Skip to content

wayland-transpositor/wprs

Repository files navigation

wprs

Like xpra, but for Wayland, and written in Rust.

wprs implements rootless remote desktop access for remote Wayland (and X11, via XWayland) applications.

Building

Source

cargo build --profile=release-lto # or release, but debug is unusably slow

The following dependencies are required for wprsc, wprsd, xwayland-xdg-shell:

  • libxkbcommon (-dev on debian)
  • libwayland (-dev on debian)

The launcher (wprs) requires:

  • python3
  • psutil (python3-psutil on debian)
  • ssh client

deb

dpkg-buildpackage --sanitize-env -us -uc -b -d -rfakeroot

This requires cargo and a rustc matching the one in rust-toolchain.toml to be installed. The debian rustc package is not used due to being too old.

Usage

On the remote host, enable wprsd:

loginctl enable-linger
systemctl --user enable wprsd.service
systemctl --user start wprsd.service

On the local host:

# starts application on the remote host (starts ssh connection, forwards sockets, starts wprsc, runs application)
wprs <remote_host> run <application>

# stops local wprs connections, leaving remote session running (tear down ssh connection and forwarded sockets, stops wprsc)
wprs <remote_host> detach

# attaches to remote wprs session (starts ssh connection, forwards sockets, starts wprsc)
wprs <remote_host> attach

System Tuning

Increasing linux's socket buffer limits as described in https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/sysctl#Increase_the_memory_dedicated_to_the_network_interfaces will result in improved performance.

TODO: test ssh socket forwarding performance with different values of wmem_default. wprs uses setsockopt to increase its buffer size, but it doesn't seem that ssh does.

Configuration Files

You can create configuration files for wprsc and wprsd instead of passing additional arguments to wprs. To see what options are available, run wprsc --help and wprsd --help.

To generate the default configs, run:

# on your local machine
wprsc --print-default-config-and-exit=true > ~/.config/wprs/wprsc.ron

and

# on your remote machine
wprsd --print-default-config-and-exit=true > ~/.config/wprs/wprsd.ron

Then update the wprsc.ron and wprsd.ron files with your desired settings.

Current Limitations

Currently only the the Core and XDG shell protocols are implemented. In particular, hardware rendering/dmabuf support is not yet implemented.

  • Touch event support is not yet implemented.
  • Drag-and-drop may be wonky in some cases.
  • XWayland drag-and-drop is not (yet?) implemented.
  • webauthn security keys don't yet work in browsers

Generally, wprs will aim to support as many protocols as feasible, it's a question of time and prioritization.

Architecture

On the remote (server) side, wprsd implements a wayland compositor using Smithay. Instead of compositing and rendering though, wprsd serializes the state of the wayland session and sends it to the connected wprsc client using a custom protocol.

On the local (client) side, wprsc implements a wayland client (using the Smithay Client Toolkit that creates local wayland objects that correspond to remote wayland objects. For example, if a remote application running against wprsd creates a surface and an xdg-toplevel, wprsc will create a surface with the same contents, an xdg-toplevel with the same metadata, etc.. From the local compositor's point of view, wprsc is just a normal application with a bunch of windows. Input and other events from the local compositor that wprsc are serialized and sent to wprsd, which forwards them to the appropriate application (the owner of the surface which the wprsc surface which received the events corresponds to).

wprs supports session resumption (wprsc disconnection and later reconnection and wprsc restarts). The wayland protocol is not natively resumable in this way because it relies on shared state between the compositor and client applications. By implementing a wayland compositor locally relative to the application, wprsd stores all state necessary for wayland applications and is also able to store sufficient state (e.g., the buffer contents for each surface as of the last commit) for a newly-connected wprsc to correctly set up all necessary wayland objects. wprsc is stateless, but wprsd is not, so a wprsd restart will still terminate all wayland applications running against it, like with any other wayland compositor.

Communication between wprsd and wprsc happens over unix domain sockets; wprsd creates a socket and wprsc connects to it. The default mode of operation is to, on the client side, use ssh to forward a local socket to the remote wprsd socket, but a different transport could be used with, for example, socat or a custom proxy application. A launcher script (wprs) is provided which sets up the ssh socket forwarding.

Protocol

The custom protocol used to serialize and transmit wayland state between wprsc and wprsd is a simplified version of the wayland protocol. Wayland objects are represented as rust types and serialized using rkyv. Unlike the wayland protocol, the wprs protocol tries to be idempotent when possible. For example, instead of the repeated back-and-forth involved in created a surface, creating an xdg-surface, creating an xdg-toplevel, waiting for it to be configured, creating a buffer, attaching the buffer, and comitting it, wprsd will send a single commit message to wprsc with the complete state of the surface (surface's attached buffer contents (if any), its role (if any) and any associated metadata, etc.) and wprsc will execute the appropriate dance with the local compositor.

Frame callbacks are scheduled locally by wprsd at the configured framerate, they are not forwarded from wprsc as that would introduce an unacceptable amount of frame latency due to network round-trips. When no wprsc is connected, wprsd pauses sending frame callbacks to wayland applications.

Buffer compression is handled using a custom multithreaded and SIMD-accelerated lossless image compression algorithm:

  1. Transpose the image from an array of structures to a struct of arrays. This makes the subequent steps significantly faster by letting them be implemented with SIMD instructions and additionally improves the compression ratio because each color channel is more closely spatially correlated with itself than with the other channels.
  2. Apply an adjacent (wrapping) difference to each color channel (differential pulse-code modulation). This improves the compression ratio by taking advantage of spatial correlation and transforms (for example) a solid-colored line into a single color byte and then a sequence of 0-bytes, or a gradient into a sequence of 1-bytes, etc.
  3. Transform each color channel into a YUV-like color space: y := g, u := b - g, v := r - g, a := a. This improves the compression ratio in a similar way as the previous step but by taking advantage of cross-color correlation.
  4. Compress the data with zstd. This algorithm was designed for reasonably good compression ratios while being extremely fast: single-digit milliseconds per frame. Decompression is done by inverting those steps.

This protocol is not stable: there is no guarantee that different versions of wprsc and wprsd, or wprsc and wprsd built with different versions of dependencies or even rustc will be compatible. This may change in the future, but it will not happen soon.

Comparison to Waypipe

Waypipe's model is analogous to X forwarding, while wprs's model is analgous to Xpra. Waypipe ~transparently forwards messages between the local compositor and the remote application, so the client ends up being stateful and sessions can only be resumed through network reconnections, not client restarts. There are tradeoffs to the two approaches. Waypipe's approach is partially forward-compatible: it can support new wayland protocols automatically, however those protocols may be broken if they use shared resources in a way that waypipe doesn't know how to handle. wprs, on the other hand, requires explicit implementation for every wayland protocol.

XWayland

XWayland support is implemented as a separate binary, xwayland-xdg-shell. The binary implements a wayland compositor (but only for the protocol features used by xwayland) and client, just like wprsd and wprsc, but in a single binary (so skipping the serialization/deserialization). This is the same model as xwayland-proxy-virtwl, which is itself inspired by sommelier. xwayland-xdg-shell was primarily written (instead of just using xwayland-proxy-virtwl) so as to share a common design/codebase with wprs and to make use of common wayland development in the form of Smithay and its wayland crates. Additionally, xwayland-xdg-shell is more narrowly focused and its sole purpose is xwayland support, not virtio-gpu or virtwl.

Like xwayland-proxy-virtwl, xwayland-xdg-proxy can be used to implement external xwayland support for any wayland compositor instead of re-implementing it inside the compositor. Aside from eliminating the need to implement xwayland support in every compositor, this approach has been reported to result in better xwayland scaling than native xwayland support in some compositor, and it allows xwayland applications to be treated more like regular wayland applications instead of getting special access.

Security

wprsd is a wayland compositor, so it has access to all surfaces displayed by applications running against it and it can inject input into them. Any process which implements the wprs protocol and connects to the wprs socket will have the same access. For that reason, the wprs socket is created in a directory which only the user has access to ($XDG_RUNTIME_DIR) and the socket itself is only readable/writable by the user. Malicious applications running as the same user as wprsd can still access this socket, but at that point you have bigger problems.

wprs does not do any auth of its own, it relies entirely on whatever transport is being used (ssh, in the default case).

Thanks

Huge thanks to the following excellent projects for making this project significantly easier than it otherwise would have been:

Thanks to Waypipe and xwayland-proxy-virtwl for paving the way in this problem space.