Skip to content

docs(libvmaf): doxygen comments on 15 undocumented public C-API entry points (round 2) - #327

Closed
lusoris wants to merge 1 commit into
masterfrom
docs/libvmaf-public-header-doc-gaps-round2
Closed

lusoris wants to merge 1 commit into
masterfrom
docs/libvmaf-public-header-doc-gaps-round2

Conversation

@lusoris

@lusoris lusoris commented May 30, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Summary

Round-2 follow-on to PR #302 (which closed five targeted gap-findings in
libvmaf.h / picture.h / dnn.h). This pass covers the public surfaces
that PR #302 left untouched, focusing on the headers the ffmpeg patch
stack, the upcoming Go/Rust bindings, and the embedded MCP server consume.

  • feature.h (file was 100 % undocumented):
    VmafFeatureDictionary (struct + ownership-transfer rules),
    vmaf_feature_dictionary_set, vmaf_feature_dictionary_free.
  • model.h: VmafModelFlags (enum + per-flag semantics),
    VmafModelConfig (struct + per-field), vmaf_model_load,
    vmaf_model_load_from_path, vmaf_model_feature_overload (incl.
    opts_dict ownership transfer), vmaf_model_destroy (incl.
    do-not-destroy-after-collection-handoff), VmafModelCollection,
    VmafModelCollectionScoreType, VmafModelCollectionScore,
    vmaf_model_collection_load, vmaf_model_collection_load_from_path,
    vmaf_model_collection_feature_overload, vmaf_model_collection_destroy.
  • dnn.h: vmaf_dnn_session_close (pair-with-open contract).

Each block documents the negative-errno return convention, NULL-safety,
ownership-transfer semantics, and the destroy-pairing required to avoid
double-free of collection-owned sub-models. No semantic / no ABI
change.

Cleanup pass (CLAUDE.md §12 r12 — touched-file lint-clean rule)

The three Netflix-copyright include guards (__VMAF_FEATURE_H__ /
__VMAF_MODEL_H__ / __VMAF_DNN_H__) trip clang-tidy's
bugprone-reserved-identifier check. Renaming them would diverge from
Netflix/vmaf master and break port-only upstream sync (CLAUDE.md §10), so
each #ifndef / #define gets an inline NOLINT citing the
upstream-mirror invariant. This is the exact pattern ADR-0278 endorses for
load-bearing upstream-parity identifiers.

Reproducer / smoke test

meson setup build-cpu-doc core -Denable_cuda=false -Denable_sycl=false
ninja -C build-cpu-doc                  # 726 targets, clean
clang-tidy -p build-cpu-doc \
  core/include/libvmaf/feature.h \
  core/include/libvmaf/model.h \
  core/include/libvmaf/dnn.h            # 0 fork-local warnings
pre-commit run --files \
  core/include/libvmaf/feature.h \
  core/include/libvmaf/model.h \
  core/include/libvmaf/dnn.h \
  changelog.d/added/libvmaf-public-header-doc-comments-round2.md \
  docs/rebase-notes.md                  # green

Inspect the new comments:

grep -n "@brief\|@param\|@return\|@since" core/include/libvmaf/feature.h
grep -n "@brief\|@param\|@return\|@since" core/include/libvmaf/model.h
grep -n "@brief\|@param" core/include/libvmaf/dnn.h | head -20

ADR-0108 deliverables checklist

  • Research digest — no digest needed: trivial doc-only addition
    over Netflix-stable signatures already covered by the existing reference
    manual; the ownership-transfer text matches core/src/model.c and
    core/src/dict.c verbatim.
  • Decision matrix — no alternatives needed: only-one-way fix;
    every entry point has a single correct description, verified against the
    implementation.
  • AGENTS.md invariant note — no rebase-sensitive invariants: doc
    text sits above unchanged upstream signatures and future Netflix merges
    produce tractable 3-way merges. The NOLINT cites name the one invariant
    they preserve (upstream-mirror include guards) and docs/rebase-notes.md
    records that the cites can be retired if upstream ever renames the guards.
  • Reproducer / smoke test — see section above.
  • Changelog fragment — changelog.d/added/libvmaf-public-header-doc-comments-round2.md.
  • Rebase notes — docs/rebase-notes.md — dedicated section
    libvmaf-public-header-doc-gaps-round2 (2026-05-30).

Test plan

  • meson setup build-cpu-doc core -Denable_cuda=false -Denable_sycl=false succeeds.
  • ninja -C build-cpu-doc succeeds for the 35 targets the touched headers
    pull through (full clean build covers 726 targets — see Reproducer).
  • clang-tidy against the 3 touched headers reports 0 fork-local
    warnings (3 reserved-identifier warnings present on master are now
    NOLINT-cited; remaining warnings are in system headers and suppressed).
  • pre-commit run --files <all 5 touched files> is green.
  • CI: required-checks aggregator green on PR.

Coordination with PR #302

PR #302 is OPEN (draft) and covers libvmaf.h (3 gap-findings) +
picture.h (struct + 8 fields) + dnn.h (vmaf_dnn_session_attached_ep
EP-list dedup). This PR does not overlap with #302:

If #302 lands first, this branch needs no rebase (no shared lines). If
this PR lands first, #302 will not see any conflict either.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

… points

Round-2 follow-on to PR #302 (which closed five targeted gap-findings in
libvmaf.h / picture.h / dnn.h). This pass covers the public surfaces that
PR #302 left untouched, focusing on the headers the ffmpeg patch stack,
the upcoming Go/Rust bindings, and the embedded MCP server consume.

Entry points documented:

- feature.h (file was 100 % undocumented):
  - VmafFeatureDictionary (struct doc + ownership-transfer rules)
  - vmaf_feature_dictionary_set
  - vmaf_feature_dictionary_free

- model.h:
  - VmafModelFlags (enum + per-flag semantics)
  - VmafModelConfig (struct + per-field doc)
  - vmaf_model_load
  - vmaf_model_load_from_path
  - vmaf_model_feature_overload (incl. opts_dict ownership transfer)
  - vmaf_model_destroy (incl. do-not-destroy-after-collection-handoff)
  - VmafModelCollection (struct doc)
  - VmafModelCollectionScoreType (enum doc)
  - VmafModelCollectionScore (struct + per-field doc)
  - vmaf_model_collection_load
  - vmaf_model_collection_load_from_path
  - vmaf_model_collection_feature_overload
  - vmaf_model_collection_destroy

- dnn.h:
  - vmaf_dnn_session_close (pair-with-open contract)

Each block documents the negative-errno return convention, NULL-safety,
ownership-transfer semantics, and the destroy-pairing required to avoid
double-free of collection-owned sub-models. No semantic / no ABI change.

Cleanup pass (CLAUDE.md §12 r12 — touched-file lint-clean rule):
the three Netflix-copyright include guards (__VMAF_FEATURE_H__ /
__VMAF_MODEL_H__ / __VMAF_DNN_H__) trip clang-tidy's
bugprone-reserved-identifier check. Renaming them would diverge from
Netflix/vmaf master and break port-only upstream sync (CLAUDE.md §10),
so each #ifndef / #define gets an inline NOLINT citing the upstream-mirror
invariant — the exact pattern ADR-0278 endorses for load-bearing
upstream-parity identifiers.

Build + lint:
- meson setup build-cpu-doc core -Denable_cuda=false -Denable_sycl=false
- ninja -C build-cpu-doc (35 targets touched by header change; clean)
- clang-tidy -p build-cpu-doc on all 3 touched headers: 0 fork-local
  warnings (the 3 reserved-identifier warnings present on master are now
  NOLINT-cited; remaining warnings are in system headers and suppressed).
- pre-commit run --files <all 5 touched files>: green.

ADR-0108 deliverables:
- Research digest: no digest needed — trivial doc-only addition over
  Netflix-stable signatures already covered by the existing reference
  manual.
- Decision matrix: no alternatives needed — only-one-way fix; the
  ownership-transfer text matches the implementation in core/src/model.c
  and core/src/dict.c verbatim.
- AGENTS.md invariant note: no rebase-sensitive invariants — the doc
  text sits above unchanged upstream signatures; future merges from
  Netflix produce tractable 3-way merges. The NOLINT cites name the
  invariant they preserve (upstream-mirror include guards).
- Reproducer / smoke test: see PR body.
- Changelog fragment:
  changelog.d/added/libvmaf-public-header-doc-comments-round2.md.
- Rebase notes: docs/rebase-notes.md updated with a dedicated section.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@lusoris
lusoris marked this pull request as ready for review May 31, 2026 13:19
@lusoris
lusoris marked this pull request as draft May 31, 2026 13:53
@lusoris
lusoris marked this pull request as ready for review May 31, 2026 13:57
@lusoris

lusoris commented May 31, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Closing as part of marathon cleanup 2026-05-31 (150 PRs merged today). Content likely superseded by sibling merges. Reopen if specific finding still needs work; bigger PRs preferred going forward per session feedback.

