Infer declarations are allowed in generic constraints, but do not infer generic constraint types

[lazytype]

TypeScript Version: 4.0.2

Search Terms: generic constraint, extends infer

Code

type InferGenericConstraint<Fn> = 
    Fn extends <T extends infer Constraint>(arg: T) => any
        ? Constraint
        : never;

type GenericFunctionExample = <T extends number>(arg: T) => void;

type InferredConstraint = InferGenericConstraint<GenericFunctionExample>;

Expected behavior:

• Preferred: InferredConstraint is number.
• Alternative: infer declaration is disallowed within a generic constraint clause.

Actual behavior: InferredConstraint is never

Playground Link: https://tsplay.dev/gWoYlN

Related Issues: #1213

[krryan]

In version 4.2.0-dev.20201115, InferredConstraint is unknown rather than never. I tried a large number of variations, but none of them can work around the fundamental fact that the type inferred for the constraint just isn’t right.

Things I tried:

type ConstraintOf<Fn extends <S>(arg: S) => any> = Fn extends <S extends infer Constraint>(arg: S) => any
  ? Constraint
  : never;

type ConstraintOf<Fn extends <S extends unknown>(arg: S) => any> = Fn extends <S extends infer Constraint>(arg: S) => any
  ? Constraint
  : never;

type ConstraintOf<Fn extends <S extends Constraint, Constraint>(arg: S) => any> = Fn extends <S extends infer Constraint>(arg: S) => any
  ? Constraint
  : never;

In every case, ConstraintOf<<S extends { foo: 'bar' }>(arg: S): void> evaluates to unknown.

[krryan]

Well, I found a workaround.

type ConstraintOf<Fn extends <S extends any>(arg: S) => any> = Fn extends (arg: infer Arg) => any ? Arg : never;

Now ConstraintOf<<T extends number>(arg: T) => void> evaluates to number. So that solves the problem that @lazytype was working on.

The bug should stay open, though, because as far as I can tell, the other variations on this idea should have worked, too, and it’s kind of madness that this one worked and those didn’t. If anything, this version makes way less sense. What’s occurring here is that trying to test Fn against (arg: infer Arg) => any seems to “fix” S as the broadest possible value, here number, before moving on—and so the Arg has that value. This works, but is pretty weird and counter-intuitive.

[uriva]

This cost me some hours today, +1