Skip to content

Post: Dark mode is not a preference, it's assistive technology#1654

Open
KatieSeeMePls wants to merge 2 commits into
a11yproject:mainfrom
KatieSeeMePls:post-dark-mode-essential
Open

Post: Dark mode is not a preference, it's assistive technology#1654
KatieSeeMePls wants to merge 2 commits into
a11yproject:mainfrom
KatieSeeMePls:post-dark-mode-essential

Conversation

@KatieSeeMePls

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Closes #1621.

Submitting the dark mode post claimed in #1621 last year. The argument:
treat dark mode as assistive technology, not a stylistic preference.

What's in this PR

  • New post at src/posts/dark-mode-is-not-a-preference.md (~1,720 words, category: Background, tag: background)
  • Author entry for me added to src/_data/authors.json, alphabetically between Joseph Mawa and Kelly Gillit

Notes for reviewers

  • Two on-record participant quotes (Daniel and Patrick) appear in the post. Both are already published on seemeplease.com with consent.
  • The 75% / 50% / 18-participant figures are presented as aggregated observations from our own panel, not a citable industry figure. Language is hedged ("Conservatively, about 75%...") but happy to soften further if needed.
  • Halation phenomenon section may benefit from a citation — I've kept it descriptive rather than referencing a specific paper, but happy to add one if a reviewer prefers.
  • I claimed this post a year ago in [Post] Dark mode isn't a preference for some #1621 with a different working title and as a docx attachment. This PR supersedes that draft entirely.

Closes a11yproject#1621.

Post draws on aggregated user-testing observations across an 18-participant
diverse-user panel, with two on-record participant quotes (Daniel and Patrick)
already published with their consent on seemeplease.com. Argues that dark mode
should be treated as assistive technology rather than a design preference,
and explains why third-party overlays and system colour inversion are not
substitutes for native support.

Also adds the author entry to authors.json, alphabetically between
Joseph Mawa and Kelly Gillit.
A real screenshot showing thin black text on a bright white background
with visible halation/bleeding — the visual phenomenon the article
describes. Cropped to remove peripheral branding so the focus is on
the bleeding-text effect itself. Figure block uses the project's
existing <figure role="figure"> + aria-label + figcaption pattern with
descriptive alt text.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

[Post] Dark mode isn't a preference for some

1 participant