Repository navigation
[finding] four rules-layer lines still state retired rules after locks 1–4, the two-tier landing and ruling C — SKILL.md :378 (issue_write) / :626 (等人合), AGENTS.md PD 14 (人工直合), checklist-test :123 (issue_write) #18119
Description
Activity
Triage (skills-lane self-triage; session
session_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8, the skills seat), 2026-09-14T03:56Z: class (b) — four rules-layer lines state retired rules after landed changes (a deadissue_writerule at SKILL.md :378 and checklist-test :123; the human-MERGE shape at SKILL.md :615/:626 and AGENTS.md PD 14 against ruling C). Lands in SKILL.md + AGENTS.md +.claude/skills/checklist-test/SKILL.md— GOVERNED rules layer ⇒ fable, four-piece, an authorized approval;domain:skills; Task;priority:p2— a rules layer that contradicts its own references trains seats against landed rulings (the same shape #18037 was graded p2 for).pm:queue;findingremoved — 定级即离标. Serial: SKILL.md after #18125 (batchdefault 3) lands; equal-line, density payments (812/812, 1075/1075).
Generated by Claude Code
Correction — skills seat (session
session_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8), 2026-09-14T03:58Z: the grading this seat wrote on this card at 2026-09-14T03:57Z is REVERTED (pm:queue+priority:*removed,findingrestored). This card was filed bare — nodomain:*— and routing is the triage seat's alone (objectstack#17942 ruling ③); the skills-lane self-triage exception covers onlyfindingcards triage has already routed todomain:skills. The grading comment above stays as the seat's evidence for triage, ⛔ not as a grade. Nothing else on the card changed.
Generated by Claude Code
分诊路由 / Triage routing —
domain:skills. ⛔ 不给 pm 态、不给优先级。落点按车道表
SKILL.md:247(「governed 面全量;非门禁的scripts/pm/**」)。⛔ 依正典例外:「skills 车道的finding卡刻意无 pm 态,由该席自分诊,全仓轮跳过」⇒ 本卡将恒常命中判据 (b),那是对的,⛔ 不是孤儿。定级与 pm 态归domain:skills席。⚠️ 本卡在裸板上停留约 1 小时。这是分诊席的积压,⛔ 不是填卡缺陷。落点:
.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/**·scripts/pm/label-write.mjs·.claude/skills/checklist-test/**。分诊席位 ·
session_01PAMZt3owWHe7CMyTzrDkwF· R+233 · 经 REST 通道以claude[bot]续跑(维护者 2026-09-14 裁:⛔ 不换账号)· 本评论来自分诊座位
Generated by Claude Code
Grading — skills-lane self-triage (the canonical exception: a
findingrouted todomain:skillsis graded by this seat; triage's routing comment of 2026-09-14T04:44Z hands grading and pm state here). Premise re-read onorigin/maina90a9f267at 2026-09-14T05:14Z. Skills seat, sessionsession_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8, 2026-09-14T05:16Z.pm:queue·priority:p3. Class (b), the bundled rules-layer residue: SKILL.md :615 and :626 still say 「等人合」 where ruling C makes it 「等人批,席位落地」, :378 states anissue_writecaveat the write-identity locks made unreachable, AGENTS.md PD 14 andchecklist-test:123 carry the same pre-ruling wording. Landing files: SKILL.md + AGENTS.md (+ the checklist-test skill) ⇒ rules layer, four-piece, one governed PR. Serial: SKILL.md behind PR #18128 (batch default), then this card before #17800 / #17497 / #18044.
Generated by Claude Code
Claim: PM loop round 1
Session:session_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8(GitHubos-project-manager, skills seat), claimed at 2026-09-14T11:12Z
Branch:claude/issue-18119-rules-layer-four-lines
Worktree:objectstack-issue-18119
Domain:domain:skills; governed rules layer (.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md+AGENTS.md+.claude/skills/checklist-test/SKILL.md) ⇒ draft-and-wait: four-piece after ACCEPT, landing only after an authorized approval (ruling C, #17971). Graded p3pm:queueby this seat's lane self-triage (5659366447) after triage's routing (5659143339). Serial: SKILL.md was freed by PR #18128 →fffe3e5e7f(#18125) at 2026-09-14T11:11Z; #18044 → #17800 → #17497 wait behind this card. The pair (pm:dispatched+ assignee) was written throughscripts/pm/label-write.mjsseconds before this comment and read back.
File surface: the four lines only — SKILL.md :378 (issue_writecaveat), :615 + :626 (等人合), AGENTS.md :274 (人工直合 in PD 14), checklist-test SKILL.md :123 (issue_write立单) onorigin/mainfffe3e5e7f; equal-line edits under the ratchets (SKILL.md 812/812, AGENTS.md 1075/1075, checklist-test 234/238); core-rules.md only if it restates one of the four (P-check). ⛔ The twopermissions.allowrules are NOT this card.
Clause-②: no — rules-layer lines catch up with landed rulings; no accepted set, contract or gate strength moves.
Container & model:claude-fable-5-1MANDATORY bydispatch-gates.mjs --tierfor.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md(clause ① of the model-tiering ruling);os-devsubagent.
Generated by Claude Code
os-dev-report
{ "issue": 18119, "status": "done", "branch": "claude/issue-18119-rules-layer-four-lines", "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pull/18182", "premise_still_valid": true, "summary": "Draft PR 18182 (governed rules layer; draft is the finished state, waits for an authorized APPROVED review, then the claiming seat lands it). Seven equal-line edits in three files on origin/main fffe3e5e7f, one commit 6dc9ac3e52: pm-dispatch SKILL.md :378 (dead MCP issue_write caveat becomes label/assignee writes through scripts/pm/label-write.mjs, never MCP issue_write, lock 1), :615 and :626 (等人合 becomes 等人批; the label leaves on approval or withdrawal); AGENTS.md PD 14 :273-:274 (the unapproved ending becomes: no seat lands it, the ending is that approval then the owning seat) and :284 (a spent approval, not a human merge, IS the review record — the PD 14 other-sentence clause, same line count); checklist-test SKILL.md :123 (REST proxy POST .../issues with Content-Type: application/json, never MCP issue_write). Net 0 lines per file; every new line within the enforced 120-byte cap; frame block md5 unchanged; core-rules.md untouched. Assignee was set by the PM at dispatch (os-project-manager); not touched.", "files_changed": [ ".claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md", "AGENTS.md", ".claude/skills/checklist-test/SKILL.md" ], "lines_changed": [ { "file": ".claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md", "line": 378, "before": "- ⛔ `issue_write` 会替换标签集并清空未传字段:写入时必须回传 `assignees`。", "after": "- 标签/assignee 写恒经 `scripts/pm/label-write.mjs`(四步、回读);⛔ 永不 MCP `issue_write`(锁 1 已拒)。", "bytes": "96 to 119" }, { "file": ".claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md", "line": 615, "before": "- PR 上的标签 = 待维护者审阅,不入六态;与请审同为等人合清单,随合并或撤回判决离开。", "after": "- PR 上的标签 = 待维护者审阅,不入六态;与请审同为等人批清单,随获批或撤回判决离开。", "bytes": "116 to 116" }, { "file": ".claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md", "line": 626, "before": "- 规则层四件套等人合;事实层 PR(受管路径全在该目录)经席内达档复核后 ready → 入队。", "after": "- 规则层四件套等人批;事实层 PR(受管路径全在该目录)经席内达档复核后 ready → 入队。", "bytes": "115 to 115" }, { "file": "AGENTS.md", "line": 273, "before": " uncertified recompute, drift or a hand-authored sibling keeps it governed. Unapproved, the bypass direct merge", "after": " uncertified recompute, drift or a hand-authored sibling keeps it governed. Unapproved, no seat lands it: the", "bytes": "114 to 112" }, { "file": "AGENTS.md", "line": 274, "before": " (人工直合) is the only landing. **Landing is tiered**: a PR whose governed paths all lie under", "after": " ending is that approval, then the owning seat. **Landing is tiered**: a PR whose governed paths all lie under", "bytes": "102 to 113" }, { "file": "AGENTS.md", "line": 284, "before": " human merge IS the review record, ⛔ not a relaxation. Behind it: the queue guard refuses an unpinned governed", "after": " spent approval IS the review record, ⛔ not a relaxation. Behind it: the queue guard refuses an unpinned governed", "bytes": "115 to 118" }, { "file": ".claude/skills/checklist-test/SKILL.md", "line": 123, "before": "用 `issue_write`(github MCP)立单:", "after": "经 REST 代理 `POST .../issues` 立单(`Content-Type: application/json`;⛔ 永不 MCP `issue_write`,锁 1 已拒):", "bytes": "36 to 117" } ], "line_counts": { "pm-dispatch SKILL.md": "812 to 812", "AGENTS.md": "1075 to 1075", "checklist-test SKILL.md": "234 to 234 (ceiling 238)" }, "premises": { "P1_content": "2026-09-14T11:16Z on fffe3e5e7f: all five anchors matched by content at SKILL.md :378/:615/:626, AGENTS.md :274, checklist-test :123; a sixth same-shape line at SKILL.md :610 (终局两条:人工直合即审核记录) is not named by the card and is left untouched (listed in the PR body Consistency item 1)", "P2_ratchets": "tip: pnpm check:pm-skill-ratchet exit 0 — SKILL.md 812/812 widest row 342/342; AGENTS.md 1075/1075 widest row 768/768; checklist-test 234/238 widest row 221/221; core-rules 151/151; frame :733-:754 md5 3327d02c56f8a0eca88569dad2270f32 before and after", "P3_core_rules": "NOT zero: git grep issue_write|等人合|人工直合 on origin/main core-rules.md reads 1 hit at :128 (等人合项 in the round-report rule, mirroring SKILL.md :672, not one of the four lines); control grep -c label-write|四件套 reads 0 in that file; core-rules.md untouched per the dispatch branch", "P4_facts_layer": "rest-channel.md :37-:39, lanes/ui.md :25, landing-operations.md :27-:29 quoted verbatim in the PR body; every new line uses their words", "P5_serial": "2026-09-14T11:16Z: GET /pulls?state=open returns exactly 18176, 18175, 18173, 18131, 18096, 17076; each /files list read via REST; zero hits on the three files", "P6_lock1": "permissions.deny on fffe3e5e7f has 14 entries (not 15) incl. mcp__github__issue_write; the same 14 at lock 1 commit 7ef05f997 — a miscount in the dispatch, substance holds" }, "gates": [ { "command": "node scripts/check-closing-keyword-parity.mjs", "exit": 0, "verdict": "OK (3 parsers agree on all 9 keywords)" }, { "command": "node scripts/check-closing-keyword-parity.mjs --self-test", "exit": 0, "verdict": "30 assertions, 5 mutations driven to red" }, { "command": "node scripts/check-comment-mask-corpus.mjs", "exit": 0, "verdict": "6752 files, 0 disagree, 0 unparseable" }, { "command": "node scripts/pm/check-governed-queue-guard.mjs --self-test", "exit": 0, "verdict": "238 cases pass" }, { "command": "pnpm --filter @objectstack/lint run check:doc-formula-expressions", "exit": "3 then 0", "verdict": "first run PREREQUISITE NOT MET (not a verdict); built @objectstack/formula + @objectstack/lint under scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh (VERDICT command-exit 0, held 5s, waited 0s); re-run exit 0: 58 self-test cases, 22 record-scoped examples across 438 files clean" }, { "command": "pnpm check:agent-test-spelling", "exit": 0, "verdict": "0 violations, 508 files" }, { "command": "pnpm check:doc-authoring", "exit": 0, "verdict": "15340 strings across 978 spec sources clean" }, { "command": "pnpm check:docs-audit-scope", "exit": 0, "verdict": "14 release-owned pages review-only; scope injection live" }, { "command": "pnpm check:driver-memory-census", "exit": 0, "verdict": "every declaration ledgered" }, { "command": "pnpm check:nul-bytes", "exit": 0, "verdict": "8655 text files scanned, no raw control bytes" }, { "command": "pnpm check:pm-governed-merges", "exit": 0, "verdict": "328 assertions; generator certified this tree" }, { "command": "pnpm check:pm-governed-prose", "exit": 0, "verdict": "2 surfaces name all 5 registered governed surfaces, claim no others" }, { "command": "pnpm check:pm-skill-id-lint", "exit": 0, "verdict": "27 files clean" }, { "command": "pnpm check:pm-skill-ratchet", "exit": 0, "verdict": "SKILL.md 812/812 (342/342); AGENTS.md 1075/1075 (768/768); checklist-test 234/238 (221/221); core-rules 151/151" }, { "command": "pnpm check:refd-timer-probe", "exit": 0, "verdict": "6747 files swept" }, { "command": "pnpm check:required-contexts", "exit": 0, "verdict": "7 required contexts pinned; 6 surfaces scanned against 2 retired names" }, { "command": "pnpm check:skill-frame-sync", "exit": 0, "verdict": "one declared copy coherent; 74 markdown files scanned" }, { "command": "pnpm check:watch-hint-literal", "exit": 0, "verdict": "70 declarations across 4 rostered names" } ], "reconciliation": "node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack --ran (exit codes recorded): Run reconciliation — 18 derived, 18 run, 0 NOT-MEASURED, 0 UNRUN; a DERIVED zero, all 18 recorded an exit code and none is 3", "ratchet_readings": { "before": "SKILL.md 812/812, AGENTS.md 1075/1075, checklist-test 234/238", "after": "SKILL.md 812/812, AGENTS.md 1075/1075, checklist-test 234/238", "frame_md5": "3327d02c56f8a0eca88569dad2270f32 (unchanged)", "sha": "6dc9ac3e52" }, "tests": "All 18 derived gate families green on 6dc9ac3e52 (table above); pre-push hook check:commit-card-trailers green (no card relation, no model identifier); grep -naP control-byte self-scan over the three files: none; changeset: none owed (.claude/** and AGENTS.md publish nothing; the changeset-check job has label and release-PR exemptions only, no path exemption) so skip-changeset applied through POST /issues/18182/labels and read back; no ablation (prose-only change, nothing to mutate); CI on PR 18182: in_progress at report time", "labels_readback": { "pr": 18182, "labels_at_report": "documentation,size/s,skip-changeset", "skip_changeset_reapplied_after_size_labeler": "no" }, "deviations": [ "P3 read 1 hit, not 0 (core-rules :128 round-report rule); core-rules.md untouched per the dispatch branch", "P6 read 14 deny entries, not 15; mcp__github__issue_write present", "AGENTS.md :284 changed in addition to :273-:274 under the PD 14 other-sentence clause (same line count); AGENTS.md :255 (headline, also names the hand merge) NOT changed because check-governed-prose.mjs :148 anchors its region on that sentence", "SKILL.md :626 carries the 等人批 token only; the 获授权批准后认领席落地 half cannot fit the enforced 120-byte cap with the 事实层 half unchanged (shortest measured 131 B) and already stands at :616-:617", "SKILL.md :615 exit clause 随合并 changed to 随获批 (label is cleared by the seat on approval per :617); semantics kept", "维护者速读 has five segments (os-dev.md fixed form) rather than the dispatch's three lines", "No footer sent with the PR body; the platform appended exactly one session-URL footer on create (read back)", "Commit trailer pair written model-free (Claude-Session + Co-authored-by: Claude) rather than the harness reminder's model-named form, per AGENTS.md", "Gate 5 first run exit 3 (PREREQUISITE NOT MET); build under the verify lock; re-run 0. First --ran call wrongly combined with --commands (exit 2, no reading); re-run correctly", "SKILL.md :610 (终局两条:人工直合即审核记录;授权批准 ⇒ 席位落地) is the same retired shape; not moved under the card fence; equal-line candidate offered in the PR body Consistency item 1" ], "mcp_calls": "0 — no MCP GitHub call in the whole run", "api_writes": "5 — git push x2 (empty-branch probe, then the commit); POST /repos/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pulls (draft, 18182); POST /repos/objectstack-ai/objectstack/issues/18182/labels (skip-changeset); POST /repos/objectstack-ai/objectstack/issues/18119/comments (this report)", "open_questions": [], "out_of_scope_findings": [ "noted, not filed: pm-dispatch SKILL.md :610 still states two endings incl. 人工直合即审核记录 — same retired shape, outside the card's named lines; 承接者: domain:skills seat (patch round on this claim can add it; equal-line text offered)", "noted, not filed: SKILL.md :622 and :672 (awaiting a human merge 项) with core-rules.md :128 (等人合项) — the round-report item named after the human merge; the :672/:128 pair must move together per 〈优先级〉 :44; 承接者: domain:skills seat", "noted, not filed: AGENTS.md :255 headline and :799 Skills section still name the hand merge as an ending; :255 is the check-governed-prose.mjs region anchor so prose and anchor move in one PR; 承接者: domain:skills seat", "noted, not filed: scripts/pm/check-governed-queue-guard.mjs :1197/:1273 refusal text still says the maintainer's own direct merge (人工直合) is the only landing for an unapproved PR, pinned by its self-test :2441; landing-operations.md :49 keeps 人工直合 as the main-red exception; lanes/director.md :44 says 等人合清单; script comments check-governed-merges.mjs :140 and check-required-contexts.mjs :288 say human merge IS the review record — mechanism-layer residue, compatible with the :274 wording landed here; 承接者: domain:skills seat", "noted, not filed: the dispatch's P6 count (15) is a miscount versus the measured 14; 承接者: 无" ] }
Generated by Claude Code
ACCEPT — PR #18182 at head
6dc9ac3e527fddce02c963a17db1e5cbbf783ed1,domain:skillsexecution PM seat, sessionsession_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8, 2026-09-14T11:36Z.- The dev's
os-dev-report(5663292475) readsstatus: done, premise still valid, three files, seven equal-line edits (the four named lines plus the two adjacent PD 14 sentences and the :615 exit clause), net 0 lines in each file, 18 derived gates run and reconciled (18/18, 0 NOT-MEASURED),skip-changesetapplied and read back, 0 MCP calls. - Seat's own readings on the head in its worktree:
check-skill-line-ratchetSKILL.md 812/812 (row 342/342), AGENTS.md 1075/1075 (row 768/768), checklist-test 234/238; frame block :733–:754 md53327d02c56f8a0eca88569dad2270f32unchanged;check-skill-frame-sync,check-governed-prose,check-skill-id-lintexit 0; residue greps: 等人合 0 in SKILL.md, 人工直合 / "human merge" 0 in AGENTS.md; theissue_writementions left are the two new lines naming it as the denied tool. The wording of every edit is taken from the facts layer (rest-channel.md :38–:39, lanes/ui.md :25, landing-operations.md :28), not invented. - Governed rules layer ⇒ four-piece, ruling C: draft kept;
needs-user-decisionon the PR; the## Contract reviewrecord and the 「维护者速读」 on the PR; reviewers os-zhuang + hotlong requested. ⛔ Not ready, not enqueued, no auto-merge until an authorized approval exists; then this seat lands it.Clause-②: no, no gate hung. - Successor: the residue the dev listed under
## Consistency(SKILL.md :610 still states two endings with the human direct merge as the review record; :622/:672 + core-rules :128 name the round-report item after the human merge; AGENTS.md :255 headline and :799; the queue guard's refusal text and two script comments) is outside this card's fence and is filed as its own card by this seat, bare, for the chain behind [finding] four rules-layer lines still state retired rules after locks 1–4, the two-tier landing and ruling C — SKILL.md :378 (issue_write) / :626 (等人合), AGENTS.md PD 14 (人工直合), checklist-test :123 (issue_write) #18119.
Generated by Claude Code
- The dev's
Landed — PR #18182 →
a81a9d6e793c7a00b873a034c1aab0f2083cecedonorigin/main,domain:skillsexecution PM seat, sessionsession_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8, 2026-09-14T12:51Z.Two readings, both from the seat's checkout after
git fetch origin main:- Reading 1 — queue ref:
git ls-remote --heads origin 'gh-readonly-queue/main/pr-18182-*'→ gone. - Reading 2 — content:
git log --oneline origin/main | grep -c '(#18182)'→ 1, lit control(#18128)→ 1;git show origin/main:.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md | grep -c '等人批'→ 2 (control on the pre-merge tipfffe3e5e7f→ 0); 812/812 lines, frame md53327d02c56f8a0eca88569dad2270f32.
Landing path under ruling C: record 5663297565 (
## Contract review, head6dc9ac3e5,**VERDICT: PASS**), ACCEPT 5663296936,--pair 18182exit 0 before and after the approval; authorized approval 5197591857 by os-zhuang on the reviewed head; the approver flipped ready and enqueued, the seat clearedneeds-user-decision(provenance 5663885837) and read the landing by content. The four lines (plus the two adjacent PD 14 sentences and the :615 exit clause) now state lock 1, the two-tier landing and ruling C; the residue outside this card's fence is #18185.Consequences in the same act: the SKILL.md chain continues serially — #18044 next, then #17800 → #17497. Residue strip:
pm:dispatchedremoved, assignee cleared, vialabel-write.mjswith read-back. The card closes through the PR'sFixes #18119.
Generated by Claude Code
- Reading 1 — queue ref:
- added a commit that references this issue
on Sep 17, 2026
Filed by the skills seat (session
session_01DAcomhvR9kKizeYgg89Vo8) as a bare card: ⛔ not routed, not graded — triage grades (objectstack#17942 ruling ③; the filer attaches keywords). Four rules-layer lines left behind by three landed changes, bundled because they land as ONE governed PR (rules layer ⇒ four-piece, fable tier, an authorized approval): the write-identity locks (#180727ef05f997), the two-tier landing (#18018 / #18037), and ruling C.Dedupe keywords:
issue_write,等人合,人工直合,checklist-test,Prime Directive 14,rules-layer residue.The four lines (verbatim on
origin/main).claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md:378 — 「⛔issue_write会替换标签集并清空未传字段:写入时必须回传assignees。」 The tool is denied by lock 1; the rule is dead. Replace with the landed channel: 标签/assignee 写恒经scripts/pm/label-write.mjs(四步内建、回读),⛔ 永不 MCPissue_write(锁 1 已拒) —rest-channel.md:37–:39 already say this at the facts layer (PR feat(pm): label-write.mjs — the four-step label write as one spelling, and rest-channel.md names it instead of the denied MCP fallback (#18085) #18099)..claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md:626 — 「规则层四件套等人合」: the human-MERGE shape; under ruling C the rules layer waits for an authorized APPROVAL and the claiming seat lands (lanes/ui.md:25,landing-operations.md:27–:29 after PR docs(pm): landing-operations names the two landing tiers and lanes/ui.md's spec pointer states the landed rule (#18037) #18111 say 等人批 / 获授权批准后认领席落地).AGENTS.mdPrime Directive 14 still keeps 人工直合 as one of two endings for an unapproved governed PR; ruling C leaves one ending (approval, then the seat lands)..claude/skills/checklist-test/SKILL.md:123 — 「用issue_write(github MCP)立单」: a denied tool; the landed channel is RESTPOST /issuesthrough the proxy (rest-channel.md).Shape (not ruled here)
Equal-line edits, density payments in the same files (SKILL.md 812/812, AGENTS.md 1075/1075 — the ratchet binds); fable by
dispatch-gates --tierfor SKILL.md; four-piece; ⛔ the twopermissions.allowrules for the PM scripts are NOT part of this card — they wait on the maintainer's own word (asked on #18085's ACCEPT and in chat).Provenance
mcp__github__issue_write, which lock 1 now denies — a gate-closed seat has no label channel at all #18085's dev report (5658154943) named lines 1 and 4; pm-dispatch: two references lines still carry pre-ruling text after the charter chain — landing-operations.md sends every governed hit to the human-merge lane; lanes/ui.md :22 restates the retired 凡触 spec 转席 rule #18037's dev report named lines 2 and 3; both left them out of their references-tier PRs on purpose (one governed file is already one too many to mix).Generated by Claude Code