SMP lookup doesn't work properly

[pstetsuk]

SMP lookup doesn't work if ProcessIdentifier defined in uppercase on server
In the example the first smpClient.getEndpoint() returns the endpoind but the second call - returns null

[phax]

Hi Pavel!
This works as expected.
According to PEPPOL Policy for identifiers (see http://peppol.eu/downloads/?rel=tab87 - or https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/svn/peppol/TransportInfrastructure/PEPPOL_Policy%20for%20use%20of%20identifiers-300.pdf) the following applies:
POLICY 3: docType and process identifier values have to be treated case sensitive

[pstetsuk]

Hi Philip!
Thank you for checking this out.

[phax]

No problem - your welcome.
In OASIS BDXR SMP this is handled slightly different.
When using the bdx-procid-transport process identifier scheme there, it will be handled case insensitive :)

[phax]

And the problem in this example is the uppercase document type ID - maybe I was telling this to Hatem by accident. Should be case sensitive (see POLICY 3)

[pstetsuk]

Yes, but I think this is not a problem.

[phax]

I modified your code slightly - the uppercase document type ID should not work

[phax]

According to https://peppol.helger.com/public/locale-en_US/menuitem-tools-participant?scheme=iso6523-actorid-upis&value=0088%3A5060510050006&sml=digitprod&action=perform all docType IDs are lowercase on your side

[pstetsuk]

This is not our SMP
In SMP response all in upper case (DocumentIdentifier and ProcessIdentifier):
http://b-f7476450c0de81b01954e004dbd142c1.iso6523-actorid-upis.edelivery.tech.ec.europa.eu/iso6523-actorid-upis%3A%3A0088%3A5060510050006/services/busdox-docid-qns%3A%3Aurn%3Aoasis%3Anames%3Aspecification%3Aubl%3Aschema%3Axsd%3AOrder-2%3A%3AOrder%23%23urn%3Awww.cenbii.eu%3Atransaction%3Abiitrns001%3Aver2.0%3Aextended%3Aurn%3Awww.peppol.eu%3Abis%3Apeppol28a%3Aver1.0%3A%3A2.1

[phax]

You're right but:
The overview at http://b-f7476450c0de81b01954e004dbd142c1.iso6523-actorid-upis.edelivery.tech.ec.europa.eu/iso6523-actorid-upis%3A%3A0088%3A5060510050006/ shows the lowercase URL!
We're getting closer....

[pstetsuk]

Looks like the issue in SMP implementation

[phax]

I added an example DocType ID in uppercase and it is shown correctly:
http://test-infra.peppol.at/iso6523-actorid-upis%3A%3A9915%3Atest
(search for FOO).

[phax]

When opening
http://test-infra.peppol.at/iso6523-actorid-upis%3A%3A9915%3Atest/services/busdox-docid-qns%3A%3ABLA-FOO-FASEL%3A%3ALOCALRoot%23%23urn%3Awww.cenbii.eu%3Atransaction%3Abiitrns014%3Aver2.0%3Aextended%3Aurn%3Awww.peppol.eu%3Abis%3Apeppol5a%3Aver2.0%3A%3A2.1 everything works.

Changing to http://test-infra.peppol.at/iso6523-actorid-upis%3A%3A9915%3Atest/services/busdox-docid-qns%3A%3ABLA-foo-FASEL%3A%3ALOCALRoot%23%23urn%3Awww.cenbii.eu%3Atransaction%3Abiitrns014%3Aver2.0%3Aextended%3Aurn%3Awww.peppol.eu%3Abis%3Apeppol5a%3Aver2.0%3A%3A2.1 (lowercase "foo") fails as expected.

But changing to http://test-infra.peppol.at/iso6523-actorid-upis%3A%3A9915%3ATEST/services/busdox-docid-qns%3A%3ABLA-FOO-FASEL%3A%3ALOCALRoot%23%23urn%3Awww.cenbii.eu%3Atransaction%3Abiitrns014%3Aver2.0%3Aextended%3Aurn%3Awww.peppol.eu%3Abis%3Apeppol5a%3Aver2.0%3A%3A2.1 (uppercase "TEST" in participant ID) works

So it must be something in your SMP implementation

[pstetsuk]

I wrote before that this is not our SMP (I don't know which implementation they are using).
But now I have enough information for our support team.
Thank you.