Symbolic error is zero?

[maxreiss123]

Hi,

I am currently employing your approach as a comparison in my article. I recently recognized that some of the rows show 'symbolic_error_is_zero' = True, symbolic_error_is_constant =True, and symbolic_fraction_is_constant=True, while that's not the case.

Since these cols, are utilized to calculate the symbolic solution rate, it should be corrected.

Some examples are given below:

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 109 in 95c053a

107,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_18_12,21,2,0.1,F*r*sin(theta),990388,True,True,0.00299*F*r*sin(theta)**2,-1/(0.00299*sin(theta) - 1.0),True,True,True,,True,1.00101783957533*(-0.00303733283874105*F*r*sin(theta) + F*r)*sin(0.998983195368663*theta),16,F*r*(1.0 - 0.00299*sin(theta))*sin(0.999*theta),13,0.0005162827919709627,0.016499225130092415,0.9999905613752621,0.9999904763711706,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 113 in 95c053a

111,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_18_14,22,1,0.1,m*r*v*sin(theta),992785,True,True,-0.00201416015625*m*r*v,sin(theta)/(sin(theta) + 0.00201416015625),True,True,True,,True,1.00100240899041*m*r*v*sin(1.00100240899041*theta) + 0.0022071211624936*m*r*v,15,m*r*v*(1.0*sin(1.0*theta) + 0.00201),12,0.004047979926360632,0.04301462823176099,0.9999937168198464,0.9999936595654215,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 127 in 95c053a

125,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_27_6,26,0,0.1,d1*d2/(d1*n + d2),990456,True,True,-d1*d2/(d1*n*(0.001007080078125*n + 1) + d2) + d1*d2/(d1*n + d2),(d1*n*(0.001007080078125*n + 1) + d2)/(d1*n + d2),True,True,True,,True,1/(0.00113830188899005*n**2/d2 + n/d2 + 1/d1),19,d1*d2/(d1*n*(0.00101*n + 1) + d2),15,3.2268940278259728e-06,0.0016570490170408356,0.999974714665222,0.9999751954093798,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 129 in 95c053a

127,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_27_6,26,2,0.1,d1*d2/(d1*n + d2),998055,True,True,d1*d2/(d1*n + d2) - 1/(1/(0.001007080078125*d1*n + d1) + n/d2),(d1*n*(0.001007080078125*n + 1) + d2)/((0.001007080078125*n + 1)*(d1*n + d2)),True,True,True,,True,1/(1.000771475687/(0.0010003337743525*d1*n + d1) + 1.000771475687*n/d2),19,1/(1/(0.00101*d1*n + d1) + n/d2),16,5.980836816431247e-08,0.00019119319043141327,0.9999995359497623,0.9999995384045899,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 130 in 95c053a

128,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_27_6,26,3,0.1,d1*d2/(d1*n + d2),992978,True,True,0.00201416015625*d1**2*d2/((d1*n + d2)*(d1*(n + 0.00201416015625) + d2)),(d1*(n + 0.00201416015625) + d2)/(d1*n + d2),True,True,True,,True,1/((n + 0.0019224713153486)/d2 + 1/d1),13,d1*d2/(d1*(n + 0.00201) + d2),12,3.127271531459177e-07,0.00043851755523821806,0.999997558940073,0.9999975528609417,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 200 in 95c053a

198,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_39_22,41,3,0.1,T*kb*n/V,992740,True,True,-0.00299072265625*T*kb/(V*n),n**2/(n**2 + 0.00299072265625),True,True,True,,True,T*kb*n/V + 0.00344212678213302*T*kb/(V*n),18,T*kb*(n**2 + 0.00299)/(V*n),14,4.974185936545748e-05,0.004976863550352293,0.9999995009684124,0.9999995131599114,True

For some ''symbolic_fraction_is_constant' is true, while there is a variable within the fraction:

some examples are given below:

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 125 in 95c053a

123,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_25_13,24,3,0.1,q/C,990867,True,True,1.0*q*(6.49094581604004e-5 + 0.008056640625*I)/C,1 + 0.008056640625*I,False,False,True,,True,q/((0.00846899325487376*I)*C**1.0 + C),13,q/(C + 0.00806*I*C),10,1.0663838070942548e-08,8.668507739582301e-05,0.9999999825688749,0.9999999825591659,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 230 in 95c053a

228,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_44_4,47,3,0.1,log((V2/V1)**(T*kb*n)),990527,True,True,T*kb*n*(log(V2**1.0/V1**0.0040283203125) - 0.9959716796875*log(-0.00299*V1 + 1.0*V2)),log(V2**1.0/V1**1.0)/log(-0.00299 + 1.0*V2/V1),False,False,True,,True,0.995707043711612*T*kb*n*log(-0.0033887053840977 + 1.00431146522012*V2/V1),14,0.996*T*kb*n*log(-0.00299 + 1.0*V2/V1),14,0.0011083949158640792,0.022401351642743792,0.9999973262925587,0.9999973153338042,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 231 in 95c053a

229,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_44_4,47,4,0.1,log((V2/V1)**(T*kb*n)),991712,True,True,log((V1**(0.995*exp(0.00201*n) - 1.0)*V2**(1.0 - 0.995*exp(0.00201*n)))**(T*kb*n)),1.0*exp(-0.00201*n),False,False,True,,True,0.994894119596975*T*kb*n*exp(0.0015288203998037*n)*log(V2/V1),15,log((V2/V1)**(0.995*T*kb*n*exp(0.00201*n))),16,0.0010522559740366267,0.018663063787689855,0.9999975489484415,0.9999975360000571,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 232 in 95c053a

230,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_47_23,48,0,0.1,gamma**0.5*pr**0.5/rho**0.5,992754,True,True,gamma**0.5*pr**0.5*(1.0 - 0.9969482421875*exp(-0.00299*cos(gamma)))/rho**0.5,1.0*exp(0.00299*cos(gamma)),False,False,True,,True,0.99717661508239*gamma**0.5*pr**0.5*exp(-0.00312750185770815*cos(gamma))/rho**0.5,16,0.997*gamma**0.5*pr**0.5*exp(-0.00299*cos(gamma))/rho**0.5,16,1.2449068867105948e-05,0.0025246582478609014,0.9999727268053158,0.9999726190446243,True

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 233 in 95c053a

231,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_47_23,48,1,0.1,gamma**0.5*pr**0.5/rho**0.5,992075,True,True,gamma**0.5*pr**0.5*(1 - 0.998046875*I)/rho**0.5,-1.001953125*I,False,False,True,,True,(0.997536609977967*I)*gamma**0.5*pr**0.5*exp(0.000591989882820977*gamma)/rho**0.5,17,0.998*I*gamma**0.5*pr**0.5/rho**0.5,12,3.618289830343033,1.7779798261937356,-6.993288733381811,0.0,False

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 234 in 95c053a

232,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_47_23,48,2,0.1,gamma**0.5*pr**0.5/rho**0.5,991757,True,True,gamma**0.5*pr**0.5*(1 - I)/rho**0.5,-I,False,False,True,,True,pr**0.5*(-gamma/rho + 2.0432227517946e-5/rho)**0.5,18,1.0*I*gamma**0.5*pr**0.5/rho**0.5,12,inf,inf,0.0,0.0,False

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 235 in 95c053a

233,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_I_47_23,48,3,0.1,gamma**0.5*pr**0.5/rho**0.5,990704,True,True,gamma**0.5*pr**0.5*(1 - I)/rho**0.5,-I,False,False,True,,True,gamma**0.5*(-1/(rho/pr - 2.06035500449218e-5*rho/(gamma*pr)))**0.5,25,1.0*I*gamma**0.5*pr**0.5/rho**0.5,12,inf,inf,0.0,0.0,False

PhySO/benchmarking/FeynmanBenchmark/results/noise0.100/results_detailed.csv

Line 329 in 95c053a

327,PhySO,Feynman,feynman_II_15_4,68,2,0.1,-B*mom*cos(theta),995029,True,True,0.001007080078125*B*mom*cos(693*theta),cos(theta)/(cos(theta) + 0.001007080078125*cos(693*theta)),True,True,True,,True,1.00087248029004*B*mom*(-cos(theta) - 0.0014429818417238*cos(693.009413621858*theta)),15,-B*mom*(cos(theta) + 0.00101*cos(693.0*theta)),13,0.00014486879540687395,0.008889776650710451,0.9999947356138663,0.9999946896213472,True

Best regards
Max