/stopsound doesn't work for resource pack sounds

[some1chan]

Describe the bug

When using /stopsound with a specified source (or with a *), the sound will not stop.

To Reproduce

Run the following commands on Bedrock:

1. /playsound record.pigstep record @p
2. /stopsound @p record record.pigstep

Expected behaviour

Pigstep should stop playing, after running the /stopsound command in the repro section.

Screenshots / Videos

No response

Server Version and Plugins

No response

Geyser Dump

https://dump.geysermc.org/haIF2KPMWKe4o7z0yY0ZzHsZtTRtn98D

Geyser Version

2.0.0-SNAPSHOT (git-master-90442a8)

Minecraft: Bedrock Edition Version

1.18.2

Additional Context

According to #1768, this was resolved, but maybe it broke (possibly around #2493?).

Coincidentally with #2493, I'm also using JukeboxExtended to play custom music, and has gotten the music to play cross-platform. While getting this to work, I believe to have rediscovered the bug.

Extra notes: /stopsound @p does stop sounds properly, but /stopsound @p * record.pigstep doesn't.

[Camotoy]

I'm not marking this as confirmed, but I was able to replicate your behavior. I think I know what's up.
record.pigstep isn't a valid Java Edition sound. The format should be minecraft:music_disc.pigstep, which is a valid sound, and the Cat sound plays and stops with this format. But Pigstep doesn't have this mapping on our end, so it just passes on the sound if you do specify record.pigstep.

[Camotoy]

I updated the mappings so /playsound will correctly start and stop Pigstep. Let us know if this fixes your issue!

[some1chan]

Although that fixed the repro, it unfortunately didn't fix my issue. Turns out, my actual issue was that Bedrock resource pack sounds could be played, but couldn't be stopped without stopping all sounds. Is that something that could be fixed?

To Reproduce

1. Download this example pack, put it in the packs folder, then restart.

This pack contains a file named example.ogg, along with the required sound_definitions.json and manifest.json data. This should make it playable in Minecraft via command.

2. Join the server on Bedrock, and run the following commands:

• /playsound example record @p
• /stopsound @p record example

Expected behavior

The example sound should stop playing, after running the last command.

Additional Context

I definitely didn't do my due diligence of creating a fresh Paper server, and testing the pack. I only tested an already-existing server with different data, and with a Bedrock single-player world to see if the pack worked. Let me know if you have trouble reproducing it. Thanks!

[some1chan]

Sorry for the bump. Any updates on this?

[BoyStijn]

Same can be said about playsound from java if i run /playsound minecraft:music_disc.pigstep record @A bedrock players wont hear the audio

[RuNan2]

I'm in the same situation. The resource pack sound does not stop. I hope it's resolved soon!

[Camotoy]

This issue is probably resolved now. If it isn't, let us know. Thanks!