updating with new JEP process #52
Conversation
choldgraf
force-pushed
the
new-jep-process
branch
from
7d4a027
to
51e83ba
Compare
| | | ||
| +--------------+ +-----------+ +-----+-----+ +-------------+ +-----------+ | ||
| | | | | | | | | | | | ||
| | pre-proposal +---> submitted +--------------> RFC/FCP +-------------> in progress +---> completed | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Nit: Perhaos make this RFC (Request for Comments) for people who might be unfamiliar with the term.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
+1 from me, OK if I leave out the "FCP" in that case, to save space?
| ``` | ||
| +-----------+ | ||
| | | | ||
| +-----------+ | withdrawn | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Do we have an arrow that takes you from one (or more) of the steps to withdrawn?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
yeah I wondered about this too - I wasn't sure how to do this without having a bunch of arrows cluttering up the viz. Maybe we can have a "floating arrow" that doesn't come directly from one box to make it clear that at any point it can move into "withdrawn"?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Floating arrow works. Or and endnote in the document that lets people know you can move from any state to withdrawn. Endnote seems like it would be the least obtrusive and most informative.
choldgraf
force-pushed
the
new-jep-process
branch
from
ae32ef8
to
3d54989
Compare
|
OK, just added a commit that addresses both of your comments. For the "withdrawn" section, I added a short note in the diagram, as well as note at the beginning of the "phases" section of the document |
|
Sounds good -- thanks. |
jupyter-enhancement-proposal-guidelines/jupyter-enhancement-proposal-guidelines.md
Show resolved
Hide resolved
choldgraf
force-pushed
the
new-jep-process
branch
from
6840487
to
e32a811
Compare
|
Hey all - comments addressed. Ready to merge from my perspective (note this should be seen as one PR implementing JEP #29 , and more can follow if there are other things to improve), or happy to address more comments! |
|
wohoo! thanks all for your comments |
This is one step towards implementing the meta-JEP from #29
It does the following:
Happy to take comments or suggestions!