Skip to content

Conversation

@IanMayo
Copy link
Member

@IanMayo IanMayo commented Feb 10, 2026

Summary

Add comprehensive specification and design documentation for feature 075-branching, which enables analysts to create independent plot branches from any point in the analysis log history. This includes the feature specification, data model, research findings, implementation plan, and TypeScript contract definitions.

Key Changes

  • spec.md: Complete feature specification with user scenarios (P1-P3), functional and non-functional requirements, acceptance criteria, and edge cases for branching from log entries, snapshot boundaries, and nested branches
  • data-model.md: Entity relationship diagram and detailed schema for BranchOrigin, BranchRecord, FileProvEntry, and SystemRecordProperties with state transition examples
  • research.md: Phase 0 research addressing six key questions: STAC Item storage strategy, state reconstruction from current segment vs. snapshots, two-way link maintenance, service architecture, and branch identifier format
  • plan.md: Implementation roadmap with constitution check, project structure, phase breakdown, and success metrics
  • quickstart.md: Step-by-step implementation guide with code examples for adding BranchOrigin type, extending LinkML schema, implementing branch service, and wiring into existing Log Service
  • contracts/branch-service.ts: TypeScript interface definitions for BranchService, BranchServiceDeps, and pure helper functions (TrimProvenanceToEntry, CreateBranchRecord, CreateBranchOrigin, etc.)
  • contracts/branch-types.ts: Shared type definitions including BranchOrigin, BranchFromOptions, BranchResult, BranchPointLocation, and error codes
  • checklists/requirements.md: Specification quality validation checklist confirming all mandatory sections and requirements are complete
  • media/: Planning post and LinkedIn snippet for stakeholder communication

Notable Implementation Details

  • Extends existing dependency injection pattern from feat(017): add specification for VS Code hide activities #71 (Log Service) and feat(017): hide non-essential VS Code activities on extension activation #74 (Snapshot Service)
  • Uses deep-copy + trim-provenance approach for current-segment branches (avoids tool replay complexity)
  • Limits pre-snapshot branching to snapshot boundaries; arbitrary pre-snapshot entries deferred to Phase 6 (replay engine)
  • Maintains two-way links via BranchRecord (source side) and BranchOrigin (branch side) in system records
  • Branch identifiers use format branch-{8-char-uuid-suffix} for uniqueness and filesystem safety
  • Relative paths for branch asset references enable catalog portability
  • All operations are offline-capable with explicit error handling for missing snapshots or failed writes

Specification Status

All mandatory sections completed with no [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers. Constitution check passes all 11 articles. Ready for implementation planning.

https://claude.ai/code/session_01MvTioWVxqxubx6dVEK1wvH

Define the user-facing requirements for creating alternative analysis
paths by branching from any point in a plot's Log history (SRD P5).

https://claude.ai/code/session_01MvTioWVxqxubx6dVEK1wvH
Phase 0 research, data model, API contracts, quickstart guide,
and media content for the branching feature (SRD P5, E02 Phase 5).

Key decisions:
- Branches as independent STAC Items (not source assets)
- Deep-copy + provenance trim (no tool replay for current segment)
- Pre-snapshot branching limited to snapshot boundaries initially
- Two-way links via system record BranchRecord/BranchOrigin

https://claude.ai/code/session_01MvTioWVxqxubx6dVEK1wvH
51 tasks across 6 phases: setup, foundation (pure helpers),
US1 (branch from current segment - MVP), US2 (navigation API),
US3 (snapshot-boundary branching), and polish with evidence.

https://claude.ai/code/session_01MvTioWVxqxubx6dVEK1wvH
- Add BranchOrigin, BranchResult, BranchServiceDeps types (T001-T004)
- Create branchService.ts with factory pattern (T005)
- Implement pure helpers: findEntryInFeatures, trimProvenanceToEntry,
  createBranchRecord, createBranchOrigin, createBranchProvEntry (T006-T010)
- Implement branchFrom() for current-segment branches (T020-T022)
- Implement locateBranchPoint() with snapshot chain walk (T021, T040)
- Implement getBranches() and getBranchOrigin() navigation (T033-T034)
- Handle snapshot-boundary branches and REPLAY_NOT_AVAILABLE (T041-T042)
- 33 unit tests covering all user stories (T011-T019, T028-T032, T036-T039, T043)
- Extend LinkML schema with BranchOrigin class (T025)
- Add branched-system-record.json golden fixture (T024)
- Update existing fixtures with branchOrigin: null field

https://claude.ai/code/session_01MvTioWVxqxubx6dVEK1wvH
- sample-branch-geojson.json: example branch plot with BranchOrigin
- branch-creation-flow.md: step-by-step branch creation walkthrough
- shipped-post.md: blog post celebrating feature completion
- linkedin-shipped.md: LinkedIn summary for shipped feature
- tasks.md: mark all 50 tasks (T001-T050) as completed

https://claude.ai/code/session_01MvTioWVxqxubx6dVEK1wvH
- logService.test: branchFrom stub now references BranchService, not "not implemented"
- snapshotHelpers.test: createSystemRecord now includes branchOrigin: null

https://claude.ai/code/session_01MvTioWVxqxubx6dVEK1wvH
@IanMayo IanMayo merged commit 285320a into main Feb 10, 2026
5 checks passed
@IanMayo IanMayo deleted the claude/speckit-branching-logic-tGM5I branch February 10, 2026 22:22
IanMayo pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Feb 11, 2026
Cross-referenced 20 merged PRs from the last 72 hours with backlog
items. Verified completion via task checklists and evidence artifacts.

Newly completed (all tasks done, evidence present, PRs merged):
- #70 PROV schema foundation (PR #205/#206)
- #71 Log Recording service (PR #207)
- #72 Log Panel (PR #211)
- #73 Undo/redo split (PR #210)
- #74 Snapshots (PR #209)
- #75 Branching (PR #215)
- #77 Fix VS Code extension bugs (PR #217)
- #77 STAC File Tree Component (PR #217)

Also: reordered active items by status priority (implementing >
specified > approved > proposed), then by total score descending.
Removed 7 duplicate completed entries at bottom of table.

https://claude.ai/code/session_013y5hsr6RyeCaAFbegJG2W9
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants