Skip to content

dvc: provide granularity for commands that could target specific tracked files #2458

Closed

Description

This can be seen as revisiting feature request #1026

UPDATE: Please scroll down to #2458 (comment) for most recent, summarized requirement.
Here is the original context also (still relevant):


There's different scenarios in which being able to manipulate files granularly independently of how they were committed/pushed to DVC could be useful. The problem with using dvc add -R now is that it can generate lots of .dvc files, but what if a directory could be added without -R (producing a single DVC-file) and yet other commands (lock, update, get, etc) could be applied to individual files inside the added directory tree?

Example (from iterative/dataset-registry@7476a85)

Project 1:

$ tree
.
└── tutorial
    └── nlp
        ├── Posts.xml.zip
        └── pipeline.zip
$ dvc add tutorial
...
$ dvc push
...

Project 2:

$ dvc import {project-1-url} tutorial/nlp/pipeline.zip
...
$ tree
.
├── tutorial
│   └── nlp
│       └── pipeline.zip
└── tutorial.dvc

Not sure about where the .dvc would have to be placed in this example though.

And also this is how Git works, I believe. Files are tracked individually (in fact it doesn't even recognize empty dirs).

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    feature requestRequesting a new featurep1-importantImportant, aka current backlog of things to doproduct: VSCodeIntegration with VSCode extension

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions