📄 Preprint (DOI-backed)
Beyond Correctness: Measuring Cognitive Stability and Confidence Calibration in Human Understanding
Zenodo (v1.0): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18269740
An AI-driven framework for measuring human understanding, confidence calibration, and cognitive stability.
The Human Cognition Measurement System (HCMS) is a research-grade cognitive assessment framework designed to move beyond right-or-wrong evaluation. Rather than treating intelligence as a static score, HCMS models how a learner thinks, how confident they are, how consistent their reasoning remains, and how well-calibrated their understanding truly is.
This repository represents the final consolidated research system and product implementation, spanning Phases 1–15 of structured development.
HCMS evaluates cognition across multiple, interdependent dimensions:
- Understanding Level — Depth, structure, and correctness of conceptual grasp
- Confidence Calibration — Alignment between self-reported confidence and actual performance
- Consistency — Stability of reasoning across attempts and conditions
- Misconception Detection — Rule-based and statistical identification of cognitive errors
- Adaptive Feedback — Targeted remediation and reinforcement strategies
- Robustness Analysis — Resistance to noisy, incomplete, or adversarial inputs
- Explainability — Transparent decision tracing and feature-level attribution
HCMS_Final/
│
├── phases/ # Complete research history (Phases 4–12)
│
├── cognition_ai/ # Final integrated system layer
│ ├── run_full_system.py # End-to-end execution entry point
│ ├── config.json # System configuration
│ ├── outputs/
│ │ └── final_learner_report.json
│ └── paper/ # Research paper (Markdown)
│ ├── abstract.md
│ ├── introduction.md
│ ├── related_work.md
│ ├── methodology.md
│ ├── experiments.md
│ ├── results.md
│ └── conclusion.md
│
└── README.md
The phases/ directory preserves scientific rigor, traceability, and experimental evolution.
The cognition_ai/ directory represents the deployable system and final research artifact.
pip install -r requirements.txtpython cognition_ai/run_full_system.pyAfter execution, a finalized learner cognition profile is generated at:
cognition_ai/outputs/final_learner_report.json
{
"Understanding Level": "Partial",
"Calibration": "Miscalibrated",
"Consistency Score": 0.83,
"System Verdict": "Needs targeted remediation"
}This output reflects how a learner thinks, not merely whether an answer was correct.
HCMS was developed through 15 structured research phases, including:
- Controlled experiments — Testing core cognitive behaviors
- Validation & consistency checks — Ensuring reliability across trials
- Confidence–accuracy correlation analysis — Measuring self-awareness of understanding
- Stress testing — Evaluating performance under noise and adversarial conditions
- Explainability & decision tracing — Transparent reasoning analysis
- Adaptive feedback systems — Personalized remediation and reinforcement
- Full system integration — Cohesive end-to-end framework assembly
Each phase builds upon the previous, maintaining strict scientific continuity.
The complete research paper is available at:
cognition_ai/paper/
- Abstract
- Introduction
- Related Work
- Methodology
- Experiments
- Results
- Conclusion
All files are written in clean Markdown, ensuring academic readability and publishing compatibility.
HCMS is designed for scalable, intelligent assessment across educational and research domains:
- Education Technology (EdTech)
- Adaptive Learning Platforms
- AI-driven Assessment Systems
- Cognitive Science Research
- Personalized Skill Evaluation
- Intelligent Tutoring Systems
Scales from individual learners to institution-level assessment.
Traditional assessments ask:
Did the student get it right?
HCMS asks:
Do they truly understand — and do they know that they understand?
This distinction enables:
- Deeper learning outcomes
- Early misconception detection
- Personalized intervention strategies
- Fairer and more meaningful evaluation
- ✅ Research complete
- ✅ System consolidated
- ✅ Final product operational
- ✅ Paper drafted
- ✅ Ready for publication, demonstration, or extension
Muhammad Rayan Shahid Independent AI Researcher Founder — ByteBrilliance AI
This project represents a deep exploration into human cognition, AI alignment, and meaningful assessment, developed with rigor, patience, and purpose.
“Not everything that can be measured matters — but understanding how humans think, does.”