[BUG] Releases 1.8.1 and 1.8.2 on PyPI don't work when installed with_$EXTRA or with-$EXTRA

[volans-]

Describe the bug

When trying to install the latest version of Prospector from PyPI 1.8.1 with some extras like with_everything or with_pyroma a warning is printed and Prospector is installed without the extras.

To Reproduce

$ pip install "prospector[with_pyroma]"
Collecting prospector[with_pyroma]
  Using cached prospector-1.8.1-py3-none-any.whl (85 kB)
WARNING: prospector 1.8.1 does not provide the extra 'with_pyroma'
...

or

$ pip install "prospector[with_everything]"
Collecting prospector[with_everything]
  Using cached prospector-1.8.1-py3-none-any.whl (85 kB)
WARNING: prospector 1.8.1 does not provide the extra 'with_everything'
...

Expected behavior

It should install Prospector with the selected extras.

Environment:

• OS: macOS 12.6.1
• Prospector version 1.8.1
• Python versions: 3.9.15 and 3.10.8

[sbrunner]

Isn't it related to this issue?
python-poetry/poetry#6819

[Pierre-Sassoulas]

Does [with-everything] works ?

[volans-]

Isn't it related to this issue? python-poetry/poetry#6819

It looks like it, [with-everything] does actually work.

[Pierre-Sassoulas]

I think we have to upgrade the doc, this is a poetry behavior that will be painful to change.

[ckleemann]

This issue also happens when installing from pip. There is a glitch in the doc. Before it was [with _ everything] now it is [with - everything]

[volans-]

It looks like it, [with-everything] does actually work.

Actually I have to correct myself, although the pip installation works, prospector is not able to run the extra tool though.

Repro steps:

$ pip install "prospector[with-everything]"
...

$ pip freeze | grep -E '(pyroma|prospector)'
prospector==1.8.1
pyroma==4.1

$ cat prospector.yaml
pyroma:
  run: true

$ prospector --profile prospector.yaml test/

Cannot run tool pyroma as support was not installed.
Please install by running 'pip install prospector[with_pyroma]'

[sbrunner]

For me, you should publish prospector with on older version of poetry since it is fixed in pip...

[Pierre-Sassoulas]

I think you mean we should use an old version of poetry when releasing but I did not understand "this is fixed in pip" @sbrunner ?

[sbrunner]

In this issue python-poetry/poetry#6819
It says that an issue in pip about PEP 685.
Issue in pip: pypa/pip#11445
Merged pull request in packaging: pypa/packaging#545
Release issue in packaging: pypa/packaging#569
In the last message we see that should be done soon :-)