Deduplicate - Musical transpose

[hobovsky]

From #39

1. Musical Transposer - Chromatic

• 7 kyu
• Input is a single note, possibly a sharp.
• Satisfaction: 91% with 176 solutions
• No pending issues
• C# only
• Published: Sep 16, 2017
• Author last seen: Dec 2024

2. Transposing a song

• 7 kyu
• Input is a sequence of notes, possible sharps and flats.
• Satisfaction: 86% with 977 solutions
• 2 pending issues, including one complaint about incorrect handling of flats.
• 3 languages (no C#), No pending translations
• Published: Jul 28, 2015
• Author last seen: Oct 2021

Conclusion

• Retire 1. Musical Transposer - Chromatic
• Keep 2. Transposing a song and fix issues related to handling of flats

[hobovsky]

I have no good idea how to handle this group. Possible ways are:

• Keep both, because they are sufficiently different,
• Keep 1, because it has fewer problems,
• Keep 2, because it's richer and fix the domain issues (ensure that flats are not mixed with sharps, ensure that flats are transposed to flats).

What do you think?

[ejini6969]

Keep 2 retire 1, more languages, more solutions, more complexity and non-trivial than 1.

[hobovsky]

"Keep 2." then. It could use some fixing tho, to remove domain-specific issues.