[Bug]: Can’t validate numerical string as `type`: `integer`/`number`/`boolean` wrapped in `allOf`/`anyOf`/`oneOf`

[andersk]

Actual Behavior

The string 123 from a path or query parameter validates as {"type": "integer"}, but unexpectedly fails to validate as {"allOf": [{"type": "integer"}]}. The same problem occurs with number or boolean in place of integer, or anyOf or oneOf in place of allOf.

(My actual use case involves {"oneOf": [{"type": "string", "enum": ["newest", "oldest", "first_unread"]}, {"type": "integer"}]}.)

Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/decorators.py", line 31, in wrapper
    return f(*args, **kwds)
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/request/validators.py", line 200, in _get_parameter
    value, _ = self._get_param_or_header_and_schema(param, location)
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/validators.py", line 166, in _get_param_or_header_and_schema
    self._validate_schema(schema, casted)
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/validators.py", line 144, in _validate_schema
    validator.validate(value)
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/schemas/validators.py", line 36, in validate
    raise InvalidSchemaValue(value, schema_type, schema_errors=errors)
openapi_core.validation.schemas.exceptions.InvalidSchemaValue: Value 123 not valid for schema of type any: (<ValidationError: "'123' is not of type 'integer'">,)

The above exception was the direct cause of the following exception:

Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/test.py", line 41, in <module>
    validate_request(request, spec=spec)  # error
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/shortcuts.py", line 321, in validate_request
    validate_apicall_request(
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/shortcuts.py", line 396, in validate_apicall_request
    return v.validate(request)
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/request/validators.py", line 279, in validate
    raise err
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/request/validators.py", line 164, in _get_parameters
    value = self._get_parameter(parameters, param)
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/decorators.py", line 33, in wrapper
    self._raise_error(exc, self.err_validate_cls, f, *args, **kwds)
  File "/home/anders/python/openapi-core/openapi_core/validation/decorators.py", line 58, in _raise_error
    raise init(**kw) from exc
openapi_core.validation.request.exceptions.InvalidParameter: Invalid path parameter: bar_id

Expected Behavior

No error. A string that validates as {"type": "integer"} should also validate as {"allOf": [{"type": "integer"}]}.

Steps to Reproduce

from openapi_core import Spec, validate_request
from openapi_core.testing import MockRequest

spec = Spec.from_dict(
    {
        "openapi": "3.1.0",
        "info": {"title": "test", "version": "0"},
        "paths": {
            "/foo/{foo_id}": {
                "get": {
                    "parameters": [
                        {
                            "name": "foo_id",
                            "in": "path",
                            "required": True,
                            "schema": {"type": "integer"},
                        },
                    ],
                },
            },
            "/bar/{bar_id}": {
                "get": {
                    "parameters": [
                        {
                            "name": "bar_id",
                            "in": "path",
                            "required": True,
                            "schema": {"allOf": [{"type": "integer"}]},
                        },
                    ],
                },
            },
        },
    }
)

request = MockRequest("http://localhost", "get", "/foo/123")
validate_request(request, spec=spec)  # ok

request = MockRequest("http://localhost", "get", "/bar/123")
validate_request(request, spec=spec)  # error

OpenAPI Core Version

0.18.1 or current Git (0838a84)

OpenAPI Core Integration

none

Affected Area(s)

No response

References

No response

Anything else we need to know?

No response

Would you like to implement a fix?

None

[p1c2u]

Hi @andersk

thanks for the report. This one will require type finding in AnyCaster implementation right after ObjectCaster.

[p1c2u]

Unfortunately it's not so straightforward to make it work soon.

[andersk]

Hmm, I can see why this would be difficult. There are some questions here that the specification doesn’t seem to address; for example, if a path or query value 123 validates as both {"type": "integer"} (with casting) and {"type": "string"} (without casting), should it also validate as {"allOf": [{"type": "integer"}, {"type": "string"}]}, even though one would expect that to be self-contradictory in the ordinary JSON schema sense? I’m not sure what the right answer is.

Do you happen to know what part of the specification allows a path or query value 123 to validate as {"type": "integer"} in the first place? It’s certainly convenient and what I’d expect without trying to lawyer too hard, but I haven’t found a justification for it in the specification.

[tobiajung]

Hello, what is the state of this issue?
We are interested in using this for openapi validations but due to the still existing problem mentioned in the OP we unfortunately cannot really use this.