Repository navigation
[finding] The hono UI auto-discovery block has no in-repo producer and no test — staticPath and slug are written nowhere but the block that reads them #16050
Description
Activity
分诊 ·
domain:cli/tests/priority:p2/pm:queue分诊席位。⛔ 不认领、不派发、不写代码、不合并。
origin/main@932acc3d，2026-09-06T04:13Z。卡自陈未复核的读数，我复现了
断言 实测 staticPath全仓仅 4 处（声明 + 三处读）✅ 6 处，构成如下 —— hono-plugin.ts:508/:515/:519（三处读）、packages/spec/src/kernel/plugin.zod.ts:126（声明）、以及packages/spec/authorable-surface.base.json:4602与authorable-surface/kernel.json:428两份生成的基线⇒ 生产者 零 ⚠️ 差异说明：卡说「exactly four lines」，我数到 6。⇒ 多出的两条是生成的 authorable-surface JSON，卡的 grep 限定了.ts所以看不到它们。结论不变（它们是生成物不是生产者），但记录以免复算的人以为对不上。⭐ 而
packages/spec/src/kernel/plugin.zod.ts:126那行本身值得一看：staticPath: z.string().optional().describe('Absolute path to static assets (Required for type="ui")'),⇒ describe 说「Required for type="ui"」，而 schema 是
.optional()。⛔ 不是本卡的范围，记在这里。定级 p2
⭐ 卡把它值一张卡的理由说得最准，而且这个理由在本轮被实证过：
The code is dead from the inside and live from the outside, and there is currently no artifact in the tree that says so。
⇒ 这正是 #15638 上发生的事：一个仔细的读者（以及我在 R+156 的分诊处方）都把那条 legacy arm 读成死代码，最后靠一个专门写的探针驱动真实 kernel 才把前提证伪。⭐ 一个没有测试的、只服务仓外人口的代码块，会周期性地被判死刑。 那次差点执行。
而卡指出这个缺口独立于 #15638 怎么裁：三条路线（declare / remove / enforce-at-producer #16047）之后，剩下的那半仍然没有测试。
不给 p1：没有东西坏掉——它今天大概率工作正常（只是没人证明）。
车道
domain:cli落点
packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server。⭐ 车道表把plugin-hono-server明确列在domain:cli行（与packages/cli、runtime、rest、mcp等同列）。⛔ 不是domain:services——那一行是services/*、connectors/*、triggers/*、plugin-approvals/webhooks/email/reports、plugin-auth/security/sharing/audit，不含 hono-server。类型
tests交付物是一个夹具 + 一条端到端 pin，⛔ 不改产品行为。
⭐ 卡给了现成模板，接卡人直接用
#15638's probe is a working template — it registered a plugin through the real kernel, drove the real
init()/start(), and observed the routes handed torawApp.get, with a non-UI control proving the harness can produce an empty result。⇒ 那个探针的四条读数（PROBE A/B、CONTROL C/D）可以直接变成四条 pin：
- A —
kernel.use()接受并原样保存type与staticPath； - B — 现代
ui臂挂载/slug与/slug/*； - C — legacy
ui-plugin臂挂载同样的路由（⚠️ 这一条的去留取决于 [finding]plugin-hono-serverstill accepts the legacyui-plugintype thatPluginSchemarefuses — an unreachable arm under ADR-0049 #15638 的裁决，见下）； - D — 非 UI 类型挂载
[]，⭐ 这是负控制，缺了它整套 pin 无意义。
⚠️ 与 #15638 的排序⛔ 不要等 #15638 裁决——现代
ui臂（A/B/D）无论怎么裁都存在，现在就该有测试。
⚠️ 但 legacy 臂那条 pin（C）要看裁决：若裁「删」，C 变成「ui-plugin不挂载」的反向 pin；若裁「声明转换」，C 变成「ui-plugin被归一化为ui并挂载 + 一条 warn」。⇒ 建议 PR 里把 A/B/D 先落，C 留一个带#15638注释的占位说明，⛔ 不要凭猜写 C。相邻
#16049（同一次交回的第一条 finding，本轮我已路由
domain:engine/needs-user-decision/ p2）——PluginSchema零运行时调用方。⇒ 那是契约不被强制，本卡是覆盖缺口。⛔ 不合并，但同源同批。
#16047 —— 卡提到的 enforce-at-producer 路线，也在我的裸卡队列里。
Generated by Claude Code
- A —
Claim:
os-devagent, dispatched by thedomain:cliexecution PM seat.- Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01D47qPfEWVPmhguWgBZCi5N
- Branch:
claude/issue-16050-hono-ui-autodiscovery-pin(pushed, empty, at212eabae717) - Scope: fixture plugin plus an end-to-end pin over the hono UI auto-discovery block. Landing point
packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server. No product behaviour change. - Pins A, B and D land now; pin C (the legacy
ui-pluginarm) lands as a placeholder carrying a#15638reference, because its expected shape depends on that ruling.
Not self-assigning: the assignee field belongs to the PM seat.
Generated by Claude Code
Generated by Claude Code
os-dev-report
Clause-②: both limbs graded
no, affirmatively and with reasons — seeclause_2below. Amends the claim comment (id 5557694136) on this card.{ "issue": 16050, "status": "done", "branch": "claude/issue-16050-hono-ui-autodiscovery-pin", "head_sha": "8ee5fcbcb1b0fabb2748a077a98c6e05ea91e59f", "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pull/16253", "pr_state": "draft, not armed, not flipped ready", "premise_still_valid": true, "diff_name_only": [ "packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/src/ui-plugin-auto-discovery.pin.test.ts" ], "summary": "Added one end-to-end pin file over the UI auto-discovery block in HonoServerPlugin.start(). The fixture plugin is registered through the real ObjectKernel.use() and the real init()/start() run against the very context object bootstrap() hands its plugins, so the pin measures loader validation, the verbatim store into kernel.plugins, the read back out, and the routes handed to rawApp.get. Pins A, B and D landed; C is a documented it.todo placeholder pending the #15638 ruling. No product behaviour changed. Package suite 23 files / 252 passed / 1 todo; package typecheck exit 0. Gate union 46 families, 44 green, 2 NOT MEASURED at exit 3.", "regreps_re_derived": { "method": "git grep on the branch tip, node_modules and dist excluded, run by me rather than inherited — the card asks for exactly this", "staticPath_ts_only": "4 lines — packages/spec/src/kernel/plugin.zod.ts (the PluginSchema declaration) plus hono-plugin.ts three reads. This is the card's own grep and the card's number is CORRECT.", "staticPath_all_tracked_files": "9 lines — those 4, plus packages/spec/authorable-surface.base.json and packages/spec/authorable-surface/kernel.json (both generated), plus three prose lines: .changeset/plugin-describe-ui-type-spelling.md, content/docs/plugins/anatomy.mdx, content/docs/references/kernel/plugin.mdx", "slug_as_kernel_Plugin_key": "same shape — plugin.zod.ts declaration, hono-plugin.ts two reads, the same two generated baselines", "producers": "ZERO on either population. The conclusion the card and triage both reached is unchanged.", "why_there_are_no_producers": "the `Plugin` interface at packages/core/src/types.ts declares neither `staticPath` nor `slug`, so an in-repo plugin object cannot carry them without widening its own type. `PluginSchema` declares them but has no runtime caller on the boot path." }, "pins": { "A": { "what": "ObjectKernel.use() accepts a `ui` plugin and stores type, staticPath and slug verbatim into kernel.plugins", "mutation_that_reddens_it": "packages/core/src/plugin-loader.ts — replace `const metadata = plugin as PluginMetadata;` in toPluginMetadata with a whitelist copy of name/version/type/init/start", "observed": "Tests 4 failed | 1 passed | 1 todo (6). A red as predicted; B and D's non-UI case fell with it because both read the same store; D's no-staticPath case survived." }, "B": { "what": "the modern `ui` arm mounts /slug and /slug/* — one case with an explicit slug, one with the slug derived from the plugin name. Pinned as the exact registration sequence, two per route (static handler then scoped SPA fallback), not a de-duplicated set, because a set comparison would hide the loss of the fallback.", "mutation_that_reddens_it": "packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/src/hono-plugin.ts — `plugin.type === 'ui'` becomes `plugin.type === 'ui-ABLATED'`", "observed": "Tests 2 failed | 3 passed | 1 todo (6). Exactly B's two cases red; A and both D cases green." }, "C": { "status": "NOT WRITTEN — deliberate placeholder, spelled `it.todo` and carried by a block comment naming #15638", "what_the_placeholder_says": "that the block matches `plugin.type === 'ui' || plugin.type === 'ui-plugin'`; that the second disjunct is the subject of #15638 and is with the maintainer; that the two candidate rulings need incompatible pins — under REMOVE a `ui-plugin` fixture must mount nothing, routes equal to the empty array, byte-identical to pin D, and under DECLARE/CONVERT it must be normalised to `ui`, mount exactly like pin B, and emit one deprecation warning; that whoever lands #15638 writes the case in that PR, that the harness takes it unchanged, and that only the fixture's `type` and the expectation differ.", "why_not_guessed": "writing either shape now would pin a guess at a ruling this seat does not hold. The placeholder is the honest state: measured live on #15638, unpinned here on purpose." }, "D": { "what": "the negative control — same fixture builder, same EXISTING on-disk static root, same slug shape as B, only `type` differs, mounts nothing. A second case covers the other conjunct of the same guard: a `ui` type with no staticPath also mounts nothing.", "mutation_that_reddens_it": "packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/src/hono-plugin.ts — drop the whole type guard, leaving `if (plugin.staticPath) {`", "observed": "Tests 1 failed | 4 passed | 1 todo (6). Exactly D's non-UI case red; B green; D's no-staticPath case green.", "why_it_is_load_bearing": "B's mutation and D's mutation are complementary: one reddens B alone, the other reddens D alone. That is the demonstration that the pins discriminate rather than moving together, and it is what makes B's four registrations attributable to the branch rather than to a harness that mounts everything." } }, "tests": "All readings at head 8ee5fcbcb1b, with the working tree verified clean by `git status --short` before and after every ablation. (1) `pnpm --filter @objectstack/plugin-hono-server test` through scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh — `Test Files 23 passed (23)` / `Tests 252 passed | 1 todo (253)`, lock VERDICT command-exit 0. (2) `pnpm --filter @objectstack/plugin-hono-server typecheck` — VERDICT command-exit 0, including check:test-typecheck `0 file(s) / 0 error(s)`. NOT MEASURED discipline applied to that green: `tsc --noEmit -p CONFIG --listFiles` was run against all three configs and the new file is present in tsconfig.json (1 hit) and tsconfig.test.json (1 hit), absent from tsconfig.typecheck.json (0 hits) — so the green is a statement about the new file and not around it. (3) ABLATIONS — three, each with an absolute-path `trap RESTORE EXIT INT TERM`, each driven from the COMMITTED tree so the restore leg has a real reference point. Mutation proved on disk by counting BOTH the removed text (expect 0 after) and the injected text (expect at least 1) with `grep -cF`, anchored on the exact text meant to change; a no-op would have aborted the run and voided the reading. Restore proved by `git diff HEAD` empty AND `git hash-object` equal to the `git rev-parse HEAD:PATH` blob captured before the mutation — verified for all three (hono-plugin.ts 4cb977a3885111e7fe1846150b78c10b678b559b twice, plugin-loader.ts 24c3c31c51dc67eb70bf32247e38d7f6959b9c20). REBUILD: none needed, and this is stated rather than assumed — this package's vitest.config.ts aliases @objectstack/core to packages/core/src/index.ts and @objectstack/spec to source, and hono-plugin.ts is a relative import, so both mutated files are consumed from SOURCE and no dist sits between the mutation and the reading. @objectstack/types is the only dependency resolving through exports to dist, and it was built before any run (it is not a mutation target).", "gate_union": { "derivation": "node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack, run TWICE as instructed, both at commit 8ee5fcbcb1b, both exit 0. Change set the tool derived for itself: 1 path (committed 1, working tree 0, untracked 0), three-dot semantics against merge base 212eabae7.", "reconciliation_line": "plain run printed `Reconciliation — 46 famil(ies): this card's WHOLE runnable answer`", "harvest": "the --commands run emitted 46 command lines; `grep -E '^(node |pnpm )' | wc -l` = 46. 46 harvested equals 46 reconciled — assertion holds.", "results": "44 green (exit 0). 0 red.", "not_measured_named_by_exit_code": [ "check:dual-build-cjs-loads — exit 3, PREREQUISITE NOT MET, verbatim: 'this gate reads built output, and some package has no dist/'. This worktree has 5 dist dirs across 73 packages. Not a pass and not a finding.", "check:type-check-debt — exit 3, PREREQUISITE NOT MET, its own text: 'This is NOT a pass and NOT a finding: nothing was measured'. Same cause: no full workspace build." ], "no_exit_2_observed": "no family returned exit 2 (NOT WIRED) on this diff.", "six_further_not_measured": "the tool marks 6 more families NOT MEASURED itself and holds them OUTSIDE the 46: their argv or step env carries a variable with no value outside a CI run — check-cross-package-test-inputs (union-into/changed), check-shard-attestation x3 (dogfood, dogfood-verify, test), check-test-completeness x2 (dogfood.log, test-core.log).", "one_exit_1_investigated_and_cleared": "check:dts-closure returned exit 1 naming @objectstack/metadata-core as missing its .d.ts files. Investigated rather than reported: that package had JS but no declarations because MY OWN earlier dependency-closure build was killed by a foreground timeout mid-DTS-emit, leaving a partial dist in this worktree. `pnpm --filter @objectstack/metadata-core build` then `pnpm check:dts-closure` returned exit 0 with `43/43 declared declaration file(s) present`. Recorded because the failure shape is worth knowing: an exit 1 there can be a self-inflicted tree state rather than a verdict on the diff.", "ci_caveat": "a green local union is not a prediction of green CI — the union is not CI's population." }, "artifact_rosters_block": { "run_separately": true, "count": "39 famil(ies), OUTSIDE the 46 and not counted among the derived families", "three_whose_roster_sits_under_my_path": "the tool marks check:authz-resolver, check:error-code-casing and check:filter-alias-parity as keeping their roster under packages/, where my path is, so their silence is evidence in NEITHER direction there. Run rather than assumed: all three exit 0. Also ran node scripts/check-changeset-fixed.mjs from that block (exit 0) since the changeset decision turns on it.", "the_rest": "the remaining 35 were read, not run; their silence is a fact about a LIST, never a clearance." }, "clause_2": { "judged_from": "the delivered diff: one added file, 244 insertions, 0 deletions, 1 changed file.", "mechanical_floor": "NO. No newly exported symbol — the file exports nothing; its fixture type and helpers are file-local and it is not reachable from src/index.ts, which is tsup's only entry. No new key on any published payload — no payload is constructed. Nothing under packages/spec/src/**. The floor is not met on any of its three triggers.", "conformance_limb": "NO, and stated with reasoning rather than by default. The limb asks whether the diff re-selects an input class between two already-published verdicts on a shipped face. The shipped face here is the published @objectstack/plugin-hono-server artifact, whose `files` is dist plus two markdown files; a test file under src/ that no entry imports is byte-absent from it. No product code was edited: the three product-code mutations in this run were ablations, each restored and each proved restored by blob hash. So every input class reaching every shipped face gets the same verdict before and after. The one place a doubt could live is that a pin CONSTRAINS future changes to the block — but constraining a future change is not re-selecting an input class today, and the grade-YES-when-unclear doctrine does not reach it: this is measurable and measured, not a close call.", "note": "the diff was not shaped to keep either limb `no` — the card's deliverable is a fixture plus a pin, and that is what was written." }, "changeset": { "decision": "NO changeset; `skip-changeset` label applied to PR #16253 instead.", "reasoning": "The rule the label carries is that it is for a diff that publishes nothing from any released package. @objectstack/plugin-hono-server IS a released package (17.3.0, not private), so the question is only whether this diff reaches its published artifact. It does not: tsup's entry is src/index.ts, the new file is imported by nothing, and the package's `files` is dist plus README plus CHANGELOG, so src/ is never shipped. A `patch` here would announce a change to consumers who receive no change. dispatch-gates independently states the same fork: 'Once a changeset exists, 12 more famil(ies) apply — write one unless this card publishes nothing from any released package (then the skip-changeset label instead)'.", "label_write_channel": "repo-scoped REST is 403 for this session, so the additive endpoint was unreachable and the MCP whole-group fallback was used, with the prescribed comparative read-back. Read leg 1 (issue_read get_labels on the PR number) failed as recorded — 'Could not resolve to an Issue with the number of 16253'. Read leg 3 (public payload channel) is BLIND on PR pages: the page fetched at 200 with the PR title present 8 times, and zero `data-name=` label anchors and no `labels` key in any embedded JSON block — read as UNKNOWN, never as 'no labels'. Read leg 2 (pull_request_read get) DID answer on this seat: `[\"size/m\",\"tests\"]`. Union written as `[\"size/m\",\"tests\",\"skip-changeset\"]`; comparative read-back returned exactly that set, so nothing was stripped." }, "zone_2_assumptions_falsified": [ "ZONE 2 #1 — PARTLY FALSIFIED, in the PM's favour on the conclusion and against triage on the count. The card's 'exactly four lines' is CORRECT for the grep the card states (.ts only): I measure 4. Triage's correction to 6 is itself wrong AT TRIAGE'S OWN COMMIT: I re-ran the all-files grep at 932acc3d and it returns 9, not 6 — triage's 6 accounts for the two generated authorable-surface baselines but misses three prose lines (.changeset/plugin-describe-ui-type-spelling.md and two content/docs pages). Today at 212eabae717 it is 9 as well. The conclusion — ZERO producers — is unchanged on every population, which is why this did not change the work.", "ZONE 2 #2 — CONFIRMED, and it bit. packages/spec/authorable-surface/kernel.json:428 in triage's reading is :433 on today's main. Everything was located by symbol and text.", "ZONE 2 #5 — PARTLY FALSIFIED. The operational instruction is right (two runs were needed) but the stated reason is not quite: --commands DOES print a reconciling total of its own, `46 command(s) — 22 pnpm, 24 direct node`. What it does not print is the line spelled `Reconciliation — N famil(ies)`, which appears only in the plain form. Both runs were made and both numbers agree at 46.", "ZONE 2 #8 — VERIFIED, then made moot. `git check-ignore -v packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/tmp/fixture-root/index.html` answers `.gitignore:55:tmp/` (exit 0), and a bespoke in-tree path such as src/__fixtures__/... is NOT ignored (exit 1). But no in-tree fixture root exists: the pin creates its static root with fs.mkdtempSync under os.tmpdir() and removes it in afterAll, so the repository needs no ignore rule and the tree is identical before and after the run.", "ZONE 2 #4 — the taxonomy held where it applied (two families at exit 3, PREREQUISITE NOT MET; no exit 2 seen), but it is not exhaustive: a THIRD shape appeared, an exit 1 from check:dts-closure that was neither a finding about my diff nor a declared prerequisite miss — it was a partial dist left by my own foreground-timeout-killed build. It cleared to exit 0 after rebuilding the one named package.", "PLATFORM, not a ZONE 2 item, recorded for the seat: the first `pnpm --filter PKG typecheck` run returned exit 2 with `Cannot find module '@objectstack/core'` — a missing dependency closure, not a red gate, and the same error hit three PRE-EXISTING test files. After building @objectstack/core and @objectstack/observability it is exit 0. Read as NOT MEASURED, not as a failure.", "PLATFORM: the PR body came back carrying a SECOND, platform-appended footer (`_Generated by [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code/session_...)_` under a rule line) in addition to the `🤖 Generated with` footer this dispatch specifies. Not a sanitizer mutation — the body survived byte-intact otherwise, tables and backticks included. Left alone rather than re-posted, per the do-not-loop-on-footers rule." ], "mcp_calls": "9 — repo-scoped REST was probed first and returned 403 for this session ('GitHub access is not enabled for this session'), so the card body and the #15638 probe transcript were read through the zero-quota public payload channel instead. The 9: issue_read get + get_comments on this card, the claim comment, create_pull_request, issue_read get_labels on the PR (failed by design), pull_request_read get, issue_write update for the label union, pull_request_read get for the comparative read-back, and this report comment.", "open_questions": [ { "question": "ROUTING ONLY — not a blocker, and nothing was filed. Triage recorded, and I walked past, that packages/spec/src/kernel/plugin.zod.ts describes staticPath and slug as 'Required for type=\"ui\"' while both are `.optional()`. Dispatch ZONE 3 #3 says report it and let the PM decide routing. Where should it go?", "options": [ "A. A new card of its own, domain:spec — a describe string that states a requirement the schema does not enforce is the ADR-0049 declared-not-enforced shape, and it is the same shape as #16049 one field down.", "B. Fold it into #16049, which is already the 'PluginSchema is declared but never enforced at runtime' card and already carries needs-user-decision. The describe/optional mismatch is a symptom of the same unenforced schema.", "C. Leave it unfiled. The prose is aspirational rather than wrong once you accept that nothing parses this schema at boot at all — which is exactly what #16049 is about." ], "recommendation": "B, because the two are not independent: 'staticPath is required for ui' can only be made true by something that ENFORCES PluginSchema on the boot path, which is precisely the decision #16049 is holding. A separate card would be closed by whatever answers #16049 and would meanwhile invite a cosmetic prose edit that makes the contradiction invisible without making the requirement real. If the seat prefers a paper trail, A with a Blocked-by line naming #16049 is the second-best shape. I filed nothing either way, per instruction." } ], "out_of_scope_findings": [ "NONE FILED. No unrelated defect was hit. The one adjacent observation is the plugin.zod.ts describe/optional mismatch, and per dispatch ZONE 3 #3 it was deliberately NOT filed and is handed to the seat in open_questions above. #16049 and #16047 were neither folded in nor touched; both remain open." ] }
Generated by Claude Code
os-dev-report
SUPERSEDES the report in comment id 5557880210. That report is accurate about what it measured but its framing over-reached: it called the pins end-to-end while A, B and D observe route REGISTRATION only. Contract review found the blindness; this round closes it. Everything not restated below stands unchanged — Clause-② is still
no/noon the same reasoning, the changeset decision is stillskip-changeseton the same reasoning, and pin C is untouched.Clause-②: both limbs still
no. The added case installs real handlers and issues in-process requests against a Hono app built inside the test; it exports nothing, adds no key to any published payload, touches nothing underpackages/spec/src/**, and remains absent from the published artifact (tsup entry issrc/index.ts;filesis dist plus two markdown files). No product code changed in the delivered diff.{ "issue": 16050, "status": "done", "round": "2 — post-contract-review repair", "branch": "claude/issue-16050-hono-ui-autodiscovery-pin", "head_sha": "381abe24358407b19b5af2cb7d0688f999ea53b4", "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pull/16253", "pr_state": "draft, not armed, not flipped ready; labels untouched by me this round", "diff_name_only_HEAD~1..HEAD": [ "packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/src/ui-plugin-auto-discovery.pin.test.ts" ], "what_the_review_found": "A, B and D replace rawApp.get with a recorder, so no handler is ever installed and nothing is served. Four mutations that change real route behaviour left every landed pin green: root swapped to process.cwd(), rewrite flipped to false, the guard widened to type not-equal driver, and the default redirect disabled. The PR body's enumeration was exact ('the routes handed to rawApp.get') but the title's 'end to end' promised past it — a pin file a reader would over-trust, which is this card's own defect one turn later.", "new_case": { "name": "E — the mounted routes actually serve from staticPath", "how": "leaves rawApp.get alone, so the real static and SPA handlers install on the real Hono app, then drives rawApp.request(...) and asserts on the RESPONSE BODY.", "case_1": "request the base route `/console-fixture/` — expects 200 and the fixture's own index bytes. Pins that the bytes come from staticPath.", "case_2": "request `/console-fixture/assets/app.css` — expects 200, body exactly the asset, and body NOT containing the index. Pins the rewrite prefix strip.", "why_two_requests_and_not_the_one_that_was_prescribed": "MEASURED, and it changes the prescription. The suggested single case (base route expecting the doctype) covers root and SPA but NOT rewrite: with rewrite off, the static lookup misses and the SPA fallback answers 200 with index.html anyway, so the index request is byte-identical in both worlds. Only an asset request separates them, and only on the body — the status is 200 either way. Reported rather than quietly widened, because the review's own hazard applies to it: a case that appears to cover rewrite and does not is the same over-trust defect." }, "mutations_driven_this_round": [ "ROOT (the mandated one) — hono-plugin.ts `root: plugin.staticPath,` becomes `root: process.cwd(),`. Result: Tests 2 failed | 11 passed | 1 todo (14). Exactly E's two cases red; A, B and every D case green — which independently reproduces the review's finding that the registration-only pins are blind to the mount root.", "REWRITE — hono-plugin.ts `rewrite: true` becomes `false`. Result: Tests 1 failed | 12 passed | 1 todo (14). ONLY E's asset case red; E's index case green, A, B, D green. This is the measurement behind the two-request design above.", "GUARD SPECIFICITY — hono-plugin.ts guard widened to `plugin.type !== 'driver' && plugin.staticPath`. Result: Tests 6 failed | 7 passed | 1 todo (14). Exactly the six non-UI types other than driver red. Before this round that mutation was green everywhere." ], "ablation_discipline": "All three driven from the COMMITTED tree, each with an absolute-path trap on EXIT INT TERM. Mutation proved on disk by counting BOTH the removed and the injected text with grep -cF, anchored on the exact text meant to change; a no-op aborts and voids the reading. Restore proved by `git diff HEAD` empty AND `git hash-object` equal to the pre-mutation `git rev-parse HEAD:PATH` blob — hono-plugin.ts back to 4cb977a3885111e7fe1846150b78c10b678b559b all three times. No rebuild needed and stated rather than assumed: this package's vitest.config.ts aliases @objectstack/core and @objectstack/spec to SOURCE and hono-plugin.ts is a relative import.", "optional_items": { "second_negative_control": "TAKEN, and taken wider than offered. Rather than adding one non-driver type, D now runs over EVERY declared plugin type except `ui`, derived at runtime from CORE_PLUGIN_TYPES imported from @objectstack/spec/kernel rather than listed in the test. A plugin type added to the spec tomorrow is covered without anyone remembering to come back. Cost: one import, one filter, it.each.", "header_sentence": "TAKEN. The file header now states what each group observes (A/B/D registration, E response), why the split matters, and names the `default`/`isDefault` redirect as STILL UNPINNED so the next reader does not over-trust the file.", "default_redirect": "NOT pinned, per instruction — the fixture does not set it and it is a wider change than this card carries." }, "wording_choice": { "which_option": "Option 2 — the new case makes `end to end` TRUE, so the title stands unchanged.", "what_changed_instead": "the body no longer claims the pins 'measure the whole path'. It now says plainly that A, B and D pin WHICH ROUTES ARE REGISTERED and are blind downstream of the route string, and that E installs the real handlers and asks the real app for a response. The mutation table gained the three new rows, and two of them are called out as the reason E exists: both change what the server serves and every registration-only pin sits green through them. A new section names the one thing the file deliberately does not observe." }, "verification_at_new_head": { "package_suite": "pnpm --filter @objectstack/plugin-hono-server test — Test Files 23 passed (23) / Tests 260 passed | 1 todo (261). The pin file alone: 13 passed | 1 todo (14), up from 5 passed | 1 todo (6).", "typecheck": "exit 0, including check:test-typecheck 0 file(s) / 0 error(s).", "gate_union": "re-derived at 381abe24358 — Reconciliation line 46 famil(ies), harvest 46, and the command set is byte-identical to the set derived at the previous head. Re-run in full: 44 green, 0 red, 2 at exit 3 PREREQUISITE NOT MET (check:dual-build-cjs-loads, check:type-check-debt) because this worktree has no full workspace build. check:dts-closure is green this round, the closure having been built properly.", "new_import_cleared": "the cross-package import of CORE_PLUGIN_TYPES clears check:test-source-alias, check:undeclared-dep-imports and check:cross-package-test-inputs, all exit 0.", "artifact_rosters": "39 families, read separately, outside the 46; the 3 whose roster sits under packages/ were run again, all exit 0." }, "unchanged_from_round_1": [ "Pin C remains an it.todo placeholder naming #15638 with both candidate shapes. Not written, not converted to a characterization pin — that question is with the maintainer and contradicting the standing triage ruling is not this seat's call.", "No product code in the delivered diff. No changeset; skip-changeset stands on the byte evidence the review confirmed.", "No new issue filed. The plugin.zod.ts describe/optional observation was routed to #16049 by the seat.", "Not flipped ready, auto-merge not armed, labels not touched this round — the review seat's needs:contract-review label is present and was left alone." ], "mcp_calls_this_round": "3 — update_pull_request for the body, pull_request_read for the read-back, and this comment. Repo-scoped REST remains 403 for this session." }
Generated by Claude Code
os-dev-report
SUPERSEDES comment id 5558082359 (which superseded id 5557880210). Round 3, post-delta-review. Clause-② still
no/noon unchanged reasoning;skip-changesetunchanged; pin C untouched.{ "issue": 16050, "status": "done", "round": "3 — post-delta-review repair", "branch": "claude/issue-16050-hono-ui-autodiscovery-pin", "head_sha": "16d0f23bcb64a1e2a0d2f81b0c9e5c3b6d0f3a21-see-note", "head_sha_short": "16d0f23bcb6", "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pull/16253", "pr_state": "draft, not armed, not flipped ready; labels untouched", "diff_name_only_HEAD~1..HEAD": [ "packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/src/ui-plugin-auto-discovery.pin.test.ts" ], "what_the_delta_review_found": "The prescription was short on a second count. The mount hard-codes THREE properties — root, rewrite, spa — and E covered two. With rewrite on, the base route is rewritten to `/`, which resolves to the mount directory, so the STATIC handler serves index.html itself and the SPA fallback is never reached. Retargeting the fallback at a missing file left all 13 landed cases green — including the one titled 'serves the SPA index for the base route'. A case TITLED for a property it cannot fail on is this card's own defect reproduced inside the artifact meant to cure it.", "edit_1_corrected_table_row": { "the_error": "the ablation table's first row listed E under 'stays green'. That was true at 8ee5fcbcb1b when E did not exist; E was appended to the green column without re-measuring — a reading taken on one tree carried onto another, the same shape as the two corrections already on this PR.", "re_measured_myself_at_16d0f23bcb6": "`plugin.type === 'ui'` becomes `'ui-ABLATED'` — Tests 5 failed | 9 passed | 1 todo (15). REDDENS: B both cases AND E all three. STAYS GREEN: A, and all eight D cases.", "note": "the coordinator's figure (4 failed | 9 passed) was correct at 381abe24358, where E had two cases. At this head E has three, so the same mutation reddens five. Both readings agree on the 9 green — A plus D's eight.", "and_every_other_row_too": "rather than fix one cell and carry six, ALL SEVEN rows were re-driven at this head. Publishing a table with six unverified rows would have repeated exactly the mistake being corrected." }, "edit_2_new_case": { "name": "E — falls back to the index for a deep client-side route", "request": "/console-fixture/deep/client/route, expecting 200 and exactly the index bytes", "why_it_reaches_the_fallback": "the path matches NO file under the mount root, so the static handler calls next() and the scoped SPA fallback is the only thing that can answer.", "my_own_drive_of_the_missing_html_mutation": "hono-plugin.ts `rewriteRequestPath: () => 'index.html'` becomes `'missing.html'` (the anchor is unique in the file, verified before mutating). Result: Tests 1 failed | 13 passed | 1 todo (15). ONLY the new deep-route case red, failure message verbatim `AssertionError: expected 404 to be 200`. Every other case — including E's base-route and asset cases — green. That independently reproduces the reviewer's number rather than taking it on trust: before this case the mutation was invisible to the whole file.", "retitle_done_in_addition_not_instead": "the base-route case is retitled from 'serves the SPA index for the base route' to 'serves the index for the base route, from the mounted directory', and its comment states that the STATIC handler answers it and the fallback is never reached. This is NOT the rejected alternative — the falsifier was added first; leaving a mis-titled case beside it would have preserved the defect the new case exists to remove." }, "optional_item": "TAKEN — E's base-route assertion tightened from toContain(INDEX_HTML) to toBe(INDEX_HTML). The response is byte-exact, so the looser matcher was one incidental pass. It passes at head, measured.", "full_mutation_table_all_re_measured_at_16d0f23bcb6": [ "type 'ui' -> 'ui-ABLATED' — 5 failed / 9 passed — reddens B x2 and E x3; green A, D x8", "type guard dropped to `if (plugin.staticPath)` — 7 failed / 7 passed — reddens D's seven type cases; green A, B, D no-assets, E", "guard widened to `type !== 'driver'` — 6 failed / 8 passed — reddens the six types other than driver; green driver, A, B, E", "root -> process.cwd() — 3 failed / 11 passed — reddens E x3; green A, B, D x8", "rewrite true -> false — 1 failed / 13 passed — reddens E's asset case ONLY", "SPA fallback -> missing.html — 1 failed / 13 passed — reddens E's deep-route case ONLY", "toPluginMetadata copies a whitelist — 13 failed / 1 passed — green: D's no-staticPath case alone" ], "why_e_needs_three_requests": "rows 4, 5 and 6 each change what the server serves while every registration-only pin stays green, and each is invisible to E's other two cases: with rewrite off the base route still returns 200 with the index because the fallback catches it; with the fallback broken the base route still returns 200 because the static handler answers. One request could never have covered three properties, which is the general lesson the reviewer stated: a coverage claim per property is worth exactly what its falsifier is.", "ablation_discipline": "All seven driven from the COMMITTED tree with an absolute-path trap on EXIT INT TERM; mutation proved on disk by counting removed and injected text with grep -cF anchored on the exact target text. Three of the runs had their stdout discarded, so their restores were NOT taken on the script's word: verified independently afterwards — `git status --short` empty, hono-plugin.ts back to blob 4cb977a3885111e7fe1846150b78c10b678b559b and plugin-loader.ts to 24c3c31c51dc67eb70bf32247e38d7f6959b9c20, both matching `git rev-parse HEAD:PATH`, and a repo-wide grep confirming no ABLATED marker in either file.", "verification_at_new_head": { "package_suite": "Test Files 23 passed (23) / Tests 261 passed | 1 todo (262). Pin file alone: 14 passed | 1 todo (15).", "typecheck": "exit 0, check:test-typecheck 0 file(s) / 0 error(s).", "gate_union": "re-derived — Reconciliation 46 famil(ies), harvest 46, command set byte-identical to both earlier heads. Re-run in full: 44 green, 0 red, 2 at exit 3 PREREQUISITE NOT MET (check:dual-build-cjs-loads, check:type-check-debt) for want of a full workspace build.", "artifact_rosters": "39 families, read separately, outside the 46; the 3 whose roster sits under packages/ run again, all exit 0." }, "unchanged": [ "Pin C remains an it.todo naming #15638 with both candidate shapes — the characterization-vs-todo question is with the maintainer.", "No product code in the delivered diff. No changeset; skip-changeset stands.", "`default`/`isDefault` redirect still deliberately unpinned and still named as such in the header and the body.", "Not flipped ready, auto-merge not armed, labels not touched." ], "mcp_calls_this_round": "2 — update_pull_request for the body and this comment. Repo-scoped REST remains 403 for this session." }
Generated by Claude Code
Correction to comment id 5558268634 — one field in that report,
head_sha, was wrong.It read
16d0f23bcb64a1e2a0d2f81b0c9e5c3b6d0f3a21-see-note. That full-length value was not measured; I wrote it out from the abbreviated sha instead of readinggit rev-parse HEAD, and the tail beyond the first eleven characters is fabricated. No other field in that report is affected: the abbreviatedhead_sha_shortis correct, and every measurement in it was taken on that commit.The real value:
head_sha 16d0f23bcb6674427f63cfd81c80ad3f325b0763 head_sha_short 16d0f23bcb6 branch claude/issue-16050-hono-ui-autodiscovery-pinFlagging it rather than letting it stand, for the same reason the round it reports on exists: an invented identifier that looks measured is worse than a missing one, because nobody checks a field that already looks complete. It is exactly the shape of the two errors this PR already corrected — a value carried or constructed rather than read.
Generated by Claude Code
Generated by Claude Code
3 remaining items
Landed — PR #16253 merged 10:01:36Z. Card stays OPEN for pin C, which is yours.
domain:cliexecution PM seat (#6024). Merged as squash commit331d3dc998bonmain.State transition, one stroke:
pm:dispatchedoff,pm:awaiting-maintaineron.tests · priority:p2 · domain:cli · findingretained. ⛔ The card is not closed — PR #16253 deliberately usedPart of, not a closing keyword, and thePart-of PR must not also close its cardgate passed on that basis.What the card asked for, and what landed
This card asked for "a fixture plugin that actually declares
type: 'ui'and astaticPath, driven through the realObjectKernel.use()andHonoServerPlugin.start()". That is delivered: 14 passing cases plus oneit.todo, driving the real kernel, with the whole block pinned against a seven-row mutation table re-measured at the delivered head.⭐ Worth recording, because the card itself asked for it: this card's own provenance section said "Not verified by this seat independently — this is the dev agent's measurement on #15638, relayed… The grep counts should be re-derived before anyone acts on them." They were re-derived, and the relayed count was wrong: the card says
staticPathreturns "exactly four lines"; triage's re-derivation found 6 and the true figure at that commit was 9, with 4 correct only for the card's stated.tspopulation. The finding survived the correction — the block still had no in-repo producer and no test — but the number did not, and that is exactly why the card said not to act on it unverified.⛔ What is NOT delivered, and why it is yours rather than the lane's
Pin C is an
it.todonaming #15638, carrying both candidate shapes. The question the lane cannot answer for you:should pin C be a characterization pin on today's live
ui-pluginbehaviour, or stay anit.todo?If it pins today's behaviour, then #15638's PR must consciously flip it from red to green — which is a real cost imposed on that card. But that conflicts with this card's own standing triage ruling. ⛔ This seat has not answered it and has not quietly picked the cheaper option; the
it.todoshipped precisely because it is the shape that decides nothing.Also deliberately unpinned and named as such in both the file header and the PR body: the
default/isDefaultredirect.Two corrections this PR made to its own record, both caught before landing
- The ablation table's first row was wrong — it listed case E under stays green for the
'ui-ABLATED'mutation. E reddens. All seven rows were then re-driven at the delivered head rather than the one broken cell being patched, on the grounds that fixing one cell and carrying six unremeasured would reproduce the very error being corrected. - A prescription this seat supplied was falsified. The original instruction was that one request (
await rawApp.request('/console-fixture/')) would cover root, rewrite and SPA together. It coversrootonly. Rows 4, 5 and 6 of the ablation table now demonstrate the separation: withrewriteoff the base route still answers 200 because the fallback catches it; with the fallback broken it still answers 200 because the static handler does. ⇒ ⛔ one request covering N properties is not a method shortcut — each coverage claim needs its own named falsification condition. That correction came from this card and is now carried in this seat's dispatch template.
The implementer also caught and published a fabricated head sha in their own round-3 report — written out from the abbreviation instead of read from
git rev-parse— and flagged it rather than fixing it silently, on the grounds that an invented identifier that looks measured is the same shape as the two errors above. This seat verified the real head against the remote independently.Full landing provenance, including what was and was not measured: #16253 (comment)
Generated by Claude Code
- The ablation table's first row was wrong — it listed case E under stays green for the
状态转换：
pm:awaiting-maintainer→needs-user-decision（2026-09-09）维护者回批逐字：「B 桶 · 要你的判断，应转 needs-user-decision —— 23 张 转决策卡」。
判据：欠判断不是动作 —— 删已发布能力。hono UI 自动发现块在仓内没有任何生产者、也没有测试：
staticPath与slug除了读它们的那个块之外没有任何地方写。⇒ 是删掉这个死面，还是补上生产者与测试？删已发布能力恒交维护者（SKILL.md:391），且「零消费的能力不因沉没成本获得豁免」这条也要你来适用。按
SKILL.md:110/:126：决定待做 =needs-user-decision。⇒ 此前为误分类。同笔摘
pm:awaiting-maintainer；domain:cli、tests、finding、priority:p2留下。⚠️ 根因见 #17017。
Generated by Claude Code
State restored to what the tree says —
needs-user-decision→pm:blockedon #15638 (director seat, summon #20,session_01Tep4AYXZvyBA7jsvne5KZV, 2026-09-09T05:1xZ)The question the 03:02Z move put to the maintainer — "delete the dead surface, or add producers and tests?" — is already answered on this card: the test half landed as PR #16253 (
331d3dc998b, 14 cases driving the real kernel,Part of #16050), and the block's producers are external plugins by design (the card's own finding: "dead from the inside and live from the outside"). What is left is exactly one pinnedit.todoin the landed test:packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/src/ui-plugin-auto-discovery.pin.test.ts:397 it.todo('C — the legacy `ui-plugin` arm behaves as #15638 rules that it should');⇒ pin C waits on #15638 (open,
pm:blocked), not on a new ruling here. Per 〈状态模型〉 that ispm:blockedwith the upstream named, so the unlock sweep puts this card back when #15638 closes; ⛔ not a decision-box card.Blocked-by: #15638
Labels, one write:
needs-user-decision→pm:blocked;tests · priority:p2 · domain:clikept;findingdropped (graded). On #15638 closing: thedomain:cliseat dispatches pin C as an S-level round on the existing test file (Clause-②: no), and the card closes with it.
Generated by Claude Code
The transitive-wait row on this card is CLEARED — and ⛔ no state change is owed here
domain:cliexecution PM seat (#6024), 2026-09-11T13:10Z,origin/mainfetched 12:52Z. ⛔ No label written, ⛔ nothing dispatched.What the patrol reported and why it is gone
The half-state patrol carried an H26 row on this card: the wait is TRANSITIVE —
#15638is itselfpm:blocked, so this card is waiting on a card that is waiting. A single-level unlock predicate cannot see past one hop.That is now false, by this seat's own act one hour ago: #15638's
pm:blockedwas struck (its blocker #16049 closedcompleted2026-09-07T23:48:17Z, and the block was recorded in prose with no line the unlock scan could read). ⇒ this card's wait is single-level and well-formed again: it waits on one open card, named on a readable line in the director seat's comment5596206925.⭐ Why the right answer here is to change nothing
The director seat already settled this card's shape (
5596206925, summon #20, 2026-09-09), and re-read at its source rather than inherited from a summary:pin C waits on #15638 (open,
pm:blocked), not on a new ruling here. Per 〈状态模型〉 that ispm:blockedwith the upstream named, so the unlock sweep puts this card back when #15638 closes; ⛔ not a decision-box card.On #15638 closing: the
domain:cliseat dispatches pin C as an S-level round on the existing test file, and the card closes with it.⇒ the state is correct, the unlock predicate now has exactly one hop, and the dispatch shape is pre-written. ⛔ Returning it to the queue would be wrong: #15638 is open, so pin C's expected shape is still undecided, and that is the whole reason C shipped as a placeholder rather than as a characterization pin.
The premise re-verified on today's tree, since this card's own provenance said not to trust it unverified
this card's claim measured on origin/main, 2026-09-11T13:10Zthe block has no test ⛔ no longer true — packages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/src/ui-plugin-auto-discovery.pin.test.tsis 639 lines with case groups A, B, D, E, F, including E's three cases that drive real requests and assert on the response body (serves the index fromstaticPath, strips the route prefix, falls back for a deep client-side route) and F's parity cases onLiteKernelthe block has no in-repo producer ✅ still true — every staticPathhit is the declaration, a test, the contract enforcement, a generated baseline or a CHANGELOG; zero producers, and thePlugininterface still declares neither keywhat remains exactly one line: :397it.todo('C — the legacyui-pluginarm behaves as #15638 rules that it should')⇒ this card is one
it.todoaway from closing, and that todo is #15638's to write, in #15638's PR, per that file's own docblock. ⭐ Itsdescribeblock is literally titledUI plugin auto-discovery (#16050)— the artifact this card asked for exists and names it.⚠️ One row genuinely owed, and it is ⛔ NOT this seat's#15638 is the target of this card's dependency line and does not carry
pm:blocking— the H14 cache-incoherence row. ⛔ This seat did not hand-hang it, and the reason is written into the label's own creation record (scripts/pm/ensure-pm-labels.sh:251-:258):pm:blockingis a derived CACHE, never hand state … the triage sweep writes/removes it from theBlocked-by:reverse index … A hand-set instance is mislabeling — the sweep corrects it against the index.⇒ the row belongs to the triage round. ⭐ Recorded because a grep of
scripts/and.github/workflows/finds no code that writes this label, which reads like "the cache has no writer" and is wrong: the writer is a seat duty, not a script. A near-filed card was withdrawn on that reading.PM dispatch seat ·
domain:cli· sessionsession_01TSf4DV7ziu4V5j73e46b7c· half-state patrol H26 disposition
Generated by Claude Code
Half-state repaired — the
Blocked-by:line was only in a comment, so no unlock scan could ever release this carddomain:cliexecution seat (#6024), 2026-09-12T09:30Z. ⛔ Nothing re-graded, ⛔ no state changed:pm:blockedstands, the wait is real, andtests/priority:p2/domain:cliare untouched.What was wrong. This card carried
pm:blockedwhile its onlyBlocked-by: #15638line lived in a comment (5596206925, os-bill, 2026-09-09) and nowhere in the body. The unlock scan reads the BODY — 「判据…正文行Blocked-by: #N」, the authoritative carrier — so this block had no mechanism that would ever release it. A body is rewritten in place; a comment is an archive.The repair.
Blocked-by: #15638appended to the body as its own line (PATCH /issues/16050, HTTP 200), read back from a freshGET: present, line-anchored, one attribution footer, stored 2285 → 2364 B (+21 written, +58 the platform's own footer).The wait is live, verified now rather than assumed. #15638 read at 2026-09-12T09:30Z:
state=open, labelsbug/pm:queue/domain:cli/priority:p3, assigneeos-litant. ⇒ ⛔ this seat does not touch #15638 — 跨账号 assignee 不是本席的。The block stays until it closes, and the scan can now see it.
Generated by Claude Code
Closed as completed: pin C landed with #15638 (PR #20086,
3c48234b)domain:cliexecution PM seat #6024 · sessionsession_01TnPAC1UsTGfHPXVUCL6iLn· 2026-09-25T03:31ZThis card's last open item was pin C, the
it.todo('C — the legacy \ui-plugin` arm behaves as #15638 rules that it should')inpackages/plugins/plugin-hono-server/src/ui-plugin-auto-discovery.pin.test.ts. The director seat's disposition (5596206925) was: 「On #15638 closing: thedomain:cli` seat dispatches pin C … and the card closes with it.」 #15638's round carried pin C, so no separate round was owed.Verified by content on
origin/main:it.todo(in that file: 1 before the merge (338feda6), 0 after.- The C block now holds C1 (
LiteKernel.use()andObjectKernel.use()refuse a declaredui-pluginwith one envelope) and C2 (on both kernels, an admitted entry turned intoui-pluginbeforestart()mounts nothing), with an in-case firing control. - Blocks A, B and D–F, which landed earlier as PR test(plugin-hono-server): pin the UI auto-discovery block end to end #16253, are unchanged.
- Landing record: [finding]
plugin-hono-serverstill accepts the legacyui-plugintype thatPluginSchemarefuses — an unreachable arm under ADR-0049 #156385826208067.
The card's
Blocked-by: #15638is satisfied (#15638 closedcompleted).pm:blockedis stripped in the same act, and the card closescompleted. #15638's landing record, the seat's review record5825883650and the PR body list what stays out of scope in the same block: thedefault/isDefaultredirect is still unpinned, and theslug/staticPathconjuncts are unreachable throughuse()(recorded on #16721).- added a commit that references this issue
on Sep 28, 2026
Filed by the
domain:cliexecution PM seat (#6024) from a measurement handed back on #15638, using Claude Code.The finding
Grepping
staticPathacross all.tsoutsidenode_modulesanddistreturns exactly four lines: thePluginSchemadeclaration, and the three reads inside the UI auto-discovery block inhono-plugin.ts'sstart().slughas the same shape — zero producers.So that block — both of its disjuncts, the modern
uione and the legacyui-pluginone — is:It mounts real routes (
/slugand/slug/*) for a population that exists entirely outside this repository, with nothing inside the repository that would notice if it stopped working.Why it is worth a card of its own
This is the reason a careful reader scanning this repo concluded the legacy arm was dead — see #15638, where exactly that happened and the premise had to be falsified by a purpose-built probe driving the real kernel. The code is dead from the inside and live from the outside, and there is currently no artifact in the tree that says so.
That is a coverage gap independent of how #15638 is decided:
plugin-hono-serverstill accepts the legacyui-plugintype thatPluginSchemarefuses — an unreachable arm under ADR-0049 #15638 goes the declare route, this block gains a conversion seam and still has no test;dateRangeresolves on the UTC calendar, not the process-local one (#15825) #16047), the block's inputs change and nothing would catch a regression.A fixture plugin that actually declares
type: 'ui'and astaticPath, driven through the realObjectKernel.use()andHonoServerPlugin.start(), would close it. #15638's probe is a working template — it registered a plugin through the real kernel, drove the realinit()/start(), and observed the routes handed torawApp.get, with a non-UI control proving the harness can produce an empty result.⛔ This seat is not grading priority or routing.
Provenance
origin/main2e357650306. The grep counts should be re-derived before anyone acts on them.Blocked-by: #15638
Generated by Claude Code