Inconsistent gossipsub message ids between lodestar and others #7879
Description
Describe the bug
I added some logs in gossipsub:
- when we ask for unknown message ids that we don't have (through IWANT)
- when we publish messages through
data_column_sidecartopics - when we received any messages of
data_column_sidecartopics
this is what I get
- we asked for a lot of unknown message ids, for example
0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb
May 27 09:08:36 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x6c538be1e390673bedb4fdbcea6c34978d580941 topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_2/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAkuXyVXHNFQjZyVPQt6xAGaGq5q1yLCJmoGGhDENvhn6wu
May 27 09:08:37 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAmU2E1j8iHu4PZihuchWtzK38CiDUNKZrgLKkaRBUvCndX
May 27 09:08:37 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAm59uhu9MirEWq2Bt24sVt1ZKYUdnb7d6aprfcy3YDRQoY
May 27 09:08:37 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAmU2E1j8iHu4PZihuchWtzK38CiDUNKZrgLKkaRBUvCndX
May 27 09:08:37 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x6c538be1e390673bedb4fdbcea6c34978d580941 topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_2/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAmU2E1j8iHu4PZihuchWtzK38CiDUNKZrgLKkaRBUvCndX
May 27 09:08:37 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAm7FQUgiRxj7gDnYRJRR236nb4ZH6qh8jmJx5uJRHMAUif
May 27 09:08:38 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x6c538be1e390673bedb4fdbcea6c34978d580941 topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_2/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAm9cNLuwuhfpaRVgATmhH4YQfAkTmyhjGgWCyWXFPxLpu3
May 27 09:08:38 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAm59uhu9MirEWq2Bt24sVt1ZKYUdnb7d6aprfcy3YDRQoY
May 27 09:08:38 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAkuXyVXHNFQjZyVPQt6xAGaGq5q1yLCJmoGGhDENvhn6wu
May 27 09:08:38 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAmU2E1j8iHu4PZihuchWtzK38CiDUNKZrgLKkaRBUvCndX
May 27 09:08:38 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x6c538be1e390673bedb4fdbcea6c34978d580941 topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_2/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAm9cNLuwuhfpaRVgATmhH4YQfAkTmyhjGgWCyWXFPxLpu3
May 27 09:08:38 [3842161]: @@@ asking for message 0x4821367047e8d3d5c56ee85ff12a3c3d208223cb topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy peer 16Uiu2HAm59uhu9MirEWq2Bt24sVt1ZKYUdnb7d6aprfcy3YDRQoY
it's so common that I think they are the correct message ids of majority of clients
However, later on lodestar published a different message ids on the same subnet
May 27 09:08:48 [3842161]: @@@ publish to topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_2/ssz_snappy msg 0xde52b9b26a1f6248dfe7a5d82c5c5e12d75d6e0a
May 27 09:08:48 [3842161]: @@@ publish to topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_3/ssz_snappy msg 0x29b2b3663debeb0e90bab673b29d01a252a40996
May 27 09:08:48 [3842161]: @@@ publish to topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_20/ssz_snappy msg 0xb97ad57212790e17a87b4e798706c8265692d3d8
May 27 09:08:48 [3842161]: @@@ publish to topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_30/ssz_snappy msg 0xca3ac77650916addba2247b8d861ec4a2294ae54
May 27 09:08:48 [3842161]: @@@ publish to topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_38/ssz_snappy msg 0xda5cf374e6cc6fc8d2470ea1f3c10bb1d2e7c34e
May 27 09:08:48 [3842161]: @@@ publish to topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_66/ssz_snappy msg 0x4c1e9b07321f6b080bd132518a75e754b02e11e2
May 27 09:08:48 [3842161]: @@@ publish to topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_108/ssz_snappy msg 0x95f1ec3fa9a36e64c1432e7a268502fd61a8b393
May 27 09:08:48 [3842161]: @@@ publish to topic /eth2/82cb98a6/data_column_sidecar_118/ssz_snappy msg 0x5ad180619318f6229778ca67f6a7bfd8bf853ed1
Expected behavior
lodestar should compute the same message id to other peers
Steps to reproduce
No response
Additional context
No response
Operating system
Linux
Lodestar version or commit hash
peerDAS