How does this compare to `run: corepack enable`?

[mmkal]

Similar to #30 - I am wondering if there's an advantage to using this vs just running corepack enable, which as far as I understand, will instruct node itself to download and install pnpm, and will respect the packageManager field in package.json.

I'm doing this in my expect-type repo (permalink) and it seems to be working - is there a downside that you know of?

[zkochan]

The advantage is that this installs the "executable" version of pnpm, which is bundled with node.js using vercel/pkg. The "executable" version of pnpm is a bit faster and can run on any version of node.js.

[segevfiner]

Is this really true? Isn't this a flag https://github.com/pnpm/action-setup/tree/v2#standalone ?

[paescuj]

Surely, an advantage over corepack is that the action already takes care of store prune, see https://github.com/pnpm/action-setup#use-cache-to-reduce-installation-time.

[jrr]

One downside is that corepack is still marked as experimental: https://nodejs.org/docs/latest-v20.x/api/corepack.html

[zkochan]

@segevfiner yes, it is turned off by default at the moment.

There is nothing wrong with corepack. In our docs we actually recommend corepack for all CIs except Github actions: https://pnpm.io/continuous-integration. But there is nothing wrong with using corepack instead of this action.

[karlhorky]

Edit: as of pnpm/action-setup@v4, the error described below is surfaced proactively to users with suggestions how to fix the configuration.

One downside of pnpm/action-setup vs corepack enable is that it can lead to ERR_PNPM_BAD_PM_VERSION failures on pnpm install when using the packageManager field in package.json:

1. Configure a pnpm/action-setup step with version: 'latest'
2. Configure packageManager in package.json with an old version eg. "packageManager": "pnpm@9.0.3"
3. Observe the ERR_PNPM_BAD_PM_VERSION error below on pnpm install on CI 💥

$ pnpm install
 ERR_PNPM_BAD_PM_VERSION  This project is configured to use v9.0.3 of pnpm. Your current pnpm is v9.0.4

If you want to bypass this version check, you can set the "package-manager-strict" configuration to "false" or set the "COREPACK_ENABLE_STRICT" environment variable to "0"

Workaround 1

Remove the version: 'latest' config to enable packageManager support:

       - uses: pnpm/action-setup@v3
         with:
-          version: 'latest'

Workaround 2

Switch pnpm/action-setup to corepack enable to resolve this error:

-      - uses: pnpm/action-setup@v3
-        with:
-          version: 'latest'
+      - run: corepack enable

Workaround 3

Always keep packageManager in package.json immediately up to date, eg. using a bot like Renovate bot

[karlhorky]

@zkochan because of the ERR_PNPM_BAD_PM_VERSION error above, maybe pnpm/action-setup should be removed as the recommendation for GitHub Actions?

(to avoid users running into this footgun, especially since packageManager is the recommended way of setting a pnpm version on some platforms like Netlify)

Or, alternatively, if pnpm/action-setup would automatically respect the version in packageManager in package.json, that would be another option (as a feature request to pnpm/action-setup).

[segevfiner]

Doesn't it already have a feature to look at packageManager if you don't specify version? Check the README, I remember I configured it like this.

[karlhorky]

Indeed, I somehow missed this!

As per the pnpm/action-setup docs about the version option, to use the packageManager version, you can just omit the version config:

version

Version of pnpm to install.

Optional when there is a packageManager field in the package.json.

However, this should probably error in the action when packageManager is set and version is specified.

I'll create an issue

[karlhorky]

Ok I ended up creating a PR for this instead - to throw an error if multiple versions of pnpm are specified:

• Throw error when multiple versions specified #122

[jasonkuhrt]

It seems that using core pack does not enable global installs?

Run pnpm install -g tsx
 ERR_PNPM_NO_GLOBAL_BIN_DIR  Unable to find the global bin directory

Run "pnpm setup" to create it automatically, or set the global-bin-dir setting, or the PNPM_HOME env variable. The global bin directory should be in the PATH.

https://github.com/graffle-js/graffle/actions/runs/11783197937/job/32819852527?pr=1259