Codebase for training transformers on systematic generalization datasets.

The official repository for our EMNLP 2021 paper The Devil is in the Detail: Simple Tricks Improve Systematic Generalization of Transformers.

Please note that this repository is a cleaned-up version of the internal research repository we use. In case you encounter any problems with it, please don't hesitate to contact me.

Setup

This project requires Python 3 (tested with Python 3.8 and 3.9) and PyTorch 1.8.

pip3 install -r requirements.txt

Create a Weights and Biases account and run

wandb login

More information on setting up Weights and Biases can be found on https://docs.wandb.com/quickstart.

For plotting, LaTeX is required (to avoid Type 3 fonts and to render symbols). Installation is OS specific.

Downloading data

All datasets are downloaded automatically except the Mathematics Dataset and CFQ which is hosted in Google Cloud and one has to log in with his/her Google account to be able to access it.

Math dataset

Download the .tar.gz file manually from here:

https://console.cloud.google.com/storage/browser/mathematics-dataset?pli=1

Copy it to the cache/dm_math/ folder. You should have a cache/dm_math/mathematics_dataset-v1.0.tar.gz file in the project folder if you did everyhing correctly.

CFQ

Download the .tar.gz file manually from here:

https://storage.cloud.google.com/cfq_dataset/cfq1.1.tar.gz

Copy it to the cache/CFQ/ folder. You should have a cache/CFQ/cfq1.1.tar.gz file in the project folder if you did everyhing correctly.

Usage

Running the experiments from the paper on a cluster

The code makes use of Weights and Biases for experiment tracking. In the sweeps directory, we provide sweep configurations for all experiments we have performed. The sweeps are officially meant for hyperparameter optimization, but we use them to run multiple configurations and seeds.

To reproduce our results, start a sweep for each of the YAML files in the sweeps directory. Run wandb agent for each of them in the root directory of the project. This will run all the experiments, and they will be displayed on the W&B dashboard. The name of the sweeps must match the name of the files in sweeps directory, except the .yaml ending. More details on how to run W&B sweeps can be found at https://docs.wandb.com/sweeps/quickstart.

For example, if you want to run Math Dataset experiments, run wandb sweep --name dm_math sweeps/dm_math.yaml. This creates the sweep and prints out its ID. Then run wandb agent <ID> with that ID.

Re-creating plots from the paper

Edit config file paper/config.json. Enter your project name in the field "wandb_project" (e.g. "username/project").

Run the scripts in the paper directory. For example:

cd paper
./run_all.sh

The output will be generated in the paper/out/ directory. Tables will be printed to stdout in latex format.

If you want to reproduce individual plots, it can be done by running individial python files in the paper directory.

Running experiments locally

It is possible to run single experiments with Tensorboard without using Weights and Biases. This is intended to be used for debugging the code locally.

If you want to run experiments locally, you can use run.py:

./run.py sweeps/tuple_rnn.yaml

If the sweep in question has multiple parameter choices, run.py will interactively prompt choices of each of them.

The experiment also starts a Tensorboard instance automatically on port 7000. If the port is already occupied, it will incrementally search for the next free port.

Note that the plotting scripts work only with Weights and Biases.

Reducing memory usage

In case some tasks won't fit on your GPU, play around with "-max_length_per_batch " argument. It can trade off memory usage/speed by slicing batches and executing them in multiple passes. Reduce it until the model fits.

BibTex

@inproceedings{csordas2021devil,
      title={The Devil is in the Detail: Simple Tricks Improve Systematic Generalization of Transformers}, 
      author={R\'obert Csord\'as and Kazuki Irie and J\"urgen Schmidhuber},
      booktitle={Proc. Conf. on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP)},
      year={2021},
      month={November},
      address={Punta Cana, Dominican Republic}
}