Type=address fields are not editable

[gena01]

It seems that some tags are missing when mapping letter boxes, things like support and post:* addresses would need much easier if they could be provided in the UI. I am sure there's possibly other tags missing as well.

[mnalis]

I'm not sure if you mean amenity=post_box or amenity=letter_box when you say "letter boxes", but the former does include support=* when you click More fields.

But unless I'm wrong, Every Door uses id-tagging-schema for such presets, so you want to open issue there instead.

Or you could even do a PR, it looks simple enough:

https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/main/data/presets/amenity/post_box.json

or

https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/main/data/presets/amenity/letter_box.json

[gena01]

I did mean amenity:letter_box.

Updated with screenshots, what am I missing?

[mnalis]

Thanks for clarification that this is about amenity=letter_box tag.

As I said above, the issue seems to be in another project called id-tagging-schema which Every Door uses, so you should report issue / suggest changes there (and then the next release of EveryDoor would pull those changes automatically)

[gena01]

I am looking at their preset and it does have post tag. Somehow that's not recognized as post:* instead of the addr:* tag(s). This makes tagging things like house numbers on letter boxes a bit more challenging.

[mnalis]

I've created PR for support tag at openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema#1005

---

As for post:*, you might be correct there @gena01. I'm not an expert there, but I think post field in https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/main/data/presets/amenity/letter_box.json should be expanded to list of keys defined in https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/main/data/fields/post.json automatically.

That post field expansion however:

• seems to work correctly for example in SCEE which uses id-tagging-schema (via osmfeatures) , showing all those post:* keys
• It also seems to work in iD editor (although it seems to offer only 5 out of two dozen post:* keys? But that limiting is maybe due to iD UI-specific tweaks)
• However, EveryDoor 3.1 does not seem to expand that post field at all in amenity=letter_box, but it is lost completely. It is unfortunately beyond me why (could be me missing something, but perhaps it might also be EveryDoor bug?)

[Zverik]

Every Door currently filters out fields with the address type, hence no post:*=*. Given it handles addresses differently, it may be tricky to implement. I'll let this hang around.

[Zverik]

Done in 4.0.

[mnalis]

Just an note that support & colour tags have been added to amenity=letter_box in openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema#1005 (comment)

So hopefully next Everydoor build should be able to specify those, if I understand correctly.