Skip to content

[Bug][VMI Layout] group4 ui16 -> ui32 width-changing vinterpret_cast fails in packed UE8M0 exponent packing #1586

Description

@Zhendong404

Summary

在 packed UE8M0 scale-factor packing 中,vcmax(group=4) 的结果是 grouped 4xui16,随后需要做 width-changing vinterpret_cast:

4xui16  ->  2xui32

目的是把两个 8-bit exponent 拼成一个 16-bit packed word,再 vcvt 回 4xui16 写入 SF UB。

当前 PTOAS 报 layout contract 失败:width-changing bitcast 需要 source 为 contiguous,但 source 从 group reduce 继承的是:

num_groups = 4, slots = 1

ensure_layout 没有 grouped -> contiguous 的 materialization 规则,因此编译失败。

Minimal PTODSL shape

mask128 = pto.vmi.create_mask(128, size=128)
mask4 = pto.vmi.create_mask(1, size=4, group=4)

scale4 = pto.vmi.vcmax(amax128, mask128, group=4)

# same-width reinterpret: group layout is preserved
bits = pto.vmi.vinterpret_cast(scale4, to_dtype=pto.ui32)

# group layout is carried through the elementwise/integer conversion
exp16 = pto.vmi.vcvt(
    pto.vmi.vshrs(bits, 23, mask4),
    to_dtype=pto.ui16,
    saturate="NOSAT",
)

# width-changing reinterpret: 4xui16 -> 2xui32
packed32 = pto.vmi.vshrs(
    pto.vmi.vinterpret_cast(exp16, to_dtype=pto.ui32),
    8,
    pto.vmi.create_mask(2, size=2),
)
packed16 = pto.vmi.vcvt(packed32, to_dtype=pto.ui16, saturate="NOSAT")

The failing operation is the second vinterpret_cast:

%packed32 = pto.vmi.vinterpret_cast %exp16
    : !pto.vmi.vreg<4xui16, #pto.vmi.layout<num_groups = 4, slots = 1>>
   -> !pto.vmi.vreg<2xui32>

Actual error

VMI-LAYOUT-CONTRACT: pto.vmi.bitcast operand #0 has type
!pto.vmi.vreg<4xui16, #pto.vmi.layout<num_groups = 4, slots = 1>>
but requires
!pto.vmi.vreg<4xui16, #pto.vmi.layout<contiguous>>;
pto.vmi.ensure_layout has no registered materialization support:
source/result layouts do not match a supported ensure_layout table row

Environment

  • PTOAS 0.66 (v0.66-8-gb729c955c)
  • TileKernels per_block_cast VMI path
  • Reduce/bitcast shape: 128xf32 -> vcmax(group=4) -> 4xf32 -> ... -> 4xui16 -> 2xui32

Expected behavior

Allow a grouped 4xui16 value to feed a width-changing vinterpret_cast to 2xui32, either by:

  1. adding a legal num_groups=4, slots=1 -> contiguous materialization path, or
  2. recognizing this specific width-changing bitcast as layout-preserving where physically valid.

The former is the direct fix; the latter may be a useful optimization if the grouped physical layout already matches the required byte layout.

Workaround

Avoiding the width-changing vinterpret_cast and packing the two exponents entirely in the original 16-bit domain. This is not implemented in the kernel because it changes the VMI dataflow and may affect the desired ASC-aligned form.

Related issues

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions