Skip to content

Support for nightly releases in pypi #8792

Open

Description

I would like to open a discussion around what might nightly build support in pypi look like.
First, a small IRC paste:

omry> What's the general take on publishing nightly releases to pypi? the package is not large (about 200kb now), but I am not sure if things like maintaining last X nightlies are doable (nuke old nightly as if they never existed).
mgedmin> my gut feeling is "please don't", but I'm not a pypa member
PSFSlack5> omry: If the project is small, it's not really a big deal.
omry> PSFSlack5: my concern is more about polluting the version name-space. is there a programmatic way to delete packages?
PSFSlack5> omry: There is not. Some projects do a separate project name entirely, like https://pypi.org/p/tf-nightly
omry> PSFSlack5, that's not a bad solution. It would be nice to have a programmatic interface to manipulate packages for cases like this.
omry> in the tf example, they upload about 1GB a day: https://pypi.org/project/tf-nightly/2.4.0.dev20201018/#files
omry> I don't think they want to keep old nightlies forever.
cooperlees> omry: Prob worth an issue / discussion @ https://github.com/pypa/warehouse/issues
cooperlees> I'd love to see nightlies be able to only keep the last x weeks of nightlies for example and stable releases. Would be helpful for bandersnatch / mirror peoples

Something that could be nice is a way to maintain X last nightly packages automatically and have older nightlies be automatically deleted.

The pip client can potentially provide a specific error for people who are trying to install deleted nightly packages, something like:

The nightly package foo==version expired. 
Please install a newer nightly package or switch to a stable release.
nightly versions: [newest K nightly versions]
stable versions: [newest K stable versions]

Pip should also not show nightly packages in the message it normally shows when there is a mismatch version number.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions