Skip to content
Open
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
18 changes: 15 additions & 3 deletions docs/wealth-creation/active-and-passive-investing.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ sidebar_position: 6

The central difference between the two investment approaches is around how often managers make investment decisions and review the portfolio.

Passive investing tracks market-weighted indices or portfolios whereas active investment follows a more hands-on approach. The latter involves a team of research analysts and portfolio managers that construct a fund or portfolio with a certain mandate. The main objective is to beat the market benchmark. Active managers make investment decisions on your behalf, which is also why these funds come with an extra, but justifiable cost, given that the fund outperforms the market.
Passive investing tracks rule based indices or portfolios of which the most popular type of rule is market weighted whereas active investment follows a more hands-on approach. The latter involves a team of research analysts and portfolio managers that construct a fund or portfolio with a certain mandate. The main objective is to beat the market benchmark. Active managers make investment decisions on your behalf, which is also why these funds come with an extra, but justifiable cost, given that the fund outperforms the market.

### Chasing alpha

Expand All @@ -33,8 +33,20 @@ Passive investing is the cheaper of the two approaches but these fees are justif

In many cases, passive funds outperform active funds in the long run, but there is a subset of active fund managers that have been able to show results in the long run. You want to invest your money with these managers. A passive investor can’t outperform the market, as their return is the market benchmark minus the fees.

But selecting the winning manager is very a difficult thing to do and is akin to picking the winning stocks. The S&P Dow Jones Releases the [SPIVA Scorecard](https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/research-insights/spiva/#south-africa) yearly. In this report they compare performance of active managers against their indexes.

Wealth creation is long term game so on the SPIVA Scorecard for 10 year+:
- Global Equity only 3.33% of fund managers outperforms the index and on the
- Local Equity only 4.58% of fund managers outperforms the index.

If you also take into account its not always the same Fund managers that beats the market as they shift in the rankings every year, it makes choosing a winning active manager very difficult.

Another thing to take into account is when choosing an active fund is fees a [Morning Star](https://www.morningstar.co.uk/uk/news/149421/how-fund-fees-are-the-best-predictor-of-returns.aspx) did a study showing that fees are the biggest predictor on Real Returns of a fund. And cheaper funds normally performs better

### So, active or passive?

Decide upfront which type of investor you are. Do you have the time and expertise to go it alone? Do you want to own the market or have something more tailored to your risk profile? In these volatile times, active management may be a better choice for investors new to the scene.
The most important thing is to start investing. You can go months with analysis paralysis trying to decide what is the best method. But in most cases you can switch later there is a fee associated with fund switching but long term the opportunity cost of not entering the market is higher. And the easiest to start with is a broad based index fund.

Decide which type of investor you are. Is market returns enough for you or are you chasing alpha and accepting the risk that comes with chasing alpha. Or do you want to tailer the investments to your risk profile. If you are new to investing consider talking to a Financial Advisor preferably one that charges an hourly rate rather than a portion of assets under management.

Before investing, do your own research about what you’re getting into. If you’re paying for a service, such as active management, it must be justified by the value provided. You also don’t have to stick to one approach, there’s a place in a portfolio for active and passive managed funds.
And do your own research when you have the opportunity. If you’re paying for a service, such as active management, it must be justified by the value provided. You also don’t have to stick to one approach, there’s a place in a portfolio for active and passive managed funds.