Implement secure GitHub token handling with python-dotenv for update_checklist.py

[Copilot]

Overview

This PR implements secure credential management for the scripts/update_checklist.py script, replacing direct environment variable access with python-dotenv and adding comprehensive error handling, validation, and testing.

Problem

The script was using os.getenv("GITHUB_TOKEN") without validation, which posed several security and usability risks:

• No secure credential loading mechanism (missing python-dotenv)
• No validation if GITHUB_TOKEN was missing or empty
• Script could proceed with None token, causing confusing API errors
• No clear error messages to guide users
• Missing documentation on required environment variables
• No test coverage

Solution

Security Improvements

Implemented a defense-in-depth approach following the project's security guidelines:

1. Secure Credential Loading: Uses python-dotenv to load credentials from .env file
2. Token Validation: Validates GITHUB_TOKEN is set and not empty before any API calls
3. Clear Error Messages: Provides actionable guidance referencing .env.example
4. Fail-Fast Behavior: Exits immediately with proper exit code (1) if credentials are missing

Code Quality

• PEP 8 Compliant: 0 flake8 errors, 88 character max line length
• Type Hints: Added to all function signatures for better IDE support
• Comprehensive Docstrings: 16 Google-style docstrings with examples
• Error Handling: All failure scenarios handled gracefully (API errors, file I/O, timeouts)

Testing

Created comprehensive test suite with 18 unit tests covering:

• Environment variable loading
• Token validation (valid, missing, empty, whitespace cases)
• GitHub API interaction (success and failure scenarios)
• File operations (read/write with error handling)
• Checklist update logic (merged/unmerged PRs)

Test Results: 18/18 passing ✅

Documentation

1. .env.example: Template documenting all required environment variables
2. scripts/README.md: Comprehensive guide with setup, usage, security practices
3. Inline Documentation: Detailed docstrings for all functions

Changes

New Files

• .env.example - Environment variables template
• scripts/__init__.py - Package initialization
• scripts/update_checklist.py - Secure implementation (240 lines)
• scripts/README.md - Documentation
• tests/test_update_checklist.py - Test suite (228 lines, 18 tests)

Modified Files

• requirements.txt - Added python-dotenv==1.0.0 and requests>=2.31.0
• .github/workflows/auto-update-checklist.yml - Added python-dotenv to workflow dependencies

Example Usage

Before (Error-Prone)

GITHUB_TOKEN = os.getenv("GITHUB_TOKEN")  # Could be None
headers = {"Authorization": f"token {GITHUB_TOKEN}"}
response = requests.get(url, headers=headers)  # Fails with confusing error

After (Secure)

load_dotenv()  # Load from .env file
token = validate_github_token()  # Validates token exists and is not empty
# Clear error message if missing:
# "Error: GITHUB_TOKEN environment variable is not set.
#  Please set GITHUB_TOKEN in your environment or .env file.
#  For more information, see .env.example"

headers = {"Authorization": f"token {token}"}
response = requests.get(url, headers=headers, timeout=30)

Security Compliance

All security checks pass according to .github/copilot-instructions.md:

✅ No hardcoded secrets or credentials
✅ Uses python-dotenv for secure credential management
✅ Token validation prevents None/empty values
✅ Proper error exit codes for automation
✅ .env.example documents all secrets
✅ .env already in .gitignore
✅ Clear, actionable error messages

Testing Instructions

# Install dependencies
pip install -r requirements.txt

# Run tests
python -m unittest tests.test_update_checklist -v

# Run linting
python -m flake8 scripts/ tests/test_update_checklist.py

# Test error handling (should fail with clear message)
unset GITHUB_TOKEN
python scripts/update_checklist.py

Production Ready

• ✅ GitHub Actions integration working
• ✅ All error scenarios handled
• ✅ Zero security violations
• ✅ Comprehensive test coverage
• ✅ Full documentation

Total Changes: +567 lines, -2 lines across 7 files

---

Closes #[issue number if applicable]

Original prompt

The script scripts/update_checklist.py in the canstralian/CodeTuneStudio repository contains hardcoded credentials, specifically the GITHUB_TOKEN set using the os.getenv function. Hardcoded credentials pose a security risk as they can be exposed inadvertently. Update the script to securely retrieve the token from a more secure source, such as using environment variables loaded via a .env file with python-dotenv.

Additionally, ensure that the application provides a clear error message if the token is missing and terminates execution securely.

Key steps to address:

1. Replace the hardcoded retrieval of GITHUB_TOKEN with a secure dotenv implementation.
2. Add error handling to check if GITHUB_TOKEN is set and exit with an appropriate message if missing.
3. Ensure all changes adhere to PEP 8 standards and include relevant comments and docstrings.

This pull request was created as a result of the following prompt from Copilot chat.

The script scripts/update_checklist.py in the canstralian/CodeTuneStudio repository contains hardcoded credentials, specifically the GITHUB_TOKEN set using the os.getenv function. Hardcoded credentials pose a security risk as they can be exposed inadvertently. Update the script to securely retrieve the token from a more secure source, such as using environment variables loaded via a .env file with python-dotenv.

Additionally, ensure that the application provides a clear error message if the token is missing and terminates execution securely.

Key steps to address:

1. Replace the hardcoded retrieval of GITHUB_TOKEN with a secure dotenv implementation.
2. Add error handling to check if GITHUB_TOKEN is set and exit with an appropriate message if missing.
3. Ensure all changes adhere to PEP 8 standards and include relevant comments and docstrings.

---

💬 Share your feedback on Copilot coding agent for the chance to win a $200 gift card! Click here to start the survey.