Skip to content

3161 only for parking=surface #2466

Open
@maro-21

Description

@maro-21

Continuing my post #626 (comment) and other posts in that thread,
and also #1722
I would like to again ask for change this issue, because it generates a lot of issues and a lot of false positives and it suggests wrong values out of nowhere. So:

  • It should check ONLY amenity=parking with parking=surface because only these parking lots need parking aisles.
  • Currently there are many parking=* values, so it should NOT suggest adding parking=street_side. Why it does?!
    http://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/#item=3161&zoom=16&lat=51.15494&lon=16.89976&level=1%2C2%2C3&tags=&fixable=
    This text is even contradictory, because in the title it suggests adding a road, and in the content it suggests adding value parking=street_side:
    Image
    These parking values don't need an access way:
    underground
    carports
    garage_boxes
    sheds
    lane
    street_side
    on_kerb
    half_on_kerb
    shoulder
    layby
  • Don't raise this issue for parking lots WITHOUT parking= because when you don't know what kind of parking it is, you don't know if you need to add a road, and in most cases you don't need to, because surface parking lots are already in the minority. The majority are small street parking lots.
    I would suggest not to have issues for amenity=parkings without any parking=* because there would be too many of them. There is a StreetComplete task to choose the parking type. So Osmose will work only for Surface parking lots.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions