not support configuring a STAC application with common extensions disabled #263

Open
@sirosen

Description

@sirosen

Describe the bug

When attempting to define a stac-fastapi-core-based application with the Query Extension disabled, I found that stac-fastapi-core would emit an attribute error and crashfail.
Specifically, the logic for handling a POST Search request here:

I found that this also happens with the sortby and token pagination extensions. Removing these makes the application inoperable.

To Reproduce

  1. Create a new application, e.g., based off of the mongodb example
  2. Remove the QueryExtension from the application's extensions
  3. Start the app (it will start)
  4. Send any valid POST Search
  5. 💥

Expected behavior

With Query disabled, searches should function.
The same holds for Sort and Token Pagination, but the case is clearest with Query (which is deprecated).

Additional context

I'm experimenting with building an application for my team, so I don't have a lot of knowledge around STAC. We're still learning the spec(s) and trying things out.
For now, we're trying to get a very early stage prototype up and running, so I've implemented this very clumsy hack:

class CustomizedCoreClient(CoreClient):
    async def post_search(self, search_request, request):
        object.__setattr__(search_request, "query", None)
        object.__setattr__(search_request, "sortby", None)
        object.__setattr__(search_request, "token", None)
        return await super().post_search(search_request, request)

I think the best pattern for the stac-fastapi-core code would be to check with hasattr(...) or three-argument getattr(..., ..., None).

I'm happy to contribute a PR with this sort of fix if it would be welcome.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions