Widget: Not all element look up options work when using multiple locators

[wazzeps]

Is there an existing issue for this?

• I have searched the existing issues

Current Behavior

Suppose we have 2 locators to look up a widget and 2 locators to look up a nested widget element.

In this case, looking up is performed only by the combinations

• first widget locator + first element locator
• first widget locator + second element locator

and the other two combinations are ignored

• second widget locator + first element locator
• second widget locator + second element locator

Expected Behavior

Looking up is performed on all 4 options

• first widget locator + first element locator
• first widget locator + second element locator
• second widget locator + first element locator
• second widget locator + second element locator

Minimal Reproducible Example

@HowToUseLocators(androidAutomation = LocatorGroupStrategy.ALL_POSSIBLE)
@AndroidFindBy(id = "widget1")
@AndroidFindBy(id = "widget2")
private SomeWidget widget;

@HowToUseLocators(androidAutomation = LocatorGroupStrategy.ALL_POSSIBLE)
@AndroidFindBy(id = "element1")
@AndroidFindBy(id = "element2")
private WebElement element;

Calling a method on the element with its widget which can only be found by the second locator will throw NoSuchElementException.

Environment

• OS: Ubuntu 22.04.1 LTS
• Appium Desktop: v1.22.3-4
• Appium driver: UIAutomator2
• Platform: Android API level 30
• Emulator

Link to Appium Logs

No response

Futher Information

No response

[Auto81]

Does trying the following style yield any different results?

@AndroidFindAll({
  @AndroidBy(id = "widget1"),
  @AndroidBy(id = "widget2")
})
private SomeWidget widget;

@AndroidFindAll({
  @AndroidBy(id = "element1"),
  @AndroidBy(id = "element2")
})
private WebElement element;