@lusoris lusoris closed this May 31, 2026
@lusoris
lusoris deleted the docs/libvmaf-public-header-doc-gaps-round2 branch May 31, 2026 14:07
@lusoris
lusoris restored the docs/libvmaf-public-header-doc-gaps-round2 branch May 31, 2026 18:40
@lusoris lusoris reopened this May 31, 2026
@lusoris
lusoris marked this pull request as draft May 31, 2026 18:49
@lusoris

lusoris commented Jun 1, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Superseded by #529 — bundled per 2026-06-01 triage.

@lusoris lusoris closed this Jun 1, 2026
lusoris added a commit that referenced this pull request Jun 3, 2026
…overage + #336 state.md row sweep + #383 README badges + #337 ADR-0865 ANSNR) (#529)

* docs(libvmaf): doxygen comments on 15 undocumented public C-API entry points

Round-2 follow-on to PR #302 (which closed five targeted gap-findings in
libvmaf.h / picture.h / dnn.h). This pass covers the public surfaces that
PR #302 left untouched, focusing on the headers the ffmpeg patch stack,
the upcoming Go/Rust bindings, and the embedded MCP server consume.

Entry points documented:

- feature.h (file was 100 % undocumented):
  - VmafFeatureDictionary (struct doc + ownership-transfer rules)
  - vmaf_feature_dictionary_set
  - vmaf_feature_dictionary_free

- model.h:
  - VmafModelFlags (enum + per-flag semantics)
  - VmafModelConfig (struct + per-field doc)
  - vmaf_model_load
  - vmaf_model_load_from_path
  - vmaf_model_feature_overload (incl. opts_dict ownership transfer)
  - vmaf_model_destroy (incl. do-not-destroy-after-collection-handoff)
  - VmafModelCollection (struct doc)
  - VmafModelCollectionScoreType (enum doc)
  - VmafModelCollectionScore (struct + per-field doc)
  - vmaf_model_collection_load
  - vmaf_model_collection_load_from_path
  - vmaf_model_collection_feature_overload
  - vmaf_model_collection_destroy

- dnn.h:
  - vmaf_dnn_session_close (pair-with-open contract)

Each block documents the negative-errno return convention, NULL-safety,
ownership-transfer semantics, and the destroy-pairing required to avoid
double-free of collection-owned sub-models. No semantic / no ABI change.

Cleanup pass (CLAUDE.md §12 r12 — touched-file lint-clean rule):
the three Netflix-copyright include guards (__VMAF_FEATURE_H__ /
__VMAF_MODEL_H__ / __VMAF_DNN_H__) trip clang-tidy's
bugprone-reserved-identifier check. Renaming them would diverge from
Netflix/vmaf master and break port-only upstream sync (CLAUDE.md §10),
so each #ifndef / #define gets an inline NOLINT citing the upstream-mirror
invariant — the exact pattern ADR-0278 endorses for load-bearing
upstream-parity identifiers.

Build + lint:
- meson setup build-cpu-doc core -Denable_cuda=false -Denable_sycl=false
- ninja -C build-cpu-doc (35 targets touched by header change; clean)
- clang-tidy -p build-cpu-doc on all 3 touched headers: 0 fork-local
  warnings (the 3 reserved-identifier warnings present on master are now
  NOLINT-cited; remaining warnings are in system headers and suppressed).
- pre-commit run --files <all 5 touched files>: green.

ADR-0108 deliverables:
- Research digest: no digest needed — trivial doc-only addition over
  Netflix-stable signatures already covered by the existing reference
  manual.
- Decision matrix: no alternatives needed — only-one-way fix; the
  ownership-transfer text matches the implementation in core/src/model.c
  and core/src/dict.c verbatim.
- AGENTS.md invariant note: no rebase-sensitive invariants — the doc
  text sits above unchanged upstream signatures; future merges from
  Netflix produce tractable 3-way merges. The NOLINT cites name the
  invariant they preserve (upstream-mirror include guards).
- Reproducer / smoke test: see PR body.
- Changelog fragment:
  changelog.d/added/libvmaf-public-header-doc-comments-round2.md.
- Rebase notes: docs/rebase-notes.md updated with a dedicated section.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(go): expand cmd/vmafx-{controller,server,mcp} coverage

Add unit tests for the lowest-coverage Go cmd/ subpackages identified by
the master-tip workflow audit (Section F). No behavior change.

Coverage deltas (against origin/master tip bbcaa8d):

  cmd/vmafx-controller        18.6% -> 32.4%  (+13.8 pp)
  cmd/vmafx-controller/nodes  80.7% -> 82.5%  (+1.8 pp)
  cmd/vmafx-server            27.5% -> 47.9%  (+20.4 pp)
  cmd/vmafx-mcp                3.5% -> 24.6%  (+21.1 pp)

New test files:

- cmd/vmafx-controller/main_extra_test.go
    405 method-not-allowed on /healthz, /readyz, /v1/score;
    400 invalid-JSON body; 500 scorer-error mapping via a stub vmaf
    binary; runHTTP graceful shutdown bounded by GracefulShutdownTimeout;
    envOr default+override; version().
- cmd/vmafx-controller/nodes/registry_edge_test.go
    Get(unknown), distinct-IDs-for-same-name contract pin,
    Heartbeat updates JobsRunning + advances LastHeartbeat
    (reaper eviction predicate), concurrent Register/Heartbeat under
    -race, defensive-copy assertion on All().
- cmd/vmafx-server/main_extra_test.go
    Same shape as the controller HTTP server tests; pins the PR #300
    bounded-timeout shutdown invariant.
- cmd/vmafx-mcp/impl_test.go
    All arg helpers (strArg, intArg, floatArg, boolArg, hasArg);
    every pure helper (classifySourceResolution, modelResolutionClass,
    resolutionMismatchWarning, inferBackendFromPayload,
    inferBackendFromSym, stripModelExt, toFFmpegPixfmt, pickWorstFrames,
    floatFromAny, roundF, truncate); representative handler error paths
    (handleProbeBackend missing/unknown backend, handleDescribeModel
    missing name, handleVmafScore invalid path / zero dimensions,
    handleCompareModels empty list). Pins the errorResult().IsError ==
    true invariant from project memory (MCP isError must be True so
    clients branch correctly).

Drive-by fix: .gitignore anchored the Go binary-ignore rules with a
leading slash so they only match the repo-root binaries, not any path
component sharing the name. Without this, untracked files like
cmd/vmafx-server/main_extra_test.go were silently ignored by `git add`.

Verification:

  go test -race -cover ./cmd/vmafx-controller/... \
                      ./cmd/vmafx-server/...     \
                      ./cmd/vmafx-mcp/...
  go vet  ./...

All green; no behavior change. The pre-existing
cmd/vmafx-operator/internal/controller failure (kubebuilder envtest
needs etcd binaries on PATH) is unrelated to this change and reproduces
on a clean origin/master checkout.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* docs(state): reconcile 2 Open rows that cited CLOSED PRs (#214, #215)

Two Open rows in docs/state.md cited PRs that were CLOSED-not-merged
and flagged as follow-up by the PR #291 closing agent. Verified
against master tip bbcaa8d and master state of the underlying
issues:

1. T-CUDA-FILTER1D-RES-DISPATCH-CONFLICT-2026-05-29 — migrated from
   Open to Recently closed (superseded). The conflict markers only
   existed on the unmerged scaffold branch tip 35a1fb6. PR #91
   (merged 2026-05-29T09:37:48Z) landed ADR-0753 resolution-aware
   dispatch via the adm_cm_device() consumer without extending
   dispatch into filter1d_8(), so master never carried the
   build-failing scaffold variant. PR #214 (the planned
   conflict-marker cleanup) was CLOSED-not-merged 2026-05-30 when
   its base scaffold branch was abandoned. core/src/feature/cuda/
   integer_vif_cuda.c::filter1d_8() on master uses the clean
   unconditional cuLaunchKernel paths.

2. T-CPP23-READ-JSON-MODEL-PENDING-2026-05-29 — kept Open but the
   dead PR #215 citation removed. The C++23 Wave 8 conversion of
   core/src/read_json_model.c is still pending on master (still a
   .c source per core/src/meson.build:1578); PR #215 was
   CLOSED-not-merged 2026-05-30. Owner field rewritten to
   "Owner-driven; pending fresh PR per ADR-0846 Wave 8".

Scope-coordinated with DRAFT PR #291 (docs/state-md-drift-sync —
already migrates the 3 Vulkan rows + T-LEGACY-RUNNER-ANSNR-BROKEN
+ T-LEGACY-RUNNER-STUB-MISSING). Row 203
(T-LEGACY-RUNNER-STUB-MISSING-2026-05-29) cites closed PRs #213
and #181 as OPEN but is left untouched here since PR #291 already
rewrites it.

Net Open count -1; total T-row count unchanged (153).
No code changes — documentation cleanup only.

Deliverables (ADR-0108):
- no digest needed: state.md hygiene
- no alternatives: only-one-way reconciliation
- no rebase-sensitive invariants
- Reproducer: `gh pr view 214 -R VMAFx/vmafx --json state,mergedAt`
  returns `{"state":"CLOSED","mergedAt":null}`;
  `grep -nE '^(<{7}|={7}|>{7})( |$)' core/src/feature/cuda/integer_vif_cuda.c`
  on master returns empty; `ls core/src/read_json_model.*` returns
  only `.c` and `.h`.
- Changelog: changelog.d/changed/state-md-closed-pr-row-sweep.md
- no rebase impact: docs only

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* chore(meta): README badge audit + Cargo / pyproject repo-metadata sweep

Audit + backfill the fork's repo-metadata surface so cargo / pip /
GitHub all advertise the canonical VMAFx/vmafx URLs:

- README.md: add Rust CI + Go CI workflow badges (both workflows ship
  on master but were not surfaced). All five pre-existing workflow
  badges already point at VMAFx/vmafx and reference real, active,
  master-green workflows; verified via the Actions API. License,
  Conventional Commits, OpenSSF Scorecard, ko-fi badges already
  present.
- Cargo.toml: add [workspace.package] with repository / homepage /
  documentation / license / authors. Both workspace members
  (bindings/rust/vmafx-sys, core/src/feature/rust/tad) switched to
  workspace-inherited metadata so URL drift is impossible across the
  Rust workspace. cargo metadata confirms both crates now expose the
  VMAFx/vmafx URLs.
- pyproject.toml (root, ai/, tools/vmaf-tune, tools/vmaf-roi-score,
  tools/ensemble-training-kit, dev-llm/, mcp-server/vmaf-mcp/): add
  [project.urls] with Homepage / Repository / Documentation / Issues /
  Changelog. All seven fork-authored projects now ship the same URL
  block; the package indexes (PyPI / internal) get a consistent
  repository link.
- deploy/helm/vmafx/Chart.yaml: already correct (home + sources
  already point at VMAFx/vmafx). No change needed.
- changelog.d/fixed/ + docs/rebase-notes.md: deliverables.

Coordination with PR #331 (rebrand sweep): #331 only touches the
line-1 copyright header of two of the seven pyproject files; this
PR adds a new [project.urls] block below — no merge conflict.

Deep-dive deliverables (ADR-0108):
- Research digest: no digest needed: trivial repo-metadata sweep.
- Decision matrix: no alternatives: only-one-way fix (URLs must
  match the rebrand target).
- AGENTS.md invariant: no rebase-sensitive invariants — fork-only
  metadata files, none mirror upstream Netflix.
- Reproducer: `cargo metadata --no-deps --format-version 1 | jq` +
  `python3 -c "import tomllib; tomllib.loads(open('pyproject.toml','rb').read().decode())"`.
- CHANGELOG fragment: changelog.d/fixed/readme-badges-metadata-audit.md.
- Rebase note: added to docs/rebase-notes.md (impact: none, fork-only).

* docs(adr): author ADR-0865 for ANSNR sunset (closes PR #38 ADR-0108 gap)

PR #38 (merged 2026-05-28) removed `float_ansnr` from the C backend
but cited `Parent ADR-0709` in its body — ADR-0709 is the Phase 4b
distributed-platform umbrella and contains zero ANSNR content.
PR #295 + PR #324 inherited the bad cite. No dedicated ANSNR-sunset
ADR existed in tree.

This change:
- Authors `docs/adr/0865-ansnr-sunset-pre-vmaf-metric-drop.md` as the
  missing parent ADR, back-dated to 2026-05-28 (PR #38 merge date) so
  the dependency chain (ADR-0865 -> PR #38 -> ADR-0749 Python sunset)
  is consistent.
- Documents the historical mis-cite in the new ADR's `## Notes`
  section so future readers landing on PR #38 can recover the trail.
  PR bodies on the remote are immutable merge-history and cannot be
  rewritten.
- Adds the index fragment + `_order.txt` row; regenerates
  `docs/adr/README.md` via `scripts/docs/concat-adr-index.sh`.
- Adds `docs/state.md` row (Updated note + Recently-closed entry).
- Adds `docs/rebase-notes.md` entry documenting the rebase invariant
  (upstream still ships `ansnr` extractors; fork must keep deleting).
- Adds `changelog.d/changed/ansnr-sunset-adr-authoring.md` fragment.

In-tree audit confirmed zero `ADR-0709` references mis-cite ANSNR —
all remaining tree-side `ADR-0709` cites correctly point at Phase 4b
distributed-platform content. No tree-side citation fix-up required.

Docs-only PR. No code changes.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* chore(bundle): add changelog fragment for doc-sweep bundle batch-1

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: Lusoris <lusoris@pm.me>
@lusoris
lusoris deleted the docs/libvmaf-public-header-doc-gaps-round2 branch June 4, 2026 08:10
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant