Description
Expected Behavior
I would like to be able to choose the communication protocol with the IoT Hub (e.g. Amqp_Tcp_Only, Amqp_Websocket_Only, Mqtt, etc.) in Cloud-Based mode, which was possible when using the Edge Hub.
Current Behavior
The LNS currently only support Amqp_Tcp_Only (see LoRaDeviceFactory.cs#L155), which prevents us from using the same protocol as when using the Edge Hub. Amqp_Tcp_Only uses port 5671 (and 8883 ?) which is not allowed in our firewall.
Our current implementation uses Amqp_Websocket_Only (port 443), and due to strict firewall policies we can't use this mode in our infrastructure. It should be possible to choose the protocol of our choice, as supported in the Edge Hub module with the UpstreamProtocol environment variable.
Steps to Reproduce
- Close outbound ports 5671 and 8883 in firewall
- Deploy LNS
- Connect a gateway to the LNS
-> Connection will get stuck when trying to update the Device Twin
Context (Environment)
Device (Host) Operating System
Ubuntu 20.04
Architecture
amd64
Container Operating System
Linux containers
LoRaWAN Module Version
v2.2.2
Docker
26.1.1-1
Logs
Additional Information
When ports are blocked, the communication gets stuck indefinitely in LoRaDeviceClient.cs#L106.
I forked the project and tried adding Amqp_Websocket_Only as a second protocol in transportSettings (LoRaDeviceFactory.cs#L155 but it won't connect. It only works when only Amqp_Websocket_Only is present. But I may be missing something :)