Skip to content

PROGRESS_LOG.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
265 lines (238 loc) · 14.9 KB

PROGRESS_LOG.md

File metadata and controls

265 lines (238 loc) · 14.9 KB
Raw

Progress Log

Status: active

2026-05-10 Checkpoint 1 - Repo Inspection

  • Read root structure, README.md, AGENTS.md, package.json, tsconfig.json, .openclaude-profile.json, .github/workflows/pr-checks.yml, existing docs/, .planning/, .gstack/, and key source files.
  • Confirmed requested planning docs did not already exist.
  • Confirmed this directory is not a git repository: git status --short returned fatal: not a git repository.
  • Current package version observed from package.json: 0.6.0.

2026-05-10 Checkpoint 2 - Existing Planning State

  • Read legacy local planning files and phase specs/plans before public hygiene cleanup removed them from current authority.
  • Found existing Orchestra v0.2 state: planner/skeptic/shadow/evidence/experiment concepts are already partially implemented and documented.
  • Read src/services/orchestra/ surfaces for config, orchestrator, memory, worktree manager, shadow executor, cross-review, evidence arbiter, human gate, promote, promotion store, and experiment metrics.
  • Found /orchestra-apply and /orchestra-reject command implementations and tests.

2026-05-10 Checkpoint 3 - Primary Sources

  • Collected primary-source anchors for AGENTS.md, Agent Skills, MCP resources/prompts/tools, OpenAI agent evals and trace grading, OpenAI Evals, NIST AI RMF, OWASP LLM Top 10, W3C PROV, ReAct, Reflexion, and USPTO Patent Public Search.
  • Used these sources as planning anchors in docs/PROJECT_SPEC.md, docs/AGENT_REGISTRY.md, docs/RESEARCH_PIPELINE.md, docs/EVALS.md, and docs/SECURITY_AND_GUARDRAILS.md.

2026-05-10 Checkpoint 4 - Planning Artifacts Written

  • Created:
    • docs/PROJECT_SPEC.md
    • docs/GOAL_SCHEMA.md
    • docs/AGENT_REGISTRY.md
    • docs/RESEARCH_PIPELINE.md
    • docs/EVALS.md
    • docs/SECURITY_AND_GUARDRAILS.md
    • docs/ROADMAP.md
  • Pending at this checkpoint:
    • docs/DECISION_LOG.md
    • docs/NEXT_GOALS.md
    • AGENTS.md update
    • validation command execution

2026-05-10 Checkpoint 5 - Decisions And Next Goals

  • Created docs/DECISION_LOG.md with the major planning assumptions and scope decisions for the first pass.
  • Created docs/NEXT_GOALS.md with the next 3 executable Codex /goal commands.
  • Updated AGENTS.md so future unified mth/meta/Orchestra OS work points to this planning package.

2026-05-10 Checkpoint 6 - Validation

  • Docs consistency check passed:
    • required planning files exist
    • docs/NEXT_GOALS.md contains 3 executable /goal commands
    • AGENTS.md references all 10 planning docs
    • target docs contain no open-work placeholder markers
    • required goal hierarchy and agent role terms are present
  • bun run build passed and produced dist/cli.mjs.
  • bun run smoke passed and reported 0.6.0 (Open Claude).
  • python -m pytest -q python/tests passed: 44 passed.
  • bun run typecheck failed on existing TypeScript errors across src/, including missing generated/type modules, undefined MACRO, test-runner globals in typecheck, and model/provider type errors. The docs-only planning package did not touch these source files.
  • bun test --max-concurrency=1 failed: 1276 passed, 18 failed. Failure groups include codexCredentials, /orchestra-apply and promotion store tests, OpenAI-compatible shim routing tests, sandbox path constraint test, and model alias/provider regression tests.
  • No lint script is defined in package.json; lint could not be run as a package script.
  • git status --short remains unavailable because this directory is not a git repository.

2026-05-10 Checkpoint 7 - Harness Engineering Replan

  • User corrected the planning source: MFH/Meta evidence supersedes the provisional mth assumption.
  • Reviewed private internal harness material and imported only the public-safe synthesis into this repository.
  • Recorded that private harness state is not public proof of cleanliness, release readiness, or external validation.
  • Updated AGENTS.md, docs/PROJECT_SPEC.md, docs/GOAL_SCHEMA.md, docs/AGENT_REGISTRY.md, docs/RESEARCH_PIPELINE.md, docs/EVALS.md, docs/SECURITY_AND_GUARDRAILS.md, docs/ROADMAP.md, docs/DECISION_LOG.md, and docs/NEXT_GOALS.md.
  • Planning correction: provisional mth assumption is superseded by canonical MFH evidence unless the owner later defines a separate mth.
  • Re-ran docs consistency check:
    • required planning files exist
    • docs/NEXT_GOALS.md still contains 3 executable /goal commands
    • AGENTS.md references the updated planning package, including docs/MFH_META_SYNTHESIS.md
    • target docs contain no open-work placeholder markers
    • required Goal OS plus MFH/Meta terms are present
  • Re-ran OpenClaude build sanity check: bun run build passed.

2026-06-18 Checkpoint 8 - Goal Kernel MVP Start

  • Read AGENTS.md, docs/NEXT_GOALS.md, docs/GOAL_SCHEMA.md, docs/MFH_META_SYNTHESIS.md, docs/ROADMAP.md, docs/PROGRESS_LOG.md, and docs/DECISION_LOG.md.
  • Created the current structured goal registry entry: docs/goals/CG-001-goal-kernel-mvp.md.
  • Created docs/goals/README.md to distinguish current CG-*.md goal objects from historical local goal artifacts.
  • Added scripts/validate-goals.ts and scripts/validate-goals.test.ts for required Goal OS fields, validation commands, pause conditions, rollback, governed-code claim boundaries, MFH gates, and Meta records.
  • Added goals:validate to package.json.
  • Recorded D-013 so historical local goal artifacts are not rewritten as part of the first Goal Kernel validator slice.
  • Validation results:
    • bun test scripts/validate-goals.test.ts passed with 3 tests.
    • bun run goals:validate passed with 1 valid CG-*.md goal and no provider, live model, external, or protected calls.
    • bun run build passed.
    • bun run product:typecheck-health passed with 0 diagnostics.
    • bun run product:public-claim-boundary:check passed with 0 unauthorized positive claims.
    • bun run verify:privacy passed.
  • Direct bun run typecheck --pretty false exposed broad existing src/ TypeScript diagnostics outside this docs-governance change; the changed goal validator path passed focused tests and the repo's product typecheck health gate.

2026-06-18 Checkpoint 9 - Goal Trace Policy Gate

  • Added docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-18-goal-trace-policy-gate.md as the implementation plan for the next Goal Kernel evidence ratchet.
  • Added scripts/validate-goal-traces.ts and scripts/validate-goal-traces.test.ts.
  • Added docs/goals/traces/CG-001-goal-kernel-mvp.trace.json as the first source-controlled local no-provider goal trace fixture.
  • Updated scripts/validate-goals.ts so future validated or closed goal states require passing evidence.testResults for required validation commands and existing evidence artifact paths.
  • Updated package.json so bun run goals:validate runs both schema and trace validation, and product:quality starts by running the Goal Kernel gate.
  • Added the public README and Korean README Metaforge Proof Tour so marketing language follows Goal Kernel -> Meta -> MFH -> Orchestra -> Mimesis -> OpenClaude substrate.
  • Validation results:
    • bun test scripts/validate-goals.test.ts passed with 6 tests.
    • bun test scripts/validate-goal-traces.test.ts passed with 5 tests.
    • bun run goals:validate passed with 1 valid goal trace and no provider, live model, external, or protected calls.

2026-06-18 Checkpoint 10 - Primary-Source Research Ledger

  • Added docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-18-primary-source-research-ledger.md for the research-ledger implementation slice.
  • Added scripts/validate-research-briefs.ts and scripts/validate-research-briefs.test.ts for required Goal OS research sections, local authority sources, official/original external sources, secondary-source rejection, mapping coverage, and claim boundaries.
  • Added docs/research/README.md and docs/research/templates/primary-source-brief.md as the reusable raw/wiki/decision research format.
  • Added docs/research/goal-os-governed-code-prior-art-2026-06-18.md with local authority docs, AGENTS.md, Agent Skills, MCP, OpenAI agent evals and trace grading, OpenAI Evals, W3C PROV, NIST AI RMF, OWASP LLM Top 10, ReAct, Reflexion, and USPTO Patent Public Search mapped to requirements, evals, guardrails, and decisions.
  • Added research:validate and wired product:quality so the research validator runs before product:primary-source-registry.
  • Validation results:
    • bun test scripts/validate-research-briefs.test.ts passed with 5 tests.
    • bun run research:validate passed with 1 valid goal-os-*.md research brief and no provider, live model, external, or protected calls.
    • bun run product:doc-link-integrity passed.
    • bun run product:public-claim-boundary:check passed with 0 unauthorized positive claims.
    • bun run product:primary-source-registry passed with 210 records and 144 unique URLs.
    • bun run product:evidence-manifest passed with 214 evidence records.
    • bun run build passed.
    • bun run scripts/product-quality-gate.ts passed.
    • bun run verify:privacy passed.

2026-06-18 Checkpoint 11 - Eval Flywheel And Automation Candidates

  • Added docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-18-eval-flywheel-source-reconciliation.md.
  • Added scripts/validate-eval-flywheel.ts and scripts/validate-eval-flywheel.test.ts for L0-L5, EVAL-008 through EVAL-010, mock-versus-real experiment status, proposed-only automation candidates, blocked external-call candidates, and MFH/Meta source reconciliation boundaries.
  • Added docs/evals/README.md and docs/evals/autonomous-goal-os-minimal-checklist.md.
  • Added docs/reports/automation-candidates-2026-06-18.md with A0, A1, and A4 proposed-only candidates, required approvals, pause conditions, kill switches, output paths, and blocked external-call status.
  • Added docs/reports/mfh-meta-source-reconciliation-2026-06-18.md to record public-doc reconciliation and carry forward internal MFH/Meta drift.
  • Ran bun run scripts/orchestra-experiment-runner.ts; it exited 0 and used the one-task mock fallback because a source-controlled 20-task experiment task set was absent. The ignored local runner output was removed after hygiene checks and was not treated as public proof.
  • Validation results so far:
    • bun test scripts/validate-eval-flywheel.test.ts passed with 5 tests.
    • bun run evals:validate passed with 7 proposed automation candidates and no provider, live model, external, or protected calls.
    • Focused Orchestra tests passed: src/services/orchestra/experimentMetrics.test.ts, src/services/orchestra/promote.test.ts, src/services/orchestra/promotionStore.test.ts, src/services/orchestra/humanGate.test.ts, and src/services/orchestra/evidenceArbiter.test.ts.
    • bun run product:doc-link-integrity passed.
    • bun run product:public-claim-boundary:check passed with 0 unauthorized positive claims.
    • bun run product:primary-source-registry passed with 216 records and 144 unique URLs.
    • bun run product:evidence-manifest passed with 216 evidence records.
    • bun run build passed.
    • bun run scripts/product-quality-gate.ts passed.
    • bun run verify:privacy initially caught ignored local runner output with a Windows path; the generated local files were removed and the rerun passed.

2026-06-19 Checkpoint 12 - MFH Representative Trace Pack

  • Extended scripts/validate-goal-traces.ts so goal traces declare expectedOutcome as validated, rejected, or blocked.
  • Added source-controlled trace fixtures:
    • docs/goals/traces/CG-001-goal-kernel-mvp.trace.json
    • docs/goals/traces/CG-001-missing-evidence-rejected.trace.json
    • docs/goals/traces/CG-001-protected-action-blocked.trace.json
  • Updated scripts/validate-goal-traces.test.ts so MFH accepts rejected and blocked traces only when the denial evidence is explicit and no side effects execute.
  • Updated the MFH public claim evidence map so it points to the representative trace fixtures and keeps broader cross-goal/runtime reliability claims blocked.
  • Excluded docs/product-quality/product-evidence-manifest.md from the public claim-boundary scan input set because the manifest hashes the claim-boundary report; this prevents generated-report stale loops while keeping the manifest itself hash-bound by product:evidence-manifest.
  • Validation results so far:
    • bun test scripts/validate-goal-traces.test.ts passed with 8 tests.
    • bun run goals:trace:validate passed with 3 valid traces and coverage validated=1, rejected=1, blocked=1.
    • bun run product:public-claim-boundary passed with 0 unauthorized positive claims.
    • bun run product:evidence-manifest passed with 221 evidence records.
    • bun run product:public-claim-boundary:check passed after the manifest exclusion, confirming generated claim-boundary artifacts are current.

2026-06-19 Checkpoint 13 - Static Analysis Goal Ratchet

  • Added docs/goals/CG-002-static-analysis-ratchet.md so community feedback about dead exports, dependency topology, duplicate shapes, and marker-only audits is tracked as a bounded Goal OS slice.
  • Added docs/goals/traces/CG-002-static-analysis-ratchet.trace.json as the second source-controlled local no-provider validated trace.
  • Extended scripts/validate-goal-traces.ts so the trace report now checks that valid traces cover more than one goal before cross-goal MFH wording.
  • Updated the MFH public claim evidence map to include CG-002, the static analysis trace, and the Knip, dependency-cruiser, and jscpd reports.
  • Updated README, Korean README, and public feedback docs so Knip, dependency-cruiser, and jscpd are described as wired local gates while cleanup completion, topology cleanliness, and external validation remain blocked.
  • Validation results:
    • bun test scripts/validate-goal-traces.test.ts --test-name-pattern "cross-goal" first failed because the cross-goal check did not exist.
    • After adding the check, the same focused test passed.
    • bun run goals:validate passed with 2 valid goal files, 4 valid goal traces, representative coverage validated=2, rejected=1, blocked=1, and cross-goal coverage goal_ids=CG-001,CG-002.
    • bun run product:dead-export-candidates passed with Knip 6.16.1, 637 candidate files, 1396 unused-export candidates, and no autofix/deletion or readiness claims.
    • bun run product:dependency-topology passed with dependency-cruiser 17.4.3, 2630 modules, 11983 edges, 2105 known violations, and 0 new ratchet violations.
    • bun run product:script-duplication-audit passed with jscpd 5.0.9, 19 clone pairs, 507 duplicated lines, and 1.2054781492225024 percent duplicated lines under baseline.
    • bun run product:public-claim-boundary passed with 0 unauthorized positive claims.
    • bun run product:evidence-manifest passed with 227 evidence records after adding Goal OS and trace artifacts to the manifest input set.
    • bun run product:public-claim-boundary:check passed after manifest refresh.