Skip to content

Build: NamingConventionsCheck's defaults are from a different era #33524

Closed
@nik9000

Description

@nik9000

NamingConventionsCheck defaults to considering all subclasses of ESIntegTestCase to be integration tests and doesn't know about ESRestTestCase at all. This is the correct configuration for some parts of our code base, but in the majority of our code base ESIntegTestCase subclasses are treated as unit tests and ESRestTestCase subclasses are the integration tests. It'd be more correct to default the integration test class to ESRestTestCase and override it to ESIntegTestCase in some subprojects like server.

I'm not making a value judgement on whether ESIntegTestCase subclasses should be considered integration tests, unit tests, or internal cluster tests. This is more an observation about how the classes are set up now. If we decide to shift things around at a later time then we can update the check again.

I think an optimal solution to this problem is one that entirely removes the --skip-integ-tests-in-disguise flag.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

:Delivery/BuildBuild or test infrastructureTeam:DeliveryMeta label for Delivery team

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions