Skip to content

Conversation

salinhkuhn
Copy link
Contributor

@salinhkuhn salinhkuhn commented Aug 25, 2025

Adding a third compilation flow to generate.py and mc-anaylsis.py to compare against not only SelectionDAG but also GlobalISel.

I only changed generate.py and the Mac script by adding self-contained additional functions without touching @luisacicolini code or changing any of it. I adapt her style and added a third folder for the GlobalISel flow.

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

4 similar comments
Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

3 similar comments
Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

1 similar comment
Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /home/runner/work/lean-mlir/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Copy link

bv_decide solved 0 theorems.
bitwuzla solved 0 theorems.
bv_decide found 0 counterexamples.
bitwuzla found 0 counterexamples.
bv_decide only failed on 0 problems.
bitwuzla only failed on 0 problems.
both bitwuzla and bv_decide failed on 0 problems.
In total, bitwuzla saw 0 problems.
In total, bv_decide saw 0 problems.
ran rg 'LeanSAT provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla provided a counter' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'LeanSAT proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
ran rg 'Bitwuzla proved' | wc -l, this file found 0, rg found 0, SUCCESS
The InstCombine benchmark contains 4520 theorems in total.
Saved dataframe at: /code/lean-mlir/bv-evaluation/raw-data/InstCombine/instcombine_ceg_data.csv
all_files_solved_bitwuzla_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_rw_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_bb_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_sat_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratt_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
all_files_solved_bv_decide_lratc_times_stddev avg: nan | stddev: nan
mean of percentage stddev/av: nan%

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants