[finding] 26 source comments in src/ cite src/flows/ — a directory ADR-0130 removed (blocked on Track A: file surface collides)

Part of #1904 —— #1918 的源码半边。同一类欠账，分成两张卡走的唯一原因见〈串行约束〉。

读数

ADR-0130 的搬迁（#1905）之后 src/flows/ 不存在了，但 src/ 自己的注释里仍有 26 处指向它，分布在 22 个文件：

域	文件数	站点数
`src/sales/`	10	12
`src/service/`	5	6
`src/revenue/`	3	4
`src/marketing/`	2	2
`src/docs/`	1	1
`src/sales/flows/index.ts`	—	1 ⚠️

最讽刺的一处是 src/sales/flows/index.ts:9 —— 搬迁后的新文件，注释里还在把读者指回旧路径。

⚠️ 陷阱：⛔ 不是机械加前缀就能改对

src/flows/billing-handoff.flow.ts（src/revenue/objects/quote.hook.ts:277 与 :309）没有同名后继。
它在搬迁里一分为二：

src/sales/flows/billing-handoff-closed-won.flow.ts —— 赢单时
src/revenue/flows/billing-handoff-contract-activated.flow.ts —— 合同激活时

那两条注释在讲 POST 给计费的时机，要读懂上下文再决定改成哪一个（或两个都点名）。⛔ 不要盲加 revenue/ 前缀就算完。

src/flows/index.ts（src/sales/flows/index.ts:9）同理 —— 现在有四个 */flows/index.ts，没有单一后继。

其余逐个用 find src -name <basename> 核实，前缀逐文件不同，且未必等于注释所在文件的域：
src/sales/objects/account.object.ts:448 引的 contract-renewal.flow.ts 真实落点是 src/revenue/flows/。

src/flows/*.flow.ts 这类 glob 出现在 6 个对象文件的同一句套话里（「scheduled status flips and notifications live in …」）—— 改成 src/*/flows/*.flow.ts 或点名域，⛔ 保持这 6 处改法一致，不要一处一个花样。

串行约束 ⚠️

本卡的文件面与 Track A 的三张在飞实现卡直撞：

src/sales/objects/lead.object.ts         <- #1914
src/sales/objects/account.object.ts      <- #1915
src/sales/objects/opportunity.object.ts  <- #1916

⇒ 本卡挂 pm:blocked，解锁判据是 #1916 落地（Track A 最后一张）。⛔ 在那之前不派、不开工。

⚠️ 解锁后先重新量一遍：Track A 的三张卡各自会动这些文件，站点行号会变，说不定顺手已经改掉了几处。⛔ 不要照抄本卡里的行号。

文件面

只动 src/ 下的注释。 ⛔ 零行为改动 —— 不改任何可执行代码、不改任何声明、不改任何 label 或选项。
⛔ 不碰 content/docs/ —— 那是 [finding] docs cite src/flows/ — a directory ADR-0130 removed (48 sites), and the crm_contact department roster names three values that do not exist #1918，可能已经落地或在飞。

验收

grep -rn "src/flows" src/ 命中数为 0。
每一处新写的路径在 find src -name 里有实际命中；分裂成两个的那处按上下文选对。
那 6 处套话 glob 改法一致。
git diff 里只有注释行。⛔ 任何非注释行的改动都是超范围。
pnpm verify 绿（package.json 是权威，⛔ 不自行窄化）。退出码在任何管道之前写进文件再读。
changeset：本卡是纯注释、零用户可见变化，按仓里的既有形状判断该不该挂 skip-changeset，并在 PR 正文写明理由。

追加：`src/translations/` 是第二类同形死路径（源码半边 36 处）

立卡后复量时发现的，同一次搬迁的同一种欠账，且同样撞 Track A：

$ ls -d src/translations
ls: cannot access 'src/translations': No such file or directory

真身是 src/sales/translations/。src/ 里 36 处，落在 34 个文件：

位置	文件数	站点数
`src/sales/translations/{en,zh-CN,es-ES,ja-JP}/*.ts` 的 docblock	32	32
`src/sales/dashboards/executive.dashboard.ts`	1	~2
`src/sales/flows/lead-conversion.flow.ts`	1	~2

⚠️ 那 32 处是每个语言包文件顶部 docblock 的同一句套话：

 * A new row goes in the file for ITS family, never in whichever file is
 * already open: … Full rule and rationale: `src/translations/en.ts`.

这句话本身是对的、而且重要（它是语言包的拆分纪律），只是它指的那个文件的路径变了。四个语言各指自己那份：en.ts / zh-CN.ts / ja-JP.ts / es-ES.ts，逐个核实，⛔ 不要四个都写成 en.ts。

⚠️ src/sales/flows/lead-conversion.flow.ts 与 #1914 的文件面直撞 —— 又一条本卡必须等 Track A 走完的理由。

追加验收

grep -rn "src/translations/" src/ 命中数为 0，且每处新路径在 find src 里有实际命中。
那 32 处套话改法一致，且四个语言各自指向自己那份。

Generated by Claude Code

docs: name the package that owns the file — repoint src/flows/ and sr…

PM 加宽：本卡的真实规模是 ~198 处，不是 62 处。

出处：#1943 / PR #1944 的复核。那席在 src/**/*.ts 里量到 194 处 / 104 文件；我自己复量是 198 处 / 105 文件（正则宽窄差异，三项主力逐个吻合）。

读数（PM 量，对 `origin/main`）

本卡原本只盯 src/flows/（26）与 src/translations/（36）两族，共 62 处。同一批文件里的完整集合是：

目录	处数	目录	处数
`src/objects`	36	`src/actions`	18
`src/translations`	36	`src/profiles`	16
`src/flows`	25	`src/sharing`	10
`src/data`	20	`src/dashboards`	6
`src/views`	20	`src/pages`	4

合计 ~198 处，横跨 105 个文件。

⇒ 原来的 62 处是这个集合的子集。加宽本卡，⛔ 不另开 —— 同一棵树、同一次 ADR-0130 搬迁、同一套判断。

⚠️ 判断仍然是本卡的核心，而且比文档那几张更难

#1943 的施工席点出了关键分辨，我认：

A minority are correct history（「this package's half of the list src/hooks/index.ts used to hold」）；
the rest are present-tense cross-references，例如 src/revenue/objects/contract.object.ts:231：「See the canonical capability note in src/objects/index.ts」。

⇒ 同 #1924 那条判据一字不改地适用：

记录过去状态的注释，保留它当时的路径；告诉你东西今天在哪的注释，必须是现值。

⚠️ 但源码注释比文档更难判 —— 一句「used to hold」与一句「See … in」在语法上只差几个词，⛔ 不能靠 grep 分类。逐处读。

⚠️ 一个已知的工具链陷阱（#1924 与 #1934 各被咬过一次）

src/ + * + / 这个形状的路径写在块注释里会提前结束注释，tsc 报 TS1005。vitest.config.ts 里记了这个坑。写进行注释或用文字描述。

⇒ 本卡有 105 个文件全是 .ts，这个坑必然撞上。

解锁判据不变

仍是 #1916 落地（Track A 最后一张）。本卡的文件面与 Track A 的实现卡直撞，而 #1916 目前因 #1928 的天花板裁决而挂 pm:blocked。

⚠️ 解锁后先重量一遍 —— Track A 的卡会动这些文件，行号与处数都会变。⛔ 不要照抄本评论的数字。

追加验收

那十个目录名在 src/**/*.ts 里的命中数为 0，或逐处写明为什么保留。
PR 正文的逐处判断表覆盖全部 ~198 处，每处一句理由（改了 / 保留 + 为什么）。
git diff 里只有注释行 —— 任何非注释行的改动都是超范围。

Generated by Claude Code

Transition: pm:blocked → pm:queue · reason: this card's unlock, 「解锁判据是 #1916 落地」 (body), is met: #1916 closed completed on 2026-10-03 · finding is removed in the same write, because the card already carries its grade (priority:p3) · repo:hotcrm seat, session_012zh91QzFgePbkmuHnugLN3, 2026-10-08T04:06Z

Re-derived on origin/main c529de2b, not carried:

git grep 'src/flows/' -- src = 24 lines.
git grep 'src/translations/' -- src = 36 lines.
Control: src/sales/flows/ = 6 lines, and git ls-tree -d origin/main src/ lists docs marketing revenue sales service only.

So both dead directory names are still cited, and the body's 26 + 36 is now 24 + 36.

The PM widening of 2026-09-15 (5686987990, ~198 sites) is the scope the dispatch re-measures. ⛔ Neither number is a target.

Serial order: these are comment edits across most of src/, so this card waits for hotcrm#2000 (in flight on src/sales/**, src/revenue/** and the translation packs) and then hotcrm#1907. The body's trap holds for the dispatch: billing-handoff.flow.ts has no single successor, because it split into a closed-won and a contract-activated flow. ⛔ It is not a mechanical prefix edit.

Generated by Claude Code

Carry-over for this card from PR #2012 (99d290ad): repo:hotcrm seat, session_012zh91QzFgePbkmuHnugLN3, 2026-10-08T08:18Z. Two source comments now cite tests that PR #2012 retired. Fix them in this card's comment sweep, naming the platform lint rule instead:

src/revenue/objects/opportunity_line_item.object.ts (~line 69): "test/field-groups-coverage.test.ts pins it" should cite field-group-shadowed.
src/service/flows/case-escalation.flow.ts (~line 123): "test/flow-decision-authority.test.ts enforces that" should cite flow-inert-node-condition.

Generated by Claude Code

Claim: PM loop round R76
Session: session_018Mk4tab2eCyY41UTWK7y7V
Account: zhuangjianguo (the seat's linked user as GET /user answers it; always the card's assignee)
Branch: claude/issue-1919-source-comment-paths
Worktree: hotcrm-issue-1919
Domain: repo:hotcrm (single-lane repo, no domain:* taxonomy)
Seat: repo:hotcrm#1
File surface: comment lines only, in src/**/*.ts: every comment that cites a pre-ADR-0130 top-level directory (src/flows/, src/translations/, src/objects/, src/actions/, src/profiles/, src/sharing/, src/data/, src/views/, src/dashboards/, src/pages/), and the two retired-test citations named in 6055754509. ⛔ No non-comment line, ⛔ no content/docs/**. The changeset question is decided per the card's acceptance item 6 (stop on breach; explain in the report)
Container & model: M, mode:subagent (the os-dev definition and the scripts/pm write tools live in this container's objectstack checkout), model: default (dispatch-gates --tier --repo objectstack-ai/hotcrm answers "The tier stays the PM's per-card judgment call"; no declared tier glob is hit; each site is a reading judgment, so not the floor tier)
Clause-②: no
Responsibility: n/a — not a defect card
Thread-read: 6055754509
Serial constraints cleared: #2029 is dispatched in this same round; it may edit grant entries in src/sales/profiles/*.profile.ts and the enable.feeds note in src/sales/objects/index.ts. Ordinary concurrency: this card edits comment lines only, and the later lander merges main and reruns pnpm verify. #2000 (pm:blocked; branch claude/issue-2000-picklist-metadata parked, no open PR) touches src/sales/**, src/revenue/** and the translation packs; it merges main on resume (6061167800 on #2000). #1907 and #1916, which this card waited on, are closed. No open PR in the repo.

Generated by Claude Code

os-dev-report
{
"issue": 1919,
"status": "done",
"branch": "claude/issue-1919-source-comment-paths",
"pr": "#2040",
"session": "session_018Mk4tab2eCyY41UTWK7y7V",
"premise_still_valid": true,
"summary": "Repointed the comments in src//.ts that cite the flat pre-ADR-0130 directories. I read 176 candidate sites on base ac162c9: 158 changed, 16 kept as past state or as not-a-comment, and 2 that are not hotcrm paths (an objectui URL and an @objectstack/objectql path). The two retired-test citations from 6055754509 now name field-group-shadowed and flow-inert-node-condition plus pnpm lint. Notable choices: all 9 stock flow sentences (the card said 6) use the same line-comment glob, src//flows/*.flow.ts. Each of the 32 locale docblocks points at its own src/sales/translations/LOCALE.ts. Both billing-handoff sites in quote.hook.ts name src/revenue/flows/billing-handoff-contract-activated.flow.ts, the split successor that POSTs payment_terms and contract_type when the contract activates. Some successors are not where a prefix would put them: forecast rows are in sales/data/forecast.seed.ts, task rows in sales/data/activity.seed.ts, global.actions.ts became sales/actions/activity-actions.ts, the crm_case log_call is in service/actions/case-activity.actions.ts, and the seed-user note is in objectstack.composition.ts. The diff is comment lines only, plus one empty-frontmatter changeset. The premise holds; only the card's counts and line numbers were stale.",
"tests": "pnpm verify on head 6055671 (= final HEAD), through the shared lock (OS_VERIFY_LOCK_SLOT=hotcrm-1919 bash /home/user/objectstack/scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh -c 'pnpm verify'): 'os-verify-lock: VERDICT command-exit 0 · held the lock 515s (8m35s) · waited 0s'. Stage lines: '✓ Validation passed (2483ms)'; lint --strict '18 suggestion(s)'; '✓ i18n lint gate: 0 i18n/missing-* issues'; '✓ source hygiene clean'; '✓ source token ratchet clean' (revenue ~15,641 / ~18,752, the same figures #2037's changeset recorded, so comment edits do not move it); 'Artifact: dist/objectstack.json (2319.2 KB)'; 'Test Files 173 passed (173)', 'Tests 3609 passed | 1 skipped (3610)'. Comment-only proof (1): git diff -U0 origin/main...HEAD -- 'src//.ts' | grep -E '^[+-]' | grep -vE '^(\+\+\+|---) ' | grep -vE '^[+-][[:space:]](//|/?\)' gives exit 1 and 0 lines. Comment-only proof (2): a TypeScript 6.0.2 compiler-API leaf-token comparison of base vs head over all 94 changed .ts files gives 94 identical, 0 differing. Its positive controls both differ with exit 1: editing the template-literal line activity-actions.ts:381, and changing const to let in _thresholds.ts. Artifact check: dist/objectstack.json has 0 hits for the new comment strings (for example src/sales/objects/event.hook.ts). Path check: 66 distinct newly written paths or globs, each expanded with compgen -G, 0 missing. No ablation or reverse-proof applies; nothing in the diff executes.",
"site_counts": {
"command": "git grep -n "src/DIR/" REV -- 'src/**/.ts' | wc -l (REV = ac162c9 before, 6055671 after)",
"before_after": {
"src/flows/": "23 → 1",
"src/translations/": "36 → 0",
"src/objects/": "32 → 1",
"src/actions/": "17 → 2",
"src/profiles/": "14 → 0",
"src/sharing/": "8 → 0",
"src/data/": "18 → 8",
"src/views/": "19 → 2",
"src/dashboards/": "1 → 0",
"src/pages/": "1 → 0",
"src/skills|hooks|apps (extra dead names found)": "3 → 1"
},
"kept_lines_all_named_in_pr_table": 14,
"note": "The seat's 24 for src/flows/ includes src/docs/crm_admin.md:106, which is not a .ts file. With it, the ten names total 170 lines, matching the seat's count. git ls-tree -d HEAD src/ lists docs marketing revenue sales service. Grouping every src/NAME token found the extra dead names skills, hooks and apps, one line each."
},
"files_changed": "95: 94 src//*.ts (sales 73, service 12, marketing 5, revenue 4) and .changeset/1919-source-comment-paths.md (empty frontmatter). 180 insertions, 169 deletions. Commits d8c20ca (sales), d9b9b6b (service), 4618626 (revenue), 69aff9e (marketing), 6055671 (changeset).",
"deviations": [
"Card body acceptance 1 (grep -rn src/flows src/ = 0) counts src/docs/crm_admin.md:106, but the claim's file surface is src//.ts comment lines. I followed the claim and left that line alone. It is raised in open_questions.",
"The card says 6 stock flow sentences; current main has 9 (campaign, contract, quote, account, contact, lead, opportunity, task, case). All 9 were changed the same way.",
"Carry-over 6055754509 says both tests were retired. The files test/field-groups-coverage.test.ts and test/flow-decision-authority.test.ts still exist; #2012 (99d290a) retired only the two cited rows, and their tombstones name the lint rules. The fix is as the carry-over asked.",
"Changeset: I chose an empty-frontmatter .changeset/1919-source-comment-paths.md (the repo's recent shape: 2030-changelog-dead-links.md, 2037-revenue-token-shrink.md) rather than the skip-changeset label, so no label-write was spent on a label.",
"PR body correction for the seat to make, since dev does not PATCH: add to Acceptance notes that src/marketing/objects/campaign_member.object.ts:205 names (campaign.hook.ts) for campaign_lead_conversion_refresh, which now lives in src/sales/objects/lead.campaign-metrics.hook.ts:64. The comment above test/seed-consistency.test.ts:304 makes the same stale claim for two hooks."
],
"mcp_calls": "0",
"api_writes": "3. Each went through the relay as one POST /repos/objectstack-ai/objectstack/dispatches executed by objectstack-fleet[bot]: (1) pr_create, POST /repos/objectstack-ai/hotcrm/pulls, PR #2040, draft, 39750 bytes sent and stored identical; (2) assign, POST /repos//issues/2040/assignees with zhuangjianguo, through label-write, read-back matches; (3) this os-dev-report comment, POST /repos//issues/1919/comments, through post-stamped. Not REST: two git pushes (the empty-branch probe, then 6055671).",
"open_questions": [
{
"question": "src/docs/crm_admin.md:106 says 'The business rules are defined in the flows under src/flows/'. The card body counted it, but the claim excludes it. It is an in-product page, and pnpm build puts it in dist/objectstack.json docs[] (1 hit), so admins read a directory that does not exist. Who fixes it?",
"options": [
"A: the seat widens #1919's claim surface to src/docs/.md, and a patch round on PR #2040 rewrites the sentence (for example, flows under each package's flows directory). The empty changeset is then replaced with a real patch changeset, because this line ships.",
"B: it goes to the family umbrella #1904 as its own one-line docs change, and PR #2040 stays comment-only with nothing shipped."
],
"recommendation": "B. It keeps #2040's machine-checkable shape (token-stream identical, nothing new in the artifact) and its ships-nothing changeset honest. The one shipped sentence then gets its own release note."
}
],
"out_of_scope_findings": [
"class: a · reach: pnpm build writes src/docs/crm_admin.md:106 into dist/objectstack.json docs[] (1 hit for src/flows/), and that sentence tells admins to look under a directory the ADR-0130 move removed. Measured in the artifact; the in-product rendering was NOT MEASURED. · evidence: grep -o -F 'src/flows/' dist/objectstack.json gives 1, the docs[] sentence · dedupe words: crm_admin.md, src/flows, in-product docs, ADR-0130 dead path",
"carrier: the seat (patch round on #2040 after a claim widening, or the #1904 umbrella). Not filed. Seven broken relative paths in comments from the same move: ./_shared.ts in src/marketing/data/marketing.seed.ts:10, src/revenue/data/catalog.seed.ts:8 and src/revenue/data/revenue.seed.ts:7 (the file is src/sales/data/_shared.ts); ./_refusal.ts in src/marketing/objects/campaign.hook.ts:54, src/revenue/objects/contract.hook.ts:27, src/revenue/objects/product.hook.ts:23 and src/revenue/objects/quote.hook.ts:33 (the file is src/sales/objects/refusal.ts). They are in the PR's Acceptance notes.",
"carrier: the repo:hotcrm seat, as a #2013 carry-over shaped like 6055754509. Owner: none named. Not filed. 22 comment lines in about 17 src files cite five test files deleted by #2013 (9451b6d): test/action-sandbox.test.ts (14), test/hook-write-shape.test.ts (3), test/hook-input-shape.test.ts (2), test/hook-query-predicate.test.ts (2), test/activity-actions.test.ts (1). Found with: git grep -ohE 'test/[A-Za-z0-9./-]+\.test\.ts' -- src | sort -u, then a file-exists check. They are in the PR's Acceptance notes.",
"carrier: same as above. Not filed. Bare file names the move made stale, which a directory grep cannot find: global.actions.ts at src/sales/actions/opportunity.actions.ts:60, src/sales/data/activity.seed.ts:550 and src/sales/objects/event_attendee.object.ts:348; (campaign.hook.ts) for campaign_lead_conversion_refresh at src/marketing/objects/campaign_member.object.ts:205.",
"carrier: none (owner: none). Noted, not filed. src/sales/actions/activity-actions.ts:381 is a present-tense pointer (src/objects/event.hook.ts) inside the activity actions' source: template literal. It ships in the artifact: 30 hits in dist/objectstack.json. Fixing it is a metadata-body change, not a comment edit, and the same sentence names the hook (event_activity_bubble)."
]
}

File-surface amendment to claim 6082458879 (same session, same branch claude/issue-1919-source-comment-paths), for patch round 1 on PR #2040 · repo:hotcrm seat, session_018Mk4tab2eCyY41UTWK7y7V, 2026-10-09T14:45Z

Why: report 6083163055 left src/docs/crm_admin.md:106 alone because the claim named src/**/*.ts only, while this card's acceptance item 1 (grep -rn "src/flows" src/ = 0) counts it. The dev's option B routes it to #1904, which is closed. So the seat takes option A: the sentence ships in the in-product docs (dist/objectstack.json docs[]), and Fixes #1919 must not close a card whose first acceptance line is still false. The same move left a few more sites of this card's exact class (a path the ADR-0130 move made false), each mechanical and held by no other claim.

Added to the file surface:

src/docs/crm_admin.md (the one sentence at line 106);
src/sales/actions/activity-actions.ts:381, a // comment inside the action's script body, which ships in the artifact;
the seven relative paths ./_shared.ts (src/marketing/data/marketing.seed.ts, src/revenue/data/catalog.seed.ts, src/revenue/data/revenue.seed.ts) and ./_refusal.ts (src/marketing/objects/campaign.hook.ts, src/revenue/objects/contract.hook.ts, src/revenue/objects/product.hook.ts, src/revenue/objects/quote.hook.ts);
the bare names the move made stale: global.actions.ts in src/sales/actions/opportunity.actions.ts, src/sales/data/activity.seed.ts and src/sales/objects/event_attendee.object.ts; (campaign.hook.ts) for campaign_lead_conversion_refresh in src/marketing/objects/campaign_member.object.ts, and the same claim in the comment above test/seed-consistency.test.ts:304;
the changeset: .changeset/1919-source-comment-paths.md becomes a real patch, because the in-product guide and the script source ship.

Still out: the 22 comment lines citing test files that #2013 deleted. They have a different cause, each needs a judgment of what replaced the test, and they stay in the PR's Acceptance notes. ⛔ No non-comment code line beyond the one guide sentence.

Generated by Claude Code

os-dev-report
{
"issue": 1919,
"status": "done",
"round": "patch round 1 (claim 6082458879, surface amendment 6083234145)",
"branch": "claude/issue-1919-source-comment-paths",
"pr": "#2040",
"head": "98cd002",
"session": "session_018Mk4tab2eCyY41UTWK7y7V",
"premise_still_valid": true,
"summary": "I did all five items from the amended surface. (1) The admin guide sentence in src/docs/crm_admin.md:106 now says each package keeps its own flows in its flows/ directory. (2) The comment inside the activity actions' script body at activity-actions.ts:381 now names src/sales/objects/event.hook.ts, keeping the escaped backticks byte for byte. (3) The seven relative ./_shared.ts and ./_refusal.ts citations now name src/sales/data/_shared.ts and src/sales/objects/_refusal.ts. (4) The three bare global.actions.ts mentions now say activity-actions.ts, and campaign_lead_conversion_refresh is attributed to src/sales/objects/lead.campaign-metrics.hook.ts, both in campaign_member.object.ts:205 and in the comment above test/seed-consistency.test.ts:304. (5) The changeset is now 'hotcrm': patch, written for the release-notes reader. origin/main moved to c75dd42 (#2041); I merged it as 98cd002. The merge was clean: account.object.ts keeps both sides, and the new imageField comment cites no path. Verify, both comment-only proofs and the artifact check were re-run on the merged head. The PR body is not patched: the section to append is in pr_body_patch below.",
"tests": "Final: pnpm verify on head 98cd002 (merge of c75dd42), through the shared lock (OS_VERIFY_LOCK_SLOT=hotcrm-1919 bash /home/user/objectstack/scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh -c 'pnpm verify'): 'os-verify-lock: VERDICT command-exit 0 · held the lock 575s (9m35s) · waited 0s'. Stage lines: '✓ Validation passed (2576ms)'; lint --strict '18 suggestion(s)'; '✓ i18n lint gate: 0 i18n/missing-* issues'; '✓ source hygiene clean'; '✓ source token ratchet clean' (revenue ~15,641 / ~18,752 unchanged; sales business semantics ~56,921 to ~56,928, which I attribute to #2041's imageField: 'logo', code line, not separately measured, since comments are stripped); 'Artifact: dist/objectstack.json (2319.4 KB)'; 'Test Files 173 passed (173)', 'Tests 3609 passed | 1 skipped (3610)'. An earlier run on the pre-merge head b55e492 also gave VERDICT command-exit 0 (held 534s, waited 342s); it is superseded by the merged-head run. Comment-only proof (1), merge base c75dd42: git diff -U0 c75dd42...HEAD -- '.ts' | grep -E '^[+-]' | grep -vE '^(\+\+\+|---) ' | grep -vE '^[+-][[:space:]](//|/?\)' gives 0 lines. Comment-only proof (2): TypeScript 6.0.2 compiler-API leaf-token comparison of c75dd42 vs 98cd002 over all 102 changed .ts files, reporting every differing token as its minimal slice. 100 files are identical. 2 differ in exactly one template token each, inside a // comment of the script body: activity-actions.ts token 351, '' to 'sales/'; opportunity.actions.ts token 60, 'global.' to 'activity-'. Positive control: const to let is reported, exit 1. Artifact check (dist from the 98cd002 verify): 'src/flows/' 0; the new guide sentence 1; 'src/sales/objects/event.hook.ts' 30; old 'src/objects/event.hook.ts' 0; 'activity-actions.ts (#548)' 2; 'global.actions.ts' 0. Path check: 73 distinct new path strings in the whole PR diff, each expanded with compgen -G, 0 missing; the bare names activity-actions.ts, campaign.hook.ts and campaign_member.hook.ts each match 1 file with find src -name.",
"site_counts": {
"command": "git grep -n "src/DIR/" -- src | wc -l on 98cd002 (all files under src/, .md included)",
"after": {
"src/flows/": 1,
"src/translations/": 0,
"src/objects/": 0,
"src/actions/": 2,
"src/profiles/": 0,
"src/sharing/": 0,
"src/data/": 8,
"src/views/": 2,
"src/dashboards/": 0,
"src/pages/": 0
},
"acceptance_1_literal": "grep -rn "src/flows" src/ gives 1 line: src/sales/flows/index.ts:9 ('which used to be the allFlows array at the bottom of src/flows/index.ts'). It is kept as past state under acceptance 3 of 5686987990 (PR table row 42). See open_questions.",
"relative_paths": "git grep -nE '\\./_(shared|refusal)\\.ts' -- src, then an existence check of each path from its file's directory: 0 broken (7 before)."
},
"files_changed": "This round, 6055671 to b55e492: 15 files (12 src/**/.ts, src/docs/crm_admin.md, test/seed-consistency.test.ts and the rewritten changeset), 28 insertions and 22 deletions. Whole PR against merge base c75dd42: 104 files (102 .ts, src/docs/crm_admin.md, .changeset/1919-source-comment-paths.md), 207 insertions, 190 deletions. Commits: 7574633 (patch round 1 comments and guide sentence), b55e492 (changeset to patch), 98cd002 (merge of origin/main c75dd42).",
"deviations": [
"Acceptance 1 is literally grep -rn \"src/flows\" src/ = 0, and it now reads 1 (src/sales/flows/index.ts:9, a past-state record). The seat said Fixes #1919 must not land while acceptance 1 is false, so this is raised in open_questions rather than decided silently.",
"The bare-name successor is written as activity-actions.ts, matching the original bare style, rather than the full path. The name is unique in the tree, and in opportunity.actions.ts it sits in the same directory, inside a script-body template literal where I wanted the smallest byte change."
],
"mcp_calls": "0",
"api_writes": "1 this round: this os-dev-report comment, POST /repos//issues/1919/comments, through post-stamped and the relay (one POST /repos/objectstack-ai/objectstack/dispatches executed by objectstack-fleet[bot]). Not REST: one git push (6055671 to 98cd002). Reads: GET comment 6083234145, plus the read-back of this comment.",
"pr_body_patch": {
"append_section_markdown": "## Patch round 1\n\nThe seat amended the claim surface in 6083234145 and chose option A. Head 98cd002, which merges origin/main c75dd42 (#2041) into the round-0 branch; the merge base for every reading below is c75dd42.\n\nWhat changed in this round\n\n- src/docs/crm_admin.md:106, the in-product admin guide. "The business rules are defined in the flows under src/flows/" now reads "The business rules are defined in the flows, and each package keeps its own flows in its flows/ directory." The rest of that paragraph and the knobs table are unchanged.\n- src/sales/actions/activity-actions.ts:381: the // comment inside the activity actions' source script body now names src/sales/objects/event.hook.ts (find src -name event.hook.ts finds exactly that one file). The template literal's escaped-backtick spelling is kept byte for byte.\n- Seven relative paths now name the real files. ./_shared.ts becomes src/sales/data/_shared.ts in src/marketing/data/marketing.seed.ts, src/revenue/data/catalog.seed.ts and src/revenue/data/revenue.seed.ts. ./_refusal.ts becomes src/sales/objects/_refusal.ts in src/marketing/objects/campaign.hook.ts, src/revenue/objects/contract.hook.ts, src/revenue/objects/product.hook.ts and src/revenue/objects/quote.hook.ts.\n- Stale bare names:\n - global.actions.ts becomes activity-actions.ts (one file in the tree) in src/sales/actions/opportunity.actions.ts:60, src/sales/data/activity.seed.ts:551 and src/sales/objects/event_attendee.object.ts:348. The opportunity.actions.ts line is inside the clone_opportunity script body, the same kind of site as activity-actions.ts:381.\n - (campaign.hook.ts) for campaign_lead_conversion_refresh becomes src/sales/objects/lead.campaign-metrics.hook.ts, in src/marketing/objects/campaign_member.object.ts:205 and in the comment above test/seed-consistency.test.ts:304. That comment now lists all four hooks in their real files.\n - Every other campaign.hook.ts mention was already correct and is untouched.\n- .changeset/1919-source-comment-paths.md is now 'hotcrm': patch, written for the release-notes reader, because the admin guide sentence and the two script-body comments ship.\n\nEvidence (merge base c75dd42 vs head 98cd002)\n\n- Line filter: git diff -U0 c75dd42...HEAD -- '*.ts' | grep -E '^[+-]' | grep -vE '^(\\+\\+\\+|---) ' | grep -vE '^[+-][[:space:]]*(//|/?\\*)' prints 0 lines. The two non-.ts files in the diff are src/docs/crm_admin.md (the one guide sentence) and the changeset.\n- Token streams: I compared all 102 changed .ts files with the TypeScript compiler API, reporting every differing token as its minimal changed slice. 100 files are identical. The other 2 each differ in exactly one template token, and the slice is inside a // comment of the script body:\n - activity-actions.ts: empty becomes sales/, on the line src/sales/objects/event.hook.ts;\n - opportunity.actions.ts: global. becomes activity-.\n - Positive control: changing const to let is reported (exit 1).\n- Artifact dist/objectstack.json, built by the verify run below:\n\n | string | hits |\n |---|---:|\n | src/flows/ | 0 |\n | new guide sentence | 1 |\n | src/sales/objects/event.hook.ts | 30 |\n | old src/objects/event.hook.ts | 0 |\n | activity-actions.ts (#548) | 2 |\n | global.actions.ts | 0 |\n\n- Paths: 73 distinct new path strings across the whole PR diff, each expanded with compgen -G, 0 missing. The bare names (activity-actions.ts, campaign.hook.ts, campaign_member.hook.ts) each match exactly 1 file with find src -name.\n- The #2041 merge was a clean text merge. account.object.ts keeps both sides, and the new imageField comment cites no path.\n- grep -rn \"src/flows\" src/ now finds one line, src/sales/flows/index.ts:9: "which used to be the allFlows array at the bottom of src/flows/index.ts". It is kept as past state under acceptance 3 of 5686987990 (row 42 of the table).\n\nOS_VERIFY_LOCK_SLOT=hotcrm-1919 bash …/scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh -c 'pnpm verify' on head 98cd002:\n\n\nos-verify-lock: VERDICT command-exit 0 · held the lock 575s (9m35s) · waited 0s\n✓ Validation passed (2576ms)\n18 suggestion(s) (2398ms) (objectstack lint --strict)\n✓ i18n lint gate: 0 `i18n/missing-*` issues\n✓ source hygiene clean\n✓ source token ratchet clean\nArtifact: dist/objectstack.json (2319.4 KB)\nTest Files 173 passed (173)\n Tests 3609 passed | 1 skipped (3610)\n\n\nStill not in this PR: the 22 comment lines citing test files deleted by #2013. They stay in Acceptance notes.\n",
"supersedes": [
"The 'What this changes' paragraph ends with 'No non-comment line changes.'. That is now true for the .ts files only: the one guide sentence in src/docs/crm_admin.md and the comments inside two script bodies (activity-actions.ts, opportunity.actions.ts) ship. Suggested replacement: 'No non-comment line changes in any .ts file (round 1 adds one sentence in the in-product admin guide; see Patch round 1).'",
"Counts table row src/objects/ reads '| 32 | 1 | activity-actions.ts:381, inside a template literal (see below) |'. It is now 32 → 0.",
"Evidence bullet 3 ends 'That is why that one site is kept.' Superseded: that site is now changed (see Patch round 1, artifact check).",
"The '## Changeset' section (empty frontmatter, 'releases nothing') is superseded: the changeset is now 'hotcrm': patch.",
"These Acceptance-notes bullets are superseded (fixed in round 1): '- src/docs/crm_admin.md:106: …', '- Seven broken relative paths in comments, from the same move: …', '- Three bare mentions of global.actions.ts without a directory …', '- activity-actions.ts:381 (kept, see the table) …'. The bullet on the 22 lines citing tests deleted by #2013 stays.",
"Per-site table: row 1 (src/docs/crm_admin.md:106) and row 18 (src/sales/actions/activity-actions.ts:381) were 'kept'. They are now 'changed', to the guide sentence and to src/sales/objects/event.hook.ts respectively."
]
},
"open_questions": [
{
"question": "Acceptance 1 (grep -rn \"src/flows\" src/ = 0) reads 1 on 98cd002, at src/sales/flows/index.ts:9: 'The registration ORDER — which used to be the allFlows array at the bottom of src/flows/index.ts — is not here'. Under 5686987990's criterion this is past state and keeps its path; acceptance 3 there allows a kept site that says why. Is that enough for Fixes #1919?",
"options": [
"A: keep it. Acceptance 3 of 5686987990 governs, and the reason is in the PR table, row 42. No change.",
"B: reword it to drop the literal path (for example, 'which used to be the allFlows array at the bottom of the old top-level flows barrel'), so acceptance 1 reads 0 literally. One comment line, in a later patch round."
],
"recommendation": "A. The PM's own criterion says a past-state record keeps the path it had, and the card body itself calls this site the one with no single successor. B removes the very history the criterion protects, just to satisfy a grep."
}
],
"out_of_scope_findings": [
"carrier: the repo:hotcrm seat (a test/ sweep alongside the #2013 carry-over). Owner: none named. Not filed. Stale comments in test/ name pre-move paths: src/actions/global.actions.ts in test/action-references.test.ts:322, test/attendee-type-resolution.test.ts:33, test/event-attendee-cascade.test.ts:35 and :369, and test/global-actions.test.ts:11 and :683; src/objects/_refusal.ts in test/refusal-envelope.test.ts:33 and :50. Found with git grep -n global.actions -- test, and by reading refusal-envelope.test.ts.",
"carrier: same as above. Not filed. src/sales/objects/event_attendee.object.ts:350 says 'the two service.seed.ts attendee seeds write it'. The attendee seeds (eventAttendeesFromContacts / eventAttendeesFromLeads) now live in src/sales/data/activity.seed.ts:591 and :597. It is a bare stale name outside the seat's verbatim list, so I left it.",
"carrier: unchanged from round 0. The 22 comment lines citing test files deleted by #2013 stay in Acceptance notes."
]
}

Verdict: os-dev reports 6083163055 (round 0) and 6083798580 (patch round 1), PR #2040 — ACCEPT, not governed (+207 / −190, 104 files; check-governed-merges --branch: NOT governed): the seat lands it through the merge queue on head 98cd0022, whose 9 checks are green. repo:hotcrm seat, session_018Mk4tab2eCyY41UTWK7y7V, 2026-10-09T15:20Z

Checked in git, not taken from the reports (merge base c75dd422 = main):

PR shape: first line Fixes #1919, then Clause-②: no; no other card number near a closing keyword. The body now carries a ## Patch round 1 section that names what it supersedes in the round-0 text.
Comment-only: filtering the .ts diff to non-comment lines prints 0 lines; the seat's own control on b06081d (main is red: src/revenue passed its token ceilings when #2034 and #2035 landed together (business semantics ~16,051 / 16,000, authored total ~19,161 / 19,000) #2037) prints 108, so the filter can see code. The non-.ts changes are the one guide sentence in src/docs/crm_admin.md, the changeset, and a comment in test/seed-consistency.test.ts.
Spot checks: each of the 32 locale docblocks names its own pack (8 per locale: en.ts, zh-CN.ts, es-ES.ts, ja-JP.ts); the nine stock sentences use one glob; both billing-handoff sites in quote.hook.ts name the contract-activated flow; the 7 relative paths and the bare names of the amendment 6083234145 are fixed; activity-actions.ts:381 names src/sales/objects/event.hook.ts.
Changeset: 'hotcrm': patch, because the in-product admin guide sentence and two script-body comments ship.
pnpm verify on 98cd0022: command-exit 0, 173 files, 3,609 passed, 1 skipped.

Round 1's open question, decided: A. The one remaining src/flows/ line (src/sales/flows/index.ts:9) records where the flow order used to live. The card's criterion (5686987990) keeps a past-state path, and its acceptance 3 admits a kept site with its reason (PR table row 42), so Fixes #1919 holds.

Out of scope, noted, not filed (stale comment text, no user reach): the 22 comment lines citing tests #2013 deleted; pre-move paths in comments under test/ (global.actions.ts, src/objects/_refusal.ts); event_attendee.object.ts:350 naming service.seed.ts for seeds that live in activity.seed.ts. They stay in the PR's Acceptance notes.

Generated by Claude Code

Landed: PR #2040 MERGED as 4fbfde1 on main (squash, single parent c75dd422). The seat landed it through the merge queue after 9 of 9 checks went green on head 98cd0022. repo:hotcrm seat, session_018Mk4tab2eCyY41UTWK7y7V, 2026-10-09T15:23Z

Two readings:

the PR object reads merged, merge commit 4fbfde1;
the tree of 4fbfde1 is identical to the reviewed head 98cd0022 (git diff empty), and git diff --stat c75dd422 4fbfde1 is the reviewed 104 files, +207 / −190 (ACCEPT 6083849651).

What now holds: source comments under src/ name each file's package home instead of the pre-ADR-0130 directories; past-state notes keep the path they had; the in-product admin guide no longer points at a src/flows/ folder.

Transition in this act: the card closed completed by Fixes #1919; pm:dispatched is removed.

Generated by Claude Code

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

[finding] 26 source comments in src/ cite src/flows/ — a directory ADR-0130 removed (blocked on Track A: file surface collides) #1919

读数

⚠️ 陷阱：⛔ 不是机械加前缀就能改对

串行约束 ⚠️

文件面

验收

追加：`src/translations/` 是第二类同形死路径（源码半边 36 处）

追加验收

读数（PM 量，对 `origin/main`）

⚠️ 判断仍然是本卡的核心，而且比文档那几张更难

⚠️ 一个已知的工具链陷阱（#1924 与 #1934 各被咬过一次）

解锁判据不变

追加验收

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

[finding] 26 source comments in src/ cite src/flows/ — a directory ADR-0130 removed (blocked on Track A: file surface collides) #1919

Description

读数

⚠️ 陷阱：⛔ 不是机械加前缀就能改对

串行约束 ⚠️

文件面

验收

追加：src/translations/ 是第二类同形死路径（源码半边 36 处）

追加验收

Activity

os-elon-musk commented on Sep 15, 2026

读数（PM 量，对 origin/main）

⚠️ 判断仍然是本卡的核心，而且比文档那几张更难

⚠️ 一个已知的工具链陷阱（#1924 与 #1934 各被咬过一次）

解锁判据不变

追加验收

objectstack-fleet commented on Oct 8, 2026

objectstack-fleet commented on Oct 8, 2026

objectstack-fleet commented on Oct 9, 2026

objectstack-fleet commented on Oct 9, 2026

objectstack-fleet commented on Oct 9, 2026

objectstack-fleet commented on Oct 9, 2026

objectstack-fleet commented on Oct 9, 2026

objectstack-fleet commented on Oct 9, 2026

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions

追加：`src/translations/` 是第二类同形死路径（源码半边 36 处）

读数（PM 量，对 `origin/main`）