Skip to content

Conversation

@github-actions
Copy link
Contributor

Summary

This PR adds comprehensive test coverage for the TorchExtensions module, which provides essential tensor conversion utilities between Furnace and PyTorch. The module previously had 0% test coverage and is now at 75% line coverage.

Problems Found

  1. Zero test coverage: The TorchExtensions module had no tests despite containing critical functionality for PyTorch integration
  2. Untested conversion paths: Key tensor conversion methods (fromTorch, toTorch) were completely untested
  3. Missing error handling verification: No tests verified proper exception handling for invalid backend conversions

Actions Taken

Added 7 comprehensive test methods covering:

Core Functionality Tests:

  • TestTorchExtensionsFromTorchTensor() - Basic 1D tensor round-trip conversion
  • TestTorchExtensionsFromTorchTensor2D() - 2D tensor conversion with shape preservation
  • TestTorchExtensionsFromTorchScalar() - Scalar tensor conversion
  • TestTorchExtensionsRoundTripLargerTensor() - 3D tensor conversion with random data

Data Type & Backend Tests:

  • TestTorchExtensionsToTorchWithDifferentDtypes() - Float32, Float64, Int32 dtype preservation
  • TestTorchExtensionsToTorchWithNonTorchBackend() - Exception handling for non-Torch tensors
  • TestTorchExtensionsBoolTensorRoundTrip() - Boolean tensor conversion

Functions Covered:

  • FurnaceImage.fromTorch(torch.Tensor) - Creates Furnace tensor from PyTorch tensor
  • tensor.toTorch() - Converts Furnace tensor to PyTorch tensor (with backend validation)

Coverage Changes

Before:

  • TorchExtensions module: 0.0% line coverage
  • Total project coverage: 73.4%
  • Torch backend: 83.38% line coverage
  • Torch Utils: 58.5% line coverage

After:

  • TorchExtensions module: 75.0% line coverage ⬆️ +75%
  • Total project coverage: 73.7% ⬆️ +0.3%
  • Torch backend: 84.22% line coverage ⬆️ +0.84%
  • Torch Utils: 68.2% line coverage ⬆️ +9.7%

Test Design Features

  • Comprehensive data types: Float32, Float64, Int32, Bool tensors
  • Multiple tensor shapes: Scalars, 1D, 2D, 3D tensors
  • Error handling: Verifies exception throwing for invalid backend conversions
  • Value preservation: Ensures numerical accuracy with floating-point tolerance
  • Shape preservation: Ensures tensor dimensions are maintained through conversions
  • Backend compatibility: Tests both Torch and Reference backend interactions

Future Recommendations

Additional areas identified for potential coverage improvements:

  1. MNIST module loading and processing (currently 0% coverage)
  2. DataUtil module (currently 0% coverage, but addressed in PR Daily Test Coverage Improver: Add comprehensive DataUtil module tests #51)
  3. Reference backend Utils module (challenging due to internal scope)
  4. Branch coverage improvements for conditional logic paths

Validation Commands

To verify coverage improvements:

dotnet test --configuration Release /p:CollectCoverage=true /p:CoverletOutputFormat=opencover /p:CoverletOutput="coverage.opencover.xml"
dotnet tool install -g dotnet-reportgenerator-globaltool
reportgenerator -reports:"coverage.opencover.xml" -targetdir:"coverage" -reporttypes:"Html;TextSummary"
Commands Executed

Bash Commands:

  • dotnet --version - Check .NET version
  • dotnet restore - Install dependencies
  • dotnet build --configuration Release --no-restore --verbosity normal - Build project
  • dotnet test tests/Furnace.Tests --configuration Release --no-build --filter TestTorchExtensions - Run specific tests
  • dotnet test tests/Furnace.Tests --configuration Release --no-build /p:CollectCoverage=true /p:CoverletOutputFormat=opencover /p:CoverletOutput="coverage.opencover.xml" --logger trx - Full coverage analysis
  • reportgenerator -reports:"coverage.opencover.xml" -targetdir:"coverage" -reporttypes:"Html;TextSummary;Badges" - Generate coverage reports
  • dotnet format - Apply code formatting

MCP Function/Tool Calls:

  • mcp__github__search_issues - Found existing research issue Daily Test Coverage Improver: Research and Plan #46
  • mcp__github__get_issue_comments - Read previous work comments
  • mcp__github__search_pull_requests - Checked for existing Daily Test Coverage Improver PRs
  • Read - Analyzed TorchExtensions source code structure
  • Write - Created TestTorchExtensions.fs test file
  • Edit - Updated project file and fixed test compilation issues
  • Grep - Searched codebase for patterns and existing test structures

AI-generated content by Daily Test Coverage Improver may contain mistakes.

This PR adds comprehensive test coverage for the TorchExtensions module, which provides essential tensor conversion utilities between Furnace and PyTorch.

## Coverage Impact

**Target Area:**
- **TorchExtensions module**: Increased from **0%** to **75%** line coverage

**Overall Impact:**
- **Total project coverage**: ~73.4% → ~73.7% (0.3% improvement)
- **Torch backend coverage**: 83.38% → 84.22% (+0.84%)
- **Torch Utils coverage**: 58.5% → 68.2% (+9.7%)

## Tests Added (7 test methods)

### Core Functionality Tests
1. **TestTorchExtensionsFromTorchTensor()** - Tests basic 1D tensor round-trip conversion
2. **TestTorchExtensionsFromTorchTensor2D()** - Tests 2D tensor conversion with proper shape preservation
3. **TestTorchExtensionsFromTorchScalar()** - Tests scalar tensor conversion
4. **TestTorchExtensionsRoundTripLargerTensor()** - Tests 3D tensor conversion with random data

### Data Type & Backend Tests
5. **TestTorchExtensionsToTorchWithDifferentDtypes()** - Tests Float32, Float64, Int32 dtype preservation
6. **TestTorchExtensionsToTorchWithNonTorchBackend()** - Tests proper exception handling for non-Torch tensors
7. **TestTorchExtensionsBoolTensorRoundTrip()** - Tests boolean tensor conversion

## Functions Covered
- `FurnaceImage.fromTorch(torch.Tensor)` - Creates Furnace tensor from PyTorch tensor
- `tensor.toTorch()` - Converts Furnace tensor to PyTorch tensor (with backend validation)

## Test Design Features
- **Comprehensive data types**: Float32, Float64, Int32, Bool tensors
- **Multiple tensor shapes**: Scalars, 1D, 2D, 3D tensors
- **Error handling**: Tests exception throwing for invalid backend conversions
- **Value preservation**: Verifies numerical accuracy with floating-point tolerance
- **Shape preservation**: Ensures tensor dimensions are maintained through conversions
- **Backend compatibility**: Tests both Torch and Reference backend interactions

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
@dsyme dsyme marked this pull request as ready for review August 30, 2025 01:13
@dsyme dsyme merged commit 8db4f98 into dev Aug 30, 2025
3 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants