Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Emergency Management - Symbols are missing or wrong displayed on the map #174

Closed
harrywipperfuerth opened this issue Feb 25, 2020 · 4 comments
Closed

Emergency Management - Symbols are missing or wrong displayed on the map #174

harrywipperfuerth opened this issue Feb 25, 2020 · 4 comments
Labels
accepted The issue or feature request was understood and is ready to be addressed issue unexpected behavior, error or crash, documentation deficiency upstream Upstream problem in some dependency

Comments

@harrywipperfuerth
Copy link
Member

The following symbols for emergency management are missing or wrong displayed on the map:

SIDC 2525c (following example all with the Modifier (F) for friend on the Postion 2) / Hierachy Code:

EFOPDK----H**** / EMS.OPN.LAWENF.PRSN
modifier field "AC" (Installation) is missing

EFOPBJ----***** / EMS.OPN.EMOPN.EMTM
modifier field "B" (Echelon) is missing

OFOPHA----***** / EMS.INCDNT.AIR.HJKG
OFOPHV----***** / EMS.INCDNT.MRN.HJKG
OFOPHT----***** / EMS.INCDNT.VEH.HJKG
is only displayed on the map with the "Activity Frame" for stability operation symbols, but not, as in 2525c, also for emergency management symbols with the standard frame

EFIPGB----***** / EMS.INCDNT.RAIL.HJCK
"H" should be more on the right side (not in the middle)

EFIPG-----***** / EMS.INCDNT.RAIL
EFIPGA----***** / EMS.INCDNT.RAIL.ACDNT
text modifier is from 2525d (ACC, INC), not from 2525c (A, I) and should be more on the right side (not in the middle)

EFIPE-----***** / EMS.INCDNT.AIR
EFIPEA----***** / EMS.INCDNT.AIR.ACDNT
EFIPF-----***** / EMS.INCDNT.MRN
EFIPFA----***** / EMS.INCDNT.MRN.ACDNT
EFIPH-----***** / EMS.INCDNT.VEH
EFIPHA----***** / EMS.INCDNT.VEH.ACDNT
text modifier is from 2525d (ACC, INC), not from 2525c (A, I)

OFOPD-----***** / EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DEMO
OFIPR-----***** / EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DISPOP
OFVPB-----***** / EMS.INCDNT.CRMACT.BM
EFIPBF----***** / EMS.INCDNT.CRMACT.SHTG
EFIPDO----***** / EMS.INCDNT.HAZMAT.UNXORD
WAS-WSVE--P---- / EMS.NATEVT.GEO.VOLERN
WAS-WSD-LIP---- / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.DZ
ENPBB----***** / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.DRGHT
WAS-WSGRL-P---- / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.HL
WAS-WSR-LIP---- / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.RA
WAS-WSDSLMP---- / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.DT/SD
WAS-WSS-LIP---- / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.SN
WAS-WSTMH-P---- / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.TSTRM
WAS-WST-FCP---- / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.TNDO
WAS-WSTSS-P---- / EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.TRPCYC
EFOPDOA---***** / EMS.OPN.SNS
EFOPDOA---***** / EMS.OPN.SNS.BIO
EFOPDOA---***** / EMS.OPN.SNS.CML
EFOPDOA---***** / EMS.OPN.SNS.INT
EFOPDOA---***** / EMS.OPN.SNS.NUC
EFOPDOA---***** / EMS.OPN.SNS.RAD
SFGPUULC--***** / EMS.OPN.LAWENF.POL.POLUNT
EFFPEA----H*** / EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC.GENSTA
EFFPEB----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC.NTLGAS
EFFPEE----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC.PROPNE
EFFPLA----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.ATCF
EFFPLD----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.BSTN
EFFPLE----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.FRYTRM
EFFPLF----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.HLS
WOS-ML----P---- / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.LCK
EFFPLH----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.MAINTF
SFGPIBN---H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.SP
EFFPLJ----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.RLSTN
EFFPLK----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.RSTSTP
WOS-HPBA--P---- / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.ANCRG
EFFPLM----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.TOLLF
EFFPLO----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.TIF
EFFPLP----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.TSP.TNL
EFFPMA----***** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.CV
EFFPMB----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.DAM
EFFPMB----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.DO
EFFPMC----***** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.GWWELL
EFFPMD----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.PMPSTN
EFFPME----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.RSVR
EFFPMG----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.STRTWR
EFFPMH----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.SWI
EFFPMI----H**** / EMS.INFSTR.WS.WH20TF
no symbol could be created on the map
@harrywipperfuerth
Copy link
Member Author

harrywipperfuerth commented Jun 24, 2020 •
edited
Loading

Update 23jun20

(the entry of 25feb20 must therefore be regarded as oboslet):

Due to the change from version 0.5.4 to version 0.6.0/OL and the resulting reimplementation of the symbols 2525C, the following incorrect representations in the EMS range were found during the check:

The following symbols for EMS are wrong displayed or missing on the map:

SIDC 2525c (following example all with the Modifier (F) for friend on the Position 2) / Hierachy Code:

modifier field "AC" (Installation) is missing

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
EFOPDK----H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.PRSN TODO
EFFPBA----***** EMS.INFSTR.BFI.ATM TODO

modifier field "B" (Echelon) is missing

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
EFOPBJ----***** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.EMTM TODO

is only displayed on the map with the "Activity Frame" for stability operation symbols, but not, as in 2525c, also for emergency management symbols with the standard frame

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
OFOPHA----***** EMS.INCDNT.AIR.HJKG TODO
OFOPHV----***** EMS.INCDNT.MRN.HJKG TODO
OFOPHT----***** EMS.INCDNT.VEH.HJKG TODO

"H" should be more on the right side (not in the middle)

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
EFIPGB----***** EMS.INCDNT.RAIL.HJCK TODO

text modifier is from 2525d (ACC, INC), not from 2525c (A, I) and should be more on the right side (not in the middle)

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
EFIPG-----***** EMS.INCDNT.RAIL TODO
EFIPGA----***** EMS.INCDNT.RAIL.ACDNT TODO

text modifier is from 2525d (ACC, INC), not from 2525c (A, I)

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
EFIPE-----***** EMS.INCDNT.AIR TODO
EFIPEA----***** EMS.INCDNT.AIR.ACDNT TODO
EFIPF-----***** EMS.INCDNT.MRN TODO
EFIPFA----***** EMS.INCDNT.MRN.ACDNT TODO
EFIPH-----***** EMS.INCDNT.VEH TODO
EFIPHA----***** EMS.INCDNT.VEH.ACDNT TODO

_the same symbol is in stability operations available, but yout don't find it as EMS symbol

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
OFOPD-----***** EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DEMO TODO
OFIPR-----***** EMS.INCDNT.CVDIS.DISPOP TODO
OFVPB-----***** EMS.INCDNT.CRMACT.BM TODO
OFVPP-----***** EMS.INCDNT.CRMACT.PSNG TODO

_the same symbol is in tactical graphics - CSS Points available, but yout don't find it as EMS symbol

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
G*SPPO----****X EMS.INFSTR.TSP.TCP TODO
G*MPBCB---****X EMS.INFSTR.TSP.BRG TODO

_the same symbol is in sea surface tracks available, but yout don't find it as EMS symbol

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
SFSPNM----***** EMS.OPN.EMMED.HSPSHP TODO
SFSPXL----***** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.CSTGD.CSTGDE TODO

_the same symbol is in unit tracks available, but yout don't find it as EMS symbol

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
SFGPIXH---H**** EMS.OPN.EMMED.HSP TODO

_the same symbol is in equipment tracks available, but yout don't find it as EMS symbol

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
SFGPES----***** EMS.OPN.SNS TODO

_the same symbol is in installation tracks available, but yout don't find it as EMS symbol

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
SFGPIUE---H**** EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC TODO
SFGPIUEN--H**** EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC.NUCFAC TODO
SFGPIRP---H**** EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC.PETFAC TODO
SFGPIUT---H**** EMS.INFSTR.TELCOM.TCF TODO
SFGPIT----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP TODO
SFGPIBA---H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.AIRPT TODO
SFGPIBN---H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.SP TODO

no symbol could be created on the map

SIDC Hierachy code Progress (06aug20)
EFIPDO----***** EMS.INCDNT.HAZMAT.UNXORD DONE
WAS-WSVE--P---- EMS.NATEVT.GEO.VOLERN TODO
WAS-WSD-LIP---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.DZ TODO
WAS-WSFGSOP---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.FG TODO
WAS-WSGRL-P---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.HL TODO
WAS-WSR-LIP---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.RA TODO
WAS-WSDSLMP---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.DT/SD TODO
WAS-WSS-LIP---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.SN TODO
WAS-WSTMH-P---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.TSTRM TODO
WAS-WST-FCP---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.TNDO TODO
WAS-WSTSS-P---- EMS.NATEVT.HYDMET.TRPCYC TODO
EFOPCD----H**** EMS.OPN.FIRFT.OTHH2O DONE
EFOPCE----H**** EMS.OPN.FIRFT.FIRSTN DONE
EFOPBC----H**** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.INS DONE
EFOPBE----H**** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.EICC DONE
EFOPBF----H**** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.EOC DONE
EFOPBG----H**** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.EPIC DONE
EFOPBH----H**** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.EMSHLT DONE
EFOPBI----H**** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.ESA DONE
EFOPBK----H**** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.EWDC DONE
EFOPBL----H**** EMS.OPN.EMOPN.FDDIST DONE
EFOPAC----H**** EMS.OPN.EMMED.INS DONE
EFOPAD----H**** EMS.OPN.EMMED.EMTLOC DONE
EFOPAG----H**** EMS.OPN.EMMED.HDF DONE
EFOPAJ----H**** EMS.OPN.EMMED.MFOP DONE
EFOPAK----H**** EMS.OPN.EMMED.MRG DONE
EFOPAL----H**** EMS.OPN.EMMED.RX DONE
EFOPAM----H**** EMS.OPN.EMMED.TRIAGE DONE
EFOPDC----H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.LAWENI DONE
EFOPDEC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.BDRPT.BDRPTI DONE
EFOPDFC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.CSTM.CSTMIN DONE
SFGPUULC--***** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.POL.POLUNT TODO
EFOPDJC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.POL.POLINS DONE
EFOPDNC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.CSTGD.CSTGDI DONE
EFOPDDC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.ATF.ATFINS DONE
EFOPDGC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.DEA.DEAINS DONE
EFOPDHC--H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.DOJ.DOJINS DONE
EFOPDIC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.FBI.FBIINS DONE
EFOPDLC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.SECSR.SECSRI DONE
EFOPDMC---H**** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.TSA.TSAINS DONE
EFOPDOA---***** EMS.OPN.LAWENF.USMAR.USMARI DONE
EFFPD-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.EDFAC DONE
EFFPDA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.EDFAC.COLUNI DONE
EFFPDB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.EDFAC.SCHOOL DONE
EFFPF-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.GVTSTE DONE
EFFPG-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.MIL DONE
EFFPGA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.MIL.ARMORY DONE
SFGPIB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.MIL.MILBF DONE
EFFPH-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.PSTSRV DONE
EFFPHA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.PSTSRV.PDC DONE
EFFPHB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.PSTSRV.PO DONE
EFFPJ-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.SPCNDS DONE
EFFPJA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.SPCNDS.ADLTDC DONE
EFFPJB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.SPCNDS.CHLDDC DONE
EFFPJC----H**** EMS.INFSTR.SPCNDS.ELDERC DONE
EFFPK-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TELCOM DONE
EFFPKB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TELCOM.TCTWR DONE
EFFPA-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.AGFD DONE
EFFPAA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.AGFD.AGLAB DONE
EFFPAB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.AGFD.AFL DONE
EFFPAC----H**** EMS.INFSTR.AGFD.CFDC DONE
EFFPAD----H**** EMS.INFSTR.AGFD.FRMRNC DONE
EFFPAE----H**** EMS.INFSTR.AGFD.FPC DONE
EFFPAF----H**** EMS.INFSTR.AGFD.FDRTL DONE
EFFPAG----H**** EMS.INFSTR.AGFD.GRSTR DONE
EFFPB-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.BFI DONE
EFFPBB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.BFI.BANK DONE
EFFPBC----H**** EMS.INFSTR.BFI.BLSTR DONE
EFFPBD----H**** EMS.INFSTR.BFI.FRB DONE
EFFPBE----H**** EMS.INFSTR.BFI.FINEX DONE
EFFPBF----H**** EMS.INFSTR.BFI.FSO DONE
EFFPC-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL DONE
EFFPCA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.CMLPLN DONE
EFFPCB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.FIRMAN DONE
EFFPCC----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.FIRRET DONE
EFFPCD----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.HZMTPR DONE
EFFPCE----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.HZMTST DONE
EFFPCF----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.INDSTE DONE
EFFPCG----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.LNDFL DONE
EFFPCH----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.RXMFG DONE
EFFPCI----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.CHWS DONE
EFFPCJ----H**** EMS.INFSTR.CMCL.TXRLIN DONE
EFFPEA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC.GENSTA DONE
EFFPEB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC.NTLGAS DONE
EFFPEE----H**** EMS.INFSTR.ENGFAC.PROPNE DONE
EFFPI-----H**** EMS.INFSTR.PUBVEN DONE
EFFPIA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.PUBVEN.ENCFAC DONE
EFFPIB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.PUBVEN.OPNFAC DONE
EFFPIC----H**** EMS.INFSTR.PUBVEN.RECARE DONE
EFFPID----H**** EMS.INFSTR.PUBVEN.RELIG DONE
EFFPLA----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.ATCF DONE
EFFPLD----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.BSTN DONE
EFFPLE----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.FRYTRM DONE
EFFPLF----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.HLS DONE
WOS-ML----P---- EMS.INFSTR.TSP.LCK TODO
EFFPLH----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.MAINTF DONE
EFFPLJ----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.RLSTN DONE
EFFPLK----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.RSTSTP DONE
WOS-HPBA--P---- EMS.INFSTR.TSP.ANCRG TODO
EFFPLM----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.TOLLF DONE
EFFPLO----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.TIF DONE
EFFPLP----H**** EMS.INFSTR.TSP.TNL DONE
SFGPIUP---H**** EMS.INFSTR.WS TODO
EFFPMB----H**** EMS.INFSTR.WS.DAM DONE
EFFPMC----***** EMS.INFSTR.WS.GWWELL DONE
EFFPMD----H**** EMS.INFSTR.WS.PMPSTN DONE
EFFPME----H**** EMS.INFSTR.WS.RSVR DONE
EFFPMG----H**** EMS.INFSTR.WS.STRTWR DONE
EFFPMH----H**** EMS.INFSTR.WS.SWI DONE
EFFPMI----H**** EMS.INFSTR.WS.WH20TF DONE

For the better use of the EMS for the user, the property set should be improved in the next time!

At the moment, if ODIN use the property set for equipment therefore, but these properties makes not really sense for all of the EMS symbols.

Concerning the possible content and the structure of a "first" propertey set (= implementation of those modifiers that can already be used/displayed in ODIN) see Issues for units (# 183) / equipment (# 184) and installations (# 185).

@dehmer dehmer added the accepted The issue or feature request was understood and is ready to be addressed label Nov 15, 2020
@dehmer
Copy link
Member

dehmer commented Nov 16, 2020

For now we completely ignore METOC (SIDCs starting with 'W'), even if the symbols are additionally included in EMS hierarchy.

@dehmer
Copy link
Member

dehmer commented Nov 16, 2020

We have a few different issues here:

  • Currently a symbol can only be contained in one hierarchy. This might even lead to different frames: regular vs. activity. As long as a similar symbol can be found, this is good enough for me.
  • D text modifiers in C is good enough. I cannot imagine that Beckman would be inclined to change that.
  • Some symbols are slightly incorrect (mainly text positioning). As long as users can leaf with this, we are good.

Screenshot 2020-11-16 at 09 31 34

  1. EFOPDK----H****: clarification needed - symbol or properties issue
  2. EFFPBA----*****: clarification needed - symbol or properties issue
  3. EFOPBJ----*****: clarification needed - symbol or properties issue
  4. OFOPHA----*****: slightly wrong icon (upstream)
  5. OFOPHV----*****: slightly wrong icon (upstream)
  6. OFOPHT----*****: slightly wrong icon (upstream)
  7. EFIPGB----*****: slightly wrong icon (upstream)
  8. EFIPG-----*****: slightly wrong icon (upstream)
  9. EFIPGA----*****: slightly wrong icon (upstream)
  10. EFIPE-----*****: 2525D text modifier is good enough
  11. EFIPEA----*****: 2525D text modifier is good enough
  12. EFIPF-----*****: 2525D text modifier is good enough
  13. EFIPFA----*****: 2525D text modifier is good enough
  14. EFIPH-----*****: 2525D text modifier is good enough
  15. EFIPHA----*****: 2525D text modifier is good enough
  16. OFOPD-----*****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  17. OFIPR-----*****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  18. OFVPB-----*****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  19. OFVPP-----*****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  20. G*SPPO----****X: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  21. G*MPBCB---****X: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  22. SFSPNM----*****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  23. SFSPXL----*****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  24. SFGPIXH---H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  25. SFGPES----*****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  26. SFGPIUE---H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  27. SFGPIUEN--H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  28. SFGPIRP---H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  29. SFGPIUT---H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  30. SFGPIT----H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  31. SFGPIBA---H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  32. SFGPIBN---H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  33. SFGPUULC--*****: same SIDC in different hierarchies
  34. SFGPIUP---H****: same SIDC in different hierarchies

@dehmer dehmer added issue unexpected behavior, error or crash, documentation deficiency upstream Upstream problem in some dependency labels Nov 16, 2020
@dehmer dehmer mentioned this issue Nov 16, 2020
Open
@dehmer
Copy link
Member

dehmer commented Nov 16, 2020

No further actions required.
Closing.

@dehmer dehmer closed this as completed Nov 16, 2020
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
accepted The issue or feature request was understood and is ready to be addressed issue unexpected behavior, error or crash, documentation deficiency upstream Upstream problem in some dependency
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@dehmer @harrywipperfuerth