Closed
Description
When record field names contain special characters it's not possible to assoc them:
user> (defrecord A [?])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (assoc (->A nil) :? 1)
;; Expected
#user.A{:? 1}
;; Actual
;; raises TypeError: A.__init__() got an unexpected keyword argument '?'Part of this is just a missed call to munge in the assoc method of the defrecord macro but there's another problem where it looks like the compiler is generating different key names based on the position of the special characters: I'm not sure if we just want to code around these cases or actually change how they are generated.
user> (import inspect)
<module 'inspect' from '/usr/lib/python3.12/inspect.py'>
user> (defrecord A [?])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (inspect/signature (.-__init__ A))
<Signature (self, Q__, meta=None, recmap={}) -> None>
user> (defrecord A [x?])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (inspect/signature (.-__init__ A))
<Signature (self, x__Q__, meta=None, recmap={}) -> None>
user> (defrecord A [?x])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (inspect/signature (.-__init__ A))
<Signature (self, A__Q__x, meta=None, recmap={}) -> None>
user> (defrecord A [??])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (inspect/signature (.-__init__ A))
<Signature (self, Q____Q__, meta=None, recmap={}) -> None>
user> (defrecord A [?x?])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (inspect/signature (.-__init__ A))
<Signature (self, Q__x__Q__, meta=None, recmap={}) -> None>
user> (defrecord A [??x])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (inspect/signature (.-__init__ A))
<Signature (self, A__Q____Q__x, meta=None, recmap={}) -> None>
user> (defrecord A [?x-])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (inspect/signature (.-__init__ A))
<Signature (self, A__Q__x_, meta=None, recmap={}) -> None>
(defrecord A [x?x])
<class 'user.A'>
user> (inspect/signature (.-__init__ A))
<Signature (self, x__Q__x, meta=None, recmap={}) -> None>| Unmunged | Munged |
|---|---|
? |
Q__ |
x? |
x__Q__ |
?x |
A__Q__x It's not clear to me why the class name is added here. |
?? |
Q____Q__ |
?x? |
Q__x__Q__ |
??x |
A__Q____Q__x |
?x- |
A__Q__x_ |
x?x |
x__Q__x |