FBW scans for new networks only on 5 GHz radios, warn the user or add also 2.4 GHz radios

FBW function to join an existing network does not work with 2.4 GHz only devices.
It will make the user wait and then return just a "no network found" message.

This is likely the cause of #589

The related code is:

lime-packages/packages/first-boot-wizard/files/usr/lib/lua/firstbootwizard.lua

Lines 63 to 71 in 3235c25

    
           local radios_5ghz = ft.filter(wireless.is5Ghz,  radios) 
        
           -- Convert radios to phys (get a list of phys from radio devices) 
        
           local phys = ft.map(utils.extract_phys_from_radios, radios_5ghz) 
        
           -- Scan networks in phys and format result 
        
           local networks = ft.map( 
        
               function(phy) 
        
                   local nets = iwinfo.nl80211.scanlist(phy) 
        
                   return ft.map(utils.add_prop("phy_idx", utils.phy_to_idx(phy)), nets) 
        
               end, phys)

A possible improvement would be to use 2.4 GHz radios only once the 5 GHz radios didn't find anything.

Maybe we can filter out radios that do not have a mesh interface (so if 2.4GHz radios do not have a mesh interfaces then they are not used), what do you think?

That would do!

I tested this yesterday with LROS 1.5, only using 2.4. One network found the other. Might be solved.

I tested this yesterday with LROS 1.5, only using 2.4. One network found the other. Might be solved.

The causing code didn't change, it should not be fixed...
What do you mean with "only using 2.4"?

@selankon

@selankon let's continue here the discussion started on libremesh/lime-app#324 (comment) :
there are places in firstbootwizard.lua where the 5 GHz interfaces get listed, like here:

lime-packages/packages/first-boot-wizard/files/usr/lib/lua/firstbootwizard.lua

Line 85 in be6319b

local radios_5ghz = ft.filter(wireless.is5Ghz, radios)

we could add a check and in case this list is empty do something else with the available interfaces.

We should address the following cases:

at least one 5 GHz and one 2.4 GHz (e.g. LibreRouter, TP-Link WDR3600...)
no interface at 2.4 GHz (e.g. Ubiquiti NanoStation M5, TP-Link CPE 510)
no interface at 5 GHz (e.g. Ubiquiti NanoStation M2, TP-Link CPE 210, or the router mentioned here Cannot scan the existing network for the first time using the wizard lime-app#324 (comment))

@selankon

This is important if we want to suggest FBW to non-LibreRouter users.
@selankon @spiccinini do you think that we can fix this before the 2020.2 release?

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

FBW scans for new networks only on 5 GHz radios, warn the user or add also 2.4 GHz radios #661

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

	local radios_5ghz = ft.filter(wireless.is5Ghz, radios)
	-- Convert radios to phys (get a list of phys from radio devices)
	local phys = ft.map(utils.extract_phys_from_radios, radios_5ghz)
	-- Scan networks in phys and format result
	local networks = ft.map(
	function(phy)
	local nets = iwinfo.nl80211.scanlist(phy)
	return ft.map(utils.add_prop("phy_idx", utils.phy_to_idx(phy)), nets)
	end, phys)

FBW scans for new networks only on 5 GHz radios, warn the user or add also 2.4 GHz radios #661

Description

Activity

spiccinini commented on Jun 4, 2020

ilario commented on Jun 4, 2020

luandro commented on Mar 21, 2022

ilario commented on Mar 22, 2022

ilario commented on Dec 16, 2022

ilario commented on Feb 28, 2023

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions