Skip to content

Strange currency code strings like X+|\u0019F allow to create a CurrencyUnit #428

@gerardbosch

Description

@gerardbosch

I faced something strange when instantiating CurrencyUnit from the currencyCode string.

Some strings like "X*", "X+|" and others were allowed to create a currency.

Here is a small test to exemplify the situation and some comparison with java.util.Currency:

  @Test
  void monetaCurrencyUnit() {
    // SOME STRANGE STRINGS ARE ALLOWED! The test PASSED
    Monetary.getCurrency("X*");
    Monetary.getCurrency("X*|helloWorld");
    Monetary.getCurrency("X+|\u0019F\"CW:'NEvS�\u0017N\u000BL\u001B ~K\u0001");
  }

  @Test
  void monetaCurrencyUnitLowerHistorical() {
    // This fails as I was expecting, and that led me think that the Moneta impl of currency is more sound.
    // Because on the other hand, when using java.util.Currency, it works.
    Monetary.getCurrency("EUr");
  }

  @Test
  void jdkCurrency() {
    // Both throw exception as I would expect (not the case in Moneta `CurrencyUnit`: `Monetary.getCurrency()`)
    java.util.Currency.getInstance("X*");
    java.util.Currency.getInstance("X+|\u0019F\"CW:'NEvS�\u0017N\u000BL\u001B ~K\u0001");
  }

  @Test
  void jdkCurrencyLowerHistorical() {
    // I was not expecting this, but only some currencies work when the last char is lowercase like:
    java.util.Currency.getInstance("ESp"); // YUm ok, BEf ok, DEm ok, ADp ok (they're all historical currencies), EUr also works
  }

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions