Skip to content

amp-list cause line-break that cannot be reversed with CSS #23675

Open
@jaygray0919

Description

Our goal is to implement a tool-tip similar to this Washington Post example:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2019/03/19/blake-bortles-signs-with-rams-one-year-deal-back-up-jared-goff/?utm_term=.6657442a70fc

Here are three scenarios to illustrate our issue:
https://dailyfood.io/amp/tooltip/question.html
A quick explanation of the 3 scenarios:
1 inline but no amp-list (to prove that inline keeps multiple <div>s together)
2 one amp-list (hierarchical); amp-lightbox for EACH item
3 multiple amp-list (one list per item; multiple items); one amp-lightbox template

AMP page rendering adds CSS which, somehow-somewhere, forces a line break in scenario-3. Candidates:

i-amphtml-element
i-amphtml-layout
i-amphtml-fill-content
i-amphtml-replaced-content

Another possibility, from AMP documentation:

amp-list div[role="list"] {
    display: grid;
    grid-gap: 0.5em;
  }

For us, this is a severity-2 issue because we have a work-around (scenario-2). But scenario-2 dictates significant page-bloat due to "one amp-lightbox per item", and the amp-mustache item processing (#open /close) adds complexity and bloat.

Bottom line: we cannot use multiple amp-lists in a single paragraph, as is effectively achieved in the WaPo example:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2019/03/19/blake-bortles-signs-with-rams-one-year-deal-back-up-jared-goff/?utm_term=.6657442a70fc

Cathy Zhu @cathyxz looked at this issue and suggested we copy @CrystalOnScript Crystal Lambert on this thread.
Cathy thought Crystal might have a template/example that uses amp-bind, where we could bind an amp-list item to a <span> element (an inline element that would allow us to use items from multiple amp-lists in a single <p>). We then would link the amp-list item to an amp-lightbox template.

However, an ideal solution would fix scenario-3, without requiring the overhead of an amp-bind step. An amp-bind step makes the structure less portable/reusable among different documents.

Metadata

Assignees

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions