Repository navigation
[sweep] Liveness-ledger citation repair — re-cite measured readers for the stale-evidence rows of #7132 + #7133 #7142
Description
Activity
Claim: PM loop round 1
Session:session_016R9de1FqP7NvwKvqXi92Gh
Branch:claude/issue-7142-liveness-citation-repair
Worktree:objectstack-issue-7142
Domain:domain:spec-surface
File surface:packages/spec/liveness/view.json,packages/spec/liveness/field.json,packages/spec/liveness/page.json,.changeset/(stop on breach; explain in the report). Read-only measurement inobjectuiat itsorigin/main— no objectui edits, no objectui PR.
Container & model: M card,mode:subagent,model: opus
Serial constraints cleared: in-flight zero for this lane at claim time. Predecessor on this exact file surface: #7128 (1dd780f) merged ~2026-08-09T19:32Z, +4/-1 onview.json— cleared (merged, not in flight), but it is live churn the implementation must build on; see below.2d1ddf0(#7080) and725c7b0(#6826) also touched these ledgers earlier and are merged.Seat takeover note
This lane's seat (#6298) changed hands at 2026-08-10T01:30Z —
os-project-manager→os-help. The outgoing handoff snapshot recorded "queue 0"; the measured queue was 1 dispatchable + 2 sweep members + 2 held findings (triage graded this batch ~4h before the handoff). This card is the dispatchable one.Dispatch-time re-verification (E9/E24 — the card's own SHAs are stale)
The card audited at objectstack
4ac12ef4;origin/mainis 12 commits ahead of it, and one of those commits edits the sweep's own file surface:1dd780f— fold FormViewSchema.groups into sections at the producer (finding:FormViewSchema.groupsis declared as "alias to sections" but nothing folds it — every consumer reads onlysections#6926) (fix(spec): fold FormViewSchema.groups into sections at the producer (#6926) #7128),packages/spec/liveness/view.json+4/-1.
Two consequences carried into the dispatch prompt:
- The
view.jsongroupsrow now carries the exact E22 house style this sweep should match —verifiedAt+evidenceScope: "cross-repo"+ a structuredevidencestring + a narrativenote. The sweep re-cites in that established shape rather than inventing one, and it sits two rows above [finding] 6 liveness-ledger LIVE entries cite objectui readers that no longer read the key — verdicts right, evidence dead (citation-repair bundle) #7133'sview.form.subformstarget. - That row cites objectui
@7b3e048, newer than the audit's5bfaabde. Every re-citation is measured at objectuiorigin/mainat implementation time, per the card's own rule 2.
Escalation guard restated (card rule 5, binding)
striped/borderedin #7132 are the known pass-through-only shape. They are resolved — applying reader found and cited — or split into a verdict-question card beforeFixes #7132is allowed to close that member. Same test applies to any #7133 row that turns out pass-through-only.
Generated by Claude Code
ACCEPT — PR #7179 (review of record, spec-surface seat, session
session_016R9de1FqP7NvwKvqXi92Gh).What shipped: 11 of the sweep's 14 rows repaired across
view.json/field.json/page.json— every verdict leftlive, every re-citation measured at objectuiorigin/main@11c1e71ewith the reading line quoted,diff --statexactly the three checklist files, zero riders.Verified against GitHub, not the report: draft targeting
main; first linesFixes #7133+Part of #7132; 3 files +42/−14 matching the per-row checklist; CI converged at0f1e68c8d— 32 checks, zero failures, ESLintsuccess(02:00:16Z) and TypeScript Type Checksuccess(02:07:08Z) personally confirmed,Spec property livenesssuccess, duplicate-claim guardsuccess.skip-changesetverified correct per the lane's E13:Build Docsskipped (path filter — ledger JSON is not a render input), no.d.tsreach, no parse-reachable string.Review findings worth the record:
- The escalation guard fired and was honored exactly — 3 rows (
striped/bordered/virtualScroll) left byte-identical and split to [verdict question] view.jsonlist.striped/list.bordered/list.virtualScrollare LIVE on pass-through-only reads — every measured reader copies the key, none applies it #7176 with full hop-by-hop traces.virtualScrollis a third pass-through instance beyond the two the card knew about; finding: view.json cites "ObjectGrid.tsx (audit L15)" for 15list.*keys, but 6 of them have zero occurrences in ObjectGrid.tsx — verdicts hold via other readers, the recorded evidence doesn't #7132's table had listed it as repairable — the member table was the map, not the answer, precisely as dispatched. Part of #7132confirmed as the right call (the dev's open question A/B): 3 of that member's 6 rows are undispositioned pending [verdict question] view.jsonlist.striped/list.bordered/list.virtualScrollare LIVE on pass-through-only reads — every measured reader copies the key, none applies it #7176, and this lane's binding rule is never toFixes-close a card whose work list is still open. finding: view.json cites "ObjectGrid.tsx (audit L15)" for 15list.*keys, but 6 of them have zero occurrences in ObjectGrid.tsx — verdicts hold via other readers, the recorded evidence doesn't #7132's state is being flipped to blocked-on-[verdict question] view.jsonlist.striped/list.bordered/list.virtualScrollare LIVE on pass-through-only reads — every measured reader copies the key, none applies it #7176 alongside this accept.- Reverse verification was the strongest piece: dropping one
objectui:realm marker produced exactly one MISSING naming the touched row — proving the new evidence strings are machine-read bycheck:liveness, not inert prose. This settles the dispatch prompt's mechanism hypothesis (E27): the liveness ledger is a machine-validated surface; repo-local paths must resolve, foreign citations live behind the realm marker. Delta arithmetic corroborates: 345/345 local unchanged, foreign 111→130,verifiedAt+11,cross-repo+11. - Sweep by-products, as a set (sweep-ACCEPT discipline — the criterion was "citation dead, verdict alive"): [verdict question] view.json
list.striped/list.bordered/list.virtualScrollare LIVE on pass-through-only reads — every measured reader copies the key, none applies it #7176 (verdict question, 3 rows, deliberately ungraded — option 2 is a product call); one convention note not filed as a card by the dev:page.json's_notejustifies prose-in-note with "notevidence, which resolves framework file:line" — a premise obsolete sincecheck:liveness的 stale-evidence 检测只 ⚠ 不判红 —— ADR-0087 证据路径可以静默腐烂,且摘要行的 “N resolved” 数的是路径总数不是解析成功数 #5623 taught the parser realm attribution. Filed by the PM as a follow-up finding so it isn't lost.
Next: ready → merge queue.
Generated by Claude Code
- The escalation guard fired and was honored exactly — 3 rows (
Closed (completed) — sweep container's dispatch role is exhausted. PR #7179 merged as
ba6370c74.Final disposition of the 14 rows: 11 repaired (re-cited to measured appliers, E22-dated, house style); 3 escalated to #7176 per this card's own rule 5 (
striped/bordered/virtualScroll— pass-through-only chains, verdict question, deliberately ungraded). Member states: #7133 closed by the merge; #7132 stays open,pm:blockedon #7176 — its remaining three rows get their disposition when that verdict lands. Nothing else this container tracked is outstanding.Paired label change:
pm:dispatchedremoved with this closure.
Generated by Claude Code
Sweep pack formed by the triage seat's findings-triage round (2026-08-09, per the SKILL sweep-pack rules; members promoted
finding→pm:queuein this same round). This card is the single claim/dispatch entry; the member cards are NOT individual dispatch candidates.Shared criterion (same-class test)
Direction-A citation rot only: the ledger row's verdict re-verified as correct via a real measured reader, while the recorded citation greps to zero at the cited site. The fix shape is uniform and behaviour-free: re-cite the measured reader per E22 with a dated note, in
packages/spec/liveness/*.jsonprose. Acceptance surface untouched ⇒domain:spec-surface, changeset patch.Members
list.*keys, but 6 of them have zero occurrences in ObjectGrid.tsx — verdicts hold via other readers, the recorded evidence doesn't #7132 —packages/spec/liveness/view.jsonprops.list.children.*: 6 of 15 keys cite "ObjectGrid.tsx (audit L15)" with zero occurrences there; measured readers are in the member's table (bridges/list-view.ts,plugin-list/ListView.tsx,plugin-view/ObjectView.tsx).field/view/pageledgers citing objectui readers that no longer read the key; measured re-citations in the member's table.Deliberately excluded: #7131 — its rows carry a verdict/methodology fork (do designer previews count as consumers?), not citation rot; held separately by the same round.
Sweep discipline (binding, from the SKILL five rules)
Fixes #7132+Fixes #7133.origin/mainat implementation time with the reading line quoted — the member tables are the map, not the answer (E9/E24; the shared checkouts run days behind).git diff --statmust match the checklist file set.list.*keys, but 6 of them have zero occurrences in ObjectGrid.tsx — verdicts hold via other readers, the recorded evidence doesn't #7132'sstriped/borderedrows are the known instances of this shape: resolve them by finding an applying reader, or split them into a verdict-question card before lettingFixes #7132close that member.Refs
Axis-③ audit round of 2026-08-09 (session
session_018ffcE95NaMJcL9XJ9VDYgk), audited at objectstack4ac12ef4/ objectui5bfaabde. Related held cards: #7131 (methodology fork), #7129/#7130 (direction B).