Checkboxes should have more prominent style

[schemar]

The checkbox of a task should have a prominent style in order to signify a task.
If possible, use existing css variables from the background/foreground to be in line with the current theme.

[schemar]

See also https://github.com/deathau/obsidian-snippets#checkboxes and https://github.com/deathau/obsidian-snippets/blob/main/checkbox.css

[SimplGy]

I'm sort of poking around for a way to adjust theckboxes in editor view. I notice all this css is only for the preview.

Just curious; have you find a way to target checkboxes in the editor view? (especially, differentiating complete VS incomplete VS some of the new states like canceled)

I'm looking in dev tools but I see very generic things like cm-list-1, nothing like data-task="completed"

[schemar]

Hey there, I wouldn't know how to style checkboxes in the editor view. How do you edit the [ ] text in the editor if it is styled as a checkbox? Or maybe I don't get what you want to achieve?

[SimplGy]

Ah, didn't realize the use case isn't obvious.

• I only use edit mode, and I use a lot of checkboxes.
• I have keyboard shortcuts to toggle checkbox, complete, incomplete. You can also just type an x
• having the checkbox colorized is useful for scannability. Also it's psychologically rewarding to see green ✅ completed checkmarks. I think there might be some research supporting this claim :)

I did hack in some css, but it relies on selectors that were clearly not named for what I'm using them for, so I expect it to break at any time. It's been stable for a few months though, which is great.

I prepared a video showing how I use checkmarks in edit mode:

obsidian.tasks.-.edit.mode.mov

There's some existing precedent I've found for doing things with checkboxes in edit mode:

• Code Mirror, syncing checkbox clicks: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/62684743/sync-checkbox-click-in-html-to-content-of-markdown-editor
• HyperMD's click to toggle checkbox, and also here

The new wysywig mode isn't really something I'm looking for, personally. I still want to see the MD syntax, but I do like a color or other hint when the syntax is picked up.

Here is the CSS snippet for how I style these (really bad, would like to add more obvious sigils and be able to support in progress/indeterminate tasks too):

/* 
 * Make checklists easier to see in "edit mode" (normal text editor mode)
 * Styling for checkboxes in edit mode.
 * completed task: "good"
 * incomplete task: "notice"
 *
 * would love to support the other checkbox states, but need to enhance codemirror annotation first.
 */
/* The checkbox itself */
.HyperMD-list-line .cm-property {
	color: #499c49 !important;
	font-weight: bold;
        background-color: rgba(120,255,120,0.05);
}
/* The text of this task (sibling of the checkbox) */
.HyperMD-list-line .cm-property + [class^="cm-list-"] {
	/* Goal: make it look happy & successful, but also toned down a little bit, since the task is finished */
	color: #91dd91 !important;
}

/* Incomplete Tasks are kind of amber/yellowish */
.HyperMD-list-line .cm-meta {
	color: orange !important;
	font-weight: bold;
        background-color: rgba(255,200,200,0.10);
}
/* The text of this task (sibling of the checkbox) */
.HyperMD-list-line .cm-meta + [class^="cm-list-"] {
	/* Goal: make it look a little different/brighter than normal text, but not too much */
	color: palegoldenrod !important;
}

[pcause]

the new task collector plugin allows different styles to say a task is in progress and the like. They do this by placing different characters in the checkbox ( a > or / or ..). It would be great if tasks could work with this and only sow items as completed if a certain set of characters were present in the checkbnox. So [x] or [-] might be completed but anything else, [>] would not be treated as completed.

[schemar]

Thanks, @pcause. It would be nice to have these semantics in Tasks and I'd be happy to review a PR with those changes. However, due to my limited time, I won't be able to provide this soon.

[sytone]

I have been playing with a change that allows multiple states for a task, I have the basics in place for switching between them. For the query part there would be a new filter type called state.

So the pattern below would apply. For rendering the user can do what they want based on the status character via CSS like task collector.

state (includes|does not include) ( |x|-|/|etc....)

@SimplGy and @pcause would that help out your scenarios?

[claremacrae]

I have been playing with a change that allows multiple states for a task, I have the basics in place for switching between them. For the query part there would be a new filter type called state.

That's awesome news - thanks @sytone !

So the pattern below would apply. For rendering the user can do what they want based on the status character via CSS like task collector.

state (includes|does not include) ( |x|-|/|etc....)

@SimplGy and @pcause would that help out your scenarios?

I can't find it at the moment, but somewhere recently I pasted in this repo a link to a dataview issue or discussion where progress on its implementation of custom task status characters was being used.

I was thinking it might be worth seeing if that feature in Tasks might try to use the same vocabulary and search approach as Dataview, if possible and not difficult.

Ahah - here it is:
blacksmithgu/obsidian-dataview#812

And I had posted it in #628. Oh, which you just commented in earlier!

[SimplGy]

Sounds like interesting stuff sytone. In my case, I'm only ever in edit mode, and I'm not super interested in the scraping/collecting aspect of things. Of course I'm not the only user, but I'm most interested in simple things on top of the basic text file behavior:

• a keyboard shortcut (there's one for "toggle checkbox status" now, that should probably be changed to "cycle checkbox state" for heavy users of the in progress and other states of checkboxes
• easy CSS targeting of done, in progress, not done (etc) in the edit mode. For the whole line of text ideally, but also for the checkbox chars. I have a workaround in place for this now.