Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[AC-432] Checking that an existing Organization is not assigned to any Provider before being assigned #2840

Conversation

r-tome
Copy link
Contributor

@r-tome r-tome commented Apr 6, 2023

Type of change

- [ ] Bug fix
- [X] New feature development
- [ ] Tech debt (refactoring, code cleanup, dependency upgrades, etc)
- [ ] Build/deploy pipeline (DevOps)
- [ ] Other

Objective

Check if the Organizations already belong to any Provider before assigning them to a Reseller.

Code changes

  • bitwarden_license/src/Commercial.Core/Services/ProviderService.cs: Checking if each OrganizationId already has a ProviderOrganization entry

Before you submit

  • Please check for formatting errors (dotnet format --verify-no-changes) (required)
  • If making database changes - make sure you also update Entity Framework queries and/or migrations
  • Please add unit tests where it makes sense to do so (encouraged but not required)
  • If this change requires a documentation update - notify the documentation team
  • If this change has particular deployment requirements - notify the DevOps team

@r-tome r-tome changed the base branch from master to feature/billing-obfuscation April 6, 2023 16:57
Copy link
Member

@eliykat eliykat left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

We should definitely add this check. I would prefer using the existing method providerOrganizationRepository.GetByOrganizationId and then checking for null though, it avoids adding a sproc and we'll only ever have 1 or 0 results here, so adding a count method seems unnecessary.

…ionIdsAsync with call to IProviderOrganizationRepository.GetByOrganizationId
@r-tome r-tome marked this pull request as ready for review April 10, 2023 15:02
Copy link
Member

@eliykat eliykat left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Sorry! I was wrong on this one. I missed that we need to query by multiple organizationIds. Your previous solution was the correct one to avoid looped async database calls.

I have re-reviewed changes up to and including commit 4daebe4. If you can revert to that commit then I'll approve.

EDIT: my only question is whether returning -1 from the SQL sproc is consistent with EF behaviour. Will EF also return -1 if there are no Ids provided? In general, do we return -1 if there are no matches found, or do we return 0? I don't really mind either way, but it should be consistent between SQL and EF implementations.

…rganizationIdsAsync with call to IProviderOrganizationRepository.GetByOrganizationId"

This reverts commit ee6e095.

# Conflicts:
#	util/Migrator/DbScripts/2023-03-22_00_ProviderAddExistingOrganizations.sql
@r-tome
Copy link
Contributor Author

r-tome commented Apr 12, 2023

EDIT: my only question is whether returning -1 from the SQL sproc is consistent with EF behaviour. Will EF also return -1 if there are no Ids provided? In general, do we return -1 if there are no matches found, or do we return 0? I don't really mind either way, but it should be consistent between SQL and EF implementations.

EF does not return -1 but that is the standard behavior across Repository methods that receive multiple Ids as argument. For example CollectionRepository.GetManyByManyIdsAsync, CollectionCipherRepository.UpdateCollectionsAsync, OrganizationUserRepository.GetManyAsync to name a few

@r-tome r-tome requested review from eliykat and a team April 12, 2023 10:14
@r-tome r-tome changed the title AC-432-add-existing-organization-flow-server-admin-portal-database [AC-432] Checking that an existing Organization is not assigned to any Provider before being assigned Apr 12, 2023
@r-tome r-tome merged commit 7f5d6c0 into feature/billing-obfuscation Apr 13, 2023
@r-tome r-tome deleted the AC-432-add-existing-organization-flow-server-admin-portal-database branch April 13, 2023 08:48
r-tome added a commit that referenced this pull request Apr 14, 2023
* [EC-1014] Create Organization Status (Pending/Created) (#2610)

* [EC-427] Add columns 'Type' and 'BillingPhone' to Provider table

* [EC-427] Provider table Type and BillingPhone MySql migrations

* [EC-427] Provider table Type and BillingPhone Postgres migrations

* [EC-427] Add mysql migration script

* [EC-427] Add mysql migration script

* [EC-427] Updated Provider sql script to include default column value

* [EC-427] Removed default value from Provider.Type column

* [EC-427] Changed migration script to include a default value constraint instead of updating the null type

* [EC-427] Updated Sql project Provider table script

* [EC-427] Changed migration script to use 'Create OR Alter' for views and sprocs

* [EC-427] Added default values for 'BillingPhone' and 'Type' fields on sprocs [dbo].[Provider_Create] and [dbo].[Provider_Update]

* [EC-427] Adjusting metadata in migration script

* [EC-427] Updated Provider sprocs SQL script files

* [EC-427] Fixed migration script

* [EC-427] Added sqlite migration

* [EC-427] Add missing Provider_Update sproc default value

* [EC-427] Added missing GO action to migration script

* [EC-428] Redirect to Edit after creating Provider

* Revert "[EC-428] Redirect to Edit after creating Provider"

This reverts commit 6347bca.

* [EC-1014] Create OrganizationStatusType and add Status column to Organizations table

* [EC-1014] Added EF migrations

* [EC-1014] dotnet format

* [EC-1014] Changed Organization.Status from SMALLINT to TINYINT

* [EC-1014] Set Organization.Status default value = 1

* [EC-1014] Setting Organization.Status default value as 1

* [EC-459 / EC-428] Admin panel: Add Provider Type to list and creation flow (#2593)

* [EC-427] Add columns 'Type' and 'BillingPhone' to Provider table

* [EC-427] Provider table Type and BillingPhone MySql migrations

* [EC-427] Provider table Type and BillingPhone Postgres migrations

* [EC-427] Add mysql migration script

* [EC-427] Add mysql migration script

* [EC-427] Updated Provider sql script to include default column value

* [EC-427] Removed default value from Provider.Type column

* [EC-427] Changed migration script to include a default value constraint instead of updating the null type

* [EC-427] Updated Sql project Provider table script

* [EC-427] Changed migration script to use 'Create OR Alter' for views and sprocs

* [EC-427] Added default values for 'BillingPhone' and 'Type' fields on sprocs [dbo].[Provider_Create] and [dbo].[Provider_Update]

* [EC-427] Adjusting metadata in migration script

* [EC-427] Updated Provider sprocs SQL script files

* [EC-427] Fixed migration script

* [EC-427] Added sqlite migration

* [EC-427] Add missing Provider_Update sproc default value

* [EC-427] Added missing GO action to migration script

* [EC-459] Added Type column to Providers list

* [EC-428] Added Type, BusinessName and BillingEmail to CreateProviderModel

* [EC-428] Updated Create Provider view to include new fields

* [EC-428] Updated ProviderService to not create a ProviderUser for the type Reseller

* [EC-428] Added custom validation for Provider fields depending on selected Type

* [EC-428] Redirect to Edit after creating Provider

* [EC-428] Setting Provider status as Created for Resellers

* [EC-428] Redirect on Provider creation depending if self host server

* [EC-428] Split ProviderService.CreateAsync into two methods: CreateMspAsync and CreateResellerAsync

* [EC-428] Created ICreateProviderCommand and added service for injection on Admin.Startup

* [EC-428] Modified Provider views to use DisplayName attribute values

* [EC-428] Moved ICreateProviderCommand to Core project

* [EC-428] Adding ICreateProviderCommand injection next to IProviderService

* [EC-428] Moved CreateProviderCommand to Commercial.Core project

* [EC-459] Added Type column to Providers list

* [EC-428] Added Type, BusinessName and BillingEmail to CreateProviderModel

* [EC-428] Updated Create Provider view to include new fields

* [EC-428] Updated ProviderService to not create a ProviderUser for the type Reseller

* [EC-428] Added custom validation for Provider fields depending on selected Type

* [EC-428] Redirect to Edit after creating Provider

* [EC-428] Setting Provider status as Created for Resellers

* [EC-428] Redirect on Provider creation depending if self host server

* [EC-428] Split ProviderService.CreateAsync into two methods: CreateMspAsync and CreateResellerAsync

* [EC-428] Created ICreateProviderCommand and added service for injection on Admin.Startup

* [EC-428] Modified Provider views to use DisplayName attribute values

* [EC-428] Moved ICreateProviderCommand to Core project

* [EC-428] Adding ICreateProviderCommand injection next to IProviderService

* [EC-428] Moved CreateProviderCommand to Commercial.Core project

* [EC-428] Moved CreateProviderCommand to namespace Bit.Commercial.Core.Providers

* [EC-429] Provider details screen updated with Type, BillingPhone and Organization details (#2666)

* [EC-430] Admin portal: Update organization information screen (#2672)

* [EC-430] Added ProviderOrganizationProviderDetailsView to get Provider details for an Organization

* [EC-430] Added Provider information to Organization Edit/View on Admin panel

* [EC-430] Remove "Add to Reseller" button

* [EC-430] Removed unused property OrganizationEditModel.ClientOwnerEmail

* [EC-430] Replaced IProviderOrganizationRepository.GetProviderDetailsByOrganizationAsync with IProviderRepository.GetByOrganizationIdAsync

* [EC-430] Deleted ProviderOrganizationProviderDetails and ProviderOrganizationProviderDetailsReadByOrganizationIdQuery

* [EC-429] Only show Create/Add Existing Organization buttons for Reseller providers (#2723)

* [EC-432] Add existing Organizations to Provider (#2683)

* [EC-432] Added ProviderOrganizationUnassignedOrganizationDetails_Search stored procedure

* [EC-432] Added IProviderOrganizationRepository.SearchAsync

* [EC-432] Created controller ProviderOrganizationsController to assign Organizations to a Provider

* [EC-432] Filter existing organizations by plans Enterprise or Team

* [EC-432] Existing Organization name links to edit page

* [EC-432] EF filtering out existing organizations by plan type enterprise or teams

* [EC-432] Creating multiple ProviderOrganization records

* [EC-432] Added ProviderOrganizationUnassignedOrganizationDetails_Search stored procedure

* [EC-432] Added IProviderOrganizationRepository.SearchAsync

* [EC-432] Created controller ProviderOrganizationsController to assign Organizations to a Provider

* [EC-432] Filter existing organizations by plans Enterprise or Team

* [EC-432] Existing Organization name links to edit page

* [EC-432] EF filtering out existing organizations by plan type enterprise or teams

* [EC-432] Creating multiple ProviderOrganization records

* [EC-432] Renamed migration script and added missing sproc

* [EC-432] Saving multiple events for the created ProviderOrganizations

* [EC-432] Included unit testing for ProviderService.AddOrganizations and EventService.LogProviderOrganizationEventsAsync

* [EC-432] Removed async from NoopEventService.LogProviderOrganizationEventsAsync

* [EC-432] Remove unused dependency setup in ProviderServiceTests.AddOrganizations_Success

* [EC-432] Renamed AddOrganizations to AddOrganizationsToReseller and removed addingUserId and key arguments

* [EC-432] Added DisplayName attributes to ProviderOrganizationViewModel and used them in the view

* [EC-432] Reverted changes to input fields

* [EC-432] Moved unassigned organizations search to Organizations repo

* [EC-432] Moved AddExistingOrganization action to ProvidersController

* [EC-432] dotnet format

* [EC-432] Fixed unit test issues

* [EC-432] Removed unnecessary Html.DisplayNameFor for labels

* [EC-432] Renamed OrganizationSearchViewModel to OrganizationUnassignedToProviderSearchViewModel

* [EC-432] Modified IEventService.LogProviderOrganizationEventsAsync to receive an IEnumerable as parameter

* [EC-432] Updated IProviderOrganizationRepository and replaced CreateWithManyOrganizations method with CreateManyAsync

* [EC-432] Deleted ProviderOrganization_CreateWithManyOrganizations

* [AC-432] Simplified Organization_UnassignedToProviderSearch query

* [AC-432] Removed unnecessary setup

* [EC-432] Checking if stored procedure exists before creating

* [EC-432] Renamed migration file to recent date

* [EC-435] Admin Portal: Add new Organization creation flow UI (#2707)

* [EC-435] Created _OrganizationForm partial view. Added actions for creating an Organization assigned to a provider

* [EC-435] Remove logic for creating an organization

* [EC-435] Created partial view _OrganizationFormScripts

* [EC-435] Remove unused ReferenceEventType

* [EC-435] Added TODO comment on Organization Create

* [EC-435] Checking if Provider type is Reseller on creating new assigned organization

* [EC-435] Setting the Organization plan type as TeamsMonthly by default when adding to a provider

* [EC-435] Removing unused buttons

* [EC-435] Switched hidden fields to form submit route value

* [EC-435] Moved _OrganizationForm and _OrganizationFormScripts to Shared folder

* [EC-435] Moved Create organization actions from OrganizationsController to ProvidersController

* [EC-435] Fixing bug on saving Organization that would have BillingEmail as null

* [EC-435] Added null check to Provider

* [EC-435] Moved trial buttons script logic to Edit view

* [AC-431] Add new organization invite process (#2737)

* [EC-435] Created _OrganizationForm partial view. Added actions for creating an Organization assigned to a provider

* [EC-435] Remove logic for creating an organization

* [EC-435] Created partial view _OrganizationFormScripts

* [EC-435] Remove unused ReferenceEventType

* [EC-435] Added TODO comment on Organization Create

* [EC-435] Checking if Provider type is Reseller on creating new assigned organization

* [EC-435] Setting the Organization plan type as TeamsMonthly by default when adding to a provider

* [EC-435] Removing unused buttons

* [EC-435] Switched hidden fields to form submit route value

* [EC-435] Moved _OrganizationForm and _OrganizationFormScripts to Shared folder

* [EC-435] Moved Create organization actions from OrganizationsController to ProvidersController

* [AC-431] Added new ReferenceEventType OrganizationCreatedByAdmin

* [AC-431] Added method IOrganizationService.CreateOrganization

* [AC-431] Creating new Organization with Pending status and assigning to Provider

* [AC-431] Added method to IMailService to send invitation to initialize org

* [AC-431] Added methods CreatePendingOrganization and InitPendingOrganization to IOrganizationService

* [AC-431] Org invite includes initOrganization parameter

* [AC-431] Modified existing Accept organization user action to initialize org

* [AC-431] Updated ProvidersController method name

* [AC-431] Created OrganizationUserInitInvitedViewModel to link to 'accept-init-organization' url

* [AC-431] Added action AcceptInit to OrganizationUsersController

* [AC-431] Resend owner invite

* [AC-431] dotnet format

* [AC-431] Removed unused parameter 'addingUserId' from IProviderService.AddOrganization

* [AC-431] Removed setting manual values for CreationDate and RevisionDate

* [AC-431] Updated OrganizationService.InitPendingOrganization to throw exceptions when the Organization does not meet the required criteria

* [AC-431] Modified OrganizationUserInitInvitedViewModel to inherit properties from OrganizationUserInvitedViewModel

* [AC-431] Removed unecessary parameter check

* [AC-431] Moved method description to IOrganizationService.InitPendingOrganization

* [AC-431] Moved ApplicationCacheService.UpsertOrganizationAbilityAsync and ReferenceEventService.RaiseEventAsync to OrganizationService

* [AC-431] Creating collection after creating organization

* [EC-435] Fixing bug on saving Organization that would have BillingEmail as null

* [AC-431] Deleted OrganizationUserInitInvitedViewModel and added parameter InitOrganization to OrganizationUserInvitedViewModel.cs

* [AC-431] Checking if the user has any existing SingleOrg policies before initializing an Org

* [AC-431] Remove commented code

* [EC-435] Added null check to Provider

* [EC-435] Moved trial buttons script logic to Edit view

* [AC-431] Added EncryptedString attribute to OrganizationUserAcceptInitRequestModel.CollectionName

* [AC-431] Refactored plan check condition

* [AC-431] Remove duplicate _applicationCacheService.UpsertOrganizationAbilityAsync call

* [AC-431] Removed IMailService.SendOrganizationInitInviteEmailAsync

* [AC-431] Added parameters ClaimsPrincipal and IUserService to IOrganizationService.CreatePendingOrganization

* [AC-434] Hide Billing screen for Reseller clients (#2783)

* [AC-434] Added ProviderType to ProfileOrganizationResponseModel

* [AC-434] Migration script

* [AC-434] Fixed indentation on migration script

* [AC-434] Hiding sensitive subscription data if the user does not have permissions

* [AC-434] Fixed missing dependency in unit test

* [AC-434] Altered BillingSubscription.Amount and BillingSubscriptionUpcomingInvoice.Amount to nullable

* [AC-434] Replaced CurrentContext.ManageBilling with ViewBillingHistory, ViewSubscription, EditSubscription and EditPaymentMethods

* [AC-434] Reverted change on BillingSubscription.Amount and now setting Subscription.Items = null when User does not have permission

* [AC-434] Added ProviderOrganizationProviderDetails_ReadByUserId

* [AC-434] Added IProviderOrganizationRepository.GetManyByUserAsync

* [AC-434] Added CurrentContext.GetOrganizationProviderDetails

* [AC-434] Remove unneeded join Organization table

* [AC-1255] Search Existing Organizations by partial Email (#2830)

* [AC-1255] Added email search field input validation

* [AC-1255] Reverted added email pattern

* [AC-1255] Modified Organization search by Email to search using substring

* [AC-1276] Displaying an Organizations pending owners if the Organization is in a Pending status (#2834)

* [AC-432] Checking that an existing Organization is not assigned to any Provider before being assigned (#2840)

* [AC-432] Checking if any of the selected Organizations is already assigned to a Provider

* [AC-432] Changed ProviderOrganization_ReadByOrganizationIds to only get count

* [AC-432] Replaced IProviderOrganizationRepository.GetCountByOrganizationIdsAsync with call to IProviderOrganizationRepository.GetByOrganizationId

* [AC-432] undo new line

* [AC-432] Fixed unit test

* Revert "[AC-432] Replaced IProviderOrganizationRepository.GetCountByOrganizationIdsAsync with call to IProviderOrganizationRepository.GetByOrganizationId"

This reverts commit ee6e095.

# Conflicts:
#	util/Migrator/DbScripts/2023-03-22_00_ProviderAddExistingOrganizations.sql

* [AC-432] Created new migration script for ProviderOrganization_ReadCountByOrganizationIds
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants